One of the most painful lessons of this crisis is the extent to which America cannot or will not identify with Chinese pain. Every horror that is happening here happened first in Wuhan. We covered it. Many people did not care.
News: The Trump administration will not join a global effort to develop, manufacture and equitably distribute a coronavirus vaccine, in part because the World Health Organization is involved. Details on the Covax decision from
@yabutaleb7
and me.
Australian intelligence officials tell Sydney Morning Herald that U.S. briefings on Wuhan lab theory are mostly write-ups of news reports and "contained no material from intelligence gathering."
Update: This message from a man warning, gleefully, that I may be the next journalist to be murdered, does not violate
@Twitter
’s rules on abusive behavior, per Twitter. 1/2
It's pretty surreal watching from Beijing as the Washington press corps and its critics go bananas over a fancy party. There are journalists in jail. There are sources in jail. Where is the sense of proportion?
A remarkable interview about the conspiracy and delusion gripping this country. This nurse says some patients would rather believe they have *lung cancer* than believe the coronavirus is real.
A South Dakota ER nurse
@JodiDoering
says her Covid-19 patients often “don’t want to believe that Covid is real.”
“Their last dying words are, ‘This can’t be happening. It’s not real.’ And when they should be... Facetiming their families, they’re filled with anger and hatred.”
Incredible video: Bruce Aylward of WHO is asked about Taiwan's coronavirus response and dodges in a pretty spectacular way. Then ends the interview. Remarkable interview by
@yvonne_tg
for
@rthk_enews
.
No, the idea that these guys were indispensable is what protected them for so long. Journalism will be just fine without them. Think of the talent that never broke in or left because of harassment.
Maybe a small part of you wondered, like I did, whether the disastrous attempt to conceal the outbreak of a novel coronavirus in Wuhan would make Beijing realize that transparency makes us all safer. Big nope. Today's news is another reminder that Beijing is doubling down.
News: WHO told me over the weekend that they have pressed China for data on healthcare worker coronavirus infections. China has not sent it. And yet WHO keeps praising Beijing.
“It’s genocide, full stop. It’s not immediate, shocking, mass-killing on the spot type genocide, but it’s slow, painful, creeping genocide,” said Joanne Smith Finley of “These are direct means of genetically reducing the Uighur population.”
A few people noted that HK's Carrie Lam mentioned
@WHO
and
@DrTedros
in her remarks about postponing the election. I was curious, so I checked with
@WHO
. Tedros/Lam have not discussed this issue, per WHO statement.
A thing to keep front and center on Wuhan: Many people work 6 days a week, 12 hours a day, or more,
so that once a year they can go home for Spring Festival. This is a public health disaster and also a big heartbreak for millions and millions of Chinese families who live apart.
A remarkable trove of documents detailing Xi’s plans for Xinjiang, obtained by
@ChuBailiang
and
@austinramzy
. I’ve followed this for years, but reading it all in print made my blood run cold.
Thanks to all the Internet Dads for the think pieces about how reporters ignored the lab theory. Have been reporting on this for more than a year. Conclusion since last summer has not changed: leak theory is possible, worth pursuing, but no conclusive evidence either way — so far
And finally: Twitter reviewed it again and locked his account (see below). Glad they acted eventually but can’t help but wonder if they would have taken a second look if I didn’t have a verified account.
I'm not easily shocked, but I am stunned, really, by the number of people who have written to express support for Duterte's call to shoot female rebels in their vaginas, arguing, earnestly, that it is needed to fight terrorism. Mutilating women is how you start wars, not end them
My head is spinning: Expulsions. Xinjiang sanctions. TikTok. WeChat. Extradition. Sanctions on Carrie Lam. The U.S.-China relationship has changed so quickly, and so profoundly, that it is hard to keep up.
After five years covering China—and more than a decade in Asia—I’m soon moving to D.C. I’m in debt to every person who took the time (and, often, the risk) to share their story. Here, if you'll indulge me, are five I’ll never forget:
Duterte's government was this week forced to clarify that, yes, the 1986 People Power revolution that paved the way for Philippine democracy happened, after one of his communication officials implied it was—wait for it—fake news.
What health officials could have said: Face masks work in many contexts, but we are short, so please stay home and/or make your own. By flip flopping, they are losing public trust—right when they need it most.
"...China has crushed the freedom of Hong Kong, intensified oppression in Xinjiang, killed Indian troops, threatened Taiwan and sanctioned Australia. By signing a deal with China nonetheless, the EU has signalled that it doesn’t care about all that."
Casually calling criticism of Chinese tech "xenophobia" erases Chinese netizens who risked jail time to speak out about the Great Firewall. Not to mention ongoing from Hong Kong, where PRC surveillance and censorship looms ever larger.
TikTok: We have nothing to do with the the Chinese government, how dare you.
Tech Twitter: They have nothing to do with the Chinese government, how dare you.
The Chinese government:
What’s striking to me is that there’s almost nothing in this “dossier” that wasn’t in the press by Feb 1. China’s initial coverup was covered pretty extensively in the first month of the crisis. It was U.S. interest in this information that changed dramatically.
“A research dossier compiled by the so-called "Five Eyes" intelligence alliance states that China intentionally hid or destroyed evidence of the coronavirus outbreak, resulting in the loss of tens of thousands of lives around the world”
“Some Tweets may seem to be abusive when viewed in isolation, but may not be when viewed in the context of a larger conversation. While we accept reports of violations from anyone, sometimes we also need to hear directly from the target to ensure that we have proper context.” 2/2
Good morning from Beijing, where Kim Jong Un may or may not be. Bloomberg sources say he’s here. South Korean media say it’s his sister. Others say it’s someone else. The motto for China reporting should be: “Does anyone know what’s going on?”
One side note from today's reporting: I asked WHO if there was anything else they would like to say about the Aylward Taiwan interview where he appeared to dodge several questions and they sent a statement alleging
@RTHK
re-shot the interview 1/
Thanks to all the gentlemen who have written to inform me that China covered up the outbreak of a novel coronavirus in Wuhan. Perhaps you will be interested in this Washington Post story dated Feb. 1.
NEWS: First of the ‘Snowden refugees’ has been granted asylum in Canada. Woman who helped the whistleblower in Hong Kong is now on her way to Toronto, her lawyer told us. She will be resettled in Montreal.
BREAKING: State Department issues health alert to U.S. citizens in China after government employee reported unusual symptoms. Embassy Beijing confirmed to
@washingtonpost
that diagnosis is mild traumatic brain injury. This will raise fears of Cuba-like attack. Story coming.
Canadian transport minister — a former astronaut, for real — does a great job of explaining what happened with the Angle of Attack Censor on the Lion Air flight.
We
@washingtonpost
covered China's Coronavirus response. Our reporting showed officials (1) tried to downplay (2) disparaged experts/press (3) minimized case counts—all spurring spread. NOT drawing a tidy parallel but am seeing a *similar* pattern here 1/n
I'm surprised by how many Americans seem to think things are going to pop back to normal. Friends in China were in lockdown for 7 weeks. Schools are still closed. People go outside a bit now, but wear masks. Months, not weeks. But it will pass.
I’ll never understand the barely restrained glee in tweets about U.S.-China conflict from American journalists. It’s almost like a big chunk of this country [checks notes] loves war.
China absolutely did downplay H-H transmission. But Chinese officials admitted Jan. 20 that the virus was spreading person to person. Why ask Tedros to hold back this info on Jan 21? We need to know more about what information was reportedly exchanged. 2/2
This is what macho populism looks like: Duterte brings a woman on stage. Asks if he can kiss her. She shakes her head “no.” He keeps pushing. Kisses her. And the crowd cheers.
English needs a better word than “strongman” to describe authoritarian populists. Because you know all these dudes are like, “wow, much strong, so man.”
#Geneva
journalists asking
@mbachelet
if she will indeed publish long awaited
#China
report before she leaves office. She says 'we are trying'. Which is a little different to the categoric yes we thought we had.
@UNHumanRights
what's going on?
Hard not to see President Duterte's misogynistic rhetoric as part of a global backlash against women and the LGBT community as macho-populism gains ground.
So many stand-out details in this piece, but I cannot get over the account of the sympathetic Han official who was purged and used as a warning to others. It means something that people tried to stop this. And that they were crushed.
A remarkable trove of documents detailing Xi’s plans for Xinjiang, obtained by
@ChuBailiang
and
@austinramzy
. I’ve followed this for years, but reading it all in print made my blood run cold.
Biden and Trudeau talked today. Canadian readout says they will meet next month. They discussed covid-19 cooperation, the border, defense, climate change, the detention of the two Canadians in China. Trudeau expressed displeasure on Keystone. 1/
So now Interpol is like oh yeah our missing-in-China chief “resigned” bye. Shouldn’t they be calling for a transparent investigation, for due process, protection of his rights?
Saying that Europe should not get dragged into a conflict between China and the US (a) is the CCP position and (b) obscures the fact that Taiwan’s future matters for itself because Taiwan is not a chip, but a real place
I have been covering the coronavirus outbreak since late January. One strange feature of this crisis is how many experts have told me something along the lines of "it is too soon to talk about what went wrong," or "this is not about politics." I find this troubling. Here is why:
Der Spiegel, citing German intelligence, says Xi and Tedros talked on Jan 21. They report that Xi asked Tedros to hold back info on human-to-human transmission and delay pandemic warning. WHO says it didn't happen. Two things about the Der Spiegel timeline strike me... 1/3
Statement on False Allegations in
@derspiegel
: Reports of a 21 Jan phone call between
@DrTedros
& 🇨🇳 President Xi are unfounded & untrue. They didn’t speak on 21 Jan & have never spoken by 📞
Such inaccurate reports distract & detract from WHO's & the 🌍’s efforts to end
#COVID19
There needs to be some rhetorical space between "Hong Kong is dead" and "Hong Kong will be fine." The national security law is an unprecedented threat. But anyone who has been watching knows that Hong Kong people are going to keep fighting—just as they have for years.
A weird thing about the Taiwan coronavirus coverage is this implicit suggestion that because it handled the coronavirus well, it has now somehow proved itself. There is no shortage of evidence that Taiwan is a thriving democracy, people.
Need some legal scholars to weigh in, but Article 38 seems to suggest that non-permanent residents of HK (aka anyone) could be charged for violating national security law while abroad (aka anywhere in the world). Can critics of China still visit HK, or transit through HKIA?
If you're gonna listen to any speech about
#Ukraine
🇺🇦, let it be this one.
The Kenya ambassador to the UNSC perfectly explains how people across Africa understand Ukraine, and what the Kremlin's acts of aggression mean in our post-colonial world.
When in reality, across much of the world, said policies are turning many people with no real, previous opinions on China into critics. And people are not in awe of the awkward, overheated Twitter posts — many are laughing at them. 3/
It starts; so soon. For the first time in 30 years, Hong Kong authorities denied permission to hold the
#TiananmenVigil
. If there is any doubt about Beijing’s intent, it is to deny Hong Kongers a voice and a choice, making them the same as mainlanders. So much for two systems.
When considering the CDCs latest on masks, it is worth remembering that they waited months to recommend masks in the first place, essentially ignoring the experience of *all of East Asia,* a decision that many public health experts see as significant, dangerous misstep.
Today I asked the Executive Yuan to draw up a humanitarian assistance action plan for
#HongKong
citizens that lays out clear, complete plans for their residence, placement, employment, & life in
#Taiwan
as soon as possible.
Trump now says he will let Microsoft buy TikTok, but only if Treasury gets a cut. So the strategy is oppose state capitalism by engaging in state capitalism, I guess?
Brussels mood: I’m at an accreditation office getting a new badge. Pull something out of my backpack and the guy asks with a wink if it’s a bag of cash from the Parliament.
This story about China's offer to help Malaysia cover up the 1MBD fraud in return for "Belt and Road" projects is incredibly revealing. But one example: Officials offered to bug the Hong Kong homes of
@WSJ
reporters investigating the fraud.
This is just huge. China has said for years that the U.S. must provide specific evidence on Huawei. Now we have specific, detailed allegations. I’ll be shocked if this is not a turning point for the company’s global ambitions.
After 173 days with no childcare, my baby went back to daycare today. So many feelings — relief, nerves — but also anger, so much anger, that there is still so much danger when simple public health measures might have kept people safe.
Really, really have to wonder if America would have been wearing masks earlier if people actually recognized the hard-earned expertise of folks in Hong Kong, Taiwan, South Korea, China, etc.