EXCLUSIVE: Marc Tessier-Lavigne’s Alzheimer’s research was called “the miracle result.” Now, colleagues allege that a 2011 internal review found “falsified data” and Tessier-Lavigne “walked around…with a broom and swept up the footprints in the dirt.”
BREAKING: Stanford president to resign his post, retract “at least” 3 papers, after our reporting in
@StanfordDaily
exposed multiple papers with data manipulation and his refusal to retract studies when given opportunities over the course of 2 decades.
My piece today in
@theatlantic
is the product of five months of work, dozens of hours of interviews, and a lot of personal anguish. It tells the story of a campus consumed in unique fashion by bigotry, of reasonable students enabling rancor. Take a read!
The NYT asked me to write a guest essay about the resignation of Stanford's president. My takeaway? This is so much bigger than one man and his research. Scientific integrity is vital and its guardrails have proven insufficient:
A coalition of
#Stanford
students has called the brutal mass murder and kidnapping of Israeli civilians "legal" and "legitimate...resistance." Never mind that children and grandparents were dragged from their homes and a literal peace festival. Never mind the defiled corpses.
Putting aside whether this decision is right, I just want to note that an educated student who says she is against genocide and violence has a literal hammer and sickle in her bio.
This seems incompatible, no? The Soviet Union is responsible for the genocide of millions…
i’m an organizer with CU Apartheid Divest
@ColumbiaSJP
, in my 3 years at
@BarnardCollege
i have never been reprimanded or received any disciplinary warnings
i just received notice that i am 1 of 3 students suspended for standing in solidarity with Palestinians facing a genocide.
NEW: swastikas have appeared across campus
@Stanford
, popping up in several student residences and a library. “We write with some sickening news,” begins the letter from faculty living in one dorm.
Stanford’s culture of silence is impressively intense. It partly stems from a longtime dearth of investigative/accountability journalism — people just aren’t used to being asked hard questions, nor do they see the value in them. I butt up against this constantly.
After FTX sued Sam Bankman-Fried's parents, both of whom are Stanford Law School professors, I contacted every faculty member at the school for their reaction.
Fewer than a dozen replied, and of those who did, only three were willing to go on the record.
Parties that require you to denounce Israel to get in? Swastikas in dorms? Activists protesting an anti-antisemitism event by shouting that Jews are “child traffickers” who “will all be replaced”? Welcome to
@Stanford
since 10/7.
"Crypto magnate Sam Bankman-Fried was scheduled to speak to a Stanford class this winter, The Daily has learned. The topic of the course? Tech ethics." This and more previously unreported details in my latest piece:
Even if you disagree with a Holocaust survivor, you owe them respect. The heckler's veto is not protected speech and it's an utter shame that people think this is the right way to make a point.
WATCH: Susanne DeWitt, an 89 year-old Holocaust survivor who was arrested and sent to Dachau Concentration Camp at age 4, was repeatedly heckled by demonstrators as she spoke in favor of the City of Berkeley's Holocaust Remembrance Day proclamation.
Beyond honored to receive a 2023 George Polk Award. None of this would be possible without the incredible, brilliant, and supportive team I've had
@StanfordDaily
. My editors–including
@sbcatania
,
@kate_selig
, and
@RileyOriana
–are phenomenal – and my knowledgeable advisors (1/
No statement from
@Stanford
yet on the massive and utterly brutal terror attack in Israel. For reference, Stanford typically has statements up about mass shootings within hours. It had a statement about Ukraine the same day. But silence here.
BREAKING: Stanford provost to step down, with little explanation and no warning. The Dean of Research also stepped down a month and a half ago. That means two of the top scientists in embattled president Marc Tessier-Lavigne’s administration are out in as many months.
This photo should go down in the annals of history as the picture of true bravery. Navalny chose to go back. He knew what would happen—they’d already tried to poison him twice. But he stood up for what he believed in.
We need more Navalnys in the world and far, far fewer Putins.
Stanford President Marc Tessier-Lavigne faces years of allegations of scientific misconduct in his research, including papers he coauthored containing images which researchers say appear "definitely photoshopped.” My latest
@StanfordDaily
On a day dedicated to celebrating fathers, I want to recognize my own, a brilliant, kind man who was shaped my life more than anyone else. Thank you
@peterbakernyt
for being my inspiration and best proponent. I love you infinitely and I wish desperately to live up to your example
Everyone, and I mean everyone, should read
@anneapplebaum
’s Gulag and Red Famine. The horror of the Soviet Union is not a question of ideology it is a reminder of human cruelty at its most despicable. The history of the Holodomor, especially, is far too unknown.
Putting aside whether this decision is right, I just want to note that an educated student who says she is against genocide and violence has a literal hammer and sickle in her bio.
This seems incompatible, no? The Soviet Union is responsible for the genocide of millions…
Blockbuster Alzheimer’s paper retracted by former Stanford president after a decade of resistance | Marc Tessier-Lavigne had declined to withdraw the paper as recently as this summer, when he resigned as president |
@StanfordDaily
As a journalist, my job is to seek out the truth and confront untruths. This is a blatant example of a vicious lie. There are legitimate grievances about the treatment of Palestinians — ones I've been vocal about in the past to no end. Nothing is an excuse for stealing children.
The piece also, somehow, compares Hamas to Ukraine... Never mind that Zelenskyy is on Israel's side, never mind that Hamas' tactics are so brazenly different than the Ukrainians.
College campuses have been torn apart at the seams for the last two weeks in a way not seen since the ’60s. The tension — and fear — is palpable. And outrageous displays of ignorance have been widespread.
Wow. Marc Tessier-Lavigne, who resigned as
@Stanford
president this summer for overseeing labs that produced falsified research at 3 different institutions over 20 years, returns to biotech with $1bn in funding.
Among the head-turning details:
ex-Stanford prez Marc Tessier-Lavigne returns to biotech as CEO
investors include ARCH, Foresite, NEA, F-Prime, Sequoia, Lux
board includes Carolyn Bertozzi, ex- J&J CEO Alex Gorsky, former FDA head Scott Gottlieb
.
@Stanford
continues to be wrapped up in the case of convicted crypto fraudster Sam Bankman-Fried, whose parents are longtime professors at the Law School.
Of note: faculty have previously been warned that using Stanford letterhead in this manner is against policy.
A huge thank you to
@JeffreyGoldberg
,
@YAppelbaum
, Honor Jones, and everyone else who helped on this piece. It was a massive undertaking and I hope the final product reflects the work that went into it.
83-year-old Linda Sinrod holds the world record for oldest female ice hockey player, and nothing is standing in her way.
Tonight, we have the pleasure of hosting Linda as part of our ceremonial puck drop for Women in Hockey Night.
#ALLCAPS
|
@GDIT
Gwen Ifill was one of my favorite people to ever exist. To appear now on NewsHour, with the inimitable
@GeoffRBennett
, is such a privilege. Thank you for highlighting this reporting
@NewsHour
Stanford President Marc Tessier-Lavigne will resign next month over questionable handling of flawed scientific research.
Reporter
@tab_delete
of the
@StanfordDaily
first published the allegations back in November and has been covering it since.
A reminder of the risks data sleuths assume by identifying cases of research manipulation. Powerful scientists will go to great lengths to protect their careers, even when significant evidence points to fabrication.
This isn’t just about one kid, it speaks to a much broader issue of ignorance—people are willing to use symbols that signify terror and violence without knowing or caring about the context behind them. This, in turn, makes it all the harder to have productive conversations.
A year ago today, I published the biggest investigation I’ve ever conducted. Insiders at Genentech told us that pioneering Alzheimer’s research used in a $4bn stock boost was actually faked — and that executives had tried to keep that from emerging.
My grandfather talked about student journalism more than anyone I know. He loved his college newspaper so much and would sit me down and talk for hours about his experience. He died just two weeks before my own college career began. I do this for him.
These student journalists are beyond impressive. Writing live updates while yourself locked down during a shooting is a situation no college student should face. They rose to the occasion and served their community — exactly as the best reporters do. Incredibly proud.
The front page of tomorrow's
@dailytarheel
–
I shed many tears while typing up these heart-wrenching text messages sent and received by UNC students yesterday. Our campus was on lockdown for more than three hours.
Beyond proud of this cover and the team behind it.
BREAKING: More papers co-authored by Stanford's President have alleged image manipulation. Plus, the University has announced the structure of its investigation into its own president and some researchers are disappointed. My latest
@StanfordDaily
No journalist should be unsafe doing their job — much less a journalist who is a college student covering their own campus. This is deeply upsetting and absolutely unacceptable.
@UCLA
has a lot of explaining to do.
There's a
@Stanford
student who's been using social media to talk about the need for a "final solution" in re Israel/Palestine. She says there's a "secret world order" pulling all the strings. The kicker? She's a human rights minor.
The new encampment
@Stanford
’s admit weekend is being orchestrated in coordination with PSL — an organization that supports Syria’s Assad (who gassed his own people), denies Tiananmen Square, supports the annexation of Crimea, etc etc.
.
@Stanford
has been consumed since 10/7. Rival protest encampments grew large enough to be seen in satellite images of the school. Students are told they support genocide for wearing kippahs, and accused of terrorism for wearing keffiyehs. My latest:
.
@Stanford
, a school that now has four Taylor Swift classes, has not offered its “Vietnam War” class since 2020. Four whole years ago.
Students have started and graduated without the opportunity to study something that not so long ago sparked violent protests across our campus.
Student journos tend to know their communities better than natl journos swooping in to do a story when it’s newsy. Long-term connections and consistent coverage pay off big time when it counts! Nobody owns a beat like someone who lives and studies in the place they’re covering.
“We wanted to keep chasing it”: How student journalists at Harvard and the University of Pennsylvania are beating big-time reporters to the punch.
Click the image to read more:
My Pappou was the kindest and most thoughtful man I knew. I will always seek to live up to his example. Here’s to 2024 and to experiencing love so deep and meaningful.
As we say goodbye to 2023, we remember those who won't be joining us in 2024. Too many, I'm afraid. For me, most of all, this angel of a man. My New Year's resolution is to be more like him every day. ή άγάπη ούδέποτε έχπίπτει
BREAKING: Marc Tessier-Lavigne, who resigned as president of
@Stanford
amid a falsified research imbroglio, is now off the board of
@Regeneron
, where he served for years. He has had 3 papers retracted from
@ScienceMagazine
and
@CellPressNews
, with more expected from
@Nature
.
@ZaidJilani
I’m a college student, why are you so surprised that I care about colleges…
If it doesn’t matter to you then ignore it! There are plenty of great journalists covering this war—I’m not one of them. I cover universities and the students at them, not the Middle East.
Can someone explain to me why college athletic conferences aren't geographically based? Why would Stanford want to play against schools thousands of miles away, forcing kids out of classrooms for long stretches of time???
As was inevitable, a tent camp is currently being erected
@Stanford
. So far all peaceful protest with no real skirmishes. Crowds seem notably thinned compared to the heights of activism previously.
#Stanford
has refused to condemn the massacres in Israel and Nagorno-Karabakh — even
#Harvard
which received a lot of heat for its position has condemned the terrorist slaughter by Hamas.
@Stanford
, despite having taken other positions in the past, won't.
"Let there be no doubt that I condemn the terrorist atrocities perpetrated by Hamas. Such inhumanity is abhorrent, whatever one’s individual views of the origins of longstanding conflicts in the region." Read more from President Claudine Gay.
.
@thecrimson
has done an excellent job publishing balanced pieces with tough and fair reporting under enormous amounts of pressure. It has also provided room for thoughtful, considered opinions from all parts of the spectrum.
@BillAckman
needs to back the hell off.
The
@Harvard
Crimson refused to publish
@AlanDersh
piece which criticized President Gay’s testimony while publishing a piece which defended her.
President Gay’s ‘commitment to free expression’ is alive and well at the Crimson.
And consider that the Crimson is training our…
.
@StanfordDaily
’s historic front page today showcasing the resignation of President Marc Tessier-Lavigne following Daily investigations. This is our first issue back as we start up the school year!
Damian, who was killed yesterday in an IDF airstrike, is the first face you see in this video about the work
@WCKitchen
was doing on the border of Ukraine. We made thousands of sandwiches and thousands more hot meals every day from that warehouse. RIP.
Honored to receive a Dan Rather Medal!
My work “stands alongside some of the most significant journalistic endeavors of the year [it] not only illuminated the shoddy practices of the Stanford president but also laid bare shocking ethical lapses.”
And once more a reminder that the solution to this crisis is not to limit free speech but to further education and encourage the amelioration of uncompromising—and at a minimum unproductive—rhetoric.
“We've had protests in the past, but they haven't pitted students against each other,”
@Stanford
’s president told me. In a candid series of interviews between Sept. and Mar. we discussed his thorny role: “It’s been kind of a rollercoaster to be honest.”
how do we do this every week. a month after port arthur Australia did a gun buyback and two decades later they still haven’t had another mass shooting. it’s just like with covid: these people, these kids do not have to die.
Sen. Chris Murphy gets on his knees on the Senate floor: "I am here on this floor to beg, to literally get down on my hands and knees to beg my colleagues: Find a path forward here. Work with us to find a way to pass laws that make this less likely."
@smtology
I don’t believe she’s endorsing the USSR. Yet the hammer and sickle is inseparable from the Soviet Union and to say it is “typically understood” otherwise is the bad faith take here. You can’t white wash away that history.
“MTL knew” — a fifth source alleges that Stanford President Marc Tessier-Lavigne refused to withdraw falsified Alzheimer’s research in private correspondence to the board chair.
.
@Stanford
has selected its next president, business school dean Jonathan Levin. He is the 13th straight, white man to lead the university — which, unlike every Ivy, has never had a woman or person of color in charge.
Niko did a fantastic job getting this photo. He was unobtrusive and responsible, respected privacy, and took his shot when the moment was right. Incredible to have a record from mere moments after Tessier-Lavigne received our first comment request for this story.
Stanford President MTL walks through Main Quad minutes after receiving questions for
@tab_delete
’s latest reporting on alleged falsification in MTL’s research.
I played a 2-day waiting game for this photo. Proud of Theo and our
@StanfordDaily
team.
@StanfordDaily
@sbcatania
@kate_selig
@RileyOriana
Tracy, Glenn, Phil, and so many others made this possible. In addition, I'm duty bound to point out just how lucky I've been to have the incomparable role model of my parents to look toward. My family has stood behind me at every step and I love them to death. (2/)
In an interview today she said: “You guys can be mad about the hammer and sickle … I'm confused why everybody cares so much.”
And that right there is exactly the issue. A lot of people care because a lot of people died. So why use a symbol that to them represents that?
This isn’t just about one kid, it speaks to a much broader issue of ignorance—people are willing to use symbols that signify terror and violence without knowing or caring about the context behind them. This, in turn, makes it all the harder to have productive conversations.
BREAKING:
#Stanford
Law School had moved classes tomorrow to zoom over fears of violence due to the ongoing turmoil on campus over the Israel-Palestine debacle.
The new Twitter/X “feature” that hides article headlines is absolutely nonsensical and moronic. It’s just one more step in making this platform unusable for news curation and dissemination — which is, of course, a goal for Musk.
Everyone, and I mean everyone, should read
@anneapplebaum
’s Gulag and Red Famine. The horror of the Soviet Union is not a question of ideology it is a reminder of human cruelty at its most despicable. The history of the Holodomor, especially, is far too unknown.
Last night, Jews at
#Stanford
gathered in a tearful vigil to mourn those lost in the brutal terrorist attack by Hamas. Then, hours later, messages were scrawled in White Plaza, where the vigil was held, saying “2-4-6-8 smash the Zionist settler state” “Israel is dead” and more.
After resisting calls to retract this paper for more than a decade, former
@Stanford
President Marc Tessier-Lavigne has withdrawn the study he once said would “turn our current understanding of Alzheimer’s upside down.”
EXCLUSIVE: Marc Tessier-Lavigne’s Alzheimer’s research was called “the miracle result.” Now, colleagues allege that a 2011 internal review found “falsified data” and Tessier-Lavigne “walked around…with a broom and swept up the footprints in the dirt.”
.
@Stanford
refuses to condemn mass rape and murder by Hamas or take a stance on the ethnic cleansing in Nagorno-Karabakh, saying the University doesn’t take stances. Except it has taken a stance on Ukraine and George Floyd among other issues.
I love this industry. But watching news organization after news organization spiral is both so sad and utterly terrifying. Is this what my friends and I are heading toward? Should we really keep going?
So grateful for the support of a wonderful group. I met many heroes today who exemplify the bravery and sacrifice of journalists—real journalists—who risk their lives every day.
“If you’re wondering why I’m up here … I am too,” jokes Stanford freshman
@tab_delete
— youngest-ever winner
@PolkAwards
.
(Some of the answer was revealed in his remarks: Theo said he’s faced intimidation + threats as he broke stories that put Stanford president’s job at risk)
INBOX: under significant pressure,
#Stanford
has released a new statement on the terror attack in Israel. "As a moral matter, we condemn all terrorism and mass atrocities. This includes the deliberate attack on civilians this weekend by Hamas," said the president and provost.
Important credit to
@MicrobiomDigest
and the folks at
@PubPeer
who identified a number of the allegations that eventually ended Marc Tessier-Lavigne's tenure as Stanford president.
Congratulations to
@peterbakernyt
of the
@nytimes
, winner of the WHCA’s 2024 Award for Excellence in Presidential News Coverage Under Deadline Pressure – Print. To see the winning coverage and more,
I don’t normally comment on journalism fuck ups because there are plenty of people here who do, but this is a good example of just how far higher ed coverage at national papers often lags behind student journalism (and their own publications’ standards).
Contrary to a report by The Washington Post, no protesters have been arrested, and the encampment has not been broken up by Penn's administration. Rather, the encampment remains intact and uninterrupted at this time.
So impressed by the
@dailypenn
reporters/editors/staffers absolutely kicking ass and serving their community at a time of great tension. Moments like these are exactly when we need reliable, thorough student journalism.
BREAKING:
@Wharton
's Board of Advisors is calling on Penn to change leadership with "immediate effect," alleging a "dangerous and toxic culture," according to a letter to President Liz Magill first obtained by
@dailypenn
.
A look at my transcript shows that when
@tab_delete
told me the academic courseload he took while reporting these stories I said a very rude word out loud and then immediately apologized that it was not directed at him specifically, I was just stunned
I also want to recognize my grandfathers, both of whom passed this year. I was so incredibly lucky to be close to them and admire their example. They were wonderful human beings, who always put others above their own.
@sbg1
and
@peterbakernyt
have given me an incredible life.
Stanford pledged to revise its policies to prevent a man who had pretended to be a student and lived in dorms for a year under false pretenses from returning. But he’s back, and his ex says he continues to stalk and harass her on campus.
@StanfordDaily
NEW: Genentech has disclosed an additional allegation of research misconduct in Stanford President Marc Tessier-Lavigne’s lab and said he published an Alzheimer’s study despite concerns over its reproducibility. Latest
@StanfordDaily
“I know that I’m a target,”
@Stanford
’s president told me, not long after his house was vandalized and days before an effigy of him was covered in blood. (1/2)
Dozens of
#Stanford
professors and students have signed a letter to the president and provost about its lackluster response to the Hamas terror attack.
@Stanford
’s response “downplays the horrific gravity of the situation,” they write.
According to an instagram post, they were protesting investment in “weapons manufacturers, including Boeing, Lockheed Martin, BlackRock, and others.” BlackRock is not a weapons manufacturer. It manages index funds.
A group of Berkeley law students accepted an invitation to dine at the private home of dean Erwin Chemerinsky and his wife, a law professor, then disrupted the event and refused to leave. Bizarrely, this student claims her conduct is protected by the 1st Amendment. Activists are…
Stanford has known of an imposter living in dorms and harassing students since at least late 2021 but failed to notify students or keep him off campus. Spanning 5 dorms and numerous removals, this is my latest for
@StanfordDaily
Former
@Stanford
President Marc Tessier-Lavigne promoted a paper he said identified the likely cause of Alzheimer’s while on a campaign to increase Genentech’s sale price. Now the study has been retracted. Slides from a 2009 investor presentation below.
“As a rabbi tried to leave the anti-antisemitism event, protesters began pursuing him, chanting, ‘There is only one solution! Intifada revolution!’” (1/3)
Stanford has refused to give a full accounting of its financial relationship to FTX; Joseph Bankman is still active at Stanford Law School even as both he and his wife, Barbara Fried, have been sued by FTX for improper enrichment.
In its new suit against Joseph Bankman and Barbara Fried, FTX alleges Sam Bankman-Fried's father funneled money to Stanford, where he is a professor.
A university spokesperson tells me Stanford "will be returning the funds in their entirety."
“More than ever, it would seem Stanford is due for some serious introspection. Yet the one thing Silicon Valley seems incapable of is shaking off its own mythology.” My latest in
@NYMag
.
Student journalism is an incredible community. This year I’ve had the pleasure of getting to know badasses from MA, FL, NY, IL, MI, NC, WI, and a dozen other places, all dedicated to their communities. To any student journalist who might see this: keep it up you’re doing great!
The Student (Small) Award goes to
@StanfordDaily
for investigating the allegations of research misconduct by the president of Stanford. This series sparked headlines across the country.
#IREAwards
If you think it’s impossible to think about multiple things at the same time then you’re going to lose it when I tell you that students take more than one class every semester!
The sequel to Maus is on prominent display in the library today. Why the sequel? All copies of the original are checked out. Massachusetts says no thank you to Tennessee.
EXCLUSIVE: Marc Tessier-Lavigne’s Alzheimer’s research was called “the miracle result.” Now, colleagues allege that a 2011 internal review found “falsified data” and Tessier-Lavigne “walked around…with a broom and swept up the footprints in the dirt.”
A twist of fate has triggered an unusual situation in which a newly designated tenured professor, the ex-president, must retract two high-profile studies his first day on the job. My latest
@StanfordDaily
, with exclusive behind the scenes reporting.
This comes almost exactly a year after
@Stanford
revealed that it had curtailed Jewish admissions in the 1950s. Over the last year, there have been several antisemitic incidents on campus, including swastikas scrawled on the door of a Jewish student in my dorm.