Forum on law, rights, and security. Editorial Board includes former senior government officials, top civil society attorneys, and law professors. Based
@nyulaw
.
EXCLUSIVE:
@just_security
has obtained unredacted versions of Trump administration emails about Ukraine aid.
They show the Pentagon repeatedly sounded the alarm that the freeze on funding was in violation of the law.
@K8brannen
reports:
NYT now reporting that Sean Spicer received KT McFarland's Dec. 29 email about Flynn's call w/ Kislyak on sanctions.
Then why did Spicer tell the press on Jan. 23 that Flynn's call was about "holiday greetings"?
VIDEO CLIP:
Worried that the
#January6thCommittee
documents might someday disappear?
Don't be. Just Security has you covered.
We created permanent links (via
@permacc
) for all deposition transcripts.
Sorted by witnesses' affiliation, date of deposition and more.
With breaking news that
#BoltonBook
names Pat
#Cipollone
(President's lead impeachment lawyer) as participant in meeting on Ukraine pressure campaign...
We are re-upping this recent article by legal ethics expert Stephen Gillers
With Judge Jackson saying House Intel Committee's Russia probe was stymied because of Stone's obstruction. It "led to an inaccurate, incomplete and incorrect report."
We are re-upping this relevant analysis by
@BarbMcQuade
👇
#StoneSentencing
Klan Act expert and First Amendment expert assess LTC Vindman’s lawsuit against Trump associates for conspiracy involving witness intimidation.
Bottom line up front: A strong legal case
By Professors
@Richard_Primus
@UMichLaw
& David Schulz
@YaleLawSch
NEW
United States of America v. Rudolph W. Giuliani
Former U.S. Attorneys—
@BarbMcQuade
and
@JoyceWhiteVance
—draft a "Mock Indictment" based on publicly available evidence of Giuliani's misconduct.
Powerful warning by former Senior Pentagon Analyst
@kyle_a_murphy
on why he just resigned.
"I have seen up close the president’s disdain for democratic values, and recent events should be put in the context of a continuous slide toward authoritarianism."
Pentagon officials are considering whether there is a need to increase the number of National Guard troops to as many as 13,000 for Inauguration Day, according to a defense official with knowledge of the plans.
That & more:
Welcoming Adam Klasfeld (
@KlasfeldReports
) as Just Security's new fellow.
Klasfeld will provide expert coverage for the public on legal issues concerning democracy, the rule of law, and related litigation.
United States v. Trump
- A "Model Prosecution Memo" on the effort to pressure Vice President Pence
Detailed legal analysis of the former president’s potential criminal liability.
By former U.S. Attorney and professor
@UMichLaw
@BarbMcQuade
"The Soul of the Justice Department: Who Must Stand Up For It Now"
Powerful essay by Lisa Monaco, who served in the Clinton, George W. Bush, and Obama Justice Departments before serving as Assistant to the President for Homeland Security.
FBI and DHS received intelligence warning of violence on January 6, but failed to follow their policies for reporting social media intelligence or communicate with partner agencies.
Allison Mollenkamp shares the takeaways from a new Senate report:
A special
#July4th
essay
Former Acting Attorney General—who served in HW Bush and Clinton administrations and advisor to several Presidents—calls for officials to resist unethical orders, report abuses and, when necessary, resign and speak out.
#Patriots
Don't debate whether the pardon power is absolute. That's a distraction.
Dangling a pardon for Manafort and Flynn raises a very different question, writes
@alexgwhiting
.
And the answer to that question: Trump and his lawyer likely obstructed justice.
Important:
The indictment of 13 Russians omitted an obvious charge. Why? The answer reveals why Mueller may be going after American co-conspirators—including members of the Trump campaign—next.
Former White House Counsel Bob Bauer in a new piece:
The Curious Case of Alvin Bragg
By
@AWeissmann_
An expert analysis of how
@ManhattanDA
#AlvinBragg
may be playing a multi-level chess game in prosecution of Trump entities and associates.
8. Chairman Joint Chiefs of Staff Milley's testimony is significant on many levels.
The VICE PRESIDENT issued "orders" for the military to secure the Capitol.
That is not a role for the VP. Shows complete breakdown. While Meadows told Milley to paint a different "narrative."
EXCLUSIVE: Full Text of Declaration of 58 former senior U.S. officials refuting President Donald Trump's claim of national emergency on southern border.
"The declarants notably include officials who served in the Trump administration, including ..."
There are three historical precedents that make clear the Senate can conduct a second
#impeachment
trial of Trump even after he leaves office.
@MichaelGerhard8
— top impeachment law expert — explains:
New and special essay by
@JeffSonnenfeld
"The Republican Party and its most active voters may nominate a candidate who is – as a matter of law – simply ineligible to become president."
A Manhattan judge refused to dismiss 34 felony charges related to former President Donald Trump allegedly falsifying business records to smother a scandal during the 2016 presidential election.
Trial to begin in March, per
@KlasfeldReports
.
Two U.S. Capitol Police Officers file suit against Donald Trump for injuries resulting from
#CapitolRiot
Added as
#9
to our Trump Litigation Tracker (with link to court filing).
(h/t
@MalathiNayak
)
With NYT bombshell (FBI opened counterintel investigation on Trump)
Worth your time (re)reading this article by former FBI and CIA officials
@AshaRangappa_
@john_sipher
@alexzfinley
“Collusion Doesn’t Have to be Criminal to be an Ongoing Threat”
Former White House Counsel and top election law expert Bob Bauer:
"Russia's Internet Research Agency is now revealed to have been among the largest Super PACs operating in the 2016 elections."
Breaking:
President
@ZelenskyyUa
announces initiative for states to create a treaty to collect Russian assets to compensate victims of Russia's war on Ukraine.
Read this analysis by experts of new group that will advise Ukraine. They explain the project.
We recommend you bookmark this.
A deep dive analysis of constitutional and statutory limits on use of any armed force in connection with the
#2020election
.
From
@protctdemocracy
's
@chrstnkwn
, Rachel Homer, and Deana El-Mallawany.
How does Donald Trump's alleged $130,000 hush money payment to Stormy Daniels gross up to $420,000 and 34 felony charges in New York?
Our infographic shows how the lawyers, a shell company, and a tech firm all fit together.
@KlasfeldReports
' story 👇
Litigation Tracker updates:
1. Manhattan DA focusing on chief financial officer, Allen Weisselberg, whose cooperation may be key (Ben Protess,
@WRashbaum
@maggieNYT
)
2. Fulton County DA seeks grand jury subpoena this week (
@ReporterJCB
@TamarHallerman
)
Thanks to
@Lawrence
for featuring a discussion with
@AWeissmann_
of the January 6th ‘model prosecution memo’ we published.
And for mentioning that our Mar-Lago model prosecution memo anticipated DOJ charges.
Link to the J6 memo:
Watch the discussion:
Surprise criminal charge in Trump target letter: 18 USC 241 (conspiracy against rights)
What does that law say?
How has DOJ used it in past?
What alleged Trump conduct meets elements of crime?
@NormEisen
@rgoodlaw
@JoshuaGKolb
@jacob_gaba
with answers.
Former Department of Justice, FBI, and Pentagon officials propose specific questions to ask
#BillBarr
.
By
@jgeltzer
@AshaRangappa_
@rgoodlaw
Plus an invitation for readers to send in their questions to add to the list.
This week, a federal judge ruled that Chad Wolf was likely serving unlawfully as acting DHS secretary.
He's not alone.
At least 15 other senior Trump administration officials are serving illegally.
@beccadamante
w/ more:
New public resource:
A comprehensive calendar of all dates in the criminal and civil trials involving former President Donald Trump, as well as dates in the 2024 election schedule.
By
@NormEisen
,
@rgoodlaw
,
@SivenWatt
, Samara Angel and Beth Markman
Public Resource, fully updated:
Comprehensive calendar of all dates in criminal and civil trials involving former President Donald Trump, as well as dates in the 2024 election schedule.
By
@NormEisen
@rgoodlaw
@SivenWatt
@Samara_Angel_
and Beth Markman
With Breaking News: Close Trump associates - but not Trump - indicted in
#Arizona
election interference case.
Our editor-in-chief
@rgoodlaw
breaks down the indictment’s curious contents and omissions.
Thanks to
@maddow
for this great discussion of
@AWeissmann_
’s latest Just Security article.
Weissmann analyzes gaps in Trump’s pardons of Manafort, Stone, and others. Openings through which the Justice Department can now pursue justice.
#January6Clearinghouse
update
District of Columbia vs. Proud Boys, Oath Keepers, et al, COMPLAINT (Dec. 14, 2021)
Direct link to
#Racine
document:
Link to our
#January6th
Clearinghouse:
New and important
@john_sipher
(former CIA Senior Intelligence Service) writes that most recent revelations in Russia investigation provide additional credibility to the Steele dossier.
Master Calendar of Trump Court Dates: Criminal and Civil Cases
Fully updated as of October 2, 2023 for the opening of civil fraud trial in New York.
Produced by
@NormEisen
@rgoodlaw
@SivenWatt
@Samara_Angel_
and Beth Markman
Stewart Rhodes Should Get No Leniency For Leading Anti-Government Paramilitary Group
By Mary McCord (
@GeorgetownICAP
) and
@jhglick
With an authoritative account of the Oath Keepers' record of taking up arms against government.
#militias
#January6th
<thread>
Historian of political rhetoric,
@jenmercieca
annotates a recent Tucker Carlson presentation.
She begins with general research on conspiracies and propaganda, with insights from cognitive science.
Then a section-by-section dissection.
New Resource tool:
Litigation Tracker: All Pending Criminal and Civil Cases Against Donald Trump
This resource tool, including a detailed Chart, keeps up to date on major developments in ongoing cases.
Did we miss anything significant? Let us know.
“In prosecuting a criminal case, simplicity is usually better; the focus is on the false statement itself, not its technical tax consequences.”
Former head of DOJ Criminal Tax Division and other experts write on Manhattan DA’s criminal case against Trump.
Bill Barr versus Joe Biden
Former Acting Attorney General Stuart Gerson (served with Barr in the George HW Bush administration) and
@KPNatsFan
(15-year DOJ career) warn of the weaponization of the Justice Department in 2020 presidential election.
Nearly 5,000 National Guard troops will remain in Washington through March 12 amid concerns over potential violence arising from online chatter among QAnon supporters who suggest former President Trump could still be inaugurated on March 4.
That and more:
With a national security crisis upon us, the US Intelligence Community is without a Senate-confirmed Director of National Intelligence.
Brett Holmgren, former senior director for intelligence on the NSC, on why a big problem just got bigger:
How can a president actually declassify a document? What procedures do they need to follow? How does government classification and declassification work day-to-day?
Brian Greer (
@secretsandlaws
) and Wendy Leben provide the insider view.
“I testified at Barr's Senate confirmation hearing. I urged the Senate to reject the nomination… I am not saying here that I told you so. Rather, my warning was insufficiently dire.”
by Neil Kinkopf (
@GeorgiaStateLaw
)
#BillBarr
"I have studied and worked to prevent genocide for forty years..."
Leader in the field of mass murder and early warning signs, Dr. Gregory Stanton (
@genocide_watch
) writes about the deep connections between
#QAnon
and the original Nazis.
#Antisemitism
NEW
Experts game out likely DC Trial Start Dates for former president Trump, now that DC Circuit has ruled.
Most likely short timeline:
Trial start by around early June-end early Sept
Most likely long timeline:
Trial start by late July-end late Oct
BREAKING:
Unanimous passage of bipartisan amendment in House declaring President has no congressional authority to use U.S. Armed Forces against
#Iran
.
Amendment is to National Defense Authorization Act (
#NDAA
)
Stay tuned for our coverage
Full text of 2 amendments that passed:
#Jan6Clearinghouse
Update
Full Text: Letter from Donald Trump's attorney Doug Collins to Jeffrey Rosen on testifying without executive privilege (Aug. 2, 2021)
Clearinghouse:
Direct link to letter:
#January6th
Comey was not alone
New info:
Two witnesses—then-FBI General Counsel Baker and then-FBI Director's chief of staff Rybicki—listened in on Comey’s side of phone calls with President Trump when President attempted to alter course of Russia investigation.
The pardon for
#SteveBannon
has been released (h/t
@matthewacole
).
It contains significant gaps that allow the Department of Justice to pursue other criminal charges.
@AWeissmann_
writes a new postscript to his article.
NEW DOCUMENT:
1. House Judiciary Committee release of encrypted email exchanges between
#Parnas
and
#Nunes
' aid
#DerekHarvey
Added to our Clearinghouse:
2. Our Timeline of Nunes-Harvey-Parnes-Giuliani activities:
link:
Russian Ambassador: Trump-Putin made “important verbal agreements”
Gen Votel: "National Defense Authorization Act, as a law, prohibits us from... synchronizing, collaborating with Russian forces”
@rgoodlaw
on how that law works (including its loopholes):
3. This quote is new:
Committee Vice Chair
@RepLizCheney
says the Committee has testimony that President Trump, when told his supporters sought to hang Vice President Pence, responded:
“Maybe our supporters have the right idea. Mike Pence deserves it.”
The Supreme Court will consider whether former Presidents enjoy immunity from criminal prosecution for official acts during their tenure in office.
@nyulaw
expert panel of
@gtconway3d
, Trevor Morrison, and
@kateashaw1
discuss. Moderated by
@AWeissmann_
.
Watch
@AWeissmann_
's terrific exposition of the American Autocracy Threat Tracker.⬇️
Thanks to
@NicolleDWallace
#DeadlineWH
for focusing on this issue.
The Tracker can be found here at Just Security:
Looks like Trump-Giuliani just dangled a pardon in front of Manafort and others who might cooperate with Mueller.
@alexgwhiting
(prof
@Harvard_Law
) explains why that can make a strong case for obstruction of justice:
The US Supreme Court is considering whether the Constitution prohibits subpoenas issued to Trump’s accounting firm, Mazars USA.
A decision on a stay may come as early as today.
@marty_lederman
explains what’s going on and possible outcomes.
4. Important
@RepLizCheney
plays testimony of Trump aides and officials telling Trump (and Meadows) they'd clearly lost the election.
Direct witness testimony strengthens this case of criminal liability.👇
Read
@BarbMcQuade
's model prosecution memo:
Questions the Supreme Court Should Ask at Thursday’s Oral Argument on Presidential Immunity
By
@rgoodlaw
@AWeissmann_
"Is your view that we should decide this case expeditiously only if we are going to rule in your favor? But otherwise take our time?"
The Justice Department has asked a federal judge to force the two top lawyers in Trump’s White House to provide additional testimony to a grand jury investigating Trump’s efforts to reverse his election defeat.
@CNN
reports.
That & more:
Today's
#impeachment
resolution adopted by the House of Representatives includes a key provision that has the potential to become a game changer.
Former White House Counsel W. Neil Eggleston explains:
5. Trump's acting Deputy Attorney General Richard Donoghue told Jeff Clark:
“What you are proposing is nothing less than the United States Justice Department meddling in the outcome of the election.”
i.e., illegal
Political Coercion Act, 18 USC §610
2. Bill Barr:
Three discussions with Trump on 11/23, 12/1, 12/14.
“I made it clear I did not agree with the idea of saying the election was stolen and putting out this stuff, which I told the President it was BULLSH*T.”
Reason for his resignation.
The efforts of Trump and his officials to manipulate government institutions to overturn the
#2020election
results remind
@douglaslondon5
of despots abroad.
He says the country’s future depends on a rallying for action in response.
#January6thHearings
.
"How can Congress or the public trust that you are taking all steps to assess this failure if you cannot admit that you were part of a catastrophic intelligence and/or law enforcement failure?"
@AWeissmann_
@rgoodlaw
have questions for FBI Director Wray