We are extremely disturbed to learn photo journalist
@photobracken
was arrested by the RCMP while she was documenting arrests in Wet'suwet'en territory today. RCMP are refusing to release Amber, in violation of her charter rights.
After 11 months of dogged reporting from The Narwhal and beyond, Doug Ford has succumbed to public pressure and walked back his controversial Greenbelt plans. It highlights the role of independent journalism,
@balkissoon
writes in this week’s newsletter.
The Narwhal has uncovered the existence of an email that could reveal how Ontario chose the areas where it dropped Greenbelt protections. The Ford government’s refusal to release it violates the public’s right to know,
@balkissoon
writes.
#onpoli
#cdnfoi
Ontario Auditor General Bonnie Lysyk just dropped an explosive 95-page audit of the Ford government’s decision to open huge swaths of Greenbelt land to development. Turns out, developers influenced those cuts — and non-elected political staff led the way.
We strongly condemn this behaviour by the RCMP, who were informed
@photobracken
was on assignment for The Narwhal. Amber also carried a formal letter of assignment with her.
Talk about timing. In September, prominent developer Michael Rice paid $80M for land that’s been protected for almost two decades.
Weeks later, Doug Ford announced changes to the Greenbelt. Rice’s land was suddenly set to open up for housing.
Parks Canada has sent a letter to the Ontario government warning Greenbelt development would violate a federal-provincial agreement and likely cause “irreversible harm” to species at risk, natural ecosystems and farmland. via
@EmmaMci
#onpoli
On Friday, Ontario Premier Doug Ford broke his promise to not open up the protected Greenbelt to development. And that’s just the tip of the iceberg when it comes to bleak news these days for the province’s environmental protections.
#onpoli
🧵
BREAKING: “It was a mistake to open the Greenbelt,” Premier Doug Ford said, adding that the land opened to development would be returned to the protected area — which he says he will never touch again.
#onpoli
via
@EmmaMci
@fatimabsyed
“We’re running at a 50 per cent capacity.”
“[They] whittled away a world-class firefighting response program.”
“We all knew this was going to happen.”
Alberta firefighters are speaking out about UCP government cuts. via
@trinamoyles
#ABWildfire
#abpoli
🥁 Drumroll please! 🥁
After an outpouring of support from readers, we are thrilled to announce the launch of our new Ontario bureau, led by the incredible
@balkissoon
and with superstars
@fatimabsyed
and
@EmmaMci
!
Via
@mikedesouza
In the wake of reporting by The Narwhal and
@TorontoStar
, MPP
@maritstiles
is calling for an auditor general probe into the Ford government’s Greenbelt changes — and how much developers might stand to gain. via
@EmmaMci
#onpoli
A watchdog said his handling of the Greenbelt files was “chaotic and almost reckless.” Now, new information links Ryan Amato, the political staffer at the centre of the Greenbelt scandal, to the head of the Ontario Provincial Police.
#onpoli
@Thetrilliumca
It's 5:03 p.m. in Ontario but we've got BREAKING NEWS: The Narwhal has learned the Ontario government is mulling changes to environmental laws that it believes will block lawsuits from landowners and fast-track highway, energy and transit projects.
#onpoli
SCOOP: The Alberta gov said its renewables pause came after a request from the Alberta Electric System Operator, but emails show the operator’s top official found the plan ‘very troubling’ and was ‘not comfortable’ supporting it.
@drewpanderson
reports
INVESTIGATION: Over half the parcels of land set to lose long-standing Ontario Greenbelt protections include properties purchased since the Progressive Conservatives won the 2018 election, The Narwhal and
@TorontoStar
have found.
#onpoli
The results are in: NDP Leader Wab Kinew is set to lead Manitoba through the next four years, bringing the Progressive Conservatives’ seven-year reign to a close. Here’s what that means for the environment,
@jsrutgers
writes.
#mbpoli
#mbelxn
#mbelxn23
🗳
INVESTIGATION: Doug Ford’s government forced Hamilton to sprawl into farmland and green space after requests from unnamed third parties, ignoring expert warnings about unknown (and unassessed) environmental risks. via
@EmmaMci
+
@fatimabsyed
#onpoli
Ten First Nations are launching a lawsuit against Ontario and Canada today, arguing that resource extraction has violated Treaty 9 and Indigenous jurisdiction for over a century. The case could stall the province's plans to mine the Ring of Fire.
SCOOP: Senior staff in Doug Ford’s office discussed changes to the Greenbelt months before Ontario opened parts of it to development, documents show. The records cast doubt on the government’s narrative about how cuts were made.
via
@EmmaMci
#onpoli
Tomorrow, Ontario Auditor General Bonnie Lysyk is releasing her report on the Doug Ford government’s decision to open 3,000 hectares of the protected Greenbelt to development.
@emmamci
and
@fatimabsyed
have been all over this story: here’s what to read to catch up.
#onpoli
🧵
Internal documents show Ontario asked researchers to downplay the findings of a report on how climate change will impact food, buildings and people. Now the government seems to be avoiding its suggested solutions,
@fatimabsyed
reports.
#onpoli
The cabinet shuffle shows the Greenbelt scandal is hurting the Ford government, but a leaked document suggests it’s still choosing development over environmental protections. via
@EmmaMci
,
@fatimabsyed
&
@balkissoon
#onpoli
BREAKING: Charges have been dropped against journalists
@photobracken
and
@M_Tol
, who were arrested and detained for three nights on civil contempt charges while reporting on militarized RCMP raids on
#Wetsuweten
territory.
#PressFreedom
On a chilly winter day in November 2021, news broke that Amber Bracken (
@photobracken
) had been arrested by the RCMP while reporting for The Narwhal from Wet’suwet’en territory in northwestern B.C. Uproar ensued.
Special project G*: newly released documents show the code word and other secrecy measures the Ontario government used in 2022 while planning to open parts of the Greenbelt to development,
@emmamci
writes.
#onpoli
“I’m very worried about what’s happening with the Greenbelt,” federal Environment Minister
@s_guilbeault
warned Ontario this morning. The minister added that he's halted projects elsewhere that threaten endangered species.
#onpoli
#cdnpoli
Cutting into the Greenbelt. Sending more sewage towards Lake Ontario. Gutting conservation authorities.
We’re tracking all the ways Doug Ford is altering Ontario’s environmental policies in his second term. via
@EmmaMci
@fatimabsyed
#onpoli
The Ford government is slashing environmental protections.
And it turns out Ontario has been neglecting things for years — from flood risks to the Niagara Escarpment to invasive species.
@EmmaMci
+
@fatimabsyed
break down new auditor general findings.
All too often, these incidents also involve Indigenous Rights. Previous court rulings have been clear: the arrest of Indigenous Peoples on their lands concerns every single person in this country — and should be a matter of public record, not hidden behind police lines.
First Nations leaders were kicked out of Queen’s Park today, after dozens of people travelled thousands of kilometres to oppose development without Indigenous consent.
“He wants to destroy my territory, he should come and talk to me.”
@EmmaMci
#onpoli
Breaking: Federal cabinet has rejected Steven Guilbeault’s request for an emergency order to protect the endangered spotted owl.
“It’s like the rug was totally pulled out from under us,” Spuzzum First Nation’s Chief says. via
@sarahcox_bc
#cdnpoli
#bcpoli
A leaked confidential document shows Doug Ford was advised of environmental risks in the PC’s new housing legislation, but moved forward anyway to win developer support.
@fatimabsyed
&
@EmmaMci
have a list of protections he wants to weaken, or cut.
#onpoli
In filing this lawsuit, our goal is to clear a path for all journalists in Canada to do their work without risk of police interference. Let’s be clear: we would never have been able to take this bold step without the support of our thousands of readers, donors and members.
“Several RCMP buses have been spotted coming up the hill.”
On Friday, militarized police officers smashed open a tiny house and arrested Indigenous land defenders, and media, on
#Wetsuweten
territory. Here's what happened, as captured by
@photobracken
:
Hours before the long weekend, the Ontario government dropped *another* series of new development changes that could make it easier to build on farmland. Here’s what we know so far.
#onpoli
Our case aims to establish meaningful consequences for police when they interfere with the constitutional rights of journalists covering events in injunction zones, including liberty rights and the freedom of the press as protected by the Charter of Rights and Freedoms.
NEW: B.C. Supreme Court says the province has a duty to consult with First Nations before mineral claims are made in their territories, ruling on a case brought forward by Gitxaała Nation and Ehattesaht First Nation,
@FrancescaFionda
reports.
#bcpoli
Today, when we walked into a courthouse in Vancouver to file our court documents, we imagined thousands of you walking with us, hand in hand in this mission to hold the RCMP accountable.
To not move forward with this case would be to turn our backs on what’s right — and to turn our backs on all the stories that happen in remote places without the watchful eyes of journalists, due to the chilling effect of arrests like these.
Dealing with fallout over a report calling his land-use policies "biased" in favour of developers, Premier Doug Ford said houses on the Greenbelt are a must for Ontario to keep welcoming immigrants.
@fatimabsyed
poked a few holes in that idea a while back.
In more
#onpoli
news, the Ford government is set to open the Greenbelt up for development. While
@fatimabsyed
&
@EmmaMci
dig deep to understand what’s going on, here’s EVERYTHING you need to know about it — from how it was founded to why it’s protected.
Overriding local planners, the Doug Ford government threw another curveball at six municipalities on Tuesday — forcing at least four to sprawl outward — in a long series of changes to farmland and development.
@EmmaMci
and
@fatimabsyed
explain
#onpoli
A topless person interrupted
@AvrilLavigne
at the
#Junos
to protest development in Ontario's Greenbelt.
What's happening with the Greenbelt you ask? We've got you covered.
(We assume Avril thought "why'd you have to go and make things so complicated?")
Amber’s arrest sparked international media attention, outrage from press freedom organizations and an all-hands-on-deck legal effort to get her out of jail. Thousands of our readers wrote letters to government officials demanding her release. Hundreds donated for legal aid.
The Narwhal has snagged six award nominations from the Canadian Association of Journalists.
“We are so honoured to see the tireless work of our nonprofit newsroom recognized alongside the best journalism in Canada,”
@reporteremma
says.
As a small, non-profit news organization, we didn’t want to have to bring a lengthy, expensive litigation against one of the most powerful organizations in our country. But ultimately we realized we had no other choice.
This is going to be a long journey, and we invite you to walk with us.
1. Sign up for our live online event on Wednesday:
2. Make a donation to our legal defence fund:
Land defenders and journalists who were arrested by RCMP last week in Wet'suwet'en traditional territory are about to appear in court. We will be live-tweeting updates over here.
Pardon the extra chipper Narwhal staff this week — our not-so-little little publication has been nominated for *three* National Newspaper Awards this year!
@NNA_CCJ
.
@photobracken
has been released from jail — on the condition that she'll appear in court in February.
The fight for press freedom in Canada continues. The RCMP must be held accountable for illegal actions against journalists. Take action:
Another award nomination? In this economy??? Kidding! We’re thrilled to share our first ever nomination for the Michener Award — one of Canada’s highest honours in journalism — with
@TorontoStar
for our reporting on the Greenbelt scandal!
@EmmaMci
🥳
Four First Nations in Manitoba have signed a historic conservation agreement, which is set to make the pristine 50,000-square-kilometre Seal River Watershed region the province’s first federally recognized Indigenous protected area,
@jsrutgers
reports:
THREAD: When we sent
@photobracken
to Wet’suwet’en territory to report on one of the biggest stories in the country, we didn’t anticipate she’d become part of the story.
The Narwhal has earned its first wins at the National Newspaper Awards, sharing prizes with
@IndigiNewsMedia
and
@TorontoStar
for journalism published in 2023.
NEW: The RCMP has been collecting information about their interactions with journalists
@photobracken
and
@M_Tol
in a national database that tracks law enforcement investigations, affidavits released today reveal.
@mikedesouza
reports:
Ontario’s minister of natural resources will soon have the power to overrule — or bypass — conservation authorities to greenlight development. “It’s just going to cause chaos,” an
@ecojustice_ca
lawyer told
@fatimabsyed
.
#onpoli
We have major news! ☀️ The Narwhal wants to expand to Ontario — but first we need to know we have your support.
We’re ready to open a bureau and produce even more investigative journalism. Here’s where you come in: sign up and spread the word.
NEW: On Dec. 28, during the holiday break, the Ford government told conservation authorities their ability to protect vital watersheds and species at risk — services they’ve provided for 50 years — would be limited as of Jan. 1. via
@fatimabsyed
#onpoli
The number of Alberta oil and gas wells overdue for inspection has more than doubled since 2018, to more than 7,500.
Meanwhile, the province has paused approvals for renewables projects, citing concerns about future liabilities. via
@DrewPAnderson
#abpoli
Internal docs reveal resource industries and gov sought the ‘surrender’ of Indigenous land rights in the wake of the precedent-setting Delgamuukw decision, which affirmed Aboriginal title on unceded territory
via
@Martin_Lukacs
@shiripasternak
#wetsuweten
The Unist'ot'en camp is located 66 kilometres from the infamous Highway of Tears, notorious for its connection to the disappearance and murder of Indigenous women in B.C., many of whom camp founder Freda Huson knew personally.
#bcpoli
#wetsuweten
Requests have now been made for integrity commissioner and auditor general probes into Doug Ford’s Greenbelt changes. Today, Ontario’s housing minister refused to directly answer questions about whether he gave developers advance notice.
@EmmaMci
#onpoli
📣 New job alert! 📣
The Narwhal is eager to take the lead from an Indigenous editor to ramp up our coverage of Indigenous-led conservation! Application deadline: Jan. 26. Spread the word!
Our eagle-eyed Ontario bureau is keeping track of how the Doug Ford government is changing environmental policy in its second term. The newest additions to our rolling list are about Ontario Place, mine waste, suburban sprawl and more.
Recently our editorial team has been discussing something challenging but perhaps unsurprising: the vast majority of story pitches we receive are from writers who are white, in part because we haven’t done more to seek out non-white writers.
It’s
#CAJAwards
day, and we’re proud to announce that
@photobracken
has won the photojournalism category award for her work documenting Wet’suwet’en land defenders. Bracken was wrongfully arrested and detained by the RCMP while covering police raids.
Our Ontario team is still tracking all of the Ford government's changes to environmental policy. Item 26 in today's update: a proposal to exempt some developers from making plans to limit water use, reduce flood risk or protect drinking water 👀
#onpoli
@photobracken
BREAKING: The Narwhal and photojournalist Amber Bracken have filed a lawsuit in British Columbia’s Supreme Court against the RCMP for wrongful arrest, wrongful detention and violation of our Charter rights.
Here's one of the many photos shot by
@photobracken
before her arrest on Friday. Pictured: militarized police breach a locked tiny house on Gidimt’en territory. Stay tuned for more coverage, and go here to support independent journalism:
“Indigenous people don’t need the Crown authority to do this,” lawyer
@Kris_Statnyk
said. “What Gwininitxw did was based on laws that are way older than Canada.”
via
@writermjs
The timeline of the Doug Ford government’s decision to remove parcels of land from Ontario’s Greenbelt has always been murky. Our chronology works backwards from today's auditor general report to Ford's 2018 promise to leave the protected area intact.
B.C. just signed a “historic” $1-billion nature agreement, promising protections for whittling old-growth forests and species at risk. “It’s nature, it’s conservation, it’s restoration, but it’s also about reconciliation,”
@s_guilbeault
told The Narwhal.
A historic agreement between the Haida and B.C. recognizes the First Nation's ownership across the Haida Gwaii archipelago — meaning a colonial government is no longer lord of the land via
@hakaimagazine
Oil barrels lying on the ground. Murky water flowing into wetlands, lakes and rivers.
A growing list of infractions reveals a pattern of
#CoastalGasLink
failing to abide by the rules of the pipeline project’s environmental permits,
@writermjs
reports.
At least 11 species at risk live along the planned route of Ontario's Highway 413. Documents obtained by
@EmmaMci
and
@njaved
suggest the Ford government's pet project might require a full, lengthy federal intervention.
Our first collab w
@TorontoStar
!
NEW: Coastal GasLink is being accused of failing to prevent sediment from entering a Wet’suwet’en river.
“Here, we’ve had such a blatant ignoring of the rules,”
@SevernSuzuki
said.
via
@writermjs
Most of the forest fires still burning in Canada are caused by lightning. But there are many — inc. politicians — who say these fires are caused by space lasers or arsonists. Here's why they're wrong and what we need to do to curb climate misinformation
At 88, Jane Goodall is as determined as ever. “I think I have a mission. And the mission is to keep hope alive. And encourage people to take action now, not just moan and groan.”
@reporteremma
in conversation with the naturalist behind
@JaneGoodallInst
:
A collection of internal emails, draft official plans & scrawled, handwritten notes brings the public behind the scenes during chaotic weeks last fall, as Ontario prepared to open the Greenbelt for housing development.
@EmmaMci
&
@fatimabsyed
report:
Alberta paid $14 million to landowners in 2022 on behalf of delinquent oil companies that couldn’t — or wouldn’t — pay rent for oil and gas activity. When companies don’t pay, the tab is almost always footed by taxpayers,
@DrewPAnderson
writes.
#abpoli
We are absolutely THRILLED to announce that the one and only
@sarahcox_bc
has been named co-winner of the 2021 Press Freedom Award for her tenacious coverage of B.C.’s
#SiteC
dam. 😍💫
The RCMP has launched an investigation into the Ontario Greenbelt scandal, weeks after Premier Doug Ford announced he would reverse the controversial plan amid backlash.
@EmmaMci
+
@fatimabsyed
break down everything that’s been happening.
#onpoli
The Ford government has plans to build homes in York Region. But where would the poop go? South to Lake Ontario, threatening the Great Lakes — and ruffling feathers across the border by violating an international agreement,
@fatimabsyed
explains.
#onpoli
The Alberta government is proposing to reallocate billions of litres of water that could potentially be used by the coal mining industry. It's a move that is drawing criticisms from environmentalists and ranchers alike.
#ABpoli
Via
@sharonjriley
The Schneider family (you know them from their hot dogs) will donate 95 hectares of pristine land to a land trust for conservation and public recreation, after Wilmot Township drops its requirement to pave paradise for a parking lot. via
@shykettle
:
Canada said the Sinixt were extinct, but they fought all the way up to the Supreme Court to prove they weren't. This weekend, after waiting more than a year due to COVID-19, hundreds gathered on their territory in Nelson to celebrate the major court win:
The Ford government wants more new homes in York Region. But where would the poop go? South to Lake Ontario, threatening two Great Lakes watersheds — and possibly violating a protection agreement between Ontario, Quebec and eight U.S. states.
Exclusive: Canada Action, a non-profit that bills itself as a “grassroots” natural resources advocacy group, received $100,000 from a major oil and gas developer, documents obtained by The Narwhal reveal.
The small Rocky Mountain city of Fernie, B.C., is on the hunt for a new backup drinking water supply after selenium levels in wells downstream of Teck-owned coal mines exceeded provincial guidelines. via
@ainscruickshank
#bcpoli
Political staffers central to the Greenbelt scandal were paid the equivalent of a full 2023 salary despite quitting last summer, Ontario’s Sunshine List shows. Sources and information requests suggest Ryan Amato and Jae Truesdell received exit packages.
Of the 15 parcels slated to lose protections, eight include properties purchased since the election of Ford, who in 2018 told a private audience he’d “open a big chunk” of the Greenbelt if he became premier, an investigation by The Narwhal and
@TorontoStar
reveals.
#onpoli
Crown lawyers say the First Nation 'abandoned' its land. The Nuchatlaht say the land was stolen from them. Inside the first-ever title case argued in B.C. since the province introduced UNDRIP legislation. Via
@LavoieJudith
Outgoing auditor general Bonnie Lysyk, the author of the bombshell report on Ontario’s Greenbelt and developer influence, sat down with
@EmmaMci
and
@fatimabsyed
for an exit interview to reflect on a decade as a watchdog — and what’s next.
#onpoli