“They sit in their mansions, powdered and perfumed, gorging on sweet meats and Madeira” #, fondling their concubines, and pronounce on the irresponsibility of the huddled masses who are to blame for the Black Death”.
Why migrants leaving Delhi ? For want of money or food ? NO. Just irresponsible. There is no money/ jobs waiting for them back home. It’s to utilise their forced ‘chutti’ to catch up with their families or errands back home. Gravity of situation hasn’t dawned on them.
@Si_lv_er
I must speak as a citizen . She abuses martyr Karkare, celebrates the assassin of Gandhi . She is a Lok Sabha Candidate? politicians from all parties not mobilising to end this? Apology is enough?
Your silence is complicity.
Act together to save the republic. If you can.
I have been warning about this but government is sunk in a self congratulatory decadent stupor, lapping up praise from cheerleading courtiers, who design opulent celebratory events, slogans and campaigns to gloss over the serious problems before us and trivialise policymaking.
I am director of NIPFP.
This is my street. I can confirm that these Indians have no food beyond today. PWD please pay them a months wages at once,or organise for their food and hygiene needs.
@ArvindKejriwal
if NIPFP can help with our lockdown limited logistics please direct us
Satsang Vihar Marg,
#NewDelhi
67, nr Delhi Archives. 45-50 people, families of migrant workers frm Jhansi, PWD casual workers. No work, No pay. No food for more than a day. And no way to go back home. Many like this in Delhi.
@CMODelhii
@ArvindKejriwal
@PMOIndia
#Covid_19india
Ashwaniji, respectfully disagree. In London I’ve seen Israeli afghan Iranian Burmese Pakistani American students protest. In 1980s South African Korean students. Indian students protested against Emergency in 1975
The inferiority complex lies in suppressing student dissent
I don’t know Swami ji, but he is talking sense, that while abroad no other country’s students demonstrate against their govts, but Indian students do. Because we suffer from inferiority complex. Request Indian diaspora, stop cursing India and if possible build good image of India
The police must break their habit of hitting people indiscriminately It is the WRONG thing to do in these circumstances and can lead to social unrest. STOP IT AT ONCE.
@DelhiPolice
I saw this morning with my own eyes a rickshaw and my local fruit vendor being roughed up. 110067
Rathin Roy PhD (Cambridge).
India citizen
Ali Cheema PhD (Cambridge). Pakistan citizen
Scholarship students ordinary background
31 years of friendship, collegial affection.
We can still meet without being lynched
Thank you, London the melting pot of the subcontinent ♥️
Why has delhi govt banned the movement of fresh chicken and other meats from local farms? Dera farms, a 40 year outlet has been denied a pass to move produce. Fish are rotting. Why is Delhi Govt needlessly destroying the supply chain and local economy?
@ArvindKejriwal
@LtGovDelhi
What nonsense. First tax rich states and transfer to poor states now prevent them from investing further in human development? Is the government of India determined to drag everyone to the level of the bigoted least common denominator?
This is unacceptable
@ptrmadurai
TamilNadu can't add more medical colleges: National Medical Commission (NMC)
Reasons given by NMC
1. There should be uniform distribution of doctors across the country. The recommended ratio of doctors is 1:1000 and TN already has 1 per 600 population,
2. Medical colleges shall…
I had no idea that a country had a market capitalisation. In which market is the price of Bharat to be auoted? Which entity has valued the price of my country at 300 lakh crores?
Ten years ago, our country’s market capitalisation stood at only Rs 74 lakh crores. It has doubled every five years since then and has reached 300 lakh crores today. It is now ranked fifth among the 10 most valued countries.
- Smt
@nsitharaman
. (1/n)
This is an exercise in erudite brilliance from someone who is emerging as a major economic statesman of our country.
In this thread I am going to quote what I consider to be key points of political economy from the article:
🧵
My article on the Economies of Tamil Nadu and Uttar Pradesh…🙏 to
@frontline_india
for keeping it outside their paywall.
For the last 5 years, Per capita growth in UP has been ~2% lower than TN.
If it were to miraculously become 2% higher EVERY year, it would still take 60+…
How nice that people in the ministry of finance are meeting people in the ministry of finance. Charming. This did not happen before, I presume? Finance minister interacting with her own officials?
As a part of the ongoing series of interactions, Finance Minister Smt
@nsitharaman
interacted with the Directors and Deputy Secretaries of the Budget Division.
My first column after recuperating from a three month fight with COVID and pretty serious complications. I take this opportunity to thank friends, well wishes and followers on Twitter for their concern, affection, positive thoughts, and prayers.
Non pay wall photo is here
Opinion| The Union government is so fiscally ineffective that it can only spend an incremental 0.4 per cent of GDP on healthcare in a pandemic, against a global average of 1.2 per cent, writes
@EmergingRoy
#Healthcare
#GDP
#IndianEconomy
Closing my dead mother’s account at Axis bank, wanowrie, Pune, Bank: I’d must open account with them or accept a demand draft -mailed in due course. When I protested and asked to see the rule Bank manager Mr Shrivastava said “Axis Bank operates according to practices not rules”
India’s progress to a third rate existence as a non serious country. When the least common denominator rules with the blessing of the decadent popular ruler…….
Fringe group stops Christmas celebrations at a school in Mandya's Pandavapura. Allege kids are being brainwashed & lured towards Christianity, ask school staff to install posters of Hindu gods inside school premises.
This is the fraternity that I argue we lack in India, and the main social barrier to inclusive growth. These are the qualities that we should seek in civil servants and others in public life. My heartfelt salutations to this young officer.
India has a central Govt whose core competence is performative bluster, not governance. So how to run the show? As a weak authoritarian regime, it does what it knows best - restrict, prohibit, ban, interdict.
Also, no one who lives outside the posh bits of Delhi is affected, so
Thread:
High net worth people have always kept stakes in first world countries while maintaining a presence in India. But ability to do this was limited before liberalisation it’s just more widespread now.
Suckers in India don’t get this…1/4
One thing a lot of people dont realise is that truly elite Indians don't go abroad (US/UK) to settle there. They study, spend a few years and come back to enjoy the privilege here.
The settlers are nouveau riche at best.
I am sorry that this only exacerbates my warning about the slowdown in India’s economic performance in 2019 The demand engine was spluttering before COVID. It is now in flameout. Urgent structural measures are required but who is listening....
It is always true. Bigots are cowards- always, everywhere. They bully the weak and submit abjectly when confronted They have no principles and no moral compass. That is why they are bigots. Never fear them Always confront them.
Learning point for econ students.
This is not macro data:
GST is tax data. PMI is a perception index. Auto sales is sector data.
These proxies are being passed of as macro data.
Public will be misinformed. We shouldn’t be. Without correlates, that is bad tradecraft
Delhi uni. postpones all exams at 36 hours notice.
What an appalling bunch of incompetent uncaring administrators The cruelty to students is unconscionable.
These are not academics, but rodents, feasting on the lives of young Indians. I am ashamed of my alma mater
I know of no other g20 country where becoming a civil servant is vested with so much importance
This has many ramifications but for now I just want to share my enjoyment of this unique Indian video pic
Where else could becoming a Govt factotum create so much emotional energy ♥️
As an economist working on India, I am in a lonely place. I want inclusive growth to be the outcome of a market economy. Those to my left want to use tools of a command economy to force market outcomes that they like. Those to my right don’t give a toss about inclusive growth.
Rajasthan government ahead of the curve but working quietly without drama opposite of GOI.
Remarkably,everyone is working together CM and leader of opposition regularly consulting. Jaipur taking feedback from districts and civil society to devise policies and actions. Morale high
We have set up district wise control rooms & medical control rooms for public so that one can seek information, help & assistance when needed regarding
#COVID19Pandemic
. These control rooms have dedicated phone lines, where people can call 24X7. #राजस्थान_सतर्क_है
World Bank numbers.
The wages of serial, corrosive, incompetence. The Great Inferiority Complex is costing our young dearly. Ruling party is drunk with hubris, building temples, statues like Mohammed Shah Rangila. The opposition is ideologically bankrupt.
Cry, my beloved country.
Uttar Pradesh is an economic hell hole.
The current government does a lot of trash PR which a lot of trash buy.
But the larger point:
India fails when UP our largest, most populous State, fails.
I foresee terrible consequences.
Not many know this grim reality: UP's per capita income at current prices is ₹70,797 which is half the level of Sub Saharan Africa. Excluding NOIDA, UP's per capita further plummets, comparable to the likes of Afghanistan.
UP has devolved into an economic WASTELAND
1/
Did he? I wouldn’t know. I do economics, not the alphabet. If my economics resembles an alphabet I first elucidate and then indicate the logic of the resemblance.
I am simply not competent to do it in reverse order.
This is ridiculous We’re are taking anticipatory action in full knowledge that we are a developing country with an informal sector that will be stretched by this pandemic and a healthcare system that can bear a limited burden
@samirsaran
1/2
Once hatred and bigotry become part of majoritarian politics there is no limiting it Can’t be a “proud” North Indian Hindu, persecuting beef eaters, calling people rice bags, jihadis, not renting to them or doing business with them, and expect love where not in a majority.
Hatred against North Indians in Tamil Nadu and Karnataka is systematically planted in locals. All for petty political gain. Must be stopped before it becomes unmanageable.
India had a narrow escape. If there’s one thing I did (with many collaborators) in 2019 it was to prevent a bunch of civil servants and Govt “economists” skilled in flattery, Indic ideology, whatever.. ... everything but policy tradecraft.. take us to this hell.
🚨New
@eurodad
report🚨
Sleep now in the fire: Sovereign Bonds and the Covid-19 Debt Crisis
We take a look at 549 sovereign bonds issued by 62 middle and low-income countries. Main findings in a 🧵
TL/DR - Who profits from debt in the pandemic
Let me make my personal position clear. I live and give my all to protect our constitution and our Republic. Anyone who wants a new constitution/ a new republic will reckon with my unflinching resistance. It's all I have and it may not be enough but I will be there.
This year, all recipients of the Padma awards for sports are women!
Indian women dominate sports excellence and are the spearhead of our Olympic/World Cup efforts. Wish I knew how to make this the spearhead to destroy suppression of women’s freedoms by family and society.
Excited to work again in a global context
@ODIDEV
is committed to redefine the 21st century development narrative. Bit understand this clearly:
I will continue to be closely engaged with Indian public policy in these critical times.
📣 We are delighted to announce that
@EmergingRoy
has been appointed our Managing Director, and will be joining us in September. We look forward to welcoming you, Rathin!
#COVID19
is not airborne
#COVID19
spreads via droplet & contact transmission
For
#HCW
,
@WHO
has always recommended droplet precautions, except when preforming aerosol generating procedures, where we recommend airborne precautions
See here:
A consultant to “boost up” the economy of UP to 1 trillion dollars. No politician with a modicum of economic sense would permit this ridiculous RFP. Administrative approach reigns, economy fails. Politics, public, high on the opium of news traffickers.
I am increasingly worried and concerned about the data coming in on rising poverty and hunger levels.
@kaushikcbasu
@maitreesh
Anything other than a significant secular decrease in poverty and hunger merits close and urgent attention
Tamil Nadu and Kerala richer than than Indonesia, rocket scientists, free breakfast for kids.
Uttar Pradesh: poorer than Nepal, temples vs mosques, teachers incite kids to violence and communal bigotry.
Two facets of India
We have to make a political choice Choose wisely.
This is unbelievable. I cannot believe this is happening in our country & the people concerned are not in jail. All Indians must hang our heads in
#Shame
that this is what all our constitutional rights and freedoms can be reduced to.
The crude comments made about Shahrukh Khan when he paid his respects to Lataji show how weak political leadership has fanned open bigotry. India mourns in solidarity, bigots seek to divide.
Bigoted ideology corrodes India. May these Vermin rot in this world and the next
This is the big problem with the government of India- bureaucratic incompetence each time, every time, always. Barking before they think.
Ministers are insecure and so happy with brown nosing babus There is no punishment or accountability for destroying state credibility.
Clowns
This habitual lying (a feature since at least 1998)further evidences my deepest worry - India has a weak and flailing Government whose delivery credibility is low. It can only do handouts, incarcerate kids, old people, exploit the weak. Govt boasts, talks big, to hide this.
A decision taken yesterday reversed today. It is very sad for me to see how incompetent and incapable the Finance Ministry has become. Like Air India,
@FinMinIndia
has declined from being an icon to a demonstrably dysfunctional outfit.
When economic policies ensured that Indians remained poor till 1991 because of suppression of Indian entrepreneurs and Indian capital, the only thing you can offer is ‘instinctive inclusiveness’ what a shame! Keep Indians poor,live in luxury and talk about poverty! Shame!
I am extremely pleased that Dr Anantha Nageswaran has been appointed Chief Economic Advisor. An accomplished policy professional, he will bring much needed expertise back to the finance ministry. I affectionately wish him a productive tenure.
@IlaPatnaik
@ThePrintIndia
Nehru created the Zombie Airline on 1-8-1953 by Air Corporations Act (Nationalizing Pvt Airlines). Monopoly kept AI & IA in profitable business till 1993. Modi-Luft, Damania & East-West folded later. After Kingfisher fiasco, Jet be handled like Satyam & ILFS to save this sector
The unequalising growth model has run out of steam as I have been warning since 2019. To avoid economic stagnation it is now super-critical to address the technical and institutional
Barriers to making things that the top 3-400 million want at affordable prices. 1/3
When a Central Bank has to revise its near term annual growth projection five times and by 240 basis points in 10 months it is either technically deficient or is calibrating its forecasts to political suasion. Or, worse, both.
#RBI
RBI’s growth projections getting a lot of flack this year but how often have they been materially off the mark?
@PallaviNahata
brings you the data. via
@BloombergQuint
The announcement of a committee to look at the Indian statistical system bringing in all stakeholders, headed by Dr Pronab Sen, is an important and welcome move. This is the best way to improve and maintain the high credibility of India’s statistics.
I’m pleased England won the WORLD cup (cricket apart) because it was the most cosmopolitan, multiracial team:
Ben Stokes born in New Zealand! Jason Roy in SAfrica. Capt. Eoin Morgan is Irish. Jafra Archer is Barbados born. Adil Rashid Pakistan born.
@UKinIndia
@RuchiGhanashyam
Govt of India passes imperious, but confusing “ it has been decided...” national orders on things well within the mandate of the States. No explanation based on economic or other logic is provided. On matters within GOI remit, especially saving the economy, a resounding silence
#COVID19
update
All registered shops regd under Shops & Establishment Act of respective States/ UTs, including shops in residential complexes, neighborhood & standalone shops exempted from
#lockdown
restrictions.
Prohibited: Shops in single & multi brand malls
Thank you.
I went to die and came back, somehow..
I lost my mother and could not cremate her.
I have videos of ppl dying around me as I waited for my turn.
was very very lucky to survive two phases of oxygen deprivation.
May this decadent incompetent government rot in hell!
April: a month of ashes and empty chairs for the millions still reckoning with their grief, their losses.
It may never be acknowledged in official histories, but that time—the harshness of those days but also the kindness of strangers—will live in our memories forever.
My latest column in the Business standard. Trivial policy debates, in the face of serious structural challenges that I have been pointing to for some time, can mortally wound India’s quest for inclusive prosperity. H/T
@kaul_vivek
for his recent analysis.
This is how to do it. Only insecure leaders and their brown-nosers put their pictures on everything.
Like my vaccine certificate which causes much amusement abroad
Dal, gur, ghee, you name it – ration-card holders in Tamil Nadu are getting a 21-item nutritious food pack for Pongal. And no photo of Stalin, thank you.
“ sustainable net zero” means: The West will consume as it always has, by extracting from the rest.
Climate warriors will take their children to school and on summer holidays in their electric cars powered by lithium mined by Africans
I understand Mumbai and Delhi will be slum-free by December 31 2022 all water will be so drinkable in these two prime cities that water filter companies will be redundant. Dengue, chikangunya will be eradicated.
I await this leapfrogging eagerly.
Delighted to talk at the
@FT
Future Cities Conference. India is leapfrogging the stages of sustainable urban development with greater use of technology, robust urban planning and design, and on the back of public transportation. Watch here:
I think most Indian Parents see education purely as a pathway to credentials that increase lifetime earnings. This selfish, now societal view reflects in Kota, engineer-worship, competitive exams, disrespect for humanities and a widespread inferiority complex that feeds bigotry.
On the education emergency that is putting an opportunities an entire generation and more at risk. I remain baffled by our collective refusal to prioritise the education of our children when all else is open. There is still time, we can fix this, if we care to. In HT today
The wages of incompetence.
Boasting in the future tense- a diminished country in the present tense This is what happens when you invest political capital in religious, ethnic bigotry. It wins elections but defenestrates the India growth story.
@nsitharaman
Wake up, India
Do confirm this is formally officially approved AIIMS study which underwent peer review before AIIMS sent it for publication in Lancet . Why couldn’t AIIMS publish it as its own report first in India instead of first publishing it in Lancet? We as Indians are first concerned.
Social media has become the cause of violence,hate&fake news. Govts globally have been lazy& have failed to control them. Advertisers r walking away from social media forcing them to review policies on violent content. Biz men are doing Govts job in making the world better.
“The intolerance and insecurities of the Indian state are acutely reminiscent of the despot Kamsa, the maternal uncle of Lord Krishna. Kamsa was afraid of newly-born infants; our modern state is afraid of young college girls and octogenarians.”.
N.C. Asthana IPS (retired)
Want to know why financial services get a free pass every lockdown? Why schools restaurants shut while stock markets stay open?
Simple. So the rich are protected from consequences of lockdowns. This is what engenders profit led recovery, and stock market booms.
10 restaurants in India which I will visit as soon as I can:
Amour Bistro Delhi.
MahaBelly Delhi.
Olympia Cafe Bombay.
Swati Snacks Bombay.
Gajalee Bombay.
Ling’s Pavilion Bombay
Mocambo Kolkata.
Rahimtullah Biriyani Kochi.
Koshy’s Bangalore.
Nanjai Virundhu Coimbatore
Wrong.
Basic excise duty is shareable with the states. Union chooses to levy taxes as surcharges and cesses on petrol and diesel hence they are not shareable.
Indianomics101: Excise taxes on petrol & diesel are levied separately by the Central govt and the State govts (individually). The issue of sharing Central govt's oil excise tax revenues with States does not arise! States are free to levy the crises tax they want to levy!🧐🤔
Progressive moves! Everyone above the age of 18 to be eligible to get vaccine. Vaccine manufacturers incentivized to further scale up production & empowered to release up to 50% of their supply to States & in the open market at a pre-declared price
15 months ago, I warned of a silent fiscal crisis. It is now explicit for the world to see, at a vulnerable time.
I hope the political authorities now see the value of objective assessment. It is they, not the bureaucrats, who bear the costs of Stockholm syndrome. Always.
Ill talk about that
When:
Farmers can sell outputs (including meat) wherever, at any price
Middlemen don’t fix prices
Govt does not “ban exports” to international markets or flood- domestic markets with imports when urban ppl whine
Hypocrisy of selective “free” markets
The filmmaker may please invite JNU alumni S Jaishankar and N Sitharaman for the inaugural screening of this movie. It tells their story as eloquently as the tagline.
Another movie with a political theme, JNU is set for 5 April release. The tagline says, Behind closed walls of education brews a conspiracy to break the nation. Although the J, here stands for Jahangir & N For national… but we all know where things are heading.
I write about an important analytical distinction that economics fails to make and hence is unable to satisfactorily tackle (1)inequality amid unprecedented global prosperity and (2) bigotry - the two most important global
Challenges of our times
A very important article by
@AiyarYamini
Fiscal choices are political choices- failure to deliver inclusive growth and prosperity leads to a weak “compensatory State” And that is what we have had for some time now, certainly since 2009.
The collapse of official statistics reflects reality. Whether, growth, poverty, human development, prosperity, the decline of India’s development story is stark— and sad for it is, still, reversible.
But, as often in India’s history, the State is weak, and society, effete.
Read Drèze-Somanchi: India's statistical system is in bad shape
Public surveys are under-funded or suppressed, private surveys grossly underrepresent the poor
We're supposed to live in age of big data, but this looks more like big opacity
@roadscholarz
I speak four Indian languages fluently. To counter this Hindi hegemony, I will henceforth only speak in three of them if any stranger addresses me in Hindi.
@kanimozhi
Today at the airport a CISF officer asked me if “I am an Indian” when I asked her to speak to me in tamil or English as I did not know Hindi. I would like to know from when being indian is equal to knowing Hindi.
#hindiimposition
This is welcome if true. But I implore Govt: learn the lessons of the migrant labour crisis and slum outbreaks and create such opportunities in North and East India. Work where people live and a slum free India by 2022.
@amitabhk87
via
@economictimes
Raghuram Rajan writes:
Some were hopeful they would focus on the economic agenda..Some agreed with their speeches. Some were indifferent.
And some of us feared the consequences of being critical, as critics were ruthlessly made an example of