At almost every interview I’m asked, “wouldn’t public promotion of your religion result in a vision of the good not shared by everyone, and thus exclusion and even oppression?”
Waiting for all the Rawlsians to denounce comprehensive doctrines in the public square.
Or is it possible they were talking about just *one* belief system that should be excluded…?
You know it’s a damn fine day when attacks on your book by the NYT and Reason magazine expose how left and right liberals ultimately close ranks to defend their nest. Thanks for proving my points.
There’s no Lutheran church of any significance that would inspire the opposite. Theirs is an unintentional acknowledgment of their inferiority. My thoughts: pity that should inspire our prayers.
This photo of wealthy American Protestants travelling to Rome to display their disdain for Catholics has divided opinion online, what are your thoughts?
Watch to the end. It’s how we felt every time we learned our family was growing.
And what this doesn’t show is the incomparable joy of reminiscing over the rambunctious, sometimes challenging years of infancy, with one’s marvelous adult children.
This ten-year-old Coke commercial (released only in Argentina), remains the single best minute-long argument for pro-natalism that I have ever seen.
@MoreBirths
@BirthGauge
As a proud son of sons of Ireland, it has been a challenging several years watching it seemingly supine to the colonialism of financialized, woke liberalism. I pray this referendum marks a return to the Irish way: fierce resistance imperialist efforts to eradicate Irishness.
Ireland has voted No in the Family referendum.
The final result has been just announced at Dublin Castle with 1,021,546 people, or 67%, voting No and 487,564 people voting Yes | Follow live updates:
I was profoundly honored and humbled by an invitation from Bishop Robert Barron to appear on his program “Bishop Barron Presents.” We recorded yesterday in the “Word on Fire” studio in Rochester, MN. Our discussion was ranging and, dare I say, of real depth and substance. Of…
I’ve received my annual sales report from Yale University Press. “Why Liberalism Failed” has sold over 60,000 copies since its publication (in all formats), in English alone. It has or will be translated into 20 languages. I’m blown away by this interest. Thank you, readers.
Russell Kirk wrote: “Order precedes justice and freedom.” Most so-called conservatives today argue that we need more freedom. I argue instead “it is not liberty that is primarily under assault; what is being rejected is order.”
My latest
@PostlibOrder
:
Gotta love the “freedom” people calling for my cancellation at Notre Dame. Notice that his “freedom” agenda translates into a call for an exercise of power to effect a desired end. Liberalism is relentlessly authoritarian in its efforts to dismantle a society of order and virtue.
I respectfully disagree with my friend
@McCormickProf
. The lesson we should derive from recent events is that there is no value neutrality. Arguments that he now invokes were first used to replace the Christian basis of higher education (e.g. Princeton) with a progressive faith.
It is CRITICAL that we derive the right message--and avoid deriving the wrong one--from Liz Magill's "voluntary" resignation. The wrong one is that universities like Penn need more restrictions of speech. The right one is that double standards will no longer be tolerated.
At least they are acknowledging that what they actually mean is “liberalism.” They cling to the word “democracy” - even to criticize electoral outcomes - because it confers legitimacy. They recognize that simply to describe their position as “liberal” is a losing proposition.
We don’t want you to forget what was never true. Corporations are not people. Corporations are creations of the political order, and are subject to considerations of the common good.
Notre Dame is far from perfect, but I’m grateful to teach at an institution where our Jewish students are welcome, and where our semester ends as it should: in discussion, study, examination of knowledge won these past several months, and celebration of the achievements of our…
Disappointed doesn’t quite capture my response to First Things publishing a Nietzsche-lite article by a Twitter anon. The justified opposition to Wokeism increasingly dominating the mainstream right is in danger of descending into very dark places.
No book I’ve written or will write could prove my main point more thoroughly than a single tweet by this lib. Liberalism is not neutral and enforces its version of disordered liberty. Once people see it, they can’t unsee.
Major conservative institutions are hiring individuals on the right who claim to be conservative but are openly hostile to free markets. Instead of fighting to cut the size and scope of the federal government, they are happy to utilize big government to achieve their preferred…
My next book, “Regime Change,” will be published one month from today - June 6. I attempt to answer some of the questions that arise in the wake of my last book : “what should we do”?
This paper was delivered at a conference I attended in which my book was the main bone of contention. Based on my experience at campuses all over America, Garsten was correct. As Alasdair MacIntyre, anticipated years ago, the choice comes down simply to Aristotle or Nietzsche.
In 1978 Bill Moyers denounced a political movement which sought “that a secular and pluralist society fix into law a certain moral opinion not shared by the community as a whole….”
As many of you have become aware, last week a display was erected at the Iowa Capitol by the Satanic Temple of Iowa. As I have responded to concerns from Iowans about the display, I wanted to share with you how the display came to be and my response.
How did it happen?
• The…
Perhaps the highlight of last night’s book launch wasn’t even the packed house (which was great!) or wonderful interlocutors, including Senator Vance (which was fantastic!), but getting to see and hold my actual new book for the first time. Always a bit unreal and finally real!
In which I am taken to task for believing racism is indeed a problem in America. My hopes for a multi-racial working class party are off-putting to the “right” people.
Another post-liberal is Patrick Deneen, author of Why Liberalism Failed and professor at the University of Notre Dame.
Deneen believes that racism “was and is” a big problem in America. This is a liberal talking point. Nothing “post-liberal” about it.
Earlier today I was honored to deliver a lecture at the US Naval Academy. Afterwards I was approached by a large number of midshipmen wanting to continue the discussion, with intelligence, curiosity, and deep seriousness. Later I lifted a few jars with several “Firsties” who will…
Pornhub has “completely disable[d] access to our website in Arkansas,” apparently in protest of the state's new age-verification law, which takes effect Aug. 1.
The website has banned IP addresses from Utah, Virginia and Mississippi bc of similar laws.
@IrishRoverND
on the dismissal of Tamara Kay v The Irish Rover: “The Indiana Court ruling reaffirms the Rover’s initial statement on the baseless lawsuit. As stated then, the articles were ‘fair and accurate in all respects.’”
More of this. Universities must be answerable for what their faculty have fostered, and now are further encouraging by constant caving to the anti-Semitism in their midst.
“I do not want my family’s name associated with the University of Pennsylvania — ever.”
Steve Eisman, famous for “The Big Short,” instructed
@Penn
to remove his family’s name from a scholarship at the university:
I’m scheduled to appear on “Fox & Friends” tomorrow (Sunday) morning at 8:20 a.m. It will take me the next ten hours to distill a new book into a three minute segment, in which I expect to have @ 20 seconds of actual speaking time.
But do tune in, if only to see the impossible!!
Note well that what right liberals are today “conserving” is the first stage of the progressive liberal revolution in higher education. Thus, it ends up only “conserving” the very virus that has led us to the current pass.
@VictorTWolff
@McCormickProf
This “ideal” was first advanced in the US by … John Dewey (“Academic Freedom, 1902). He understood well that its claims were not “neutral,” but harbored progressive assumptions and substance.
One of the best and most important essays I have read on the growing alignment between the racist “Eugenicons” and conventional libertarians, by the indispensable Michael Lind.
It’s not “ok with me” that a university wouldn’t “punish students for calling for the elimination of Israel and Israelis.”The very notion that calls for genocide would be OK, as long as we can also disagree over pronouns, is no less bankrupt than the current campus hypocrisy.
As a professor who favors free speech on campus, I can sympathize with the "nuanced" answers given by U. presidents yesterday, about whether calls to attack or wipe out Israel violate campus speech policies.
What offends me is that since 2015, universities have been so quick to…
My greetings to new followers near and far!
Our ruling class is corrupt and corrupting. We need regime change.
This is the title of my new book, to be released on Tuesday. Have a look!
Harvard President Claudine Gay is asked about the percentage of conservative profs at Harvard
Gay: “I don’t have that statistic, we don’t collect that data”
Harvard Crimson survey provides a glimpse: less than 3% of profs hold conservative views
80 years ago, a public school text could have a beautiful illustration of a mother with her new baby surrounded by the rest of the family. How we have so completely collapsed in 80 years will some day make for interesting history. But it's awful to watch in real time.
@PatrickDeneen
is a dangerous man who needs to be investigated for potential insurrection activities and for being a traitor to American Democracy.
@TheJusticeDept
and the
@FBI
should be looking hard at him every day.
My friend and
@MLB
pitcher Blake Treinen asked that I post this statement for him in regards to the
@Dodgers
honoring of the sisters of perpetual indulgence.
#HoldTheLine
Having naively gone through the bait-and-switch many times by journalists who claim to be seeking greater understanding of conservatism, but then write a hatchet job, I no longer accept any invitations to speak to journalists, and recommend the same to others similarly situated.
I am sure all of us have had the experience of reading a story about a subject you know well and finding it replete with inaccuracies and falsehoods. One then turns the page and reads an article about a subject one knows less well and makes the mistake of believing that this…
I learned last weekend from my best friend in High School, and the best man at my wedding, that his grandfather illustrated this book. Having now paged through it, one immediate conclusion is, let’s get this back into print. Saints as heroes, the sainthood we need today.
It was a blast to appear on Fox & Friends with my student of old (Princeton),
@PeteHegseth
. So proud of your life’s path, from a killer three-point shooting guard, to a soldier on the front lines, to a morning news superstar!
I’m thrilled to appear for the first time in the indispensable
@unherd
. I dispense with right liberal invocations of JS Mill’s arguments for free speech, arguing that Mill wanted exactly the kind of despotism of progress that dominates the West today.
Heartening to play a role in ejecting JS Mill from the conservative pantheon. Locke? Check. Mill? Check. Once you understand that conservatism is the antithesis of liberalism, then you can more easily identify its foes.
I’m very excited - and honored, to be joined by Senator
@JDVance1
, Heritage Foundation President
@KevinRobertsTX
, and Washington Post columnist
@ChristineEmba
for a discussion of my forthcoming book “Regime Change.” May 17 at CUA in DC. Info here:
This is intended not only as a critique of the right, but a warning to the left. More and more its extremism is creating the very thing they claim to be combatting.
Basic assumptions of human nature will inform academic hiring, tenuring, promotion, curriculum, admissions, student life, and so on. A worldview will predominate. One must choose.
💯 agree. Anti Wokeism is not a constructive political project. For too many, it’s become a form of performative outrage without any further ideals. Necessary, but far from sufficient.
It makes for very negative, angry and bitter people who are in a symbiotic relationship with the 'woke' provocateurs. They enjoy railing against it: they NEED their opponents and wouldn't have anything constructive or interesting to say if their opponents disappeared tomorrow
I know I've said it before, but it was a grave error for conservatives to form a coalition with libertarians. Slade can quote Garnett to try to get a conservative-ish vibe, but the position on display here is functionally leftist.
Tony Esolen is easily among the greatest teachers I have ever encountered. The fact he is now a “free agent” is perhaps the greatest indictment yet against our near-total morally and intellectually bankrupt educational system.
For the 1st time since 1987, I'm a free agent!
If there's a classical Christian / Catholic school that wants somebody who can teach 3000 years of literature, and a lot of art, history, theology, philosophy, and linguistics to boot, full time (on line, mostly):
Send me a PM.
It’s true that I and others seek to dissociate classical liberalism from conservatism. It’s incorrect that we are “white Christian nationalists.” So vital to do the reading.
Awaiting breathless NYT coverage of Pope Francis’s latest, decrying consumerism and individualism as the antithesis of “freedom,” and calling instead for commitment to community and formation of “large families” -
All this is true and very well-said. And more: only by making clear the cruelty of purported “non-judgmentalism,” we begin to
push back against the dominant narrative advanced by those who are today bringing about a culture of inhumanity and despair.
Bit tired of people saying 'there are no votes in social conservatism or having Christian values inform your politics'. Not sure that that is necessarily true, but even if it is, I don't care. If the truth put me in a minority of one, the truth would be no less the truth
Shedding light on the ugly anti-Catholicism of recent Democratic administrations, first going after nuns, now “traditional” Catholics. Thank you,
@HawleyMO
.
FBI says “traditionalist Catholics” are a terrorist risk and should be monitored. So how many spies and sources do they have in America’s churches? Garland won’t answer
There’s not an awful lot I miss about having left the DC environs, but here’s one big exception. Still, distance has not dimmed one of the great friendships of a blessed lifetime.
@KurtSchlichter
@PatrickDeneen
He is explicitly hostile to America's founding principles, and his "mixed constitution" of a "demos" that tears down the existing order through "popular uprising" to be guided by a virtuous "elite" sounds a whole lot like a Marxism-Leninism of the right.
For those who may have missed it over Labor Day weekend:
Most so-called conservatives today argue that we need more freedom. I argue instead “it is not liberty that is primarily under assault; what is being rejected is order.”
My latest
@PostlibOrder
:
Last grad seminar meeting of the semester today.✅ Wonderful discussions of very stimulating material -“Science, Technology, and Political Philosophy. A celebratory libation is in order.
I met a literary hero of mine tonight, the great
@walterkirn
. I read his marvelous memoir “Lost in the Meritocracy” while feeling a similar sense of estrangement at Princeton, albeit while I was a young professor there.
Interesting. I had applied for a “blue check” under the old regime and had been denied. I was much more active on Twitter then. Now that I’ve cut back on social media, I’m suddenly “influential.” Good move all around.
THE CHILLING EFFECT IS THE POINT.
After
@pornhub
complied with the Louisiana antiporn law, traffic to the site dropped 80 PERCENT. And for every visitor that does verify, it costs them money.
@xhamster
experienced the same.
These bills are designed to kill adult businesses.
This morning at Compact magazine: “Regime Change for America.” We have been governed for over a half-century by a Uniparty of Disorder. The popular uprising against the devastation they have wrought is a demand for order, stability, and balance.
Breaking:
21 Members of Congress, led by
@RepDLamborn
, just filed a house resolution declaring that children in the womb are legal & constitutional persons who are protected by the 14th Amendment and entitled to equal protection of our nation's laws
“Truth-seeking” is of course a core priority of academic institutions. But when truths are known, they ought then to predominate. The left understands this. Christians - those who founded the likes of Princeton - once did as well.
There’s always the temptation to think there is some pure realm of free speech. But it does not exist. The question will always be, what are the boundaries within a given institution (or nation), and why? Those boundaries themselves can be debated, but they cannot be avoided.
My final day of a week visiting, meeting, and lecturing in Vienna, Győr, and Budapest. As ever, an amazing experience and enlightening conversations made possible by
@MCC_Budapest
. Special thanks to
@BalazsOrban_HU
for his great work and marvelous new book. Köszönöm!
Phillip sees the coming world-altering changes with clarity and chilling foresight. Israel has little choice, but of those it has, nearly all are bad. A bracing thread.
Strategically what do Hamas hope to achieve? Asking this question is inseparable from asking what does Iran hope to achieve? They both abhor a two state solution, neither wants peace with Israel in any form & both want hegemony. Hamas over the Palestinian people, Iran regionally
In a better future, they won’t write lines like, “Deneen was mobbed like a pop star afterwards…” but instead, “Taylor Swift was mobbed like a political theorist afterwards….” 😂😂
Nice write-up of last week’s talk at CUA. Thanks to
@ampostliberal
and
@ISI
.
✍️
@amconmag
: “While
@PatrickDeneen
’s discussion was indeed an enlightening crash course on postliberalism, what was arguably more interesting was how young the crowd gathered … was.”
We’re just getting started. Check out our profile in TAC! ⬇️⬇️⬇️
I encourage subscribers to read the whole of this essay. I’ve been mulling these ideas for some months, particularly the notion that the great threat faced in America today is the deprivation of freedom. Rather, I think it is the deprivation of order.
After a summer hiatus,
@PatrickDeneen
returns to the pages of Postliberal Order - fittingly, “In Defense of Order.”
Citing Russell Kirk’s “The Roots of American Order, he writes, “Order precedes justice and freedom.”
Thanks,
@MattPolProf
. We may have some significant disagreements, but being serious about ideas is not one of them. And the comparison to the great Roger Scruton is humbling.
The second part of my essay, “In Defense of Order,” is now available from behind a paywall. In the essay, I continue to extend Russell Kirk’s efforts to demonstrate that the American regime was primarily founded to establish order, not detached liberty.
A renowned public intellectual,
@Ayaan
Hirsi Ali, tapped the zeitgeist with a recent article published to
@unherd
entitled “Why I am Now a Christian.” The piece is a literal come-to-Jesus moment for Ayaan, who is famous for her atheism advocacy. THREAD
He viewed such efforts as a threat to our “two-hundred-year-old tradition of tolerance, which recognizes that in a society of conflicting religious convictions, the state, through its politicians, should not choose between them.”
Time to write that long-contemplated essay on why the accusation of “Neo-Marxism” is a category mistake (a strange Marxism embraced by every corporation), and a desperate attempt by liberals who refuse to acknowledge that “Wokeism” is the end-station of their own tradition.
Right-liberalism has spent billions assembling a stable of “color-by-number” word arrangers. The first crayon they learn to use is labeling anything against “Muh Liberty” as “Progressivism.” You learn to color without ever having to think very hard at all!
THIS WEEK! Don't miss
@PatrickDeneen
in conversation with
@jennfrey
about liberalism and its discontents. This program is free and open to all. We hope to see you on Thursday!
The military is viewed as a useful widget in the ideological toolbox of liberal elites. Their misuse of these good men and women is contemptible. This important 🧵 speaks to this growing realization among those who serve our nation.
The GWOT: A Former Neo-Con’s Tale 🧵: I was a sophomore at the Citadel when I watched live as United Airlines Flight 175 hit the World Trade Center’s South Tower. The hair on the back of my neck stood up and I knew right then that everything had changed. 1/x
@VictorTWolff
@McCormickProf
This “ideal” was first advanced in the US by … John Dewey (“Academic Freedom, 1902). He understood well that its claims were not “neutral,” but harbored progressive assumptions and substance.
I'm thrilled to confirm that Mary Harrington will join me, Danny Kruger, and Maurice Glasman in a discussion of my book (and our books) in central London on October 4. Tickets are running low - you can still register here:
@moveincircles
@danny__kruger
I enjoyed a wonderful day in Charlottesville yesterday, at the invitation of The Burke Society. I spoke in the august Rotunda on “The Use and Abuse of the American Founding.” My thanks to
@wpecknold
and the good gang down at UVA!
“In the coming battles over eugenics and human dignity, let us hope that the sons and daughters of Father Abraham defeat the heirs of Nietzsche.”
Amen.
I greatly enjoyed speaking with the
@WSJ
’s Gerry Baker on his podcast, “Free Expression.” He pushed me, always respectfully, on arguments I have made in my last two books. It was a model of civil conversation, I thought, for which I was very grateful.
1/ A had recent chilling conversation with a group of teenagers and I want to tell you about it.
They were upset by my bill to ban social media's use of algorithmic boosting to teens. This practice is used to curate (often harmful) content to keep kids addicted to screens.