Kenan Malik Profile Banner
Kenan Malik Profile
Kenan Malik

@kenanmalik

35,388
Followers
1,085
Following
989
Media
42,232
Statuses

New book: Not So Black and White (Hurst). “Unsettles the pieties of contemporary race-talk” - Paul Gilroy. “A magical accomplishment” - Remi Adekoya.

London
Joined January 2009
Don't wanna be here? Send us removal request.
Pinned Tweet
@kenanmalik
Kenan Malik
19 days
If I’m only occasionally on Twitter these days, it’s because… I’m only occasionally on Twitter these days. Not quitting but haven’t got the space to engage more frequently or in debates. So, my apologies if I don’t respond to comments. Will be using mainly to link and announce.
2
1
36
@kenanmalik
Kenan Malik
2 years
“To discriminate against trans people in the workplace, to refuse to serve them in a shop, to deliberately misgender as a way of humiliating someone – that is bigotry. To argue for sex-based categories in sport – that is not”: My @ObserverUK column:
94
416
3K
@kenanmalik
Kenan Malik
3 years
Guess it may have to be an annual reminder, too, that the majority of Christians are not white, that the majority of sub-Saharan Africans are Christian (and make up nearly a quarter of the world’s Christians), 1/
Tweet media one
64
361
2K
@kenanmalik
Kenan Malik
7 months
Supporting the rights of Palestinian people is not the same as supporting Hamas but requires condemnation of Hamas, its actions and policies. Condemning Hamas is not the same as supporting Israel’s treatment of Palestinians, its occupation, bombings and collective punishment.
48
366
2K
@kenanmalik
Kenan Malik
2 years
Hoping that Salman Rushdie is not seriously injured. A reminder yet again of the costs that writers face for refusing to be bound by taboos, for challenging the demands of blasphemy.
18
281
1K
@kenanmalik
Kenan Malik
9 months
Well, this should be interesting. Just received an email from @Telegraph informing me that they’re running an article about me. 1/
50
435
1K
@kenanmalik
Kenan Malik
4 years
I would have thought that the beheading of a teacher is a bit more of a “provocation”. This is effectively an argument that says “Keep murdering people in the most barbaric ways because then you will get what you want.”
@RmSalih
Roshan M Salih
4 years
#CharlieHebdo must be shut down immediately by French authorities. This racist, Islamophobic rag is causing community relations to completely break down with its repeated provocations. They are literally crying fire in a crowded theatre. Freedom of speech isn't worth civil war.
5K
116
292
35
369
1K
@kenanmalik
Kenan Malik
3 years
A few thoughts on the Batley school Muhammed image controversy. Since the facts are unclear, these are as much about the general issues as the case itself. 1. There is no right not to be offended. This is as true in a classroom as anywhere else. Context matters.
34
362
1K
@kenanmalik
Kenan Malik
8 years
Trump's Skittles analogy reminded me of this from 1903 on Jewish immigration to Britain.
Tweet media one
52
975
1K
@kenanmalik
Kenan Malik
8 months
No. We should not impose on people of particular identities, backgrounds or experiences the responsibility for having the “right” views and judge those views more harshly than if they were held by someone, say, white, male or privileged. That’s a dangerous road to go down. 1/
@mehdirhasan
Mehdi Hasan
8 months
You could argue that she’s worse than Enoch Powell because at least he wasn’t the brown child of immigrants.
516
162
1K
46
157
1K
@kenanmalik
Kenan Malik
2 years
It’s even more frustrating to read comments from lawyers with huge platforms who apparently haven’t read the point I make in the article that it’s those without power and platforms within minority communities who most suffer from the failure of liberals to defend free speech…
@JolyonMaugham
Jo Maugham
2 years
So frustrating to read, even well intentioned like this, pieces on free speech that don't engage with relative power. Who actually has a platform to speak - and for what purpose do they use it, to challenge or to embed power?
166
78
533
25
189
1K
@kenanmalik
Kenan Malik
3 years
The romanticism of poverty, by those who can afford to romanticise it.
22
130
1K
@kenanmalik
Kenan Malik
2 months
“It is immoral to introduce the Holocaust into discussions about the destruction of Gaza. Except to justify mass killings in Gaza.”
@jpodhoretz
John Podhoretz
2 months
6 million of my family were killed.
1K
62
665
23
217
1K
@kenanmalik
Kenan Malik
2 years
Given the continuing debate about Suella Braverman, and why she could have such odious views on immigration given that she (like Priti Patel before her) is Asian and a child of immigrants, a few points to think about: 1/
35
387
1K
@kenanmalik
Kenan Malik
2 years
So, I find myself in Stewart Lee’s “Pedal Bin” alongside Donald Trump, Nadine Dorries, Eric Clapton and the Taliban. Don’t what I’ve done to upset that nice Mr Lee, but at least he could have spelt my name right. (Not that difficult given we’ve got columns in the same newspaper)
90
79
1K
@kenanmalik
Kenan Malik
9 months
@openinnovteam @StevenEdginton All I can say is that I look forward to the article. And I await the response from the government’s free speech tsar. And from free speech advocates @Telegraph . 6/
5
61
974
@kenanmalik
Kenan Malik
2 years
@JolyonMaugham Jolyon, your view seems to be that you criticising my article is “conspicuously polite” but me challenging your criticism can only be the product of “hostility or personal animus”. Let’s just say that I conspicuously politely disagree.
12
99
948
@kenanmalik
Kenan Malik
2 years
2. The views of black or Asian Tories are shaped not simply by their skin colour or immigration status. They are shaped also by class, privilege, education, etc. The focus simply on their ethnicity or immigration status shows how reductive identity thinking can be. 3/
7
113
934
@kenanmalik
Kenan Malik
4 years
Paris, Nice, Kabul, Vienna. These are not responses to particular political policies, or to the giving of “offence”. Let’s not dignify them so. They are expressions of nihilist Islamist terror, terror for purpose of sowing fear, of provoking a response.
20
231
842
@kenanmalik
Kenan Malik
9 months
@Telegraph And I’m quite happy to talk to @Telegraph journalists/executives either about immigration or about the history of race and identity politics. (So long as they pay me enough.)
21
49
867
@kenanmalik
Kenan Malik
2 years
The fact that many people care about religion does not mean I should not criticise, insult or mock it any more than the fact that many people care about the Conservative Party or Critical Race Theory or Manchester United means I should not criticise, insult or mock any of those.
@LadyVelvet_HFQ
Hend F Q
2 years
Free speech does not authorize you to insult, condescend & mock other religious figures & religions. Some people don’t care about their religion but some do. Play a stupid game - you will win a stupid prize. Your call. Some people only want fame no matter the cost/sacrifice.
2K
185
1K
41
134
843
@kenanmalik
Kenan Malik
9 months
My views on the Rwanda deportation scheme, and on the government’s immigration policies, are hardly a secret. But, just in case, here are some articles to read:
3
122
775
@kenanmalik
Kenan Malik
2 years
1. Braverman, Patel, etc do not have odious views simply on immigration. They have equally odious views on welfare, workers’ rights, etc. They are rightwing Tories and their views, like those of white rightwing Tories, on all these issues are shaped by their broader ideology. 2/
7
91
760
@kenanmalik
Kenan Malik
3 years
And at the top of this list of infamy, by far, is the UK
@ValerioDeC
Valerio De Cesaris
3 years
From 2008 to 2020 European countries repatried more than 70,000 Afghan asylum seekers, saying that #Afghanistan was a safe country. via @emmevilla
Tweet media one
8
274
369
16
389
731
@kenanmalik
Kenan Malik
1 year
It was a scuffed book. The more you give people licence to take offence, the more some will seize the opportunity to take offence.
@5Pillarsuk
5Pillars
1 year
Kettlethorpe High School headteacher, Tudor Griffiths, described the Quran desecration on Wednesday as "a sad day," and pledged "more consequences" will be implemented if necessary. Inspector Andy Thornton said the incident wasn't a criminal matter, but a learning opportunity.
1K
94
242
27
102
704
@kenanmalik
Kenan Malik
8 years
Anyone who thinks ploughing a lorry indiscriminately through a crowd is 'blowback' has long crossed the moral line.
@RmSalih
Roshan M Salih
8 years
France is an Islamophobic nation with a hugely destructive foreign policy and these horrible attacks are a terrible blowback #NiceAttack
802
101
64
56
514
582
@kenanmalik
Kenan Malik
3 years
Will probably write about Race Commission Report properly for Sunday, but a few thoughts. Having spent much of the last few years questioning arguments about racial disparities, insisting that we need to think about the complex interplay of race and class… 1/
23
290
662
@kenanmalik
Kenan Malik
4 years
‘Neither the French nor the British were the first to abolish slavery. Haiti [was] the first nation to permanently ban slavery and the slave trade from the first day of its existence’: @JuliaGaffield on the historical importance of the Haitian Revolution:
17
232
637
@kenanmalik
Kenan Malik
3 months
“What prevents British workers from having British homes are not queue-jumping immigrants but the failure of the authorities to build sufficient housing. Yet, the myth persists… nurtured by politicians, pundits and academics”: My @ObserverUK column:
159
239
662
@kenanmalik
Kenan Malik
6 years
I have no idea how porters generally treat non-white Cambridge academics but if the one example given in this thread is anything to go by, it’s not the porter who is being rude or demonstrating entitlement or revealing ‘unconscious bias’.
28
128
614
@kenanmalik
Kenan Malik
5 years
Covering up a painting deemed blasphemous is not a ‘compromise’ between freedom of expression and the censorship of blasphemy. It is giving in to those who insist that blasphemous images or texts should be forbidden or unseen:
33
284
594
@kenanmalik
Kenan Malik
1 year
What is “unacceptable” are the actions of the school, especially given that “there was no malicious intent by those involved”. I’m all for “respecting” books – all books – but not what is effectively a backdoor imposition of blasphemy regulations.
25
148
636
@kenanmalik
Kenan Malik
1 year
Publication day!
Tweet media one
52
130
635
@kenanmalik
Kenan Malik
5 years
Pakistan’s supreme court judges had the spine to set Asia Bibi free. The British prime minister apparently has neither the courage nor the compassion to grant her asylum:
37
350
561
@kenanmalik
Kenan Malik
4 years
What nurtures reactionaries, both within Muslim communities and outside it, is the unwillingness of too many liberals to stand up for basic liberal principles, to defend the right to give offence, and not retreat every time something like this happens.
20
164
579
@kenanmalik
Kenan Malik
8 years
Worth celebrating not so much that Sadiq Khan is London's first Muslim mayor but that for many Londoners that was irrelevant to their vote.
14
528
583
@kenanmalik
Kenan Malik
9 months
I should add, btw, given this seems to be what has irked @Telegraph , I am not going to be talking about immigration in this talk, just about the themes of my book, esp the history of the idea of race, of antiracism and of identity politics.
2
45
590
@kenanmalik
Kenan Malik
7 months
Now we come to the nub of the matter. For me, the bar isn’t at a different place for a “brown child of immigrants” than it is for a white politician with similar views. It’s at exactly the same place. I judge the views not the identity. One of the fundamental divides of our time.
@mehdirhasan
Mehdi Hasan
7 months
I’m not sure what’s so hard. On the issue of immigration, my bar for the white racist is lower than it is for the brown child of immigrants.
15
7
82
27
85
566
@kenanmalik
Kenan Malik
2 years
“Human beings, Rushdie observed in his 1990 essay In Good Faith, ‘shape their futures by arguing and challenging and questioning and saying the unsayable; not by bowing the knee whether to gods or to men’” My @ObserverUK column:
22
188
550
@kenanmalik
Kenan Malik
3 years
...that 5 of the top 10 countries with largest Christian populations are Nigeria, DRC, Ethiopia, Philippines, China, Brazil & Mexico. And that many critics of white supremacy can be profoundly Euro- and Anglocentric, too. 2/
8
27
521
@kenanmalik
Kenan Malik
3 years
3. There are no blasphemy laws in Britain and – despite media reports – no prohibition in Islam against depicting Muhammed. It’s a modern taboo in many Sunni strands. In Iran, there are depictions of Muhammed even in a mosque. There are many manuscripts with such depictions.
9
115
515
@kenanmalik
Kenan Malik
5 years
As Indian captain, Sourav Ganguly rarely backed down. And he seems still not to do so, refusing the BJP demand to remove Imran Khan’s portrait from Eden Gardens:
36
184
499
@kenanmalik
Kenan Malik
2 years
…especially the ones who spout off about “relative power” without seemingly understanding what it means in the real world.
10
41
510
@kenanmalik
Kenan Malik
1 year
“The very question 'was Cleopatra black or white?' tells us much more about ourselves, and our world, and the confusions that beset our understanding of race and identity, than they do about Cleopatra and her world”: My @ObserverUK column:
232
108
499
@kenanmalik
Kenan Malik
3 years
6. No teacher should be sacked simply for showing offensive material in class. The context matters.
4
44
477
@kenanmalik
Kenan Malik
2 years
Perhaps there will come a day when the only character you can play is yourself
@MailOnline
Daily Mail Online
2 years
Jewish actress Maureen Lipman says Helen Mirren should NOT have been cast as Golda Meir
55
5
10
22
44
468
@kenanmalik
Kenan Malik
2 years
I’m amazed. And thank you to Stewart Lee 🤣
@Martina
Martina Navratilova
2 years
@kenanmalik @blablafishcakes Don’t know who Stewart Lee is, but you are worth a follow regardless:)
9
12
403
13
15
454
@kenanmalik
Kenan Malik
3 years
You couldn’t make it up #9657 . Home Office denies Windrush victim Trevor Donald the right to return home to Britain for 9 years, admits it was in the wrong, but denies him British citizenship - because he was out of Britain for more than five years.
20
264
451
@kenanmalik
Kenan Malik
6 years
So, I’m a racist? Thanks for letting me know. (Wonder if James Baldwin was also a racist for debating William F Buckley? Or the many figures (from Trevor Huddlestone to Dennis Skinner) who publicly debated Enoch Powell?)
41
108
424
@kenanmalik
Kenan Malik
4 years
A few thoughts on the Trevor Phillips controversy. I’m in two minds as to whether to post this on Twitter as the very nature of Twitter discussions serves only to exacerbate the polarised character of the debate, and erase nuance. But here goes (and it may be a long thread). 1/
26
158
439
@kenanmalik
Kenan Malik
1 year
“Kureishi wrote his novels and screenplays for the same reason that I read them and watched them: to tear up the old cultural map and to discover where we stood in the new landscape we were creating” My @ObserverUK column on Hanif Kureishi:
7
109
450
@kenanmalik
Kenan Malik
9 months
Exclusive: I'm going to be talking about my book (not on immigration). And if you got out of your office a bit more you might discover that there are plenty of people who would describe Suella Braverman’s views on immigration as “odious”.
@StevenEdginton
Steven Edginton
9 months
Exclusive: Border officials are set to be addressed by a pro-migration academic @kenanmalik who has described Suella Braverman’s views on immigration as “odious”. The govt event is to be held in work hours and will discuss "whiteness and privilege".
214
168
408
14
81
445
@kenanmalik
Kenan Malik
6 months
Nothing from 5Pillars should surprise us, but, even so, this is shocking
@DillyHussain88
Dilly Hussain
6 months
This is the kind of welcome ALL Israelis should be receiving at the airports of Muslim-majority countries.
6K
1K
6K
12
65
427
@kenanmalik
Kenan Malik
3 years
Is it really so difficult to say that not all reactionaries are white? That many blacks or Asians or Latinos are conservative, even reactionary, just as it’s the case in every group?
16
44
408
@kenanmalik
Kenan Malik
1 year
“When we say… that Cleopatra was Black, we claim [her] as part of a culture and history that has known oppression and triumph, exploitation and survival.” Leaving aside that Cleopatra was an absolute monarch… 1/
161
47
416
@kenanmalik
Kenan Malik
3 years
“Many who most worry about “white decline” are also among the most strident critics of identity politics… Rightwing critics have never been hostile to identity politics. They just want to push *their* form of identity politics”: My @ObserverUK column:
47
116
411
@kenanmalik
Kenan Malik
2 years
We should also remember how much more restrictive those boundaries have become since 1988 when The Satanic Verses was published. As @Hanifkureishi has observed, it is not a novel that would be written today, let alone published.
7
118
394
@kenanmalik
Kenan Malik
4 years
I see that the Uighurs, the Tibetans, the people of Hong Kong, those shackled in cheap labour factories, any critic of the Chinese government, have all been cancelled.
@agent_of_change
Carlos
4 years
China will soon be the world's largest economy. It'll be the first nation to reach that status whose rise isn't built on colonialism, slavery & genocide, but rather on hard work, good economics & effective governance. This should earn China love, but it earns it hate in the West.
14K
1K
4K
17
121
383
@kenanmalik
Kenan Malik
1 year
It's one thing to argue that perceptions of the “intellectual” often constrained by race and class. Quite another to suggest that, before now, nobody thought of WEB Du Bois or Pauli Murray or Ralph Ellison or James Baldwin or Toni Morrison as intellectuals
12
50
392
@kenanmalik
Kenan Malik
9 months
And according to Priti Patel, to have invited me is “extraordinary betrayal of the voters who elected us to take back control of our borders in 2019”. So much for “free speech” and “diversity viewpoint” and “don’t live in echo chamber” etc, etc.
6
56
396
@kenanmalik
Kenan Malik
3 years
And, finally, since I don’t want to spend all day trapped on Twitter, I will probably ignore most responses to this thread. I have a book to write…
14
15
380
@kenanmalik
Kenan Malik
6 years
It’s 50 years ago today that Tommie Smith and John Carlos stood on the Olympic podium at the Mexico City Olympic Games with fists clenched in a protest about racism and the treatment of African Americans. A protest that still has such meaning today.
Tweet media one
7
178
359
@kenanmalik
Kenan Malik
2 years
4. The Rwandan deportation scheme did not simply fall out of the sky. It’s merely the latest development in the ratcheting up of anti-immigrant policy, from offshoring, the creation of Fortress Europe, the outsourcing of controls for third countries, etc. 5/
5
39
369
@kenanmalik
Kenan Malik
4 years
Ralph Leonard ( @buffsoldier_96 ) on the 'assumption that white people have the liberty to break out of their “roots” and become universal, cosmopolitan and protean. But “people of colour” are particular, rooted in their cultural and spiritual traditions’:
9
109
350
@kenanmalik
Kenan Malik
8 years
What the terrorists despised, what they tried to eliminate, were ordinary people, drinking, eating, laughing, mixing. 3/
18
613
332
@kenanmalik
Kenan Malik
3 years
Are these kinds of segregated, sorry multicultural, graduation ceremonies common in American universities?
Tweet media one
73
96
330
@kenanmalik
Kenan Malik
2 years
9. The real question we should be asking is not “why are children of immigrants, or ethnic minority politicians, have such odious views on immigration?” but rather “Why are so many on the left enabling odious policies?” 10/
14
53
346
@kenanmalik
Kenan Malik
5 years
So, an image from@(almost) the edge of Britain...
Tweet media one
9
42
345
@kenanmalik
Kenan Malik
1 year
“The reduction of racism to whiteness makes it more difficult to build solidarity. It has also made many blind to the realities of racism”: My @ObserverUK column: My @ObserverUK column:
32
96
345
@kenanmalik
Kenan Malik
9 months
@openinnovteam @StevenEdginton And they will “publish an accusation that your invitation is in breach of government rules on vetting outside speakers to Whitehall for "potentially problematic or controversial material that may contravene civil service values". 5/
15
38
343
@kenanmalik
Kenan Malik
3 years
So, “students of color” is a label for students from groups that, as an aggregate, perform worse? And if, as an aggregate, a group shows better performance, its members are no longer deemed to be “people of color”? I’m not sure someone has quite thought this through…
@StevenWelliever
Steven Welliever
3 years
Asian kids officially kicked out of "students of color" category by a WA school district.
Tweet media one
1K
3K
13K
26
60
327
@kenanmalik
Kenan Malik
7 years
Have to say I’m impressed by the level of reasoned debate my article seems to have generated.
@THISisLULE
Elsbeth Tashioni
7 years
Fuck you for this.
7
0
2
16
63
306
@kenanmalik
Kenan Malik
8 years
Rather they attacked places where mainly young, antiracist multiethnic Parisians hang out, places that represent diversity. 2/
15
652
319
@kenanmalik
Kenan Malik
4 years
We should in fact do the opposite in response to acts such as this: reaffirm our commitment to free speech and the right to give offence.
3
44
317
@kenanmalik
Kenan Malik
8 months
People with the same experiences or family backgrounds can interpret those experiences and that background in significantly different ways depending on their broader ideologies. It's the interpretation & ideologies we should judge, not the identity of the person holding them. 2/
15
28
324
@kenanmalik
Kenan Malik
9 months
@openinnovteam It’s a zoom meeting due to taken place next month. The email from @StevenEdginton (the Telegraph’s “Video Comment Editor”) tells me that “We will be publishing details of your previous comments describing Priti Patel and Sulla Braverman's views on immigration as ‘odious’… 3/
12
27
331
@kenanmalik
Kenan Malik
2 years
“We are the inheritors of centuries of struggle against restrictions on what we are able to say. If we forget the lessons of those struggles, we are in danger also of letting the gains of those struggles slip away.” My @ObserverUK column:
20
109
325
@kenanmalik
Kenan Malik
1 month
“Fearless” is not the first word that comes to mind to describe someone advocating collective punishment.
@etanadeeIL
Etana Hecht 🇮🇱 🇺🇸
1 month
"I treat the Palestinians in Gaza in the same way I would treat any other group that produced a horror like that. They're responsible for their actions." The fearless @DouglasKMurray sat with @EylonALevy on his podcast @stateofapod and clearly laid out the facts of how the…
2K
2K
5K
40
59
323
@kenanmalik
Kenan Malik
7 months
I judge people’s views, their hypocrisy, their record, but not by their skin colour.
@mehdirhasan
Mehdi Hasan
7 months
So you never judge anyone’s hypocrisy? Or track record? You only, in some imaginary highbrow pure manner, judge the views, in isolation? In a vacuum? Come on. Lol.
24
21
139
17
28
316
@kenanmalik
Kenan Malik
2 years
7. David Blunkett explored the possibilities of offshoring back in the early Noughties. Theresa May introduced the “hostile environment” policies. Why should we be so startled that Patel, Braverman, etc, are continuing this process, ratcheting it even further? 8/
3
44
315
@kenanmalik
Kenan Malik
3 years
Frederick Douglass on his first visit to Ireland, at the beginning of the Famine: “I have never heard songs like those anywhere since I left slavery, except when in Ireland. There I heard the same wailing notes, and was much affected by them.”
4
64
312
@kenanmalik
Kenan Malik
3 years
4. Some claim pupils were shown one of the Danish cartoons depicting Muhammed with a bomb his turban. The problem, such critics say, is racism not blasphemy. Given what happened after the Samuel Patty murder in Paris, we should be wary of taking stories as true.
3
29
308
@kenanmalik
Kenan Malik
8 years
We need to junk the fiction that attacks had any link with Syria or foreign policy. Terrorists did not target symbols of the French state 1/
46
587
302
@kenanmalik
Kenan Malik
9 months
Some months ago, I received an invitation from @openinnovteam , which is a cross-government unit that "works with academics to generate analysis and ideas for policy” to talk about the themes of my book *Not So Black and White*. 2/
1
28
310
@kenanmalik
Kenan Malik
9 months
@openinnovteam @StevenEdginton “…and your criticism of the government's Rwanda plans” and “highlighting that policy makers in the Home Office, specifically the Migration and Borders Group, were invited to your talk about your book”. 4/
1
23
308
@kenanmalik
Kenan Malik
1 year
Here’s Nigel Biggar from his new book *Colonialism: A Moral Reckoning*, providing a moral assessment of British brutality in the aftermath of the “Indian Mutiny”, including the practice of tying victims to the mouths of cannons to be blown apart:
Tweet media one
25
119
305
@kenanmalik
Kenan Malik
3 years
2. The boundaries of speech are, of course, different in a classroom than in the world outside. One is dealing with minors, building a relationship with them, encouraging them to think, and to think about issues that they may not have, or may not have wanted to.
1
33
296
@kenanmalik
Kenan Malik
3 years
5. But even if true, it’s not an argument not to have used it in class. Should one play a clip of a Bernard Manning joke, show an anti-Semitic cartoon, discuss a Charlie Hebdo cover? It depends on context.
4
22
293
@kenanmalik
Kenan Malik
9 months
Once more to quote Eric Williams: “British historians write almost as if Britain had introduced Negro slavery solely for the satisfaction of abolishing it.”
@NickBuckleyMBE
Nick Buckley 4 Mayor
9 months
Tweet media one
1K
964
4K
15
84
296
@kenanmalik
Kenan Malik
3 years
Book gets published which describes me, among other things, as “fanatical”, an “extremist” and an “Islamophobe”. Book doesn’t make a splash. So, author emails, asking me to review it: “It will be great if you took me to task”. Yeah, right🤣. Best left to fester in silence.
14
20
287