THREAD: Last fall,
@thecrimson
learned that three world-renowned professors in
#Harvard
Anthropology face accusations that they sexually harassed women, including students.
We spent eight months investigating: why this department? 1/
Thrilled to be returning to
@POLITICO
today as an energy reporter. I'll be authoring Morning Energy and stories with a focus on EVs.
Felt like the time to bring back this old pic of me as Larry the Lightbulb, from my days interning
@portlandgeneral
. Hello, energy world! 👋
Twenty-five
#Harvard
Anthro faculty signed a letter asking Gary Urton to resign Thursday.
“We see your continued presence as an impediment in our efforts to move the department in a more equitable, responsive, and responsible direction," they wrote.
Finally, this story would be nothing without the incredible editing and support of
@mollmccaff
and
@saviyonah
. I can’t thank them enough for all the time they’ve put into this piece.
I hope you’ll give it a read:
Beyond those three professors, though, dozens of people said the department has an “old boys’ club” culture that places female students at a disadvantage. An internal report I reviewed found recent female grads are taking 1.5 years longer than men to complete their Ph.Ds. 5/
Through interviews with 72 people connected to the department, I learned that that prestige — especially in tight knit field where advisors can determine career prospects through a single phone call — gives faculty in Harvard Anthro tremendous power over their students. 3/
NEW from me: Two years, zero EV chargers.
In 2021, the Biden administration secured $7.5 billion from Congress to build EV chargers. But two years later, not a single charger funded by the law has come online.
I spent so many months investigating this so that I could examine the nuances of not just what happened, but why. It’s a long read, but a story simply about the sexual harassment allegations would have not have explained the structures that students say led to them. 7/
The accused three professors are Theodore L. Bestor, Gary Urton, and John L. Comaroff. Bestor and Urton are former department chairs; all three are major names in the anthropology field, and hold lifelong appointments to one of its most prestigious departments. 2/
Just 3 of the department’s 21 current tenured faculty are female. Women said that left them lacking role models for success in anthro, and without the same career advancement opportunities as male students had. Some said male professors discouraged them from having children. 6/
Several women alleged in court documents and interviews with The Crimson that the professors wielded that power to sexually harass them and others over the past decade, sometimes without drawing attention to their conduct. 4/
Two more women — Carrie Brezine and Jade Guedes — told The Crimson this week that Gary Urton had sexually harassed them as graduate students. Brezine said Urton's repeated requests for sex began in 2003.
NEW: Harvard
#Anthro
and AAAS professor John Comaroff has been placed on paid administrative leave following allegations of sexual harassment and retaliation, which were first reported by
@thecrimson
in May.
If you know more, or want to speak with me about what’s included — or not — in this story, please reach out. Email me at james.bikales
@thecrimson
.com or send me a DM. 8/
Story on Gary Urton's removal as Director of Undergrad Studies in Harvard Anthro, as well as a number of other steps the undergrad program is taking in the wake of The Crimson's reporting last week:
incredibly honored to be taking over as Managing Editor
@thecrimson
today.
@saviyonah
has left big shoes to fill, but I'm confident our team will be up to the challenge.
Email me with story tips/ideas: james.bikales
@thecrimson
.com
It’s been a month since I joined
@politico
— I’ve been pretty quiet on here as I’ve been busy writing 21 editions of Morning Energy so far.
Leading today’s newsletter is an analysis of
@ENERGY
’s $2B loan to
@RedwoodMat
:
Two Harvard custodians continued to clean University President Larry Bacow's home for 10 days after campus shut down. Both developed COVID symptoms soon after.
Excellent labor reporting by
@matteo_wong
and Sophia Liang on Harvard's haphazard COVID protections for its employees.
Who is essential to Harvard’s health? Despite months spent planning for the fall semester, problems from the spring have recurred, putting the workers executing those plans at enormous risk. Read this week's cover story from
@matteo_wong
and Sophia Liang:
Breaking: Anthropology professor Gary Urton has been placed on paid administrative leave pending an investigation into allegations of sexual misconduct.
Harvard Anthro professor Gary Urton informed colleagues he plans to retire by the end of August. He was placed on administrative leave in June after a Crimson investigation revealed he faced allegations of sexual harassment. Story here:
Even after 2 years looking at deep-rooted problems at Harvard and the Anthro dept, I’m still shocked by this in the suit. I was grateful to everyone who spoke to me for my reporting, but I always assumed it was a last resort — not something encouraged by Harvard's own admin.
Unruly passengers on planes shouldn't have a "second chance,"
@FlyingWithSara
told me this week, calling on the FAA to make its zero-tolerance policy on disruptive behavior permanent.
My final issue of
@thecrimson
as Managing Editor — it's been an honor to lead this paper and its incredible staff. I couldn't be more confident leaving it in the hands of
@Jasper_Goodman
@raquelco15
and the 149.
Under the 148th Guard of The Crimson, we navigated a pandemic, reunited this fall, and restarted printing. We can’t express how grateful we are for your leadership. Pick up a copy of the 148's very last issue at your nearest news rack.
Drag is wildly popular today, but performers say we're at an inflection point: Attacks threaten to drive drag back underground — and with it a symbol of visibility for the LGBTQ community.
This one's been in the works since my first weeks
@washingtonpost
:
.
@Sciencing_Bi
, which had made several allegations against Harvard anthro professors, now appears to be a fake account. It’s unclear if the tweeter attended Harvard.
One note:
@thecrimson
never spoke to this person and our reporting was separate from that.
#anthrotwitter
Harvard's
#anthro
chairs told me today that this week's
@thecrimson
article has been "devastating" for the department, but pledged immediate action, including forming a committee to analyze and "dismantle" longstanding structures in the dept.
Harvard faculty, grad students, and staff are participating in the nationwide
@ScholarStrike
— replacing typical teaching and work with education on racial justice Tuesday and Wednesday. My story
@thecrimson
Harvard has determined Gary Urton abused his power by asking a grad student to join him in a hotel room in 2012.
It was not sexual harassment, however, because FAS rules didn't prohibit faculty having sexual relations with their students until 2016. Story:
Over 20% of
#Harvard
undergrads do not plan to enroll this fall, per Harvard projections:
• 5,231 undergrads enrolling
• 340 freshmen deferring admission (typical is 80-110)
• 1,632 living on campus (~25%) incl 1,168 freshmen
Story with
@kchenx
After a yearlong investigation into sexual harassment allegations I reported last year, Harvard today stripped Anthro prof. Gary Urton of his emeritus status. Urton will also be barred from campus and all University events. Story by Andy Wang
As the Kim family lowered their mother's casket into the ground, the funeral director stopped them. There had been a mistake — it wasn’t their mother inside.
Now, the family is suing for $50 million. My latest
@washingtonpost
This
@foxandfriends
segment implies all Harvard students have a mansion with perfect wifi to stay during the pandemic. That couldn’t be further from the truth:
Today’s my last day
@thehill
...
and
@AbigailMihaly
and I have a story out on how the pandemic has affected town-gown relations from rural Vermont to Los Angeles.
Harvard Law professor J. Mark Ramseyer claimed in a paper that so-called comfort women — sex slaves in Imperial Japan — were employed voluntarily. Academics across the world have criticized the paper.
@simonjlevien
in Seoul and Ariel Kim report:
“We demand nothing short of radical, truly transformative change,” Harvard
#Anthro
and AAAS students wrote in a petition to their departments this week. They asked for 3 professors accused of sexual misconduct to be fired. Story:
California isn’t tracking how many of its K-12 schools are open in-person, nor is it releasing data on positive cases in schools.
@ByRicardoCano
and I contacted all 58 counties find out how CA’s school reopenings have gone so far for
@CalMatters
:
The most reliable way for Californians to get alerts during a wildfire or other disaster is to register for their county's opt-in alert system. But as I found for
@CalMatters
, very few have:
LA County — 1%
Fresno County — 1%
Stanislaus — 4%
Read more:
In my final story for
@POLITICO
this summer, I explore a political hot-potato in Washington: a vehicle miles traveled fee. It's seen as the future for U.S. road budgets, but somehow, "like nuclear fusion," it's always 10 years away from primetime.
This piece of reporting from
@simonjlevien
is a must-read — from a year's worth of archival research, he reconstructs the hidden history of the KKK at Harvard. From
@crimsonFM
:
THREAD: The Ku Klux Klan had a chapter at Harvard University in the 1920s; in 1952, students held a cross burning in Harvard Yard.
After a year's worth of research, I attempted to construct a history of the KKK's long presence at Harvard. 1/
SCOOP: Forty-three Harvard dining workers are currently taking sick leave because they are at high-risk for COVID-19, but once their sick days run out, Harvard doesn't plan to pay them until May 28.
One more story (actually 3!) for
@CalMatters
, to wrap up a great internship.
I examine three California industries on the brink thanks to the pandemic: catering, live sports, and performing arts. What has this year meant for workers in those fields?
BREAKING: In a dramatic rebuke to the administration, Harvard's Faculty of Arts and Sciences voted overwhelmingly (179-20) today to support divestment from fossil fuels.
A judge dismissed a high-profile lawsuit against Harvard over early photos of slaves it possesses. The plaintiff, Tamara Lanier — who says she is a descendent of the people depicted in the photos — told
@thecrimson
she plans to appeal. By
@OLRiskinKutz
More than 90 percent of voters in Harvard’s graduate student union approved a strike authorization vote.
@RuoqiZhang3
and I spent 6 hours outside the count this evening for
@thecrimson
—
“Remove any delusions that travel is as it used to be before covid," a travel expert told
@hannahbsampson
and me. We spoke to people about their experiences during a miserable summer for travel:
In response to The Crimson's reporting, 341 people have thus far signed a petition calling for "transformative change" in Harvard's Anthro and AAAS departments — including the firing of Professors Urton, Bestor, and Comaroff. Story to come.
"Trust that the refusal to take or give scraps is worldmaking in other ways." Read the Transformative Justice statement collectively made by many students in Harvard Anthro & African and African American Studies regarding sexual and gendered abuse.
Harvard fall instruction will take place online with only
"rare" exceptions, with three scenarios being considered for undergrad life: maintaining low-density, housing 30-40% of students, or bringing back all students. With
@amandaysu
for
@thecrimson
New in ME this morning:
@Edison_Electric
is facing pushback from green groups over draft comments it's circulating on EPA's proposed power plant rule.
EEI told us it's considering calling on EPA to rewrite its rule regulating existing gas plants.
A family feud, a Singaporean criminal case over a private Facebook post, and a Harvard Economics professor. They’re all connected. My latest for
@thecrimson
Harvard Professor Danielle Allen was a contender for the Harvard presidency in 2018, but is now looking at a very different executive position: governor of Massachusetts.
State judicial elections are traditionally sleepy affairs, but with abortion and other civil rights issues now on the docket, they're drawing more attention, money, and candidates.
With
@praveenavsoma
for
@washingtonpost
:
Incredible package of stories on Harvard's
#coronavirus
closures by
@thecrimson
today. We explored the move's impact on:
- FGLI students
- Internationals
- Graduating seniors
- Athletes
- Faculty
- Employees
- Each Harvard school
- Public health
And that was just day one...
I spoke to Native American leaders this week for
@thehill
about why many tribal nations are taking stricter measures against COVID-19, even as neighboring state governments have moved to reopen.
Two Winthrop House tutors have subpoenaed a Crimson reporter as part of their defamation lawsuit against Eliot House's faculty dean. The Crimson plans to resist the subpoena. Read my story for
@thecrimson
here:
A journal publishing Harvard Law Prof. Mark Ramseyer's controversial paper on comfort women told
@thecrimson
it will temporarily delay print publication to "give readers access to the fullest possible picture.” Great reporting by
@simonjlevien
& Ariel Kim:
A Harvard dining services worker told me he and his colleagues want to keep working because they love and care about the students. HUDS workers (and custodians) whose facilities have closed will be for paid 30 days w/ benefits: story for
@thecrimson
Roughly 81% of Harvard College grades were in as of yesterday, compared to 94% normally in by that date.
@emaschumer
and I report on the after-effects of the grad student strike on grading for
@thecrimson
Below, Trade Representative Robert Lighthizer testifies before House Ways and Means Committee...probably.
My story
@thehill
on the tech glitches plaguing 3 House hearings today, leading to GOP calls for the House to return to in-person work.
Longtime Black activists in my hometown of Portland told me the backlash to federal agents is diverting attention from their original goals: racial justice and local police reform. My latest for
@thehill
from Portland:
Police in a Chicago suburb punched a prone teenager in the head repeatedly after he fled a traffic stop Wednesday, leaving him hospitalized with internal bleeding.
The incident was caught on video. Latest for
@washingtonpost
“We’ve done a lot to make it fire-resistant, but that hasn’t resulted in us being able to get insurance.”
Many Californians are facing insurance cancellations, despite pouring $1,000s into risk mitigation. I explored a potential solution for
@CalMatters
HGSU and Harvard negotiators are holding their final scheduled bargaining session before HGSU’s strike deadline (Dec. 3) today. Meanwhile, the University’s Provost sent an email to all Harvard affiliates with an update on the negotiations:
A daughter of Taiwanese immigrants born on Chicago’s South Side, Wu had never truly been away from her family before coming to Cambridge in August 2003.
People living in the U.S. Pacific territories are considered Americans, but they lack many of the constitutional rights enjoyed by mainland citizens — my latest for
@HarvardPolitics
here:
Seven months. That’s how long it had been since Harvard’s grad student union and the University agreed on a new contract provision, until this week.
@RuoqiZhang3
and I are back to union coverage after summer break:
Harvard’s graduate student union yesterday accepted the University’s offer for federal mediation, which will begin Jan. 7. Update from
@emaschumer
here:
Facing multiple accusations of sexual harassment, Harvard
#Anthro
prof. emeritus Gary Urton has filed a retaliation complaint against one of his accusers for publicly sharing the draft findings of an investigation into her allegations. Story
@thecrimson
:
Breaking: Harvard’s grad student workers will begin voting next week on whether to authorize a strike over the stalemate in contract negotiations with the University. Read more
@thecrimson
:
Harvard Chemistry department chair Charles Lieber was arrested Tuesday morning for lying to the FBI about research he allegedly conducted on behalf of the Chinese government. Story with
@kchenx
for
@thecrimson
... more to come later:
In an email announcing the decision, Faculty of Arts and Sciences Dean Claudine Gay wrote that in addition to reporting by The Crimson and posts on social media, her office also received direct outreach alleging harassment by Urton.
.
@kchenx
and I dug into the archives to examine Harvard's conflicts over free speech and controversial speakers over the years, ahead of Charles Murray's speech today.
The story includes "In 1983, protestors dressed as Grim Reapers disrupted a talk..."
Harvard proposed engaging federal mediators to assist in its negotiations with HGSU-UAW Thursday. Both sides must mutually ask for the mediation in order to engage the free government service. Story with
@emaschumer
for
@thecrimson
Physicians at Beth Israel Hospital saw their compensation (retirement, bonuses) cut this month as hospitals nationwide face tough financial times due to
#COVID19
. Story:
Striking workers have merged with Ethnic Studies protestors outside Emerson Hall, waiting for President Bacow to emerge from a faculty meeting
@thecrimson
Former AG and current Senate candidate Jeff Sessions appeared to refer to renowned Harvard professor Skip Gates, who is Black, as "some criminal" in an interview published in NYT today. My latest for
@thecrimson
Harvard’s health plan works for most students, but for some, it’s costing thousands out of pocket and forcing them to make risky choices for their health.
@MichelleKurilla
and I spent a month talking to those students:
The letter that prompted Dean Gay to launch a review of tenure procedures was signed by 107 Harvard faculty. Read what they wrote and why three department chairs said they signed — story with
@kchenx
for
@thecrimson
“Harvard should be offering better wages and better benefits than other universities and it should be a leader. I think it is a disappointment that the students have to be out here striking.” -U.S. Senate candidate Shannon Liss-Riordan told
@thecrimson
from the picket lines
Harvard students, join The Crimson for a conversation with two incredible journalists, Errin Haines and Wesley Lowery THIS FRIDAY at 6pm EDT. Register to attend here: