Absolutely! Of every 1,000 infecteds who show symptoms, 14 will die. Highly age dependent where the risk of getting infected is 3x and then risk of dying is another 3x in 70+year-olds compared to those in their 30s.
This is NOT seasonal flu nor even 2009 pandemic flu!
Show me a seasonal flu that leads to triage of whom to let die in icus despite intense social distancing & I’ll stop worrying. Or an exponentially growing uncontrolled pathogen that infects 1% then “dissipates”. This is wishful fantasy not contrarianism. True we need more data.
Absolutely agree with
@CT_Bergstrom
Case of poor risk comms and incomplete reading of the science. and clearly show 35-44% of all infections were caused by presymptomatic shedding of index cases.
UK pandemic response will be all that much poorer without direct input of
@neil_ferguson
. He is one of the best infectious disease modellers in the world, whom UK should treasure not flog. Prurient and puritanical headlines are a malicious distraction.
An especially astute and succinct essay on
#COVID19
protective immunity
@TheLancet
today
highlights unknowns on duration, role of T lymphocytes, what constitutes real protection, and herd immunity features
Epidemiologists study health & disease conditions within populations of people. They can play a major part in establishing access to proper sanitation & hygiene services for all.
➡️ More inspiring jobs with a purpose:
#170Jobs
#HealthForAll
Since last Dec, , HK has adopted sewage surveillance to make statutory testing orders in potentially infected apartment blocks, having netted 50+ otherwise undiscovered transmission chains so far
What a waste the we are not using wastewater surveillance, capable of forecasting covid cases 3 weeks in advance
"High-throughput surveillance could greatly ameliorate comprehensive community prevalence assessments by providing robust, rapid estimates"
When we don't measure important stuff.
A thread about the immune response to
#SARSCoV2
1. Since serology/IgG can be readily measured, this is what is conventionally used to assess an individual's response
That's a very incomplete picture
This is hugely encouraging BUT it’d be important to understand whether vax prevents INFECTION (therefore transmission) or just SYMPTOMATIC DISEASE. Cold chain storage and distribution will also be a major challenge.
We welcome today's announcement from
@Pfizer
/
@BioNTech_Group
with interim data from their Phase III clinical trial indicating 90% effectiveness of their
#COVID19
vaccine candidate.
Full statement from our CEO, Dr Richard Hatchett, on our website:
Work led by
@bencowling88
sharing the HK experience using flu surveillance as parallel proxy to show likely effectiveness of interventions against COVID-19. If HKers can do it against our background of social unrest during the past 9 months, so can the world! In solidarity.
Very important new study on impact of non-pharmaceutical interventions against
#COVID19
and influenza in Hong Kong by
@gmleunghku
team
More evidence that
#coronavirus
can be mitigated by social distancing and behavioral changes short of draconian measures
Just out: COVID-19 vaccine trials primarily assess prevention of virologically confirmed disease; NOT infection or transmission. An “effective” vax confers protection from disease but might not reduce spread...1/5
Haven’t had a chance to look closely at this preprint about
#covid19
in Israel, but interesting to see that their model "indicates that
#SARSCoV2
transmission dynamics were driven by an extremely high level of viral superspreading”. Looks like evidence is accumulating.
Of every 1,000 infecteds who show symptoms, 14 will die. Highly age dependent where the risk of getting infected is 3x and then risk of dying is another 3x in 70+year-olds compared to those in their 30s. Protect older adults!
We in
@CCDD_HSPH
were proud to support the
@hkumed
team led by Joe Wu, Kathy Leung, and
@gmleunghku
on the work reported in this new preprint on severity and transmission of
#COVID
ー19 in Wuhan
Absolutely delighted to be joining
@wellcometrust
board to help further its mission and recently announced strategy on mental health, infectious diseases and global heating
When we have serosurveys results that can clarify whether children are sufficiently infective to warrant school closures - that’s why they’re so so important
Thanks
@EricTopol
for shoutout…I’ve put together a thread here to explain in a little more detail about this and another recent preprint on inpatients...
1st report of real-world effectiveness of Paxlovid in the outpatient setting, BA.2 wave, Hong Kong
75% reduced death, 31% reduced hospitalization, 53% reduced adverse outcomes
No impact of vaccination on outcomes; superior to Molnupiravar impact
@hkumed
Our original results are NO LONGER VALID given that the reported no of exported cases have essentially doubled from 24 hrs ago when the model was completed. Reconfiguring model but expect multiples of the first estimates in a nonlinear way.
4/
#nCoV2019
"...Shanghai, Chongqing, Guangzhou & Shenzhen during this period. If SSEs were observed in the nosocomial or community settings, our statistical tool can accurately predict the final outbreak size w/in 2-5 days after 3 or more cases of the cluster has been observed."
This is one of the most succinct and best written short pieces on herd immunity, what it is and where we are heading with
#COVID19
.
If not comfortable with math, just get through the first sentences and it’s worth continuing the read.
The John Ioannidis story.
The consummate physician-researcher who "wrote that the virus might claim only 10,000 lives in the United States"
by
@PeteJamison
Simple function of an R0=2-2.5 with mass action homogeneous mixing dynamics. The attack rate of 70-80% is meaningless per se because one needs to understand 1) over what time period this could happen and 2) severity of infection. Then we can make informed decisions to mitigate.
Well done Singapore! If only all health protection agencies could emulate your professional competence and transparency from the first imported cases, until there becomes too many cases to count
Again, many many thanks for everyone’s very kind support. I was tested given my recent proximity to people leading the UK response. Positive. Which is a strange experience - to be infected by the virus one is modelling 🙄. Still feeling rough, but not awful.
Poor Hong Kong. When the magic number R has entered everyday parlance in Europe and N America, our friends in HK are deprived of the daily pleasure of checking what the prevailing R is.
@gmleunghku
@bencowling88
😂
The morning after the dramatic change in strategy to COVID-19 by this govt, I can’t help but feel angry that it has taken almost two months for politicians and even “experts” to understand the scale of the danger from SARS-CoV-2. Those dangers were clear from the very beginning.
The threat of a severe flu season during the Covid pandemic is not a given. In fact, the Southern Hemisphere has seen dramatically lower incidences of flu this season, likely a result of public health measures such as mask-wearing and hand-washing.
Need 2 more tests:
1) viral culture to determine viability of the RNA detected by PCR
2) IgG serology
If 1 is negative and 2 shows protective titre, then the patient could be safely discharged.
Marion Koopmans, publications: https://pure.eur.nl
First real world effectiveness study of Paxlovid and Molnupiravir: significant reduction in disease progression & all-cause mortality vs matched controls, more for Paxlovid, during Hong Kong BA.2 wave. Fast viral load reduction
@CarlosWongHKU
@gmleunghku
Fatal validity threats:- 1) no IRB 2) 1 month follow up only 3) severely underpowered by assuming 50% efficacy when in fact prior evidence suggests 10-20% 4) loose serostatus ascertainment diluting magnitude of efficacy
The underpowered Danish randomized mask trial, w/ only 46% of those in the intervention group adherence, and only focused on the mask wearer (no insight about transmission) is published
@AnnalsofIM
✓ commentary by
@DrTomFrieden
and editors (why publish?)
Hong Kong is overwhelmed by
#COVID19
.
- 2,071 cases confirmed yesterday
- 4,500 more suspected
- no more room in hospitals
- huge waiting lists for care & treatment
One possible intermediate host, but the puzzle is not nearly solved...much remains to be done through the “One Health” approach to identify the zoonosis in patient(s) zero
Coronaviruses detected in a small number of pangolins smuggled into China are related to SARS-CoV-2, a Nature paper reports. The degree of similarity isn’t enough to suggest they are the intermediate hosts that are directly involved in the outbreak.
Therefore, if compulsory universal PCR testing were to be implemented under “dynamic zero-covid policy”, it should be deployed mid- to late-April when case numbers will already be at very low levels in order to truly achieve elimination, or “zero covid”…7/n
@EricTopol
@OurWorldInData
This is the fundamental driver of our fatality risk (2-dose coverage by age) - and what is not shown is that the equivalent amongst older folks in nursing homes is <20%
Another update on HK’s Omicron BA.2 (“5th”) wave nowcast and forecast (we’ve made some important methodological improvements - see for full details)…1/n
A fine fine balance between expediency and robustness. Lest we forget the fundamental motivation for rigorous peer review. All the more important for COVID-19 when potentially hundreds of millions of lives are at stake.
@bencowling88
@kjoules
We desperately need an unbiased way to keep track of case count; as well as real time estimates of case fatality, all stratified by vaccination status. Time for HK to replicate REACT and/or the ONS surveys in the UK.
Doing so earlier, especially when case numbers will still be too high to properly and appropriately isolate and care for, paying particular attention to population mental and emotional wellbeing in HK’s unique context, would not be recommended…8/n
Vaccines protect against serious complications and death, but do not work nearly as well against infection. It would have been irresponsible for a medical school sharing staff and students with a major tertiary hospital not to have issued a warning
Why there is so much concern about the positive sewage samples at Kenndey Town?
This is a study from
@zhangt1968
and
@HKU_SPH
Use of Sewage Surveillance for COVID-19: A Large-Scale Evidence-Based Program in Hong Kong
New real-world evidence on covid antivirals. Sample: all initially ambulatory covid infectees in HK during BA.2.2 surge in spring 2022. Design: 1:10 propensity-score matched retrospective cohort as primary analysis; case-control for sensitivity…1/n
V disappointing especially given HK’s early and sustained privileged access to vaccines and a full year of lead time to shield the most vulnerable groups by vaccination
@EricTopol
@OurWorldInData
This is the fundamental driver of our fatality risk (2-dose coverage by age) - and what is not shown is that the equivalent amongst older folks in nursing homes is <20%
What an auspicious day for
#InternationalDayOfWomenInScience
- day of the Lunar New Year of the Ox, and a perfect palindromic day 12.02.2021! Support women scientists by creating and maintaining a safe and happy place for them to thrive!
An eminently sensible idea that could tide over the interim before mass vaccination coverage. Time for action (or at least large scale feasibility trials) and not more endless debate. Caveat: should not be used as “passport”.
Really important statement of the proposal for massive rapid antigen testing from
@michaelmina_lab
-- with compelling replies to many different grounds for skepticism. How We Can Stop the Spread of Coronavirus by Christmas
Video review of a recent study by
@gmleunghku
and colleagues. Key take-aways: patients start shedding virus ∼2 d before symptom onset, are most infectious on the day before symptom onset and stop being infectious ∼7 days after symptom onset.
#COVID19
As always, we do not hang on to data and most certainly never during the exigency of an evolving pandemic. We released this particular set of findings within 24 hours of finalising them, and posted the full preprint within the subsequent 24 hours.
@Amine19O
@Jason42146758
@gmleunghku
The media and the scientific community have been chomping at the bit for Hong Kong’s BNT vs SV data. No way could HKU keep the data private for so long; any interim data would be of tremendous interest to the scientific community
Hats off to the heroic effort by colleagues at China CDC under Geoege Gao, Feng Zhejian and Li Jun’s leadership, as well as their provincial and municipal counterparts, to provide these first epi estimates
The study published in
@NEJM
says " there is evidence that human-to-human transmission has occurred among close contacts since the middle of December 2019". The authors of the study include Prof
@gmleunghku
, Prof
@bencowling88
, & others.
#WuhanCoronavirus
Not at all. Our message was for staff and students who can be vectors of infection for the highly vulnerable patients in our teaching hospitals. We have an extra responsibility towards those we look after, as opposed to our own risk. First do no harm.
THREAD:
Today I am announcing a new massive public health research study - with
@Citibank
- to use and evaluate frequent at-home rapid testing. The study is evaluating how well workplace infections are prevented by frequent home-tests.
1/x
“Medicine is a social science and politics is nothing else but medicine on a large scale. Medicine...has the obligation to point out problems and to attempt their theoretical solution; the politician...must find the means for their actual solution” - Rudolf Virchow 2/2
Inspiring example, and infuriating contrast. Watch Chancellor Merkel explain the fragile margin of
#COVID19
transmission dynamics, and the significance of getting R below 1 vs. allowing it to reach 1.1 or 1.2. “Thin ice.” Crisis leadership from a scientist.
5th wave has peaked on March 4. Estimated no of people infected by March 7 = 1.8M (1.0-2.7M). No of daily infections to fall below 1,000 by end Apr and to below 100 by mid May…2/n
This IHME model used to be 1840s technology (Farr’s law). Now seems more like Ptolemaic astronomy with epicycles and deferents. This from an institute whose reputation is based on GBD which is valuable iff (sic) next year is like last year. Not experienced in epidemic models.
Vaccinating double the number of people with a single dose as quickly as possible is probably the right call under the circumstances in UK. Highly contextual decision that should not be directly applied to a different setting. We have lots to learn from the UK’s trial.
@EricTopol
@OurWorldInData
This is the fundamental driver of our fatality risk (2-dose coverage by age) - and what is not shown is that the equivalent amongst older folks in nursing homes is <20%
Thanks
@Peter_Ashcroft
. We made the Correction () within 24 hrs of receiving your helpful advice. Still awaiting
@NatureMedicine
to upload - probably inundated with COVID-19 papers like every other journal!
New pre-print by John PA Ioannidis
Certain to be provocative, Ioannidis and colleagues estimate the risk of dying <65 vs >80 from COVID-19
If you disagree with the result, try to articulate what you think is wrong, AND what your estimate is.
Sigh. Developed a slight dry but persistent cough yesterday and self isolated even though I felt fine. Then developed high fever at 4am today. There is a lot of COVID-19 in Westminster.
US "has registered 159 cases in 14 states but as of March 1st it had, indefensibly, tested just 472 people when South Korea was testing 10,000/d. Now that America is looking, it is sure to find scores of infections—and possibly unearth a runaway epidemic."
Unlike most places with privileged access to vaccines, HK did not manage to persuade our elderly to get jabbed for over a year despite having prioritised them - This has left us in our present v vulnerable situation
Apparent divergence with the UK of the “decoupling” between cases and severe complications/deaths is worrying. Carries massive implications not only for US, but potentially other places that are relatively immunologically naive (low prior infection +/- vax), incl HK where I live
Well done everybody
@hkumed
- while research metrics are often fraught with interpretation challenges, you should feel proud of these results that are hard earned by your dedication and inspiration. THANK YOU!
Over 70% of
@HKUMed
’s research projects assessed deemed to be “world leading” or “internationally excellent” by 🇭🇰’s University Grants Committee in the Research Assessment Exercise 2020.
Thank you to our
#academics
and
#scholars
for making this possible!
The 2 conditions are:-
1) >=2 jabs coverage >90% amongst 70+, esp those in nursing homes
2) sufficient supply and liberal use of Paxlovid for all infected 70+, those with serious chronic conditions or immunocompromised, and those who live in homes for the aged or disabled
It has taken several generations of researchers to bring this about: the late Anthony Hedley since the late 1980s, TH Lam since the 1990s to the present, Sarah McGhee, Sophia Chan through the 2000s to her current role as minister, and most recently Kelvin Wang and Michael Ni
We welcome the passing of a bill to ban e-cigarettes and heated tobacco in Hong Kong.
“It is especially crucial now that we work in tandem with support from the general public to one day achieve the aspiration of a smoke-free city" said Prof
@gmleunghku
Quite! Proud that
@DFisman
and I went to school in that city three decades ago, but feel sad for those whose health is now supposedly guarded by the author of that thread
Simple comparison of observed to expected exported cases of
#nCoV
suggests Indonesia, Thailand and perhaps Cambodia may be missing cases. New preprint
@CCDD_HSPH
w Pablo Martinez de Salazar
@NeneRiehus
Aimee Taylor
@Caroline_OF_B
Estimating an absolute risk at the start of a pandemic is like estimating the absolute risk of dying within three days after a cancer diagnosis. Not false but not either serious or sensible
New
#COVID19
Comment suggests that early comparisons between the number of cases in the worst affected European countries and in west African countries do not support the hypothesis that the virus will spread more slowly in countries with warmer climates
In👇, we ask whether the novel antivirals work in hospitalised inpts (comprising nursing home residents and already hospitalised pts due to nosocomial infection, in addition to the small % of ambulatory infectees who require admission)? - a Q unaddressed in original trials…1/n
First real world effectiveness study of Paxlovid and Molnupiravir: significant reduction in disease progression & all-cause mortality vs matched controls, more for Paxlovid, during Hong Kong BA.2 wave. Fast viral load reduction
@CarlosWongHKU
@gmleunghku
First generation vaccines very much needed BUT they are only one tool of many in the overall response. Unlikely to be the ultimate silver bullet many are expecting...5/5
What’s behind the recent surge in COVID fatalities in Hong Kong? What does Omicron mean for zero-COVID approaches?
@gmleunghku
joins
@gavincleaver
and
@jessamybagenal
to discuss the last few months of COVID in Hong Kong on a new
#LancetVoice
NYC: I need you to stay home.
It is our civic responsibility to make sure we do all we can to stave off this
#COVID19
pandemic, and that means staying home.
It doesn't matter if you have a test or not, because what your doctor will ask you to do will be the same:
#StayHomeNYC
.
Absolutely! Of every 1,000 infecteds who show symptoms, 14 will die. Highly age dependent where the risk of getting infected is 3x and then risk of dying is another 3x in 70+year-olds compared to those in their 30s.
This is NOT seasonal flu nor even 2009 pandemic flu!
Contact tracing including pets: evidence from
@hkumed
of reverse inter species spread from infected humans to dogs. Question about spread back to humans or other mammals remains.
A study in Nature reports 2 infected dogs out of 15 households with confirmed cases of
#COVID19
. Genetic sequences of the viruses from the dogs were identical to the virus detected in the human cases, suggesting human-to-animal transmission of SARS-CoV-2.
A v sensible policy that HK amongst other places should emulate, albeit further buttressed by a protective antibody titre as it continues to aim for zero covid