I’m dismayed and disappointed by the mischaracterisations, falsehoods and character assassination campaign targeting me and colleagues. I’m also dismayed that subsequent outlets chose to run the story without seeking our views or ignoring them. Here are a few facts - 🧵:
Its DR ESFANDIARY to all of you now! 😁 A big thank you to Matteo Legrenzi and
@andrewfutter
for being on my panel, and to
@MoranCSSS
and
@WQBowen
for their supervision.
Actually, respectfully disagree. Looks like deliberately planned to look impressive, display abilities and willingness but avoid casualties. If so, then thought out and careful while saving face.
This was a poor move from Iran...rushed and pretty much ineffective. With all the hallmarks of a response for the sake of responding...it achieves little, if anything, and puts the ball back in Washington’s court. Your move Trump.
Actually, as an
#Iran
-ian, I can say that my passport has always been a source of pride for me. It has nothing to do with those in power but a love for my country and my fellow countrymen.
Iran will be a respected country again — and its passport will be a source of pride for its people — once the Islamic Republic ends up in the dustbin of history like other brutal regimes before it.
My
@ibtauris
book cover’s been chosen! Its a look into the more assertive posture of the
#UAE
and the impact of that policy. Can’t wait for it to come out… now if only I had time to finalise those edits…
Jeez. In the first 30 minutes of tonight’s Tory leadership debate Rishi Sunak & Liz Truss managed to completely eviscerate the whole Tory Government
Watch in disbelief
First, no one outside
#Iran
can claim to speak for the Iranian people. Second, It somehow doesn’t it seem right to incite cancelling a woman’s voice for her opinion during a women-led protest - what happened to the space for debate and discussion?
سهشنبه به کمیته امور خارجه پارلمان بریتانیا دعوت شدم تا در جلسه اختصاصی در مورد مسائل ایران شهادت دهم. الی گرانمایه هم دعوت شده. او دیروز در واشنگتنپست خواستار برداشتن تحریمها علیه رژیم خامنهای شده. تمام تلاشم را میکنم تا صدای مردم ایران را به این کمیته برسانم.
#مهسا_امینی
The
#EU
is united in condemning
#Iran
and imposing additional sanctions, but powerless before
#Israel
’s genocide the day after Tel Aviv bombed a playground full of children. Right.
I chaired the extraordinary EU
#FAC
following the Iranian attacks against Israel.
We were united in:
- condemning the attacks
- committing to Israeli security
- preventing an escalation & calling all actors to restraint
- increasing sanctions to Iran
- not forgetting Gaza.
🧵1/4
Oh look, here a representative of the US government is trolling me because I said I'm proud to be Iranian and have an Iranian passport, and love my country and its people. A real crime clearly. Remember when US officials had better things to do, like make policy?
The current Iranian passport is issued by the Islamic Republic and bears its insignia. This regime has oppressed the Iranian people for 41 years, stealing their money, slaughtering their children, and depriving them of basic human rights. It’s OK not to be proud of that passport.
Why assassinate a nuclear scientist now? Not to slow programme down, that won't make a difference, only to make it harder for a
#Biden
admin to engage
#Iran
and resolve differences through dialogue
Hey, media, maybe next time, one of these could be the photo for an article, rather than that same one of the burning American flag and the chador-clad woman...
Put yourselves in Tehran's shoes: agrees to a deal, implements it, but doesn't get anything promised to it as
#US
walks away from that deal and faces no consequences. They receives offer to expand talks to curb other activities. I would say no too.
So
#SaudiArabia
completes its first nuclear reactor without inspectors, but tell me how the most verified nuclear programme in the world -
#Iran
's - is the problem
Wow! Wow! Wow! This is the most incredible
@UKLabour
video I have ever seen. It completely eviscerates 12 years of conservative Government. And what is so astonishing about it is it’s all done by Conservative MP’s! It should be playing on a loop
In an otherwise important piece
@NickKristof
writes: “Even as Trump is trying to denuclearize North Korea & Iran” This is incorrect. Unlike NK,
#Iran
has no nuclear weapons to be “denuclearized” & is abiding by its obligations despite
#Trump
violating it.
David Cameron: Iran attacking Israel was "reckless"
Journalist: What would Britain do if our consulate was flattened?
David Cameron: Well, w-we would take very strong action...
Journalist: Iran would say that's what they did...
Great news for MENA
@CrisisGroup
: We'll be joined in February by the stellar
@DEsfandiary
as Senior Adviser, MENA. Dina, who will become Dr later this week (🍾), has worked for
@TCFdotorg
and
@IISS_org
, among others, and has published widely on Gulf affairs. We can't wait!
Right wing
#Iran
watchers: sanctions have and will squeeze Iran, regime is on the verge of collapse.
Also right wing Iran watchers: Iran is taking over the whole Middle East, and is about to win the war in Yemen.
So let me get this straight: the official from the country that just walked out of an international treaty, tells the country that is implementing all international agreements that its a 'rogue state'. Hmm...
I am genuinely enraged at the media for the way they are talking about this crisis. ‘Civilised’, ‘European’, ‘blond and blue eyed people being bombed’ - really?
Atrocities start with words and dehumanization.
Atrocities unleashed upon millions in the ME, fueled by dictators labeled as reformists in the west.
The racist subtext: Afghans, Iraqi & Syrian lives don’t matter, for they are deemed inferior—“uncivilized.”
Its funny, as an
#Iran
analyst, you either support bombing your compatriots or you're labelled a 'regime apologist'. Takes you back to 'you're either with us, or against us'. Who knew the world was so black and white?
Zero, ZERO evidence of Hezbollah's direct involvement in this for now.
The only legitimate blame we can cast is on the whole Lebanese elite and government, including but not limited to Hezbollah, for being complacent and corrupt.
Iran: Thousands protest in the heart of the city of Isfahan with a dried river that was once the life of the city and passed under its many historic bridges. Protesters chant: Give the Zayandeh Rood back…
#زاینده_رود_من_کو
1. I never worked for Rob Malley, nor advised him. He left ICG before I joined. That such a simple, verifiable statement was included in the original article, and not disputed by subsequent ones, shows the lack of journalistic integrity and the current low bar for publishing.
What always cracks me up is when you get entire panels in
#DC
on subjects like
#Iran
,
#Iraq
etc with not a single Iranian or Iraqi on the panel. How would a panel on
#US
foreign policy or on some aspect of domestic policy look without a single American there?
Calling for helping
#Iran
through war. The kind of argument that is easy to make when you’re sitting on your plush couch thousands of miles away, and one that makes no sense ofc.
4. I am an analyst: We speak with relevant stakeholders – all over the world – to gain insight that is essential to our work. As a researcher, it is our job to accurately portray scenarios and make thoughtful recommendations that we see as means to reducing conflict.
Some personal news: excited to join
@Kennedy_School
as an International Security Fellow and
@TCFdotorg
in New York as a Fellow in their Middle East department this year! Goal: not despair over 'Murica's political situation while here
7. I travelled to meet with Iranian officials, as I travel to meet with US, European, Arab officials, all funded by my institution. We call this research.
Here's a crazy idea, how about
#Iran
-ians decide what they want from their government? Not someone who sits a million miles away and knows little about the country.
.
@FDD
: On the future of Iran, we need to collapse the regime. The Iranian regime unremittingly seeks our destruction. The Ayatollah chants ‘Death to America’ – and means it. Our country and all Americans will not be safe until the regime is gone.
The United Kingdom,, France, Germany have rejected the Trump administration's demand to reinstate U.N. sanctions on Iran. Here is their full statement:
Alright, for the 17th billion time: no one ‘gave’
#Iran
anything but access to its own money frozen abroad so
#US
taxpayer paid NOTHING. AND the amount is wrong... but hey, facts, booooring.
The Democrats and President Obama gave Iran 150 Billion Dollars and got nothing, but they can’t give 5 Billion Dollars for National Security and a Wall?
2. Similarly, I was not at Harvard in 2014. I was working for IISS, a think-tank with headquarters in Europe. While that doesn’t change much in terms of the accusations, it does demonstrate that the journalists have not done their research properly.
.
@SecPompeo
: The Islamic Republic of Iran is not a normal state. Normal states do not attack embassies and military installations in peacetime; fuel terrorist proxies and militias; serve as a sanctuary for terrorists; call for the destruction of Israel & threaten other countries.
3. The Iranian government never directed any of my work or articles. I have been critical of the Islamic Republic’s policies, just like I have been critical of the policies of other countries.
8. I cannot be held responsible for how officials present this among themselves. We are aware that officials of certain countries spin their meetings with analysts to highlight their influence. This happens in Iran, in the Middle East, and many other countries in the world.
This is the most concerning aspect of 'maximum pressure' for those sitting in the US and Europe: an entire generation of Western-friendly Iranians will slowly turn against the West as disapointment increases. This won't be resolved as soon as Trump leaves, it will linger.
Most people I’ve spoken to in Tehran since Friday have expressed support for
#Iran
’s seizing of the U.K. tanker. Educated, middle-class people often critical of the government, say IRGC was right to capture
#Stena_Impero
in response to U.K. capturing Iran’s tanker in Gibraltar
Ok, so shall we talk about what the
#US
invests in instead of masks and protective gear for its healthcare professionals? How's $400,000 on fixing a toilet flush on a boat and then making doctors wear bin bags as protective gear?
I've received this video from Iran. Listen to this woman.
The Islamic Republic of Iran & its lobbies claim
#Covid19
is killing people due to sanctions. Is that really so?
As the video shows, the regime invests money in religious banners instead of medical masks for people.
6. The Iranian government never paid for me or any of my colleagues to meet with them. When funding was needed for my peers, it was obtained by European institutions, including a European government.
Iran is full of malevolent evildoers, and Soleimani was the worst of them. But Iran is also a nation state. And the reason the U.S. doesn't kill leaders of other countries is because once you normalize assassinations, it's hard to put the genie back in the bottle.
9. Reports containing only selectively leaked documents could never accurately paint an accurate picture of the important work that I and my colleagues (both at ICG and other reputable think tanks) do.
Today, we remember the scores of innocent demonstrators killed by the Chinese Gov’t 31 years ago at Tiananmen Square for speaking out against the totalitarian regime.
We must hold the CCP accountable for suppressing freedom & for their malign activity that continues today.
Women's rights group calls on FIFA to kick Iran out of World Cup. Rights group Open Stadiums have called on FIFA to throw Iran out of the World Cup finals in Qatar in November because of the country's treatment of women.
Sanctions on
#Iran
have existed since the birth of the Islamic Repuic. Have they *at any point* prevented Iran and
#China
from building their relationship? No. Maybe its time to try something a little different?
China-Iran: The key to making sure the China-Iran deal never reaches its potential is to continue a maximum pressure campaign of secondary sanctions enforcement against any Chinese bank or company that moves forward on sanctionable business.
5. IEI was a loose, informal, network of analysts based in institutions in Europe and the US. We met with officials from all the negotiating parties during the nuclear talks and other conferences because it was our job to speak with all sides and understand what was going on.
We encourage medical professionals seeking work in the U.S. on a work or exchange visitor visa (H or J), particularly those working on
#COVID19
issues, to contact the nearest U.S. Embassy/ Consulate for a visa appointment. Please see more information here:
So, I'll say this again, how is this any different to the idiot in
#Iran
who suggested camel urine to kill
#coronavirus
? 'Trump’s Idea to Bleach Lungs to Kill Coronavirus Alarms Experts'
Sad that the vitriol against
#Iran
is so bad that even a humanitarian channel, designed to help the Iranian people, gets criticised. What had the average Iranian done to deserve this?
Risky move. Could be seen as paying for hostages. Giving
#Iran
relief valve at critical time, allowing trade to resume with terror sponsoring Central Bank, then asking for release of Americans. Question: does Tehran see weakness or benevolence?
This is an excellent interview clip for every journalism class in which
@MarthaRaddatz
pushes Pompeo to admit that coronavirus is NOT man-made right after he claimed that coronavirus was man-made.
It never ceases to amaze how much people continue to believe that
#Iran
’s position and statements right after the revolution is what drives it today. Can it not change or evolve like any other country?
Can I just point out that even in countries/cities that are completely quarantined, you're still allowed to go and do a food shop. So, why the hoarding?
Today is the 2 year anniversary of the
#US
leaving the
#Iran
nuclear deal, and the start to 'maximum pressure'. Ask yourselves: is Iran contained? Deterred? And the nuclear progr now non-existant? No? Well then what did leaving the deal achieve?
I have a better idea: how about the international community stand together to fight the global threat posed by the
#coronavirus
? That includes helping Iran to ensure that it can get the pandemic under control, thereby making the rest of the world safer.
Just an idea.
.
@SecPompeo
on new
#Iran
sanctions: The time is now for the international community to stand together against Iran’s nuclear extortion. If the world is concerned with Iran’s behavior now, it should consider how Iran would behave with a nuclear weapon.
While women in Iran risk their lives to fight against this tool of oppression, cowards in the West celebrate the hijab in the name of ‘diversity’ & commercial opportunity. Gross.
All ‘iranians have to suffer’? Interesting, weren’t these supposed to be targeted sanctions affecting just the leadership? Or are we not even bothering with that explanation anymore?
Today we sanction three Iranian companies for their role in Iran’s weapons of mass destruction program. Iran must prioritize its people's needs instead of squandering their resources to export terror. We support the Iranian people as they demand this!
That
#Iran
's response to
#coronavirus
was incompetent goes without saying. But why deny that
#sanctions
made things worse when countless experts and academics have demonstrated it through empirical research and numbers?
To those who claim that sanctions hampered Iran's response to
#coronavirus
please read my article on National Interest:
IRI knew about
#CoronaVirus
at the beginning of February but it still decided to hold mass rallies. What was the reason?
Why do many people think that critiscising sanctions and 'maximum pressure', and critiscising the policies of the
#Iran
-iam government are mutually exclusive? Why can't we do both?
Lol. We're back to this again. I never cease to be amazed by how much some people in the
#US
believe they are in a position to make demands. Deal making 101: a deal involves concessions by both sides and won't happen if the demands are too high on one side
Whoever wins the U.S. election in November, says
@elilake
, they should make sure the next nuclear deal with Iran requires the regime to fully account for its secret history
Except we don't get to pick. Our
#Iran
is a land of contradictions, both Shajarian and Soleimani. With beauty and sometimes real ugliness. Just like any other country in the world, it has both.
Mnuchin was originally averse to the new Iran sanctions but a twin lobbying campaign, first by Israeli government officials, and then FDD, prevailed on senior Trump officials
Russian state media is warning of electricity shortages in Switzerland, as it steps up its narrative that sanctions are hurting the West more than itself
‘We’re not quite sure what we mean by this, but we’re going to do it anyway, because big fancy statements make us look like we’re getting things right’
"Today, we are announcing the designation of both the United Arab Emirates and the Kingdom of Bahrain as “Major Security Partners” of the United States," says
@WhiteHouse
statement.
A short week after Brian Hook and
@StateDept
says medicine is exempt from
#US
sanctions, it becomes clear NSC is preventing payment mecanisms for humanitarian trade with
#Iran
from
#Switzerland
. What was that about wanting to reach out to Iranian people?
Thread: 1/ To those calling illegal Israel's killing of Iran nuclear weapons program chief Fakhrizadeh: US Army JAG Corps has explicitly taken the position that such killing is legal during international armed conflict, using as an example the U.S.'s own nuclear weapons program.
In a background briefing today, a senior State Department official said about the strike on Soleimani:
“This was an act of de-escalation.”
“We are ready to talk with the Iranians.”
“They are scurrying for cover.”
“The ball is in Iran’s court.”
Discuss.
This is truly heartbreaking but a must-watch. How will this make
#Israel
more secure? It will lay the foundations of further escalation and confrontation for decades to come.
Iranian outside
#Iran
says Iranian inside Iran welcome war in their country. Hmm... yes I'm sure that after 40 years of sanctions they're desperate for war too.
مشاهدات و شنیدههای من میگه که بعد از کشتار آبان۹۸ و سرنگون کردن هواپیمای اوکراینی، خیلیها در داخل ایران، طرفدار حمله نظامی خارجی شدند. این خواسته اگرچه ناشدنی به نظر میاد، اما نشونه اینه که اولویت خیلی از مردم، رفتن جمهوری اسلامیه و چندان براشون اهمیتی نداره که بعدش چی میشه.
So, so far,
#turkey
,
#Russia
and
#China
are refusing to comply with
#US
sanctions on
#Iran
and the
#EU
has put in place blocking regulations. Sanctions aren't as effective unless they're a multilateral effort, fyi.
See, this is what happens when you fundamentally misunderstand a people and its government.
#Iran
won’t talk as pressure increases because it would be suicide for the government. They will talk when they can get something tangible in return for concessions