For those of you secretly planning to vote for Cuomo because you think he can govern—don’t believe the hype. He can’t. Beyond his decimation of the subway, he bungles even his own pet projects. Story from last October
You can't turn to science to justify anti-trans legislation. When it comes to sex, there just is no there there. Powerful panel last night at
@PioneerWorks_
with
@Fausto_Sterling
, and Sarah Richardson of the
@genderscilab
, and Rebecca Jordan-Young (
@brainstormbook
).
Trans studies job! The Gender & Sexuality Studies (GSS) Program at Northwestern University seeks a full-time, tenure-line Assistant Professor with research and teaching interests strongly rooted in transgender studies, to begin September 1, 2024.
It really matters when cis journalists come out swinging against the transphobic journalistic malpractice that’s been going on.
And those of you sitting this one out in the hopes of a byline, take a stand before history passes you by.
This collection radically rewires our thinking, making visible the work that cisness has been doing all along. I’d buy it just for Emma Heaney’s introduction, which gifts us ‘a theory of sexual difference without cisness.’
The edited collection Feminism Against Cisness is available for pre-order. Until the end of tomorrow, the code CYBER23 gets you 50% off. The book is then 14 bucks.
A small part of my book has been adapted for the New York Review of Books, online. It's just out this second. And the ending has some new material (not in the book) linking the abortion disaster to transgender politics.
.
@adamconover
is a fantastic interviewer. Really appreciate his podcast (and not just because I was on it!) because he’s interested in deep dives, thinking beyond the headlines.
On this week's Factually,
@paisleycurrah
joins me to discuss how government institutions regulate and control sex and gender, and the real barriers that trans folks face daily as a result. Take a listen!
@badinfinity2
The 1990s are calling…when queer theorists, feminists, and the right all agreed that transsexuals were victims of false consciousness. (Prob delete this later because it’s not the Official History)
Maybe it's time for trans people and gender non-conforming people to stop searching for legitimacy in history, in biology, in "other" cultures. From my book:
This NYT retrospective about the closeted Ed Koch fails to mention the epic homophobia at the Times, led by Abe Rosenthal, during Koch's time as mayor.
A lovely story about my dear friend
@shannonminter5
— about his animal rescue work, and a little bit about his decades of lgbtq rights advocacy. Even after his house got blown down by a tornado, he never stopped working (& had another victory today!).
Good for Hannah Gadsby who would rather possibly kill any chance of future Netflix deals than be used as cover. Otherwise, it’s crickets from Hollywood types.
Re bad PhD advisors, my pet peeve, a lesser crime but still not great: committee members who've had the diss for months and have had opportunities to comment, read it for the first time the morning of the defense & announce they have major problems with some part of it.
Got my copy of Feminism Against Cisness in the mail. The best collection of essays I’ve seen in a long while. Edited by
@riislover667
.
Her intro rocks.
It’s my book's first anniversary this month. I write about how sex classification policies are tools of governing. In this moment, the politicization has reached new heights. But, as always, it’s not "what sex is,” it’s "what sex does” that really determines the policy.
Here we go. Using “biological sex” as a cudgel against trans people was always just the pre-game.
For the right, it’s not just “men in dresses” that’s the problem. It’s also women in pants.
In a clearly unconstitutional move, the Texas Department of Agriculture has sent out a directive that "all employees must dress in a matter consistent with their biological gender."
They are trying to bring back 3 articles of clothing laws and trying to overturn Bostock.
Who would have thought I'd grow up to be a political scientist? My talk--"What Would a Transgender Political Science Look Like?"--for a conference in Germany is happening on Wednesday, October 27 at noon US Eastern Time. DM for the link.
@amyhsin
One time I had all five NYC mayoral candidates calling for me to be fired as chair. Funny that they think that would be some sort of punishment. Sadly, it didn't happen.
Friends who are putting all syllabi together: if you're teaching something related to gender and the law, transgender politics/policy, I'd be happy to Zoom into your class to talk about my book, Sex Is as Sex Does: Governing Transgender Identity (2022), my schedule permitting.
One of the people I admire most in the world. Not just one of the smartest people but one of the kindest. And you’ll never know how much he does for LGBTQ people because he doesn’t care about fame or clicks—unless it’s recognition for his animals…
@shannonminter5
(1/4) NCLR’s Legal Director Shannon Minter celebrates his 30th year with NCLR today! He started his role at NCLR as a staff attorney in 1993, and ever since, he has seemed to do it all.
"Good journalism is about finding those stories, even when they don’t exist. It’s about asking the tough questions and ignoring the answers you don’t like, then offering misleading evidence in service of preordained editorial conclusions."
So sad to hear about Urvashi Vaid's passing. She was a tremendous gift to the LGBTQ movement. A long time ago, well before it was a thing for LGB orgs to take on trans rights, Urvashi asked
@shannonminter5
and me to do a report, Transgender Equality, for the Policy Institute.
If the Times had any reporters who'd gone to CUNY they'd know that a CUNY ID gets you on to any campus, that students move between campuses for classes--the central admin even encourages it in the name of efficiency.
You are probably right--they floated that balloon in November 2016 a bit.
Also, followers--
@ettingermentum
is the only mainstream (well, not exactly mainstream, but not us) political analyst who pays close attention to trans electoral issues and writes about them well.
If Biden loses, a lot of people in very high positions are going to have to answer as to why they facilitated his nomination. To avoid this, they will engage an all-out push to say it was the left’s fault instead of Biden’s. Trans people will be their biggest target.
Cool! Jesse Singal's cited by Attorneys General of several states as an authority on
#transgender
children! His hard work misrepresenting scientific consensus could soon be setting our rights back a few decades! Congrats to
@JeffreyGoldberg
& everyone involved!
The letter also said that any finding against AR would be unjust, that she is too famous to be found to have violated Title IX. When that kind of force comes down on a graduate student, it’s incumbent on those of us who have protection from it (e.g. tenure) to speak out 2/4
Necessary reading for anyone who wants to understand this Stock situation. (Defaming students is not a matter of academic freedom.) Also British journalism, esp. the BBC, allergic to fact-based reporting on trans issues, sadly.
I urge everyone who cares about universities, media, feminism, LGBT politics, and free speech to read my deep-dive essay on Kathleen Stock and the British media.
New study: “Evidence suggests that less than 1% of trans people who undergo gender-affirming surgery report regret. That proportion is even more striking when compared to the fact that 14.4% of the broader population reports regret after similar surgeries.
Raising the specter of "sexual redistribution" to discredit leftist arguments for economic redistribution is old conservative schtick. Marx and Engels even address it directly in The Communist Manifesto (1848). Their response then stands the test of time:
A week for amazing reviews. The latest issue of TSQ has a review of Sex Is as Sex Does, by El Friedman. So gratifying to get such a thoughtful & smart engagement with my work.
Important reporting on the problem with the culture war frame. “To call this a culture war is significantly to understate its scope and its damage, though the framing is persistent.”
I wrote about the escalating campaign against trans kids, with more than a dozen states in 2022 introducing bills directly targeting them—and how the right wins when liberals see these attacks (if they do at all) as a culture war
@badinfinity2
Also, can I say, as an um, older person with a long memory...the number of cis (esp cis LGB) folks who were definitely NOT into trans stuff years ago, even actively transphobic, now taking every opportunity to get bylines writing about trans this, trans that.
Trans studies hivemind--A student of mine is looking for scholarship on trans joy in literary criticism. It's NOT hard to scholarship on ye olde abject trans subject, looking for accounts of joy, excess, happy disruptions, etc.
And he got good results because other mayors tended to respond to him, rather than to queer CUNY assistant professors seeking the same information. And he passed all that information on to me.
A very clear dismantling of bad faith (or just plain dumb?) spins from the dudes who think the attempt to eradicate us from public life is something Dems should “compromise” on. Grateful to
@chrisgeidner
for reading Yglesias so I don’t have to.
I don’t often give attention to these folks’ arguments, but, in the midst of the 11th Circuit’s anti-trans ruling and with the 6th Circuit minors’ gender-affirming medical care ban arguments next week, it seemed both necessary and important to do so.
Study published two days ago in the Journal of Pediatrics: "Do Clinical Data From Transgender Adolescents Support the Phenomenon of 'Rapid-Onset Gender Dysphoria'?" If you're a tldr person--answer is no.
@theorygurl
does a brilliant--and incredibly funny--take down of Jill Soloway's new memoir. You won't see many honest reviews of the book, since everybody and their uncle is trying to be the next trans Hollywood consultant.
I am deeply appreciative of all the labor Grace Lavery has put into explaining this Stock situation. So much misinformation—about trans of course, but also about things like free speech, defamation, and so on. You’d think university admins would know all this, but they don’t.
I’m stunned by the legal illiteracy of my profession. But I guess i only know any of this bc I’m trans and I’m always getting yelled at. But we should all be able to differentiate:
1. fact from opinion
2. libel from defamation from opinion
3. academic freedom from free speech
Just saw MY NAME IS PAULI MURRAY at the Angelica. So many visual treats, Murray’s own voice throughout, an archive of private memories & public thought, poetry. And this Post story handles the pronoun issue artfully.
#paulimurray
@FilmmakerJulie
That new generation—they are not just nipping at our heels, they are biting our butts. Read this profile of Andrea Long Chu. Trigger warning: piety busting.
Two bathrooms in a student center that is open to the public. One bathroom requires a student ID to enter, the other does not. The lesson: university admins will use reasonable requests--i.e. for a gender neutral bathroom--to increase security/surveillance, and to limit access.
Took two mandatory sexual harassment training courses this morning—one from Columbia, where I occasionally adjunct, and one from CUNY. Columbia makes it very clear that intentionally misgendering someone is a form of sexual harassment
That student evals still count for promotion and tenure is just....incredibly wrong. I transitioned after tenure and my evals then would include things like "she-male" (could even get their transphobia right). And this anecdote doesn't include more subtle racial and gender bias.
New paper out about student evaluations and the law.
The paper finds that:
- Most universities operate outside the law in how they use evaluations.
- If you've been denied promotion/employment because of your evaluations, you potentially have a legal case.
“the anti-trans bills have targeted minors, using the framework of ‘parental rights,’ or claims about protecting children, just as anti-abortion activists did with parental consent laws for abortion beginning decades ago.” Analysis from Amy Littlefield and
@herong
Thankfully I blocked lots of liberal proceduralist “don’t-worry-Roe-will-stand” bros in the lead up to Dobbs, so at least I’ll be spared similar lectures about this bill. The Republicans play the long game and this bill is frightening.
The United States House of Representatives has just passed the "Parents Bill Of Rights" 213-208.
It is the first national bill that targets transgender youth.
It contains provisions that forcibly out them to their parents, forces teachers to misgender them.
Just in—
@theorygurl
and
@trans_historic
dissing the elders, including moi. Glad to have commissioned this for my last issue of TSQ as co-editor. Still searching for my pasture.
Colleagues--if you're teaching something related to gender and the law, transgender politics/policy, I'd be happy to Zoom into your class to talk about my book, Sex Is as Sex Does: Governing Transgender Identity (2022), my schedule permitting.
Those arguing that Reitman’s privilege undermines his case have it completely backward. Yes, it’s easier for people with privilege to take advantage of legal mechanisms like Title IX. *So* his complaint more likely signals the ghosts of lawsuits that never came to be 1/4
We can do more than say "gay": we can talk about sex, & gender & sexual justice. Thrilled to be part of this discussion on sexual justice with Shatema Threadcraft,
@cruisingatopia
, and
@dr_tey
at
@yale
on April 14. Organized by
@fischermyn
& WGSS staff & faculty.
Fed court says public university professor does NOT have a constitutional right to refer to a transgender woman as "Mr." and "he." Another win for
@NCLRights
and
@AOrrEsq
Powerful testimony today at the NYC Hall. Four CUNY faculty just testified, including Red Washburn, whose description of the extreme transphobia KIngsborough Community College unleashed on them after they transitioned left Committee Chair Helen Rosenthal almost speechless..
Indeed. “Why are the City College protesters being charged with felonies that could land them up to nine years in jail—while Columbia students are facing much lighter sentences?”
An essay by
@SaraNAhmed
that deserves a read or re-read: "Challenges to sexual harassment within universities can be...swept away, as if the challenges are themselves the products of managerialism or neoliberalism." Also-"a moral panic about moral panics."
A much-needed story but it leaves out the Times’ own central role in justifying bans on gender affirming care. Its “reporting” has been cited by the transphobic right in legislation and litigation on care bans. via
@NYTimes
The New Yorker just has to add “transgender” to modify woman to this piece, when it’s completely irrelevant. What a jerkish move on the part of the New Yorker. Where is their famed editorial carefulness?
@mashagessen
how could this possibly be relevant? am i less trustworthy? is it an attempt to clarify that this person with woman's name is in fact not a real one? why then is avital not identified as a cisgender woman? and if you HAD to say it, why not just say trans like a regular human??
I was delighted to be part of the first event ever for the Center for Applied Transgender Studies,
@transstudies
So much excitement among the many audience members...I really believe in this new generation of scholar/advocates.
Just talked with a grad student about
@badinfinity2
's not yet out book (Glorious Bodies: Trans Theology and Renaissance Literature), and I can't wait to read it.
Forgive this brief interruption to your Cuomo scrolling. Colleagues--Don't ask adjuncts to work for free: that includes "informally" supervising theses, preparing curriculum documents, doing departmental assessment. There is no justification for this. This should be a no-brainer.
Why Cuomo shouldn’t slash CUNY’s budget anymore—Brooklyn College ranks 9th nationwide among all four-year colleges for lifting low-income students into the middle class. Seven other CUNY senior colleges were ranked in the top 25.
This is a far cry from the talking points we all parrot. And if anyone is gong to take the risks and push beyond the neat and clean lines that Trans Inc. countenances, it's going to be
@theorygurl