Editor
@firstthingsmag
, Em Prof of English Emory U; author The Dumbest Generation; Literary Criticism: An Autopsy; Negrophobia: A Race Riot in Atlanta, 1906
In 1992, Pat Buchanan declared, "There is a religious war going on for the soul of our country," and 99% of the elite called him a clown or a madman or a huckster.
When you see vicious identity politics drift down into elementary grades, know that 20-30 years ago, a handful of conservative dissenters in the humanities were warning of disaster to come, only to be scoffed at by liberal colleagues and ignored by Republican politicians.
I hear lots of conservatives here stating that Big Tech has just made a huuuuge mistake in their bans. From what I can see, however, Big Tech has absolutely nothing to fear.
Any Republican Governor who fails to follow the Florida gov’s lead and expunge DEI ideology from public universities is no friend to conservatives. (Youngkin, Kemp,...)
Crazy idea: Maybe instead of nuking 2/3 of the statewide elected officials in Virginia, we should make some allowance for stupid mistakes and for the fact that people grow up and change
Political liberals can present themselves as apolitical because liberalism dominates academia, pop culture, news media, public schools, the arts, and libraries/museums, wherein liberalism becomes the invisible air everyone breathes. They genuinely don’t realize their own bias.
Conservatives need to get over their shock and incredulousness over the fact that in the public and business spheres there are now two sets of rules, one for them and one for everyone else.
People amazed at the targeting of a Frederick Douglass statue shouldn’t be. Mob anger doesn’t stop to draw distinctions. It is the entirety of the American past that is under fire, the memorialization of giants that irritates vandals who know they will never be heroes.
There is no better time for liberal arts colleges to return to traditional classical education—apps at those colleges that have one are climbing (while colleges pursuing the Woke bandwagon are scrambling).
I'm proud to announce that Gov. Ron DeSantis has appointed me to the Board of Trustees of the New College of Florida.
My ambition is to help the new board majority transform New College into a classical liberal arts institution.
We are recapturing higher education.
Wonder if Senator Sasse can work up the same righteous anger over the dossier, collusion, impeachment, Critical Race Theory throughout the Executive Branch, media suppression of Biden info, rioters running loose, Big Tech bias, ...
The lies of the press operate first at the level of diction. Note the wording of the gargantuan dogpile from Congress as a “relief bill.” If you accept their definitions, you lose the capacity to refute.
Barack Obama did something terrible to liberals. He made them believe that they transcended politics. Then, when they lost the political battle of 2016, they had no mental equipment with which to cope with it except RESIST.
The move by Texas is exactly the kind of audacity found in full on the left (and to great success) and disparaged on the right (to their endless defeat).
The most irritating thing about virtue signaling was identified by some French guy 350 years ago: "Virtue would not go so far if PRIDE did not keep it company." (La Rochefoucauld).
The reason liberals are crazy over the Court right now goes back 40-50 years, when they won the Culture War resoundingly. Ever since, they’ve believed they have History and Justice in their side, and regard any opposition to them as a violation of the proper Order of Things.
It is distressingly clear that Republican politicians have no idea of how to wage cultural debate, nor do they understand that if you can’t win a cultural debate, your politics are doomed.
To conservatives: please stop complaining about double-standards and special pleading and left wing hypocrisy. We know, we know, we got it. Now, tell us what to do. What are YOU doing?
Amazing how Republican leaders still haven’t learned that this is a rhetorical game created by the left—rhetorical in the old sense of putting one side on the permanent defensive, always in the shadow of accusation, ever vulnerable to denunciation. We’re tired of it.
I agree with
@SenatorTimScott
statement about President Trump needing to make it clear Proud Boys is a racist organization antithetical to American ideals.
(1/2)
Every time a Republican politician sits down with a liberal journalist and believes he can get his message out and win the colloquy, he plays the other side’s game.
It is downright absurd to refer to “the GOP’s culture war”—leftists have been pushing culture warfare for five plus decades, and whenever conservatives show slightest resistance, leftists frame it as right-wing kulturkampf aggression (and a good portion of the populace buys it).
The
@washingtonpost
has published 10 articles attacking my work and playing language games with critical race theory.
But they cannot hide the truth: CRT is a reductive, neo-Marxist ideology that seeks to divide us into "oppressor-oppressed," then subvert the Constitution.
This knowledge-neutrality is not conservative and it is not traditional and it is not effective. It is fundamental liberal philosophy, it is self-defeating, and it is a big reason why leftists have managed to take over primary and secondary education.
What Mr. Rufo is exposing here in the Federal government is what was happening in academia 30 years ago. If it isn’t stopped, we know where it will lead.
Critical race theory is becoming the federal government's default ideology.
In new whistleblower documents, I've discovered that the National Credit Union Administration hired diversity consultant Howard Ross to train 8,900 employees on "white supremacy."
Let's unpack it. 👇
Women earn more bachelors degrees, master’s degrees, and doctorates than men, are roughly 50-50 in med school and law school, but be prepared for four years of this nonsense.
For 50 years, Republicans sit and watch while the left takes over the entire education system and culture sphere, and the industries that go along with them, and when the progressive masters start exerting their partisanship, conservatives are surprised and dismayed.
@realchrisrufo
"Risk calculations" is exactly the right frame for broaching the woke turn in corporations. Activists hit them awhile ago when no conservative counter-pressure existed. We now have a new equation.
Liberalism used to mean:
—-color-blind society
—-free speech
—-right to privacy
—-equal treatment
—-freedom of conscience
—-pluralism of opinion
The Woke Revolution tears them all down, and liberals have raised barely a whisper of objection.
Any academic who’s been around for a few decades should get little credit for coming out against DEI only now. The identity game has been alive and well on campus for a long time, largely because of the silence of so many liberals who knew better all along.
It is time to start viewing the United States through the lens of Gibbon on decline and Nietzsche on degeneration, and to marvel at the moderate liberal’s blindness to our civilizational collapse.
For 5 decades, conservatives have been told that identity liberalism cannot be stopped. Taxes can go down, regulations cut, but identity politics goes on! Chris Rufo and Trump officials have broken the hold of that myth.
BREAKING: OMB Director
@RussVought45
is terminating critical race theory programs left and right. He just shut down the EPA, the VA, and the State Department—without breaking a sweat. ⚔️
Progressives made pronouns, acronyms, and identity labels loaded and highly political, and conservatives made a terrible mistake when they laughed and said, "Ya gotta be kidding." The left appreciates the power of words and symbols much more than the right.
At this point, any Red State governors who allow DEI to continue in public institutions have no claim to the conservative mantle. (In truth, Blue State governors who allow it have no claim to the traditional liberal mantle, either.)
The problem with anti-misinformation policies lies not with the bare idea of them—the problem is the people who will end up judging what is misinformation and what isn’t.
Don't forget that the institutional body that justified and guided the dictatorial powers of the French Revolutionaries was called the "Committee of Public Safety."
Small businesses are being wiped out by the thousands. Millions of people plunged into economic catastrophe. Yet somehow this is hardly discussed. We all pretend it isn’t happening. I’ve never seen a crisis of this magnitude so thoroughly ignored.
Remember that Mr Brooks strongly endorsed Sonia Sotomayor for the Supreme Court, and she has proven a vigorous identity politician. Establishment conservatives destroyed traditional conservatism long before Mr. Trump came along.
I’ve just watched populism destroy traditional conservatism in the G.O.P. I’m here to tell you that Bernie Sanders is not a liberal Democrat. He’s what replaces liberal Democrats.
Senator Tom Cotton has asked that the Southern Poverty Law Center’s tax-exempt should be reviewed. What the IRS will find is $500 million in assets, much of it parked off-shore, and a standard procedure of vilifying conservatives.
When I was in grad school, radicals always talked about not being “coopted”—absorbed by The Machine. Today, Woke radicals eagerly enter the elite and use the power they’re given to advance the institution in the name of “diversity—and the elite protect themselves all the way.
Lots of places are making Diversity, Inclusion, and Equity task forces now. I bet most of these have among their plans to be made a permanent feature.
Think.
Fact check: there is someone ultimately accountable for our actions as a company, and that’s me. Please leave our employees out of this. We’ll continue to point out incorrect or disputed information about elections globally. And we will admit to and own any mistakes we make.
Today Gov Cuomo linked me with the “religious right” for being pro-life. This is something new from him. He didn’t call me “religious right” when seeking my help with the minimum wage increase or prison reform. Read my full blog here:
@realchrisrufo
We now have a Grub Street class of scripted race baiters on the left whose words, no matter how dressed-up in pseudo-theoretico-critical diction, would have disgusted liberals a mere 15 years ago, but now pass as astute commentary.
Is this a historically unprecedented situation: the leaders of a nation revile the very nation that they lead? How about college presidents who condemn their own campuses? And military leaders who denounce their own branches?...
@NAChristakis
@realchrisrufo
DEI mandates are contrary to academic freedom and peer review. We have a situation in which the academic bureaucracy violates academic norms. These are not “deficits.” They are destructions.
The argument that the radical left is giving the election to Donald Trump forgets that before Covid and the Woke protests, the President was looking awfully good.
@realchrisrufo
Some of the very best novels and memoirs of the 20th c. never show up on college syllabi because they are conservative, which doesn't count as banning because liberals, being in charge of the institutions, may simply act as if they don't exist. No overt removal need happen.
All day tomorrow, and every day after that, teams of leftists will be hard at work planting leftist ideology into public, and many private, schools. What are conservatives and Republicans doing about it? Very little.
The Woke Revolution is now in the streets, but it’s been happening among professors, on local school boards, in Human Resources, in foundation board rooms, through state commissions, within professional associations, and in many other zones under the radar for a long, long time.
Terms such as “the illiberal right” aren’t firmly attached to real objects. They are tokens moved about by liberals who can’t absorb the collapse of liberalism before their very eyes, and so resort to pathological uses of words disconnected from referents.
The fault line in this culture war is authoritarianism and illiberalism vs their opposites. The illiberal right is conspicuously pernicious, and we need to maintain vigilance that the response to leftwing institutional capture is not rightwing institutional capture.
If people who voted for Joe Biden are now astounded at his first orders and regs, that shows how little the press did their basic job of informing Americans of the Dem platform and Biden’s plans.
If you compare secondary/college syllabi in the humanities from decades ago to today, you'll see huge shifts toward contemporary materials, a trend usually justified by "relevance," "diversity," or "meeting the kids where they are." Result: gross cultural illiteracy.
One thing I noticed about my hard left colleagues in academia: they weren’t the best scholars and teachers, but they were masterful at getting on committees and directing policies and personnel.
While eradicating DEI from institutions, conservatives must not make the mistake of affirming "genuine" diversity and "authentic" multiculturalism. These are not the antidotes to identity politics.
The coming political battle will pit liberals with some remaining loyalty to the First Amendment against the Woke left. The Biden Administration will be the theater of conflict. Conservatives will play a negligible role.
In the 70s and 80s, humanities critics relentlessly spoke of the necessity of showing how objective, neutral practices were no such thing, that ideological content was buried beneath a guise of “common sense.” This was considered the very essence of critique. Where’s it gone?
It's amusing that liberal writers will say "conservatives take over a progressive college and will harm institutional neutrality," without realizing that, by saying "progressive college," they are betraying the fact that institutional neutrality is a myth. They don't even see it.
@realchrisrufo
The way in which liberal academics who claim to prize dissent and protect freedoms have caved to illiberal practices of Woke and kept their mouths shut and heads down is a lot less surprising that one might think.
Conservatives have witnessed hundreds of universities, dozens of corporations, the tech companies, media firms, and professional organizations one by one team up to renounce what conservatives hold dear. And now, for once, a group of red states unifying to fight back...?
No, it is not good news, it is just less bad news, because the publicity and the spectacles that followed the “discovery” served the purposes of certain parties.
BREAKING: The nation's largest teachers union has approved a plan to promote critical race theory in all 50 states and 14,000 local school districts.
The argument that "critical race theory isn't in K-12 schools" is officially dead.
In the old days, professors assumed their main role was to be stewards of tradition. They were the guardians of greatness passing it along to the young. Critique was an important, but minor part of their duties. The roles have reversed now--no, it's worse: it's all critique.
The inability of Republicans to defend America is a direct result of the right giving the humanities up to the left in the 70s and going all in on law and economics.
Tim Cook's dishonesty was on full display during the Indiana RFRA controversy, and recall, too, that he gave big bucks to the execrable Southern Poverty Law Center after Charlottesville.
If Tim Cook decides to force Twitter off the App Store while preventing Chinese protestors from communicating via Airdrop, the destruction of Apple’s monopoly power will have to become the top priority of our party
After the Trustees of New College Florida ended the "gender studies" concentration, commentators assumed that the motivation was--and could only be--political. They're wrong. There is a specific academic-theoretical argument to be made:
In discussing the merits of the Texas suit, don’t overlook the political impact of all the states joining in. This tells the Court that a good portion of the country is deeply unhappy. Allegations of mischief can no longer be attributed merely to a bunch of cultists and crazies.
For infants and toddlers, the experience of gazing at entire faces, reading expressions and discerning others' inner feelings, and relating what they infer to what goes on inside themselves, is absolutely crucial to healthy development. Masks prevent this from happening.
When liberal academics eliminated Western Civ requirements, it was not called a case of “banning.” As Huck Finn disappears from syllabi, we are not asked to understand it as book banning.
In 1997, I asked a colleague in American Studies what was the single focus that united all the disparate parts of her field. She answered, “Against American Exceptionalism.”
@realchrisrufo
Yes, it is very important to realize that DEI and empirical facts clash—inevitably. It relies on cliches and taboos (“Diversity is our strength”) that do not hold up to inquiry, and never will.
Tucker Carlson just gave an incisive speech advising the Republican Party to set family at the very center of its platform. Not tax cuts, not the market, not limited govt, but family.
This is customary method of a leftist: to work within a system, push it and pressure it and abuse it until it stops you, then to declare the whole shebang “illegitimate.”
John Roberts was NOT happy with
@EWarren
's nasty question about whether the legitimacy of SCOTUS (and Roberts himself) would be sullied if there are no witnesses in the Senate trial
Here's how important the humanities once were: in Jan 87 at Stanford, after Jesse Jackson spoke, the marchers didn't denounce Reagan, Republicans or capitalism. No, they attacked the local humanities requirement, "Western Culture" ("Hey hey, ho ho, Western Culture's got to go!").
This is the presumption of liberals—we aren’t political, we’re just intelligent, clear-sighted, evidence-based—and the really remarkable thing is that they actually believe it.
"The truth is that most of what is presented today as sociological knowledge to college students, in Florida and everywhere else, is straightforward political propaganda from the far Left."
Do DC Republican leaders realize that Republican voters are a lot more angry at them than they are at AOC, Nancy P, Chuck S, Joe B, Kamala H...? Incensed and infuriated, fed up and feeling like chumps, and unwilling and unlikely to forget?
And do people know that many Republicans are backing a bill that will hand Ed schools $150 million per year to train civics teachers?
To Combat Woke Classrooms, Go to the Source: University Education Programs
Who in the Trump Administration should be told of this nonsense? Is there a Republican Senator willing to stand up and declare the whole idea of “diversity training” a pernicious exercise of thought control?
To stop this, we must call this out for what it is: racism masquerading as antiracism.
President Trump should immediately issue an executive order banning federal contracts that teach the toxic principles of critical race theory, race essentialism, and neo-segregationism.
/end
In my long experience in academia as both liberal and conservative, the most exclusionary personalities I encountered were the ones praising “inclusion” the loudest, and the most coercively conformist egos were the ones calling for more “diversity.”
Anyone who thinks it is Donald Trump who has radicalized the left has not paid any attention to what has been happening in academia, Silicon Valley, newsrooms, and the arts/entertainment world for the last 25+ years.
Anyone who thinks that the moderates in the Democratic Party will curb the leftists in the Party and the Biden Administration hasn’t been paying attention for the last 20 years.
It is clear that the elimination of Western Civ courses was not for a rich diverse multiculturalism. Kids know little more of other traditions than they did before, but they know a lot less about the great works, ideas, events, and people of the West. That was the precise aim.