Professor of Philosophy & Pro-Rector, CEU Vienna. Director FWF Excellence Cluster. Books include Elements of Mind, The Objects of Thought, The Meaning of Belief
My father, Walter Crane 1932-2023. He had a long and happy life, and he died peacefully at home last week. He was much loved and will be greatly missed.
Lomonosov University: "We, students, graduate students, teachers, staff & graduates of the oldest university in Russia, Moscow State University named after M.V. Lomonosov, we categorically condemn the war that our country unleashed in Ukraine" 7500 signed
After eight wonderful years, my employment at
@theTLS
as philosophy consultant editor has now come to an end because of budget cuts. I will miss my wonderful colleagues in London Bridge Street, & sorry to end this very rewarding work, getting philosophy out to a wider readership
I'm proud to announce a website in memory of my teacher and mentor, the great philosopher Hugh Mellor, who died almost two years ago on June 21, 2020. The site collects Hugh's philosophical work, downloadable papers, memoirs and obituaries, and photos.
Huge news: the Austrian research agency, the
@FWF_at
has awarded us a ‘cluster of excellence’ in philosophy. I am the director of research. With matching funding, we have €15M for five years for institutions
Not a very original thought, but: social media really brings out the mean side of people -- people I know are saying unkind and unfair things here about colleagues which I don't think they would say to their faces
The practice of asking for letters of recommendation before longlisting is a huge imposition on referees, in the current job market. Departments should think about what they are doing, asking for 100s of unnecessary letters to be sent. Updating each letter takes time, add it up
I once turned up to give a talk and no one showed up, not even the student organisers. Slightly despondent, I drank two cans of beer on the train back to London and had an early night.
Just remembering the time I gave a talk in a uk university, 3 people turned up and 1 fell asleep after 10 min. They then told me there was no money for a hotel and I had to sleep on a camp bed in someone's house. Mid way through the night their dog bit me.
Ok so German is the most wonderful language in the world despite being less logical than Hungarian... but at least those of us struggling with it don’t have this problem
So, I wrote a review of David Chalmers's new book, Reality+ for the excellent magazine, The Philosopher.
@thephilosopher1923
Spoiler: it's a terrific book, but I have a few criticisms...
@oliverburkeman
Exactly. What happened to
@Docstockk
was not that she was ‘silenced’, and nor did she claim she was. Rather, she was aggressively harassed by people who did not bother to read what she actually wrote.
@Docstockk
@kimwillsher1
@TAFKAMacM
And also this: 'the author has gone from being an unobjectionable matron of the political left to one of its most hated villains'. Matron?
Mark Rowe's biography of JL Austin is an amazing book. Not only does he being Austin to life, a complex but sympathetic character, and paints the best picture I know of 20th century Oxford philosophy, but he also tells the gripping story of Austin's intelligence work in the War
Reading Alice in Wonderland is a bit like reading Anscombe. You never know why one bit follows another, it’s all vaguely bad-tempered, and ‘should’ is used where today we say ‘would’
Today I’m drinking beer from a silver tankard which was left to me by my friend and mentor Hugh Mellor (1938-2020). Beer in a tankard is a very Hugh thing, I think.
Uladzimir Matskevich, a Belarusian philosopher, has been in detention since 4 August 2021. He is on hunger strike. CEU Philosophy Department expresses solidarity with him PLEASE RT
Some academics I know are rather proud of the old-style reading lists they used to give (the sort I got when I was a student): nothing done week by week, just a list of books or articles, no page numbers specified 1/4
Here is a (perhaps) little known fact about Hugh Mellor: when he reached the age of 70, he resigned his Fellowship of the British Academy, on the grounds that he was now 'too old and out of date' to be making decisions about fellowships, grants etc 1/2
@BritishAcademy_
If you are trying to use semantic evidence for some non-semantic thesis, then I would advise looking at evidence from a number of languages. End of today’s lesson.
The Philosophical Gourmet Report seems to have atrophied itself into irrelevance. The same star-studded departments at the top, with a few changes each time further down. I think people now have a pretty good idea of how the reputations stand. Time to wind the whole thing down?
Today is my first undergraduate class
@CEU
— the first undergraduate cohort in CEU’s history. Exciting new development for the university. (Undergrad education I mean, not my lecture)
The press release by
@CEU
has emphasised the establishment of a new campus in Vienna and it might appear to the casual reader that this is a mere development of its academic activities. So I would like to just summarise the main points for those who have not followed the story
The University of Vienna has advertised SIX philosophy postdocs as part of the Knowledge in Crisis Cluster of Excellence
@FWF_at
. Check out
@knowledgecrisis
for the details
Philosophers! 3 postdocs in philosophy
@ceu
! As part of the brand new
@FWF_at
Cluster of Excellence, Knowledge in Crisis. Philjobs ad coming v soon.
@knowledgecrisis
I'ver deleted my account. I prefer to keep my online papers on . Academia's constant requests for upgrades and limitations on which papers you can and cannot see was becoming frustrating.
One of my many objections to footnotes in philosophy works is that they can be a sign of lazy writing -- the writer has a point to make but can't quite be bothered to think exactly where in the paper it should come, so they just drop it in a footnote
This week's philosophy issue of
@TheTLS
! Rachel Fraser on AS Barwich on smell, Nigel Warburton on philosophers & the pandemic, Clare Carlisle & Yitzhak Melamed on Spinoza, Kathleen Stock on Judith Butler, Nikhil Krishnan on Isaiah Berlin, and me on Brian Cantwell Smith on AI
Department for Education: ““Toby Young’s diverse experience includes posts at Harvard and Cambridge”. Wikipedia: he was a Fulbright scholar at Harvard and he started, but did not finish, a PhD at Cambridge in the 80s. On the normal understanding of the word, these are not 'posts'
The
@OpenUniversity
has released some fascinating dialogues with philosophers from the 1970s, with short contemporary comments. Here I am commenting on Charles Taylor and Tony Quinton on mind-identity.
German translation arrived today. This must be one of the best titles ever — since I didn’t invent this specific title, I think I am allowed to say this? Everything sounds better in German. Thanks,
@IanMalcolm10
A common view among English people, I think, is that the German language is (i) ugly or 'harsh', but (ii) logical. I have the opposite view. It is the most beautiful language I know but it is absurdly illogical in many ways.
This has a kind of poetic beauty:
"David Frost could go even further and say freely and expressly: we want outside input in identifying opportunities because we do not have a clue what to do next.
"Those who supported Brexit would either shrug or nod at the sentiment"
“Germany’s past is a fractured past, with responsibility for the murdering of millions and the suffering of millions… And that is why I say that this country can only be loved with a broken heart.”
The President of Germany marks 75 years since the end of the war in Europe.
The unprepossessing village/suburb in which I grew up (Kidlington, Oxfordshire) contains this beautiful church, dating from the 13th C, with the spire added in the 1400s. Sometimes things from your past strike you as if you’ve seen them for the first time
Between 1961 and 1966, my mother now aged 84 and in good health, spent every weekday at home with three kids under 5, while my dad was at work. Not exactly lockdown but everyday I think of her with renewed admiration!
The tributes to Gil Harman are really something, and ring true to me. It's good to learn that as well as being one of the most original and wide-ranging analytic philosophers of the last 60 years, he was also a conscientious and generous teacher. RIP
'When Jacob Rees-Mogg recently wished to hark back to a certain sensibility to stiffen the sinews of our Brexit nation, he published a book called The Victorians.. We are not reviewing it in the TLS, preferring to focus on books that engage with the subject seriously'
@TheTLS
My student Nikhil Mahant (the youngest looking one in this picture) gave a brilliant defence of his Phd thesis (great title: Names are Words) on Monday. We celebrated in the v friendly Magazin restaurant (top wine list). Thanks too to Zoltan Szabo & Hanoch Ben-Yami the examiners