In cities,
@elonmusk
's hatred of sharing space with strangers is a luxury (or pathology) that only the rich can afford. Letting him design cities is the essence of elite projection.
To summarize Elon Musk's views on transit: It's terrible. You might be killed. Japanese trains are awful. Individualized transport for everyone! Congestion? Induced demand? Climate change impacts? Unwalkable streets? Who cares!
Every time I point out that efficient public transit relies on people walking to a stop, someone asks how I factor in the weather. And yet the data always show us that people do walk to public transit in all kinds of climates, from Edmonton to Singapore. 1/
Elon Musk at the
@FT
conference just now: “I have to say the this this notion of induced demand is one of the single dumbest notions I've ever heard in my entire life."
Nationalize Greyhound and merge with
@Amtrak
perhaps? Maybe the US should have an intercity public transit system where rail and bus work together, just as they do in effective urban networks.
Nationalize Greyhound. A publicly owned intercity bus service with dedicated highway lanes could do for travelers what the US Postal Service does for letters and packages: let them criss-cross the country cheaply and quickly at their own convenience.
This is the most common anti-transit statistic in the US. Most Americans have no access to useful public transit, so the rate of ridership among all Americans is meaningless.
Let’s add one nuance to this popular cartoon. The dude in his car taking 1/3 of the street space might also be a victim of oppression. He might be a low-income person who’s forced to own and drive a car for lack of options, and who is poorer as a result … 1/
While our staff is working at home, we'll be paying them US$200/month "rent" (as a bonus) for the use of their personal space. Should this be a standard practice?
The more people use cars, the worse cars work. The more people use transit, the better transit works. (Exceptions for extreme urban crowding, but true across most urban/suburban settings.)
A provocative term. Carsplaining: When urban mobility and safety is explained by someone who never uses public transport or a bike, and walks only to get to their car. Hmm.
Carsplaining. Cuando alguien que no usa el transporte público ni la bici y solo camina cuando tiene que llegar a su auto, te explica sobre movilidad urbana y seguridad vial.
Being called an idiot by
@elonmusk
caused a 15% increase in Twitter followers and sustained 500% growth in blog traffic. He's welcome to call me an idiot as often as he likes.
Elon Musk yesterday:
"In cities that are congested we've got to do something about extreme traffic, which is some combination of double-deckering freeways and building tunnels."
Policy advice that is clearly unrelated to his roles at Tesla & Boring Co.
When New York’s 14th St. was closed to cars the traffic didn’t divert to other streets. It simply disappeared. 14th St. is now a fast street for buses and the occasional truck, and a much nicer place to be.
For almost a decade, Important People have told me that we shouldn't make major investments in public transit because we're about to have self-driving cars.
Uber would like to remind you that their business model relies on increasing congestion and emissions, by shifting people from public transit to private cars.
At the
@APTA_info
conference, a Vancouver, Canada public transit planner said that they keep increasing frequencies to address overcrowding, but it just induces more ridership so the crowding comes back. We haven't begun to saturate the market for fixed route bus service in…
The universal advice that public transit is dangerous during Covid appears to be wrong. I have to wonder if this idea spread so fast only because it fits with prevailing anti-urban cultural prejudices.
@JSadikKhan
@transitcenter
"Forcing people out of their cars?" I would expect this line from Breitbart but not from a
@nytimes
writer. The point of transit oriented development is to stop forcing people into cars. The point is to give people choices; no forcing required.
Spectacular ridership recovery in Vancouver, Canada. Back to 80% of pre-pandemic. Why? A network optimized for the all-day, all-direction, all-purpose trips that people are making now.
Some quick notes about Chile's amazing new Minister of Transport,
@JuanCaMunozA
. Chile is reinventing itself as few countries dare to do, and I am so optimistic about the country's future.
“It turned out that driving a car was still faster than a
#RapidBus
while on the road, but all the extra things you have to do taking your own vehicle add up...
It may not be scientific, but on day one... the
#RapidBus
lived up to its name”
@j_mcelroy
RT if you agree that transit-riders should never have to be stuck in traffic. There is more than enough space on our roads to move busses and trains quickly, even during peak hours.
We need to start building dedicated transit lanes now.
Slip lanes encourage cars to speed around corners right where they should be watching for pedestrians. They also push bus stops further from the intersection, requiring longer walks. Except for a few places where buses need them to turn, they're hard to defend.
"Rather than design a transportation system to get the most out of America’s cities, America redesigned the cities to get the most out of the automobile." —Richard Moe
ban
#SlipLanes
Traffic engineers: Please stop designing decoratively curved pedestrian paths. People walking are in a hurry too, and people in a hurry walk in straight lines.
(or as
@lennartnout
would say, "Go home, traffic engineer, you're drunk!")
@kaitlancollins
This is not an apology. In an apology, you are very specific about what you did wrong, and to whom, and what that caused, and why you're sorry.
At Mimico GO, I just missed my train. Thankfully, today’s brand new 15-minute weekend service on the Lakeshore West Line means that you don’t really need to check a schedule - you just show up and ride!
Great job
@GOtransit
!
Like so much journalism about
@uber
, this piece is long on drama but never quite says the most important thing: You always need one driver hour per customer hour. So growth is irrelevant to profitability. The model will never scale. (1/)
Calgary refutes every US stereotype about what a high transit city looks like. It's sprawling. It's culturally associated with cowboys and oil drilling. To help its SUV drivers feel they are in touch with nature, its freeways are called trails. And yet ...
I say this all the time but here is a good reminder. Calgary has incredible transit ridership. More than Chicago, Boston, San Francisco or Washington. We are one of the best transit cities in the US and Canada. Let’s build on that!
I go to art museums in every city I visit, so I can be jaded, but I was floored by Kansas City's
@nelson_atkins
. Not huge, but every thing is excellent, all cleanly organized by period/region for an easy chronological browse. Curation serves the art, not vice versa. 10 stars.
Rush-hour commuter rail systems like Chicago's Metra will be challenging to convert to all-day operation, but there's no other way to make them relevant -- Chicago Sun Times.
This. US city gov'ts often pass the buck by saying they don't control transit, but if you control land use and streets, you control transit at least as much as the transit agency does.
City governments set the table for public transit’s success. TransitCenter’s *All Transportation is Local* guidebook is a monster policy menu for city leaders
San Francisco abolishes minimum parking requirements for development, following Minneapolis's similar action last week. Parking requirements make housing unaffordable and lock in car-dependence.
1/ It's official: by a 7-4 vote,
#SF
Board of Supervisors gives final passage to an ordinance abolishing all minimum
#parking
regulations, and thereby votes to make our fair city less congested, less polluted, more beautiful and more affordable.
Yes! Paris wins the court case allowing them to ban cars from the banks of the river, so it can be a space for people walking, or just existing. Great news.
Chères Parisiennes, chers Parisiens, je suis très heureuse de vous annoncer que la Justice nous a donné raison et que les
#berges
de Seine sont définitivement piétonnes. C’est grâce à vous et à votre mobilisation. Merci ! Vive le Parc Rives de Seine et vive
#Paris
!
#BergesDeSeine
Uber and Lyft can appear cheap because drivers rely on tips. Public transit drivers with labor contracts don’t need tips, because agencies pay them decently. Great
@DKThomp
piece about the fake meritocracy of tipping.
@APTA_Transit
Amazing post suggesting that Vancouver, Canada should envy our transit in Portland, Oregon. Portland's light rail is adorable but painfully slow across downtown. Vancouver's driverless rapid transit is underground downtown and is far more frequent ... (1/)
As I study this Portland Oregon train/tram map I can't help but think we may have made a terrible mistake in Vancouver building underground subways and SkyTrain. Hopefully we will build light rail to UBC and elsewhere throughout the region.
Tfw a publication you trust on topics you don't know well publishes a deeply ignorant piece about a topic you know well. It devastates my ability to trust. (If it's satire, it needed clearer markers)
@JeffreyGoldberg
@JamesFallows
@dccdudley
(1/)
It’s not a tale of two cities, just two views of the same the street.
One from people who need to move through the city regularly & the other from that uncle in the suburbs who likes moving in a giant metal box, no matter the setting.
"Residents of affordable housing are not often well served by basic transit service, with only a third of respondents reporting that most neighborhoods with high levels of affordable housing had transit service with 30-minute frequency or less."
@MZStrat
US traffic engineers have discovered roundabouts, but these big ones don't belong in cities. They force pedestrians to cross with a poor line of sight and too high a traffic speed, and they push bus stops much too far from the intersection. (1/2)
Today marks the start of National Roundabouts Week! Did you know that modern roundabouts can dramatically reduce severe crashes? Learn how here:
#RoundaboutsWeek
There's absolutely no room in the urbanist movement for conservatives.
The fight for equitable, climate conscious cities, worker's rights, reproductive rights, racial justice, wealth equality, and LGBTQ rights are all the same fight.
It's the fight for our future.
A double bus lane can reliably move ~150 buses per hour with various stopping patterns. An important tool where many bus services converge. Proud to have worked on one of these in Minneapolis.
@NateSilver538
Actually, this is ranked choice voting working exactly as intended. Nothing about these mailers is frustrating the people’s right to make their own choices, including taking cues from leaders that they trust.
Every plague in history has briefly boosted the argument against cities. But in the long run, density solves so many problems, and meets so many human and economic needs, that the city is always reborn.
@mattyglesias
Wrong. The added capacity is inducing movement, which is not the same as access to actual destinations that is the real purpose of most travel. for example, freeways will induce things to be built further apart, increasing the need for movement without increasing access.
Auckland, New Zealand is on track to *double* public transport ridership over 10 years. They did it with rail frequency upgrades, one great busway, and a total bus network redesign that I was honored to be part of. h/t
@AklDesignChamp
Motorists: Imagine a freeway where every exit is marked not by where it goes, but by the name of some corporation, and the signs keep changing every few years as naming deals expire and corporations merge. Would that help you find your way around?
No endorsement implied, but has a US presidential candidate ever made such a strong statement about traffic violence before? Interesting to imagine how a president who was sensitive to this issue might change Federal transport spending.
Traffic violence kills thousands and injures even more Americans every year. On World Day of Remembrance for Traffic Crash Victims, I'm sending my love to the families and friends of those who have lost loved ones. It's time to
#EndTrafficViolence
.
Rome opted not only to put light rail on the surface but also, evidently blessed with more room and less congestion than Etobicoke, in many places gave it its own space
NEW: Metro says it expects to begin 24-hour bus service on 13 routes in DC on December 17. Metro says from 9:00 pm to 7:00 am the following routes will run at least every 20 minutes: 32, 33, 52, 70, 80, 92, A6/A8, B2, H4, S2, V2, W4, X2.
#wmata
If you have friends who think
@Uber
(and its competitors) will permanently transform urban transportation, here's a good read. Bottom line: Urban transportation is a low-profit industry.
I am amazed at how many technologists who supposedly want a better world are working to destroy high-efficiency public transit. The result is a world where the fortunate go fast by private taxi, and most are trapped, hopeless, and angry. That's what the math says. (6/6)
The draft relief bill in the US Congress: $15b for public transit, $21b for the aviation industry. US transit ridership is around *10 times* US airline ridership, but I guess it matters who those riders are.
We all know what it means to miss a bus by just one minute—being at least an hour late to work, school, or visiting family during the holidays.
The Bipartisan Infrastructure Law will invest in our public transit systems to ensure folks can get where they’re going.
The problem with N American “commuter rail” isn’t the planners. The whole model, manifested in both labor contracts and contracts with railroads, is built on the assumption that peak commuters are ppl who matter most. Changing all that is a big political/legal task. … 1/
@humantransit
Too many service planners, especially where the country's commuter rail systems are concerned, are stuck in the 50s, planning entirely around people commuting to work at 9 and home at 5.
If pedestrians don't have enough space, they can't do social distancing. Especially if motorists on empty streets are driving more recklessly. Narrower streets are safer streets. You can do it with Jersey barriers.
The first and last mile is a vast problem created by poor land use planning and poor pedestrian infrastructure. It must be attacked at its root cause. 1/2
Your periodic reminder that the first-last mile problem in transit is an equity issue. Connecting persons better to/from transit stops can double transit job access from lower-income census tracts.
3 minute Skytrain headways (minutes between trains) on a Sunday afternoon mean I don’t even bother running if I see a train already on the platform. The next one’s already close. As my friend
@humantransit
always reminds us, FREQUENCY IS FREEDOM. Thanks
@TransLink
.
Scooters are increasing my optimism that with more options for travel under 2 miles (3km), public transit can be allowed to specialize in faster service for longer distances. That means slightly wider stop spacing, more limited stop services.
Space efficient, point to point, and great for the 40% of our trips that are under 2 miles. Scooters are definitely a welcome part of the new mobility mix.
Seattle's transit ridership is soaring, faster than pop growth. Here's why: (a) City leadership on transit speed/reliability and transit-oriented land use (b) investment across the network, not just rail, (c) actively engaged leaders and citizens. Read whole thread:
From 2006 to 2017, people living in Seattle increased by 23%, transit ridership increased 46%, police reported traffic collisions decreased 21%, and daily traffic volumes declined slightly by 5%.
Setting speed limits at 85% of the speed people actually drive — the “85th percentile rule” — is a way of crowdsourcing the value of human life with only motorists having a voice. Here’s some of the history.
Fascinating history of the controversial "85th percentile rule" for setting US speed limits.
The "rule" can be traced to 1937, when
@NSCsafety
suggested it for rural, open roads-- not urban streets that have many users beyond automobile drivers.