Some news from me: today is my last day at
@TorontoStar
. In my four years here I’ve grown as a journalist more than I ever could have imagined, and gotten to work with some of the brightest and kindest people in the biz.
I fact checked everything
@CPC_HQ
leader
@erinotoole
said last week. I found 7 false claims in 213 mins of public appearances. I also deemed 6 separate claims to be a stretch. That works out to a “dishonesty density” of about 1 false claim every 30 mins.
Scenes from the Starbucks at College & Dovercourt, which uses Bell WiFi. People are sitting on the sidewalk outside with their laptops
#RogersOutage
@TorontoStar
My fact check on
@NDP
leader
@theJagmeetSingh
for
@TorontoStar
In total, I found five false claims in 231 minutes of public appearances. That works out to a “dishonesty density” of about one false claim every 46 minutes.
#BREAKING
: Ontario's medical regulator has launched an investigation into Toronto physician Ira Bernstein, co-founder of the Canadian Covid Care alliance, and linked to the organization that prescribed
@TorontoStar
ivermectin. Story to come.
My final fact check, on Liberal leader Justin Trudeau, is in
@torontostar
today. In 248 minutes of public appearances last week, Trudeau made 5 false claims and stretched the truth 6 times. That's a “dishonesty density” of about 1 false claim/50 mins
Important clarification on some of the messaging from the
@NDP
this week: Trudeau didn't cut health care transfers to provinces - he kept a Harper-era policy that cut the yearly growth rate of such transfers. Currently, transfers grow by at least 3%/year.
#FactCheck
#elxn44
This is Kartik Saini, the 20 yr old student who was struck and killed by a truck driver in midtown Toronto Wednesday.
His family, who lives in India, is shattered.
"In Canada everyone follow traffic rule ... why this happened?" one relative asked me.
I fact-checked everything Green leader
@AnnamiePaul
said last week for
@TorontoStar
. I found 4 false claims in 184 minutes of public appearances, working out to a "dishonesty density" of about one false claim/47 minutes. Read my full analysis here:
#BREAKING
: Patrick Phillips, a northern Ontario doctor and a director of the organization that prescribed the Star ivermectin, a disproven COVID-19 cure, has been suspended, per
@cpso_ca
this morning.
NEW
#StarInvestigation
:
@TorontoStar
has obtained ivermectin, an disproven COVID-19 treatment, through a covert network of Canadian physicians who are prescribing it to patients willing to pay. 🧵
Michael Kovrig’s wife and sister arrive at YYZ to greet Michael who is supposed to land within the hour. After more than 1,000 days detained in China, they say news of his release was “shocking” but “the best news.” They FaceTimed him earlier and said he looked well.
@TorontoStar
At Sussex and Spadina, where 2 hours ago a woman in her 20s was stabbed in her face and head while riding the streetcar. She was taken to hospital and is stable, police say. Suspect is a woman in her 40s. Police say early reports suggest they didn’t know each other.
After a few exciting months with the politics team, I have a new role at
@torontostar
! Today I start as transportation reporter, taking the reins from the talented
@BenSpurr
. 1/3
My main takeaway is that Singh is running a truthful campaign. His mistakes — I counted five false claims total — weren’t malicious lies or Donald Trump-like whoppers, they were slip-ups that seemed largely forgivable in a campaign covering a wide range of issues in detail.
I tried to fact-check everything
@fordnation
said for a week for
@torontostar
.
But the Star’s fact checking method requires a leader to make a certain number of statements of fact to judge how truthful they are.
The PC leader made just 19 in 5 days.
Any avid winter cyclists on here wanna chat for a
@TorontoStar
feature?
Looking to speak about safety tips, the unexpected joys of biking in a snowstorm (is this a thing?), infrastructure challenges and generally how we could make Toronto more conducive to winter cycling.
The claim that most hurt O'Toole's credibility was one I couldn’t fact-check: his flop-flop on assault weapons. We’ll never know if he intentionally misled or just changed his mind, but the opacity around his position and his failure to clarify for days came across as dishonest.
Dawn Girard has lost two brothers in three years to
#opioids
. They are among 17,602 Canadians who have died from opioid overdoses since 2016 — including a projected record of 2,271 in Ontario in 2020 alone. My latest for
@TorontoStar
(a thread):
#BREAKING
: ATU Local 1587, the union representing striking GO Transit workers, has confirmed they will next meet with
@Metrolinx
on Friday. GO bus strike to last at least until then.
@TorontoStar
ATU's strike comes just 3 days after 55k CUPE education workers walked off the job. "This union-busting crown corporation has been given its privatization mandate by the same government that is revoking Charter Rights for CUPE workers," said ATU int'l President John Costa
A statement of fact is a claim that can be, for the most part, marked as true or false. The sky is blue. Ontario has a larger population than Quebec. Joe Biden won the 2021 U.S. presidential election.
Hint: “We’re going to get it done” isn’t one.
@hoccgoomusic
Hi Denise, glad to hear you’re okay. I’m a reporter for the Toronto Star. Would you be up for a quick interview? Feel free to DM or email me at lexharvey
@thestar
.ca. Take care
O’Toole’s campaign was largely truthful, which bolsters the finding that Canadian politicians are much more honest than not. While O’Toole made slightly more false claims than Paul and Singh, he didn’t stretch the truth nearly as often as Singh did.
The nationalistic language being used around these fires is so bizarre to me. This week has been such a strong reminder that the climate crisis knows no borders. Also a reality check that the choices of individual countries will mean little without strong global action.
Is
@JustinTrudeau
really taking Indigenous kids to court? Is the
@liberal_party
really proposing a tax on primary home sales? I fact checked two of Trudeau's two key debate denials for
@TorontoStar
Today is my first day as a
@TorontoStar
staffer, with the fancy new title of Newsletter Producer! Along with writing First Up, I'll be helping to build on the Star's newsletter program. So excited to join this incredible team, on what is sure to be a very calm news week 🙃🎉
Like the leaders that came before him, Trudeau had an honest week. When considering all 4 leaders’ “dishonesty density” — their rate of false claims by speaking time — Trudeau was the most truthful of a fairly evenly matched bunch.
As Ontario enters Step 3 of reopening, its worth looking at the experiences of the Netherlands and the UK, whose cases shot up after restrictions were eased. A thread on where Ontario’s at and what we can learn from others.
Some of his statements on Trudeau’s record didn’t quite pass the truth test: he made a couple of unsubstantiated accusations of Liberal “cover-ups,” mischaracterized policies like the child care agreements, and falsely said Trudeau reduced penalties for firearm offences.
The most interesting story this week was the 13 stretches. Among them, the several times Singh took credit for pandemic aid measures. The stretches also came from statements that were rooted in ideological, quintessentially NDP beliefs. I get into that more in my analysis.
81% of workers rejected Metrolinx's latest deal, the union said. ATU Local 1587 members include GO bus drivers, station attendants, maintenance workers, transit safety officers and office personnel.
They have been without a contract since June.
At Eglinton Station this morning where
@Metrolinx
CEO Phil Verster is giving reporters a project update.
Any bets on whether or not we’ll get an opening date today? 👀
@TorontoStar
Ornge, Ontario’s air ambulance and medical transport service, transported a record 327 patients in the first two weeks of April to create space in ICUs. As GTA hospitals fill up, patients are being transferred as far as Kingston. My latest in
@TorontoStar
Breaking: Kartik Saini, a 20-year-old international student from India, was the cyclist who was struck and killed by a pickup truck driver making an apparent illegal right turn on at Yonge/St Clair Wednesday, his family told
@TorontoStar
In a press release, ATU Local 1587 said "Metrolinx continues to refuse to address safety concerns by ensuring that experienced and highly trained workers remain on the job, and continues to refuse to budge on language that would protect GO Transit jobs from being contracted out."
Overall, Paul was honest. Her numbers and claims — related to Canada’s climate record, the toll of COVID-19 in long-term care, and the scope of the opioid crisis — largely checked out. As I move to fact check other leader's, I'll use our dishonesty density index to compare.
I dug into the recent spike in overdoses for
@walrusmagazine
. I asked drug users what it's like to watch the gov't pour mass resources into COVID-19 while the opioid crisis is largely ignored: “We’re fighting an uphill battle just to be seen as humans."
Under an alias,
@TorontoStar
was prescribed ivermectin through a new service called Canadian Covid Telehealth, run by doctors involved with an organization that spreads misinformation on COVID treatments and vaccines.
Today the
@TorontoStar
launches a series called Cold Truths, which features three stories I wrote based on a week of on-the-ground reporting in Svalbard, Norway — the fastest warming place on earth.
For perspective, it’s all the way up here!
In both cases, Metrolinx staff pushed back.
On the issue of excluding the MPPs, Mx said it's customary to notify all local officials.
On the # of trees, an Mx staffer said it's important for "transparency."
The province overrode Mx on both points.
Nia was 11 when she was first told that her race was a barrier to fulfilling her dreams as a ballerina. Her experience with racism in dance inspired her to start Révolutionnaire in 2019, a social platform and store selling diverse dancewear.
@TorontoStar
Communications staff at the ministry also asked Metrolinx to remove from construction notices the estimated number of trees that will be taken down, at the request of Ford’s office.
Ending the year on a positive note - a heartwarming end to story about 74-yr-old asylum seeker facing deportation, first reported by
@nkeung
@TorontoStar
It’s been a difficult year for grocery workers. For Tracey and Dino Virgona, sibling owners of
@FiestaFarms
, it’s been nothing short of exhausting — but it’s also been pretty beautiful. For
@torontostar
, I spoke to them about the ups and the downs.
The TL;DR of my
@TorontoStar
piece: Vaccines work. They save lives. Get one as you can — it may be the difference between a mild case and a severe one. But beating COVID is a team sport, and we won’t win until we’ve all crossed the finish line.
Yesterday,
@SteveRussell
and I got to ride on the Eglinton Crosstown LRT and speak to the CEO of one of the companies building it.
Here's an exclusive first look inside the LRT, and what I learned about what's causing the delays.
@TorontoStar
In five days, Ford only spoke for 25 minutes in a public forum where he could be questioned by journalists.
Because of how little he spoke — and how little of substance he said when he did speak — this exercise didn’t say much about his truthfulness.
Joining the
@TorontoStar
politics team for the next bit to fact check Canada’s federal leaders during the 2021 election campaign. Send tips/advice to lexharvey
@thestar
.com
#elxn44
In March 2003, a Toronto woman went to her doctor with fever and a dry cough after a trip to Hong Kong. She didn’t have COVID-19— she had SARS, a respiratory illness that would go on to infect hundreds in Canada, mostly in Ontario.
@TorontoStar
(a thread)
Starting Sept 5
@adriearsenault
, the first woman to be appointed
@CBC
chief correspondent, anchors
@CBCTheNational
Mon to Thurs. “I am fiercely protective of the joys and necessities of good journalism, and this is a huge privilege and responsibility."
I’m on a little trip for
@TorontoStar
this week looking at how other cities and transit systems are dealing with the complex challenges facing the TTC, like rising crime and homelessness, as well as rider wariness.
First up: Philly and
@SEPTA
That Ford sees this as a winning strategy is “alarming” for our democracy,
@timabray
told me.
He called it a slip into “content-free elections,” where leaders avoid substantive policy conversations in favour of vague talking points.
BREAKING: there were 1068 offences against customers on the TTC in 2022, a 60% increase from 2019, when there were 666. There were 735 and 734 in ‘20 and ‘21, respectively.
We’re in good shape. Thanks to a successful vaccine rollout and strong public health measures, as Dr. Peter Jüni pointed out, Ontario is the only region in the Western world that hasn’t seen exponential growth in cases once Delta took hold.
This
@_jennamoon
piece on "the world's loneliest orca" is gripping and disturbing (and a very cool digital experience). Commentary from Marineland's lawyer is icing on the cake 🙃
With recent violence on the TTC prompting calls to address homelessness on the system (despite no data to suggest homeless ppl are perpetrating the violence),
@_VictoriaGibson
& I looked at why people shelter on transit, and how they're feeling:
BREAKING: Crosslinx Transit Solutions, the consortium building the Eglinton LRT, has informed Metrolinx that “they intend to litigate and stop working with the TTC, who will operate the (LRT).”
Metrolinx calls the move “another unacceptable delay tactic” by CTS.
@TorontoStar
I fact checked everything
@StevenDelDuca
said this week for
@TorontoStar
.
I found 5 false claims and 5 stretches in 121 mins of filmed public appearances, working out to a "dishonesty density" of about 1 false claim/24 mins.
Full analysis here:
#onpoli
I’m back on the
@TorontoStar
fact checking beat for the
#OnElxn
I’ll be focusing on one leader per week, recording every claim they make and verifying it, publishing weekly in the Star.
Send tips via DM or to lexharvey
@thestar
.ca
#onpoli
#FactCheck
I fact-checked everything
@AndreaHorwath
said this week.
I found 11 false claims in 130 speaking mins, a dishonesty density of about 1 false claim/12 mins — twice the scores of Del Duca & Schreiner when I checked them.
This week I fact check
@fordnation
.
Speaking at the Empire Club yesterday, Metrolinx CEO Phil Verster said there's still no timeline on opening the Eglinton Crosstown LRT.
"I will not declare a date for it to open in advance until I have a robust schedule that I believe in.”
COVID-19 has caused a dramatic spike in overdoses across the country. Border restrictions have disrupted the flow of illicit drugs, further contaminating an already dangerous drug supply. In B.C., opioid deaths outpace COVID deaths.
Crime has risen on the TTC since 2020, despite plunging ridership.
I took a look at some of root causes driving the violence, and importantly, what it means for the system if people are too afraid to ride.
@TorontoStar
NEW: NDP MPPs
@Peter_Tabuns
&
@kristynwongtam
accused
@C_Mulroney
of weakening public trust in Metrolinx after the Star revealed her office directed
@Metrolinx
to exclude the politicians from a notice about tree removals in their ridings.
I asked Vina if Michael shared when he knew he was being taken home and how that moment felt. She said they haven’t discussed yet, in their first FaceTime they focused on how he was feeling and “saying all the things one says after not seeing each other for more than 1000 days.”
NEW: The TTC will resume ticketing for fare evasion in March in the hopes of boosting its revenue by $6M.
The agency says it's necessary for cashflow amid dwindling ridership - but advocates warn of equity implications and the need to prioritize service.
CALL OUT: I'm working on a
@TorontoStar
story about people supporting frontline workers, i.e. by caring for their kids, cooking food, volunteering at vaccine clinics. Do you know a pandemic helper doing something great in your community? DM or email me at lexharvey
@thestar
.ca
With many in Toronto calling for solutions to violence on the TTC, thought I'd re-up my
@TorontoStar
story on what Philadelphia's SEPTA is doing.
It's not perfect, but SEPTA's approach is one of the most comprehensive & compassionate I've seen.
#BREAKING
: The driver who killed 20-year-old cyclist Kartik Saini has been charged with "careless driving causing death", "turn not in safety", and "proceed contrary to sign," per Toronto police. He will appear in court Feb 16.
I've never been nominated for anything before, so two for this piece is really friggin exciting.
@mckennadeighton
&
@NathanPilla
deserve so much credit for this - their interactive maps and graphics really brought this piece to life and made the science make sense.