If strangling a woman using "sustained pressure" until she is unconscious and then dead, so that your 'hands are hurting' afterwards, does not demonstrate intent to cause serious harm... then what can?
Outrageous - 4 years 8 months:
@graemeecho
This is important and devastating BBC research:
"more than a third of UK women under the age of 40 have experienced unwanted slapping, choking, gagging or spitting during consensual sex"
We regret to inform you that
@Cosmopolitan
is promoting choking/strangulation ('breath play') as a great newbie way to spice up your love life, again.
(They link to a piece that says it can can cause stroke, brain damage, serious damage to neck, spine.)
So worth a watch: Harriet Harman MP today in
#DomesticAbuseBill
debate, on the horror of 'rough sex' defences and "men now literally getting away with murder".
"We've got another version of 'she drove me to kill her, it was her fault'"
Elizabeth McCann was 26. She was killed by a man from her college course.
He claimed she'd consented to all of it: but has been sentenced to 35 years for rape and murder.
He'd been released from a sentence for public protection for a brutal rape in 2010.
Outrageous.
And again: prosecutors accept a killer's story that violence was 'rough sex', he didn't mean to harm her, but she wanted it.
#HerNameWasSophieMoss
WTH? Teen Vogue claims:
"porn that portrays nonconsensual sex, for instance, isnโt necessarily misogynist"
that's rape porn - porn featuring *rape*
There's a phrase: "so open minded your brain's fallen out". But this is beyond even that.
Rape culture is teaching teen girls that "nonconsensual sex" (most of us call that rape) can "center pleasure and agency" and that the "seemingly racist or sexist" is just "self-aware and feminist"! Don't trust your eyes, there's no such thing as violence against women ๐ค
This is amazing. We can call this a victory. All of you who supported and cheered us along on this can feel rightly proud of this.
The Government propose clear law to end the use of rough sex defences.
Govt publish new clause for Domestic Abuse Bill to end rough sex defence. Milestone moment in battle to challenge male violence against women. This will stop men literally getting away with murder by saying it's what she wanted.
@Mark4WyreForest
@Wecantconsentto
A 'kerfuffle'
Have we learned nothing this last few years, than to give the men who kill women the last say in the headlines on how they died.
Claire Parry, mum, nurse. ๐
oh lord not again
choking ๐คฌ can ๐คฌ cause ๐คฌ brain ๐คฌ damage ๐คฌ in ๐คฌ four ๐คฌseconds ๐คฌ and ๐คฌ is๐คฌ major ๐คฌ cause ๐คฌ of ๐คฌ miscarriage ๐คฌ and ๐คฌ stroke ๐คฌ in ๐คฌ women ๐คฌ under ๐คฌ 40
there ๐คฌ is ๐คฌ no ๐คฌ 'safe' ๐คฌ strangulation ๐คฌ of ๐คฌ women ๐คฌ
Grace Millane, 22
Auckland, NZ
Grace, from Essex, had just graduated & was travelling the world.
She was killed on her birthday by a Tinder date. In his trial, he is claiming she asked him to strangle her.
She is the 59th UK woman killed by a man who claims sex, "gone wrong"
Sandra Moore's death was ruled an act of 'autoeroticism' by a coroner in Stoke.
If that were true, she would be the first woman in UK history to die in this way: it's a male act done by men to themselves & others. Astonishing a coroner could think this
"On the relatively rare occasion that a woman kills a violent man she is asked, โIf the violence was so bad, why didnโt you leave?โ
Men who claim they killed their wives because she โnaggedโ or was unfaithful are never asked why they stayed in the relationship."
GUILTY of murder of
#GraceMillane
The man - who still cannot be named - will be sentenced in February.
Heart goes to Grace's family and friends today, and hope this is some relief. x
In the week we made strangulation a specific offence, one of our followers asked us to report a video on here: porn where a woman is strangled til she foams at the mouth.
It autoplayed in her feed, it's from an @ with 30k followers.
@TwitterSupport
have not taken it down.
On "rough sex" defences:
"We are used to seeing womenโs sex lives analysed in rape cases โ to find ways of blaming them for being raped."
"Now we are seeing womenโs sex lives analysed in murder cases, to find ways of blaming them for being murdered"
The man who murdered Grace Millane has failed in his attempt to appeal his conviction and sentence. A relief.
Thanks to a court order, he still cannot be named, enjoying privacy not given to Grace.
INCREDIBLE NEWS -
@RobertBuckland
to add new offence of non fatal strangulation to law
@centreWJ
@Dontlookback198
Domestic abusers who leave no marks on victims face 7 years inside under new law
hi it's us again. choking:
๐is gendered (almost all 'choking' is by men, of women
๐causes brain damage in 4 seconds
๐in 50% of domestic abuse, 20% of sexual assault by partners
๐means a man is 7 times more likely to kill his partner
*why* do we accept this as a sex thing?
A Metropolitan Police officer has been jailed for punching and throttling a junior colleague and then telling her to lie about their abusive relationship.
He 'told her to say the bruises and marks were the result of rough sex'
Fantastic that this will make it into law, as early as next month.
Strangulation is too rarely prosecuted - but causes unique and terrible harm, and brings great risk that the perpetrator will later kill the woman.
Anna Florence Reed was 22 and on holiday with her boyfriend.
He now faces a "lesser charge than murder".
She will be the 50th British woman we know killed where men claim they died in a "sex game gone wrong".
#wecantconsenttothis
In the UK parliament tonight, MPs just voted to add to the
#DABill
to end the use of 'rough sex' defences to killing and serious injury of women.
Big moment, only a beginning. Huge thanks to
@HarrietHarman
@Mark4WyreForest
@Laura__Farris
& all MPs who pushed so hard for this
Speaker asks MPs whether they should adopt NC20 to
#DABill
on rough sex defences.
NOT A SINGLE NOE
WE DID IT!!!
[for this stage, still needs to get through the Lords, still have a number of outstanding demands on strangulation and making this law work]
Man "obsessed with watching online pornography" strangles his wife to unconsciousness and is sent on a Building Better Relationships course with a suspended sentence.
Serious question about how we deal with these dangerous men.
Wife fainted as 'dangerous' husband squeezed her neck, Hull court hears
Another violent perpetrator walking free from court. What is wrong with our judiciary?!
Remember his face ladies and stay well clear!
@InstituteFAS
Here we go again
@MensHealthMag
Why should you stop promoting strangulation?
It causes serious harm, including "cardiac arrest, stroke, miscarriage, incontinence, speech disorders, seizures, paralysis, and other forms of long-term brain injury."
"People say, โItโs only a few women a week that dieโ"
โBut itโs been a few women a week ever since I was born, and Iโm 34. Itโs a huge systemic problem. The
@FemicideCensus
says these women matter. โ
More than 60 women have been killed by men who claim she consented to the violence, and many more injured.
TODAY MPs will debate concrete proposals which could start to end the 'rough sex' defence, supported by MPs from 6 parties.
Read this thread: If you hear us talking about the social pressures on young women to submit to violence in sex - choking/strangulation, spitting, slapping, gagging, and more - and think we're overstating it.
honestly it's all here in this thread:
Rape porn (which Teen Vogue think can be self aware *and* feminist!) is a criminal offence to possess here in the UK.
Not because lawmakers are vanilla prudes: because men who watched rape porn were raping & killing women.
2/3
This is an ASTONISHING decision by the CPS - a woman's violent assault is not being prosecuted because the man accused is likely to say she consented to the violence
"Prosecutors declined to pursue charges against a man accused of assault because of fears he would claim it was consensual sexual behaviour โa decision that will intensify pressure to outlaw the โrough sex gone wrongโ defence"
@HarrietHarman
@RosamundUrwin
Worth saying that the recent government amendment to end rough sex defences will apply only in England and Wales, not in Scotland and not in Northern Ireland; where this week a young woman has been killed by a man who claimed she 'consented' to asphyxiation.
"it shouldnโt take a bunch of social media misfits bashing a mainstream womenโs magazine for an editor to remove the suggestion that depriving your brain of oxygen during sex is playful, fun, or even remotely a good idea."
[are *we* the misfits here]
So relieved to say that the jury have found this unnamed man guilty of murder this morning.
It is unacceptable that women are being blamed for their deaths-their sexual history used against them.
We will campaign until this is no longer a useful defence to the men who kill them
How many of us can't concentrate rn, awaiting the jury's verdict on the murder of
#GraceMillane
? Heartbroken + angry the 'rough sex gone wrong' argument is considered any sort of reasonable defence EVER. Pls check out the work of
@Wecantconsentto
We don't believe that women can consent to their own murder or grevious injury. We're highlighting the UK men who rely on a 'rough sex'/BDSM 'gone wrong' defence in the death or injury of a woman:
Important piece in the Sunday Times:
"Teenagers are being exposed to graphic images on social media that promote life-threatening sexual acts, such as strangulation and erotic asphyxiation."
1.
Consider why an act which is
๐ gendered (almost all 'choking' is by men, of women)
๐ intrinsically harmful,
๐ part of 50% of domestic abuse, 20% of sexual assaults by partners
๐ means a man is 7 times more likely to kill his partner
is being sold to women as a sex thing?
Looking back at a powerful speech by
@FloellaBenjamin
in the House of Lords on
#InternationalWomensDay
to
#endroughexdefence
. She spoke of our research: 60 UK women killed by men who used this defence. In some cases, the deaths werenโt even investigated as a crime.
Resharing this from the end 2019. The stat in here, that:
38% of UK women aged 18 to 39 have experienced unwanted choking, slapping, spitting or gagging in consensual sex
That's 3.6 million women
Excellent
"police will be required by government to treat it as a major priority."
Violent crime against women gets the same status as terrorist attacks
The man who murdered Grace Millane has also been convicted of astonishingly serious violence against 2 women, who he also met on tinder.
He has lost his name protection.
"do not think about him or speak his name" - thoughts with families & the women.
Tweeting this again: Natalie Connolly deserves to be remembered.
The man who killed her does not - but he will be released from prison within days. Utterly cruel.
Oh wow,
@jessphillips
on Natalie Connolly;
"I simply want to remember Natalie: a brilliant, beautiful, bright, mother, sister, daughter. A woman who had a story all of her own, about the things she loved, & cared for, I hope that now the story of Natalie Connolly can be that."
Why are we pushing back when 'choking' of women is normalised? (And it is choking of women, by men, we're almost always talking about)
Here's a great, lockdown listen with
@Lalalaletmeexp2
We often hear this from women: that they're called boring, vanilla, kinkshaming prudish sex-negative (etc etc) for not wanting to be strangled in sex by men.
There's a tiktok on here of a young woman who's proudly showing her severe bruising after a night with her "guy friend". It's REALLY distressing.
The tiktok has millions and millions of likes.
it's so distressing will link in next tweet.
Just published! Government factsheet on the proposed law to end rough sex defences.
All of *you* who helped us do this should feel a little proud.
@GraziaUK
@MumsnetTowers
Forty years ago, women said "curfew the men"
"we are sick & tired of being told not to walk alone"
Today's news on Sarah Everard is devastating: a police officer arrested for murder.
And so many women on here sharing stories of violence & fear, for daring to walk the streets.
The
@attorneygeneral
appeal failed - Sam Pybus's sentence will not be increased. Our attempt with
@centrewj
to intervene was rejected.
More to come but this could not be clearer case to show that the law (what it says and how it works) must change. Sophie Moss deserves better.
Hearing due to start soon.
@centreWJ
&
@Wecantconsentto
have applied to intervene: to ensure the court has information on the latest understanding of strangulation harms & domestic abuse.
Court of Appeal to review sentence of man who choked lover to death
The law has just changed to make it clear that you cannot use a 'rough sex' defence.
But still men will try - and will succeed if the CPS go along with the claim that being strangled to death is a sex act, rather than serious and sustained violence.
This is appallingly dangerous advice in the
@Independent
@indy100
: "choking during sex can and should be done safely"
As reported by your own paper, strangulation is terrifyingly harmful, with brain injury in as little as 4 seconds.
(We are complaining)
"I couldnโt understand how such a violent attack could be brushed aside. The failure to recognise the strangulation, the hitting, the near murder felt like a terrible letdown"
Why didn't this brave woman get justice?
'He almost killed me then walked free'
While we're all on the subject of 'choking'. Strangulation' of women in sex has been normalised through porn, and mainstream and social media made for women.
Here's
@NetflixUK
Sex/Life show Ep 1.
"Honey. You need to be choked"
Edgy and empowering!
"For teenage boys at my school, it is a โflexโ to have abused, harassed or even been violent towards a girl sexually.
Boys donโt believe their bad behaviour is sexual abuse, even if they say they do understand why itโs wrong."
Georgina, 17
"Its site is infested with rape videos. It monetizes child rapes, revenge pornography, spy cam videos of women showering, racist and misogynist content, and footage of women being asphyxiated in plastic bags."
On pornhub:
It'd meet the UK criminal threshold for extreme porn: i.e. porn featuring a life threatening act. Appallingly grim. Assume
@TwitterSupport
would want to act on this
"Claims of rough sex gone wrong are a global concern."
"We've got a list of around 250 women who have been killed in various countries around the world by men who claim at some point that they consented to it.""
"Prosecutors declined to pursue charges against a man accused of assault because of fears he would claim it was consensual sexual behaviour โa decision that will intensify pressure to outlaw the โrough sex gone wrongโ defence"
@HarrietHarman
@RosamundUrwin
(Marital rape was so often a feature of the romance novels of yore, that
@goodreads
somehow now hosts a whole "genre" for 'Popular Marital Rape Books':
Hello to new followers. We Can't Consent To This was a response to the short sentence of 3years 8 months given in Dec 2018 to the man who killed Natalie Connolly. He claimed that many of her injuries were due to consensual rough sex.
We hear from young women who learn as teens that being choked - viewed in Domestic Violence policing as being the no 1 risk factor for future homicide by a partner - is something they should expect as an expression of passion
And it's not just Cosmo
Point worth remaking:
There's no good time to suggest asphyxiation as a great new sex move, but a global respiratory pandemic when we're seeing large volumes of reports of domestic abuse is a *particularly* bad time.
Sort it out
@CosmopolitanUK
We regret to inform you that
@Cosmopolitan
is promoting choking/strangulation ('breath play') as a great newbie way to spice up your love life, again.
(They link to a piece that says it can can cause stroke, brain damage, serious damage to neck, spine.)
Well done this man: "Strangling someone for 5 to 10 minutes until they die is not rough sex."
Millane murder detective: Rough sex should not be a defence
The partner of Natalie Connolly, who left her to die with injuries he claimed were due to "rough sex", is appealing his sentence of 3yrs 8 months. The appeal begins tomorrow.
Incredible from
@Laura__Farris
"In all of these cases, what is just really extreme violence against women is given a veneer of complicity through the sexual element.
The victim has no voice"
A conviction of manslaughter is no justice for Claire Parry and her family. We are appalled by the perpetratorโs description of her murder as a 'kerfuffle', and the judge saying it was a โloss of self-controlโ. It is a myth that people have no control over their physical actions.
Patrycja Wyrebek, 20
2020, Newry, N. Ireland
Patrycja was originally from Poland. Her friends will hold a memorial walk for her in Belfast tomorrow.
She was killed on Sunday by her partner. He has told police he killed her in 'erotic asphyxiation'.
Now Anna Florence Reed is the 50th British woman to die with the claimed defence she died in a "sex game gone wrong"
These cases will continue until this defence is no longer useful to the men who kill women
Anna Florence Reed was 22 and on holiday with her boyfriend.
He now faces a "lesser charge than murder".
She will be the 50th British woman we know killed where men claim they died in a "sex game gone wrong".
#wecantconsenttothis
Now we have the guilty of murder verdict, it's worth reflecting on this.
Two thirds of women in "rough sex" defence claims have been strangled.
And the men claim the women demanded it of them.
#GraceMillane
In his closing speech, the defence barrister told the jury the defendant was โjust a young man prepared to do what his sexual partners want him to do in the bedroom,".
Partners.
@skytv
@HBO
Astonishingly, tights shop Snag is selling "Choke Me" badges to its mostly female customer base.
(Not sure young women get a free "choice" given the range of corporate pressure to celebrate and embrace their strangulation)
"letโs be clear: the so-called โrough sexโ defence is not gender neutral. The sex is โroughโ for women, not men. It is overwhelmingly women who are on the receiving end of this violence and whose health and very lives are on the line."
"We now hope that the rest of the world takes notice, and follows our lead, especially New Zealand. Changes need to be made to protect women"
Grace Millane's family calls for NZ to end rough sex defence as UK law passes, via
@nzherald
The man who murdered Grace Millane will appeal his conviction and his sentence this Thursday. He was given one of New Zealand's longest prison sentences when sentenced in February.
Thoughts with Grace's family and friends ๐
"Iโm calling time on vanilla shaming. I might have needed to learn to adapt to survive when I was 15 so no boys in school thought I was boring, but we cannot allow this to continue to be the case for young women now."
๐๏ธโโ๏ธ๐๏ธโโ๏ธ๐๏ธโโ๏ธ
TOMORROW the domestic abuse bill amendments face the committee stage in Parliament. It is vital that we have MPโs support in order for the bill so we can change the law. We really need your support by tweeting your MPโs. Below is a draft that you can tweet!
"Strangulation during sex can increase the risk ofย strokeย and brain injuries even if the person does not lose consciousness, warn scientists as MPs debate the troubling practice."
โVanilla is the new frigid,โ says 19yo Lily.
โI wrote something like โnot wanting to be choked doesnโt mean youโre boringโ & I ended up being called out for itโ
โPeople kept saying that I didnโt know how to have a good time.โ
Please read this extraordinary, powerful piece
"When a direct threat to life is slowly normalised, โit means that a woman whose partner chokes her might not report it โ and if she does, it might go nowhere"
โI wanted to be attractive to him. So I just thought: โOK, this is what gets him off, Iโll let him.โโ
This piece is a year old today - it gave a huge push to awareness of this issue and our campaign.
๐
"The family of murdered British backpacker Grace Millane have described plans to outlaw the "rough sex gone wrong" defence as "fantastic news""
BBC News - Grace Millane's family welcome 'rough sex' defence ban
As soon as We Can't Consent to This started, we heard from women who had been choked -strangled- slapped, punched, by men they were dating. Read some of their stories at:
We'll be on
@Emmabarnett
R5 Show from 10am and
@VictoriaLIVE
to discuss all this
We're concerned that rough sex - which notably has never resulted in the death of a heterosexual man in the UK - may be the reselling of domestic violence back to women as 'kink'.
Celebrating
#BDSM
culture where women are choked and beaten till they are black and blue is just the modern reiteration of "if he loves you, he beats you". Same lie, same regressive shit, same harm, same male violation imperative - shiny new packaging.
Earlier today, Harriet Harman wrote to the Attorney General to ask the 4 year 8 month sentence given to Sam Pybus for killing Sophie Moss should be reviewed as 'Unduly Lenient'
The AG has responded:
Thomas lost his sister Charlotte when she was murdered by a man who claimed she consented. Thomas calls for an end to "rough sex" claims:
โThe law needs to change to protect other women who clearly donโt consent to being injured or being killed.โ
We rarely want to talk about Broadhurst, it's Natalie Connolly who is foremost in our thoughts.
But it is important to recognise what this man did.
After leaving Natalie to die with 40 "profoundly brutal, profoundly intimate and very extensive" injuries,
Never let him forget who he is. He is the man who beat a woman to death and stepped over her as she died. Never let his millions comfort him. Never let his millions buy another woman to abuse.
#HerNameWasNatalieConolly
thanks to
@Wecantconsentto
for leading to change in the law.