Links to read our
@TheBJPsych
Advances articles about mental capacity in practice. In paper 1, we tried to dig down into the test for mental capacity. Most clinicians know the '4-stage test' but how do we really assess it?
@JamesLeeDavey
@Capacitylaw
1/2
I'm all for reducing coercive practice but this trend in mental health services to place all responsibility on patients is dangerous and heartless. Expecting people who are scared, ambivalent, or just too unwell to know they are unwell to not only advocate for their own care 1/8
Dear med students & FY1s. When any senior doctor inevitably tells you about things being harder in their day just remember: you trained & qualified in a global pandemic. Thatโs something NONE of us at any level of seniority have experienced. So fuck โem. Youโre a true badass
If youโve ever been bullied at work you will recognise the gaslighting that is going on now. She didnโt know she was doing anything wrong therefore there will be no repercussions. Hands up if this feels familiar? โOh I know X can be difficult, they donโt mean any harm thoughโ 1/3
Being a MH professional with lived experience does not automatically make you better at your job
Lived experience does not erase the power imbalance between you & your patients
Mental illness is not a leveller; experience of illness & treatment is influenced by social factors
Some interesting stuff about clinicians as โwounded healersโ on Twitter; varied views and strong feelings. Nobody asked me, so Iโm going to share my take on being a doctor with lived experience of mental illness (and treatment). This is a long thread >
My week has been an absolute smorgasbord of misogyny in medicine, a mix of personal experiences & those of friends/colleagues in both personal & professional lives. I am so SICK of it. I don't know how or when things will change because men are so protected, but I will say: 1/10
I have nothing to say about covid, mental health, work, Christmas, or Strictly. But hereโs a photo of the terrifying fucker that CHARGED at me yesterday when I was out for a run
Clinicians should (when needed) assess capacity to consent to or refuse care & TREATMENT.
Suicide is not a treatment decision.
Self-neglect is not a treatment decision.
Stop misusing legalese to justify inaction.
Thing is, thereโs no use โscrappingโ BMI without investing in eating disorder services. ED specialists donโt want to turn people down, they are FORCED to prioritise the mostly physically risky patients because they donโt have enough resources. ED services need serious investment
but also navigate the minefield of gatekeeping rules and numbers that don't get answered and computers that say 'no' is such bullshit. And the worst thing is that I don't believe for one second that those at the top really think this is respect for autonomy 2/8
or empowering patients. It suits organisations to keep patients out. Patients who mess up their performance indicators, who are too difficult to help, who won't do as they're told, who have exhausted their compassion quota. And so many of us on the ground just can't be 3/8
Iโd really like to see a joint medicine/psychiatry CPD event on the subject of mental health & nutrition. Itโs not just about eating disorders (though important). Lots of mental disorders affect nutrition, & neuropsychiatric consequences of malnutrition are too often ignored
I'm so sick of it. It is such hard work - currently for my team about 90% of the job - trying to get patients referred into the right services, all of which will put up as many obstacles as they can, asking endless questions about why they should have to take this patient. 5/8
I think patients/carers/survivors have very good reason to be suspicious of co-production. Itโs easy for clinicians to preach about the value of lived experience; MUCH harder to do true collaboration & really amplify unheard voices. I donโt know if anyoneโs truly got it right 1/6
And we honestly think that patients can navigate this when they 'decide' that they'd 'like to re-engage'? Shame on us. I've seen this exclusion in so many deaths or just deteriorations. Not just headline-grabbing ones. Every single day. 6/8
I'm a consultant psychiatrist with a lot of knowledge and experience navigating these waters. But when it comes to even my own health, it's a shrug, a prediction that the computer's gonna say no before anyone's even tried, and a 'what do you want me to do?' 7/8
bothered anymore. Saying 'no' before someone else says it to save ourselves the bother of a rejected referral. Resenting the people who come to us expecting that we'll know what to do. Forgetting that we're supposed to fight and advocate for patients. 4/8
@Nuzzzzie
He needs reporting. Heโs dangerous & heโs relying on the fact that youโre new & junior to get away with it because he is in a position of power & thinks you wonโt dare report him. This is so much more common than anyone wants to believe. Please DM me if you want support/advice
I always think about doing a ๐งต for
#EatingDisordersAwarenessWeek
& then chicken out. But here goes. The
@beatED
campaign about doctorsโ training is really important. Whatever the true โnumbers,โ understanding of EDs is badly lacking. 1/10
I am a proud lesbian and fierce supporter of trans rights. To be DMed asking me to vote for someone in a college election on the basis of their wish to end the partnership with Stonewall is like DMing a turkey and asking it to vote for Christmas.
Women putting up with this shit every day, at home or work or both, maybe thinking you deserve it or if you just tried harder you'd be respected: I see you too. We don't deserve this, it shouldn't have to be inevitable, we shouldn't have to be grateful for basic respect 10/10
My FY1 asked if Iโd ever run up Arthurโs Seat, which I hadnโt. I have now duly knackered my knees purely to try and impress the youth. Happy Christmas!
When I was having treatment for anorexia, I used all these mantras. I had little cards made to carry with me & put in helpful places. I donโt use them much now but they often turn up in random places, like the wardrobe just now. Sharing for anyone who might need some reminders
Why do we write โhas capacityโ or โlacks capacityโ in patientsโ notes without any documented capacity assessment? In just 15 years since the inception of the MCA, capacity has become distilled to a tick-box exercise in many clinical settings. 1/2
Well-meant offers of mediation, downplaying of behaviours, emphasising the perpetratorโs good qualities in the name of balance, seeing โboth sidesโ - it all adds to the sense of not being believed, which is what bullies rely on. Itโs gaslighting. 3/3
In todayโs edition of โA liaison psychiatrist screams into the abyssโ:
DOLS is not something you apply only if a patient is trying to leave hospital.
More of the same next week.
Iโd like to campaign for certain words and phrases to be banished forever from the psychiatric lexicon. Starting a list, with explanations. Please join in.
โMedically clearedโ. This is obvious, right? People (including me) have written whole articles about it.
@rcpsych
Translation: youโre being over sensitive. Other people can handle it. โIโve never personally had a problem with X, theyโve always been fine with me.โ Translation: you must be the one with the problem. โOh thatโs just Xโs wayโ. Translation: suck it up, buttercup 2/3
All MH professionals should read this, and have a strong word with themselves as soon as they start to feel defensive. This is real, this is happening to some degree in every service, and we turn a blind eye because a discharge or 'gatekeeping' is supposedly a success
I recently had a paper published by the Journal of Psychiatric and Mental Health Nursing, about my experiences of harm in mental health services; how this caused me to self-discharge; and my life now as a "service-avoider". It's available here:
Group of teenage boys tried to scare me as I ran home tonight (alone). Jumping out, shouting in my face, blocking my path and laughing at me. Yells of โfucking dykeโ behind me as I continued on my way. Guess not everyone likes my haircut.
Meaningless soundbite. We all know this is impossible so how will services get round the 28-day target you inevitably impose on them (with sanctions for failure)? By further tightening the definition of 'all who need it'. Those four words are exclusion in disguise. Do better
The next Labour Government will guarantee mental health treatment within a month for all who need it. Prevention as our watchword. Better mental health for all.
โIf you donโt properly fund mental health care, it becomes about who is best at restricting access to servicesโ
Stark truth from Allyn Thomas speaking at
@PHMMSc
today
โBehaviouralโ. It means NOTHING. All behaviour is behavioural. Itโs used (incorrectly) to distinguish between behaviour weโve decided someone canโt help because theyโre psychotic, confused etc, & behaviour that weโve decided is under conscious control. Itโs a value judgement
Can anyone please recommend up to date research/writing on utility of inpatient care for ppl with personality disorder diagnosis? Esp around developing โdependencyโ on care? Itโs something that gets repeated a lot as an argument against admission but am unsure of evidence base ๐
Me, with terror in my eyes: โI donโt have to stay awake till midnight do I?!โ
Partner, looking aghast: โGOD noโ
And this is why we are together
Imagine an oncology service that was so under-resourced that patients with early stage cancer were told they couldn't access treatment until they had lymph node spread. Parity of esteem is a fantasy.
@cmackenzies
It's not an advert that gives any confidence in the speakers' ability to engage with people as humans. The rest of the advert is also awkward and aversive. Some of the objectives look promising but it's left me with a sour feeling of distaste. Needs a rethink.
Millennials who are very cavalier about not having children: you carry on. I am in my 40s and I love being childless. Not because Iโm sexy & fun, but because Iโm knackered enough as it is without offspring.
Millennials who are very cavalier about not having children are in for a shock when they enter their 40s & realize life is only half over. What do you do at that point? Keep trying to be sexy & have fun? I expect to see a lot of sadness & confusion about what to do at that point.
I SEE YOU, male doctors who would put patients at risk rather than defer to the expertise of a female colleague. I SEE YOU, men who roll their eyes behind my back at the hysterical woman making a fuss about nothing, who dismiss my accusations of sexism as overblown 2/10
Arrived home today whilst on the phone about work. When Iโd finished my partner said in admiration/surprise: โyou sounded like a proper adult!โ Later, as we shifted a new toilet, we remarked on how grown-up weโre being at the moment.
Readers, we have a combined age of 102.
As long as serious incident reviews and inquests focus solely on individual human factors and not systemic/organisational, the potential for learning and improving will be limited and the process will always be experienced as adversarial 1/2
I absolutely love these two candid shots of me taken before and after Saturdayโs ultra. Theyโre not pretty or flattering but I think I look self-possessed and strong, and that makes me very happy โค๏ธ
In illness of any kind, support melts away after the acute phase. People expect you to be happy to be better & back to โnormalโ, & of course you ARE, but you still have the trauma & fear & guilt. You have to act as if everything is normal when actually everything has changed 1/5
Something I donโt see talked about very much is the anxiety that comes after an episode of mental illness. Even when I am not manic/depressed or in an anorexia relapse I still feel very anxious about the fact that one of those things might/will happen again at some point.
Tell me again how mental health is just as important as physical health. Tell me again how people should โask for helpโ because there is no stigma. Tell me again why life expectancy for people with certain mental illness is significantly less than the general population.
In tears trying to book a blood test, as instructed by my GP. The GPโs surgery wonโt do it because they have a policy of not doing blood tests for patients of the psych hospital up there road- and I am one. This is because their staff are โnot trainedโ to deal with us. ๐ 1/
If youโre going to accuse a woman of lying about being suicidal, a woman of colour of lying about racism, blame a woman for her husbandโs decisions, then do us all a favour & keep any
#IWD
platitudes to yourself. You are part of the problem.
โRespect for autonomyโ has become an insidious, toxic way of denying vulnerable people support because itโs less hassle to just leave them to it. In every aspect of health & social care.
Important point from
@roch61
about how diagnostic sticky labels (eg personality disorder) can blind clinicians to other mental illness, with fatal consequences. Context here is perinatal illness but highly applicable to other patients too
#RCPsychIC
#RCPsychIC22
โJunior doctors are leaving, theyโre demoralised... and because they are some of the most highly trained doctors in the world, people are begging for themโ
This consultant psychiatrist outlines problems facing the NHS and cites a โmassive workforce crisisโ in her sector
#bbcqt
This is the most misguided campaign Iโve ever seen. Iโve heard many of these things or similar, very often from people who are mentally unwell and terrified. No, itโs not ok to abuse staff, but taking quotes out of context & shaming vulnerable people is appalling
@NHSScotland
THREAD // โ ๏ธ CW / TW - viewer discretion advised
These images show just a small selection of the abuse doled out to health & social care staff in our call centres and on social media.
@HSCAberdeen
@HSCPshire
@HSCMoray
I SEE YOU, managers complicit with sexist behaviour, trying to smooth things over with faux concern before opining that there must be fault on BOTH sides. I SEE YOU, men who would rather support their bros than stand up to them, who offer mediation rather than discipline 3/10
I SEE YOU, men who try to be allies but stop short of calling out discrimination for what it is because they want to be everyone's friend (no woman has the luxury of being everyone's friend). I SEE YOU, senior consultants known for being sexually inappropriate with juniors 4/10
I SEE YOU and your fragile ego, every man who sends unsolicited mansplaining emails, who can't bring himself to congratulate a female colleague's achievement without saying "but look what I did!!" I SEE YOU speaking to clever, accomplished women like they're 4 years old 8/10
Once again, Wren says it so much better than I can. I have said so many times: โwho are we really trying to keep safe?โ We (MH services & clinicians) make ourselves the victim. So much of what happens is about protecting ourselves
I've been risk assessed a lot recently. It's not been much fun. I wrote this blog post about "risk aversion" in mental health services, to consider whose risk is actually being assessed and avoided - patients' or professionals'?
I know people will be lamenting the end of summer, but the slight chill and mist in the early morning air with the promise of autumn round the corner makes me happy
I SEE YOU, knowing you will always get away with putting your hands and your propositions where they're not wanted because female trainees are scared of harming their careers by calling it out. I SEE YOU, everyone who ever said "oh he's just like that" 5/10
The men who have bullied, undermined, dismissed, patronised and groped me and done far worse to so many more: I SEE YOU. I see you and your kind at every level of seniority, I see you when you think I don't, and I see that others see you too. 9/10
I SEE YOU, men who like to present themselves as woke supporters of women, undermining your female colleagues behind closed doors, backslapping and going drinking with your bros. I SEE YOU promoting and protecting each other, giving each other awards & accolades 6/10
โGate keepingโ. How is this so widespread? Patients are not unwelcome intruders who should be prevented from breaching our defences! We are talking about vulnerable people and whether or not they can be admitted to hospital or otherwise access care. This language is not ok.
Itโs not just psychiatry - itโs very widespread. As a liaison psychiatrist I challenge a lot of referrers who say things like โweโre not sure if itโs just behaviouralโ. I tend to ask directly what they mean by โbehaviouralโ or tell them that all behaviour is behavioural. 1/2
โBehaviouralโ is an ignorant word used by clinicians in psychiatry designed to avoid any attempt at understanding and helping a person who is clearly in distress
@autisticpuffin
@Madnotbad60
Please be assured that a number of us within the college were opposed to its message, some tried to stop its publication. The eventual compromise was that a (critical) response was allowed to be published alongside it. Itโs awful.
Suicide rates in females under 20 are the highest theyโve been in 40 years. Incredibly sobering statistic from
@ProfLAppleby
in
@NCISH_UK
webinar today.
Risk assessment nonsense:
โGuarantee their safetyโ
โFleeting suicidal thoughtsโ
โLow riskโ
All phrases whose purpose is to allay the clinicianโs own anxiety rather than to reliably predict risk.
Is anyone else completely sick of giving/hearing online talks? Iโm trying to be understanding, think of the environmental & infection control benefits plus those for whom online is easier for any reason. But I just want to interact with an audience. I donโt enjoy this ๐
First of all, all of us, whichever angle weโre approaching from, would do well to remember the human beings in all of this. Whatever you think about clinicians who share their experience and whatever they call themselves, they are humans with vulnerabilities. Be kind >
"Several people have called my actions โcourageousโ; various others have suggested that I would be a better psychiatrist for this new insight Iโve gained into my patientsโ experiences. I vehemently disagree with both views."
#BMJOpinion
by
@DrChloeBeale
I honestly didnโt think Iโd ever get here. Bar a brief lockdown relapse, Iโve been a healthy weight & discharged from ED services for almost 3 years. Still never really thought Iโd let go of the desire to be underweight again
This seems incredibly common with personality disorder diagnosis in particular. The fact that THIS diagnosis is something you canโt face sharing with the patient youโre labelling speaks volumes about what you think of them & what this label means to you.
Dear professionals. If you diagnose someone with something, tell them. Iโve heard so many people say they found out their diagnosis in a letter not even addressed to them. I found out I was (mis)diagnosed with a personality disorder in a discharge letter. Please tell them.
Anyone who cares about the dignity & care of psychiatric pts should be deeply disturbed by this. Surveillance is NOT a solution to dangerous staffing levels or poor treatment. This is another measure designed to protect staff under the guise of protecting patients
@StopOxevision
Almost 350 people have signed the
@StopOxevision
petition.
Please continue to share and sign to ask
@NHSEngland
and mental health trusts to halt the rollout of
@Oxehealth
's Oxevision surveillance technology whilst an independent review is conducted:
Remember how at the end of the year Twitter was all โthree things Iโve achieved in 2021โ?
Yeah well Iโve eaten 54 Cadbury Creme Eggs so far this year and itโs still over a month till Easter.
Compelling arguments presented for letting patients record consultations, in a really engaging talk. If we donโt worry about peopleโs capacity to consent to us taking notes, why do we fret about their capacity to make their own recording?
#RCPsychIC
#RCPsychIC22
Next up is Dr Adeola Akinola from Pennine Care NHS Foundation Trust, University of Manchester speaking on โClinical and ethical considerations for the recording of mental health consultationsโ
#RCPsychIC