My favourite reading groups, mailing lists, online courses, and sources to read/watch/engage with decoloniality / theory / feminism: 🧵
1. Reading groups:
Absolutely wow, I am speechless at the strength of the argument.
“This is the first genocide in history where people themselves are broadcasting it.”
“The world should be absolutely horrified, there is no safe space in Gaza. The world should be ashamed.”
Since 2017, the start of my PhD, I was privileged to obtain 7 Schengen visas, 1 US visa, & 2 UK visas. Each Schengen visa costs ≈ 90 GBP, and each UK visa is 700 GBP + 800 per year for health insurance. These are additional costs for the Third World scholars to be in 'the game'
Compulsory first book selfie
I am full of gratitude to my PhD supervisors, colleagues (former and current), examiners, reviewers and editors. Grateful for it to be published as part of Transitional Justice Series
Please recommend to your library
Кыргызстан - НЕ Киргизия
Туркменистан - НЕ Туркмения
(ударение) УкраИна - НЕ Укрáина (моя подруга с Украины говорит, что не должно быть созвучно с «окраина»)
Центральная Азия - НЕ Средняя Азия
Деколонизация сознания начинается с языка.
And the irony is that this country tries to “fix” and “denazify” another country. Racism exists everywhere, except that in Russia it is not even shameful; in that country, it is morally acceptable to be openly racist. No one will call off this behaviour. (11/13)
London today. Seeing a man cry with tears because of solidarity and so many people of different political stances making their stand for the oppressed was incredible. The largest protest I’ve ever been to.
I couldn’t resist 🙈:
Experts on Central Asia, after conducting 50 interviews with locals with translators, discussing co-production of knowledge, why Central Asia doesn’t need decolonisation, and why positionality is not for those who want to do objective and “real” research
I am western educated (as this is considered a move towards being “more human” in Russia and other places) and privileged in many respects. I also was privileged never to do menial work. Central Asian migrants face way worse, it's incomparable to my experience. (13/13)
@MakichyanA
Goodness gracious, I don’t know where to start… You asked - why are you racist? She basically responded - you can’t put yourself in my shoes, mind your own business. Start learning Spanish and take responsibility for your life. You can’t make this stuff up 🤦🏽♀️
It feels surreal to see the e-cover and the online page for my forthcoming first book!
Really happy to be part of Routledge Transitional Justice series!
Thank you, London, for today! The largest protest I ever attended. I’ve seen so much solidarity and praxis today - from free tea to care for one another ✊🏾🍉 People are not their governments
A woman in Russia said Central Asian people start looking more intelligent after living in Saint Petersburg, as “Saint Petersburg civilises everyone.” (10/13)
During fieldwork in Russia, people would be openly hostile to me during interviews or patronising. They would question my authority or knowledge before even hearing me speak (this is intersectional because I am a young woman). (8/13)
It took my brother over a month to find (very bad) accommodation in Moscow despite the fact he had a stable job. The advertisements in newspapers openly say: “Renting only to Slavic people.” (5/13)
Thrilled to be editing this Special Issue on 'Decolonizing the Theory and Practice of Transitional Justice' with
@S_BuckleyZistel
Pls see the Call for Abstracts - Deadline 28 February 2023
More info on the prospective journal - after collecting abstracts.
@postcolh22
Prohibition of genocide is “an absolute peremptory norm of law. Nothing justifies genocide. No exception could be made.” It would be “unthinkable” for the Court not to issue provisional measures.
First time in a long while I am not ashamed to be trained as a lawyer
When I did my fieldwork in Russia, I noticed a stark contrast in how my respondents would treat me (I am very Central Asian looking), as opposed to my colleagues from Western Europe. (2/13)
When I was on a bus with my daughter in Moscow, not saying a word and minding my own business, a woman looked at me and said: “Eww, the hairy monkeys are everywhere.” (3/13)
@EHayesdeKalaf
I very much can relate! I made friends with random strangers on the street, was offered tea in a bookshop by a shop owner, and was constantly complimented on my daughter and offered help! Truly wonderful people live in Northern Ireland 💕 best sense of humour too!
A Russian man approached me and asked, why do I study Russia. In his view, since I am from Turkmenistan, researching Russia for someone like me would be “equivalent to studying Zimbabwe.” (9/13)
Feels wrong to share but I hope I can amplify voices and causes I care about. Will be continuing my research on gender/decoloniality/Central Asia as
@NizamiOxford
Visiting Fellow. Watch this space for upcoming Book Club on postcolonial Central Asian literature! I am by grateful.
My paper on challenges and limitations of reparations in the absence of integral transitional justice processes in Russia is published in International Journal of Transitional Justice
@OUPAcademic
@OUPLaw
PM or email me if you don’t have access
@postcolh22
I would like to read more of Central Asian literature. Welcoming recommendations. What was something that you’ve read and enjoyed?
Preferably literary fiction. I do not like romance or love stories. Fine with memoirs.
Something Chinghiz Aitmatov style - but I’m open.
My mom found a tailor who upcycles vintage traditional Turkmen embroidery, and of course it merits photographs. A new trend (back to olden days) - looser-fitting traditional dresses and I love it!
My blog published. Critique of Mignolo and those who hijack decolonial agenda to justify civilizational communism, Russia's and Soviet Union's colonization and imperialism. Thank you,
@SAISReview
!
"Russia is not now and has never been a decolonial ally, and its anti-Western rhetoric does not make it any less of a colonial and imperialist country," writes
@DurdiyevaSelbi
I've put up the preprint of my chapter: "Towards Decolonial Agenda for Transitional Justice: 'The Old is Dying and the New Cannot Be Born'"
To be published as part of the 'Wretched of the Global South - Critical Approaches to International Human Rights'
Madina Tlostanova on reclaiming decoloniality, the importance of double critique, and how decolonial thinking in the past years became essentialist and lacking nuance.
A great start of the conference on decolonisation of memory
Audre Lorde. Very unlike what she usually writes. She refers to Tashkent and Samarkand as “Russia” a few times (not even the Soviet Union). She feels unease and isn’t convinced by what was “sold” to her but wants to hold on to the utopian myth, which was far from reality
Incredibly important to distinguish between coloniality and colonisation; decoloniality/decolonisation. Something many human rights and transitional justice scholars don’t do even if engage with the topic.
But…
“European colonialism” isn’t the only type of colonialism
My mother language is Qazaq. My mother missed speaking it when living away from Qazaqstan. My grandparents on my mother’s side (apa and ata) spoke Qazaq to me so I can understand the quotidian. It’s a language of music, wit, and humour, thank you for existing and persisting
Ashgabat in the late 1990s, me in the late 1990s, Stalinist times house (no longer there), a fake chimney. Things change, but the abundance of carpets is still a thing 🙌
I contributed an entry on Transitional Justice and Decolonisation for the Encyclopaedia we’re launching. Do check it out - as well as other entries - on concepts and theories! (check the one on intersectionality by
@juliagonzalezvi
!)
@postcolh22
Overjoyed by this, I am very excited about the research and also being part of an amazing team! Very grateful for this opportunity and this new chapter of my life 🙂
We are happy to welcome Selbi Durdiyeva at the
@zfk_mr
! She is interested in regime transitions, transitional & transformative justice, human rights and humanitarian law. In Marburg she is going to be a part of the research network "Postcolonial Hierarchies in Peace & Conflict"
Mignolo, this is NOT decolonisation!
Mignolo (2023!): “They [Russia and China] are simply disobeying and working on the reconstruction of their own needs and interests. They are not attacking but defending themselves from the harassment of Western design.” 🙋🏽♀️🤦🏽♀️
Conferencing now is an opportunity to talk about praxis, transnational solidarity, Fanon, the importance to take sides, genocidal drive of colonisers, and Palestine. I prefer smaller events and presenting online, though happy to see my friends in-person
Intro to German, first class.
The teacher: Which German words do you already know?
Student 1: eine Katze
Student 2: Danke
Student 3: eine Mutter
Selbi: Vergangenheitsbewältigung
“Palestinians in Gaza simply and profoundly have a right to exist.”
It’s not “simply a conflict between two parties.”
“Israel for years regarded itself as beyond and above the law”
How is it possible in 2023 to strip naked civilians before taking them into custody? This is humiliating. A reminder about prohibition of cruel, inhuman and degrading treatment both under IHRL and IHL. The videos are more disturbing, holding stripped women and men together
On the left, Gazans, today, under Israeli guns.
On the right, Kenyans, 1950s, under British guns.
Do you see? For some of us, these images, these postures, are in our genetic memories. We know what they are. Colonialism. Imperialism. Genocide.
Calling something ‘complex’ and ‘difficult’ shuts down the conversation. That’s how systemic violence persists. As academics, we shape the discourse, even if it’s a drop in the ocean. Even if it seems that no one is listening.
Watching the live stream, the historical importance of this hearing is 🙌
*They are killed if they fail to evacuate, in places where they evacuate, and while they flee*
Minimal use of audiovisual material in a respectful manner to victims
“killed with a full knowledge…”
Ladies and gentlemen, russian liberal opposition, an award-winning writer and a journalist of a newspaper that received Nobel Peace Prize. A Freedom Defender Award recipient. A member of anti-war committee.
This is all you need to know about race and racism in russia
If Gaza stays in Gaza there will be another Hamas. If it's relocated, say, to Canada, there will be Hamas in Canada. But if you send all these people to China to Uyghur re-education camps, then within ten years you'll have model Han citizens.
@olga_hepnarova_
28. Prolonged military occupation followed by illegal annexation. Establishment of settlements.
29. Arbitrary detention. Incommunicado detention. No due process rights. Cruel, inhuman and degrading treatment of detained
Decolonial is different from post-colonial because of relationship to modernity.
Postcolonialiasm takes modernity as a given; decoloniality challenges the standards set by modernity. Edward Said and G. Spivak are postcolonial. Fanon and Quijano are decolonial. 👇🏾
@yuliazagrava
I research civil society and transitional justice in Russia and why countries tend to repeat the crimes of the past if they don’t properly account for them
Delighted to have my very first ever peer-reviewed article that I wrote during the fellowship at the New School, published. It's a labor of love <3 Memory production, vandalism, violence: Civil society and lessons from a short life of a monument to Stalin'
This is the face of feminist foreign policy! Don’t dare teaching and preaching “the rest of the world” your “high ideals” if life of civilians means nothing to you. not in our name. not my feminism.
Canada, Germany, Sweden - shame
I’m learning to sketch quickly so I can do illustrations along my publications and possibly use it to document fieldwork too.
That’s one of my favourite sketches - 10 minutes for fashionable grandmas
The kindness of strangers - a woman at hotel reception let me check in 2,5 hours earlier, a man in a cafe gifted me juice, a woman in an art shop gave me a blue oil paint, a woman in a shop invited me to their event and party ❤️ Very kind people of in Berlin everywhere I go
I have a heavy heart watching videos of parents screaming for their dead children, but looking away is a privilege so I keep on watching. I am enraged, as a scholar of law of armed conflict, as a human, and mother
Not At Peace With Oneself
@SaraNAhmed
I can’t imagine this kind of question to be asked by anyone who has at least some basic understanding of: 1. History; 2. International law; 3. Politics; 4. International relations; 5. Journalism; 6. Basic human decency. The arrogance though.
@FranceskAlbs
never disappoints.
Very grateful to contribute a chapter on transitional justice and decolonisation to this volume! With an introduction by Vasuki Nesaya! Long live TWAIL! Huge thanks to Thamil and Amritha!
With great pride we can announce that our book is finally published with
@SpringerNature
-online version made available on IWD. Only made aware of the publication today by
@AVShenoy
, my great sister, friend and colleague. In that order !
Decolonisation is about uncovering the dark side of Euro-NorthAmerican-modernity. Folks who are obsessing over “being European” and “siding with the coloniser” need to understand that they aren’t decolonial. Equally, russia is a settler colonial state. I am grateful for Terrell👇🏾
I think pro-Ukraine and pro-Palestine camps,*** IN MY EXPERIENCE***, are equally insular and ignorant about each other. Both sides could stand some extensive education about each other.
I have lost friends/relationships with pro-Ukraine and pro-Palestine folk because I could not
My daughter made this, she wants to fundraise for people who are being starved in Gaza. She drew olive branches and watermelons. I explained her why we will no longer go to McDonalds or Starbucks, she understood and never asked me again.
I felt inspired and seen. A fantastic exhibition on anticolonial resistance by indigenous and migrant communities within russia. Artists are ahead of theorists and driving the theory.
In Berlin until 29 May 2023
Goodbye, une année de merde that also brought me a dream job, great people, and release of what I shouldn’t be holding on to. Wishing for peace, freedom, justice, and a little less paperwork.
You’d expect something more than “by the way, torture is not a response” from a Special Rapporteur. They cut off a person’s ear. On camera. Imagine what’s happening in incommunicado detention on illegally occupied and annexed territories by russia that we don’t see?!
#Russia
: I join my fellow
@UN_SPExperts
in condemning the terrorist attack against peaceful concert goers. Our deepest sympathies. Nothing justifies terrorism; nor is torture the response.
UN experts condemn terrorist attack on Russian concert hall
#BREAKING
US vetoes Algerian-led draft resolution that would have, inter alia, demanded an immediate humanitarian ceasefire that must be respected by all parties
IN FAVOR: 13
AGAINST: 1 (US)
ABSTAIN: 1 (UK)
Live coverage
#Israel
has had to endure barbaric terror. This terror can in no way be justified. Israel has every right to defend itself within the framework of international law. Germany stands unwaveringly by Israel's side. That is why I am travelling to Israel today. -
@ABaerbock
1/4
My mom said that as a child she couldn’t understand why so many Qazaq writers died in the 1937… Writing in any language other than russian meant it will never be published. And then comes the rhetoric how Soviet Union brought “civilisation” - they erased, killed, and imposed
Delighted to have my blog posted, on a call for decolonial agenda in transitional justice, based on my upcoming chapter. Thank you,
@FriEnt_news
@FriEnt_Blog_DwP
Humbled to contribute to the blog series along Eduardo Gonzalez
@elfjcgc
@postcolh22
This is absolutely disgraceful. Faculty and staff cannot speak up about harassment and students can’t protest.
We owe a duty of care towards our students.
Shame on you,
@univgroningen
“When you expose a problem you pose a problem” Sarah Ahmed
My first experience as a peer reviewer and I really enjoy it! I love the manuscript, learnt so much, the methodology is thorough, the writing is good, theoretical lens - interesting. Such a joy to recommend with very minor revisions and I hope it will see the light soon! 🙌
The dates and titles of the Book club of Central Asian Postcolonial Literature is out.
Reading is fighting back against erasure, we have a lot to fight back!
I’ll be including observations, notes on readings, questions for discussion. It’s soothing to talk about books 👇🏾
Join the read! One book a month the next 6 months. Book Club of Central Asian Postcolonial Literature - April - September 2024!
Hybrid - online and in- person
Read along and follow for discussion updates!
Registration link:
Dates and titles 👇🏾
Time to share this again. Genocidal drive is at core of colonial processes, especially when colonial system’s survival is at stake.
Achille Mbembe, Necropolitics (Duke University Press, 2019) p 128
@NadyaaAzerin
If you want your voice heard, wait for a foreign researcher to interview you, so you become Interviewee 19, footnote 78. But if we write auto-ethnographically, drawing on context and relationships we formed all our life - this is an essay or a memoir, not “objective research.”
@TerezaHendl
I also was super bored by his protagonists - always macho alfa males, while women were merely their objects of satisfaction. You’ve put it so well - talent for word that didn’t penetrate his patriarchal thinking.
She forgot to mention extortionist visa fees international students pay (around 3,000 per person for 3 year); also pay at least three times more the university tuition fees, no right to benefits, how they boost the staggering economy, and often write better than native-speakers
The tens of thousands coming here are not “the world’s best and brightest students”. As lecturers attest, many barely speak English, buy their essays AND bring dependents with them. It’s a con that deprives British youngsters of uni places.
No mention of how a city the size of
@DrSBorja
It is a matter of self-identification. Third World Approaches to International Law (TWAIL) is a preferred term by many scholars and I side with them.
Very happy to participate and discuss my ongoing research on how memory/experiences of coloniality configure in women’s writing in Central Asia.
For more on contested pasts, difficult victims and perpetrators, ‘implicated subjects,’ and ‘spectral inheritance’ 👇🏾
We’re happy to announce that registration for the Track 1 of the Heritage Justice II Symposium is now open!
The panels will be held virtually on 8 - 9 August (British summer time).
Please check out the programme and register at:
More details below 👇🏽
Every word is gold. This is the best address I’ve ever heard at any international forum. Straight forward, honest, founded in law, empathy, and humanity. Every word of it. It’s that simple and can be expressed in an 11 minute video.
Every minute of this epic
@UN
address from
@Palestine_UN
is worth watching. She dismantles Israel's lies and disinformation, sets out what Palestine stands for, and why it will succeed. Watch and Share!
#Gaza_War
#Gaza_Genocide
Seeing brilliance in action, fantastic
@CreativeCorazon
😻 Diana started with a note on positionality and a note on “non-space and non-time.” A wonderful mix of an incredible speaker and thinker
We studied different international law. Right “to self defence” is invoked only with respect to resort to force (ad bellum). Under jus in bello (conduct of hostilities) the actions of Israel are unjustifiable, unfounded in law, and in grave breach of international law
I spoke with Prime Minister
@Netanyahu
today. I reiterated Canada’s support for Israel and its right to defend itself, in accordance with international law. We also spoke about the need for Hamas to immediately and unconditionally release those being held hostage.
I regret reading russian literature in my formative years. Not only because of imperialism and colonialism but also a horrible image of a woman-martyr who is a footnote and decoration in men’s “heroic” fates. I hope my daughter reads Ursula LeGuin to imagine the world otherwise