Amazing that the truth is 4 notorious Churchill-bashers, masquerading as scholars, without a single dissenting voice, trashing his reputation under auspices of college founded as his memorial.
@joepike
@Fox_Claire
@BorisJohnson
@itvcalendar
He did look at photo, expressed regret for such bad experiences and handed you back your phone. Presumably putting it in his pocket was a reflex, not some sinister theft. Stop scaremongering. Impartiality makes better journalism.
The British state leads the world in solemn, moving & beautiful ceremonial that we saw at Prince Philip's funeral, part of the mystique that I'm convinced once inspired the Empire. I wept as I hadn't since my mother's funeral. His passing marked the end of an era.
My BBC Radio 4 documentary on the Jallianwala massacre, repeated Monday @ 9pm, available to listen now on iPlayer. Your chance to hear from Prof. V N Datta, foremost historian of Amritsar, now in his 90s, but as clear as ever.
@simon_schama
I would have thought a historian of the Holocaust would have been wary of using such apocalyptic language about a mere Cabinet appointment, and that too of a democratically elected woman of colour.
An announcement I should have made earlier, the passing on 1st August of my beautiful 16-year-old companion Susie, rescued stray from Glasgow, taken within a half-hour by sudden, fatal heart attack, hours before I was flying to India. At least I was with her till the end.
Outrageously partisan, biased
@BBCNews
with black journo regurgitating BLM propaganda re "decolonisation" & "Rhodes Must Fall", interviewing black teachers who echoed her views, not a single dissenting voice. How is this news & not blatant opinionating?
@PoliticsJOE_UK
@DalrympleWill
Britain needs to stop apologising & be proud of its imperial past, which brought democracy, science, medicine & the English language to most of world. It's what makes UK theworld's most multi-cultural, tolerant & cosmopolitan country today, & will continue to, Brexit regardless.
@kenanmalik
@ObserverUK
Stating the obvious. For the historical record, Cleopatra belonged to a Macedonian dynasty that preserved its bloodline purity by marrying only one’s siblings. Macedonians were typically fair-skinned, often with blonde or red hair. 1/2
@anandcheam
@DalrympleWill
Some might think it’s Wee Willie who needs to go back to school. Pity he both lacks
@KemiBadenoch
’s razor sharp intellect or historical balance. Pity he can’t read serious Indian economic historians like
@RoyHistory1
on how empire cost UK much more than it earned post 1900.
BBC on Al Qaeda, 9/11: “The attacks were carried out by the terrorist group al-Qaeda…..an international terrorist network that was founded by Osama Bin Laden in the late 1980s….al-Qaeda has targeted both civilians and soldiers in other serious attacks around the world.”
@GerryHassan
The Kashmir dispute was creation, not of British, but of Nehru, who annexed Kashmir AFTER independence & promised U.N. plebiscite he later backed out of. Hong Kong would love to have Britain back. British influence marginal in Palestine. Stop blaming yourself for everything!
@darrengrimes_
Straw man. No such choice or priorities. Nowzad flight will carry 100 humans in cabin & animals in baggage hold. Kindness to animals or fellow-humans never a choice. It’s what makes us human.
My letter in Times re Bengal Famine: 1/3
Sir, It’s a measure of the woke times we live in that even Max Hastings (Notebook, Feb 15) has swallowed fake news about Churchill and the Bengal famine. Might I suggest that, far from being “deplorable”, Churchill’s response to the famine
@toadmeister
@DalrympleWill
writes very graphic historical stories, but is most emphatically not a historian. Neither, to be precise, is
@NigelBiggar
, whose work as an ethiciist I much admire.
@DalrympleWill
@RanaSafvi
@DailyO_
Also ignores cultural reality that Mughal courts, packed with Farsi-speaking Turks, Persians, Afghans, Arabs etc. more alien to average Bengali, Tamil or Marathi peasant than European traders who at least tried to learn their vernaculars.
Just switched off Michael Palin, well past his sell by date, pontificating on British guilt for slavery in Nigeria, ignoring role of African slavers, incl. 3 million in modern slavery in Nigeria today, long after independence.
@MahanEsfahani
Pankaj Mishra is a professional Indian Marxist, married to very successful baronet’s daughter (who publishes his books), consistently trashes anything positive to with UK or its past empire.
@adgurunathan
@michael_hal
QED. I knew her grandfather well at Oxford, charming womaniser. She's no chip of the old block, I mean charm-wise. Wonder where she inherited her venom.
@holland_tom
We Indians have been cannibalising previous structures since time immemorial. British archeologists rescued several of our key Buddhist & Hindu architecture from similar fates.
@DalrympleWill
@RanaSafvi
@DailyO_
He doesn't know basic economic difference between Total GDP & per capita GDP. Repeats old tropes of pre-colonial India having 20% of world's GDP, while ignoring that was its share of world population, economy declining after Akbar, agriculture stagnating.
@dotslondon
If you have a London collection point, I can deliver some bags + several tins of Royal Canin Gastro-Intestinal Low Fat (for my dog who recently died).
@nickfshort
Role of British Indian army grossly undervalued today in Hindu chauvinist India, but much celebrated by everyone from Churchill to Imperial War Museum in UK. It was a volunteer, professional army, not conscripted.
@XerxestheMagian
Urdu was most beautiful Muslim import to India, merged with Hindi to give us Hindustani, actual spoken language of northern India, unlike Hindi, ugly, artificial creation mainly spoken by politicians. Nehru sensibly wanted Congress to adopt Hindustani, Gandhi insisted on Hindi.
@kenanmalik
@ObserverUK
2/2 While no contemporaries commented on Cleopatra’s colouring, her coins show her profile as unmistakeably Mediteranean with a rather prominent aquiline nose, rather like Faiyum paintings of Greco-Egyptians. Not remotely Black African.
@SpotTheDog90
@SocialM85897394
@BBC
Over a million tons foodgrains shipped to Bengal from other provinces & other Dominions during famine year. Problem was distribution in midst of Jap invasion.
@AndreasKoureas_
British were the first to abolish it effectively. These ex post facto indigenous claims are spurious. Sawantwadi, cited here, was a tiny principality. This is the usual Hindu nationalist denial sati ever existed and caste too.
@yusufpore
I’m afraid no one except Shashi Tharoor & BJP take Durant seriously. As he confesses,, his knowledge of India was as superficial as his history, and he was animated by an early woke-American hatred of all things British.
@saliltripathi
Poverty reduction only began in 1980s with liberalisation of economy. Nehru-Indira socialism prevented economic take-off like far eastern tigers.
@DalrympleWill
@RanaSafvi
@DailyO_
Worth remembering that your beloved Akbar reputedly slaughtered 80,000 old men, women & children at Chittor, not entirely benevolent because he also took some Rajput wives into his harem. I do value my Mughal heritage, but not at cost of whitewashing its atrocities.
@scribblercat
You don’t seem aware of basic conventions of constitutional monarchy. Palace NEVER comments on political controversies, least of all about free speech. Can you remember QE2 ever doing so?
My letter in today’s Times, defending Churchill:CHURCHILL’S LEGACY :Sir, Jawad Iqbal’s Thunderer rightly challenged the fashion among younger people to dismiss Churchill as a racist imperialist, not our saviour from the Nazis (“Churchill had flaws but we forget his legacy …1/3
@kapskom
How was Babri hubris, any more than other mosques? Or do you buy myth of Ram & Ayodhya? How would Congress castigating mosques as contempt for our "dominant religion" have reconciled us to 7 centuries of past Muslim rule? Love to know your solution, if any.
@Adrian_Hilton
The answer is very few. Most Muslim women I know favour a ban on burqas. As for Boris, a pity that left liberal political correctness has banished the British sense of humour.
@jesse_history
What a muddle. French revanchism was one of several causes of WW1, but it was to regain Alsace-Lorraine & nothing to do with fear of Royalism.
@Sathnam
No hatred from me
@Sathnam
. Just noting that your editors
@Channel4
&
@SandpaperFilms
wasted a day of my time recording 3 hour interview disagreeing with you, only to be dumped. They claimed they had others challenging you. I wonder.
In spite of major food scarcities in Europe, Churchill’s war cabinet minutes and Government of India records show that more than a million tons of grain were shipped to Bengal during that famine year,
@AatishTaseer
Sadly Hindu majoritarianism dominated Congress long before independence & drove secular Muslims like Jinnah to demand safeguards, leading to Pak demand as bargaining counter. Jinnah vindicated by current plight of Indian Muslims 18% population, 2% parliament representation.
@jaredlandry
@BaytAlFann
@Zarb_e_Kalim36
It was a genuine question. I still have no idea whether they were Africans (there were & are differences), Arabs, Muslims or Pagan. You clearly have all the answers. No need for ageist abuse.
@PoliticsJOE_UK
@DalrympleWill
So many non sequiturs for this Remain-voting historian of empire. Having lived half century in UK, I've encountered little nostalgia for empire & none among Brexiteers, nor belief that Britain can survive without allies. Lesson in pitfalls of trying to make history contemporary.
@theJeremyVine
Have you thought of joining police? They need vigilantes like you at every street corner, esply to catch all the cyclists ignoring rules of road.
@RashmiDVS
@UniofOxford
Some of us delighted you were barred. We have enough of your Hindutva poison in India, delighted to be spared it in UK. You are the oppressor, not the victim.
@aljhlester
@nationaltrust
@RestoreTrustNT
As a Restore Trust member, might I suggest the policy is in the name. It would by no means prevent research on imperial connections, but would refrain from making patronising, PC or woke value judgements on the properties it's there to conserve. That's not it's job.