Congratulations to Emma Weyant, the true NCAA champion, and to all the other female swimmers who competed.
Like many others, I look forward to the day when the record books are set straight.
Re
@tomhfh
comment yesterday that some males who identify as women "should absolutely be in women's prisons" because they "would be torn limb from limb in men's prisons"
Leaving aside the ill-informed hyperbole, women's prisons are not there to protect males from other males
“As a lawyer for 20 years and justice secretary for almost eight, I’ve seen some legal absurdities. But this tops it all... It’s... about dogma overriding common sense. Women prisoners are being harmed by this and vital crime statistics rendered useless”
Does it matter that the awful murder of Jorge Martin Carreno by a male offender - Scarlet Blake - is set to be recorded as a female crime?
A short thread
The BBC referred to “the fact that Blake is a transgender woman… across our output”, apart from “the report on News at One on 26 February”, according to this
@BBCNews
response to complaints
Reader. It didn’t
A thread
I've written this piece for
@Telegraph
on why it matters that some male crimes are being recorded in the official statistics as female crimes
Below a summary thread
"If it would be assault for a man to view a woman undressing, or to touch her body without her consent, then it remains assault even if that man... is wearing women’s clothing, and even if he has a government-issued gender-recognition certificate"
Class just one male convicted of murder as female, then total annual female murder convictions go up by around five per cent
Class five males convicted of murder as female, then total annual female murder convictions go up by around 25 per cent
It's been a joy today watching so many grounded, thoughtful and smart women completely own a patronising male journalist trying to mansplain gender to them.
The Court accepts that the housing of male prisoners in women's prisons may cause female prisoners to "suffer fear and acute anxiety". It's not transphobic. It is a perfectly reasonable and grounded concern.
The Court also agrees that male prisoners who identify as women have a higher rate of sexual offending than female prisoners. In other words, their sexual offending patterns are more in line with males, not females.
It's ill-advised for a group of charities to try to force
@ChtyCommission
to revoke the charitable status of another charity. It smacks of an anti-democratic grift.
They should focus on their own charitable objects, rather than trying to police those of others.
I wish J K Rowling a long and happy life.
As for those spewing violence and misogyny under a certain hashtag, grow up and reflect on what it means to live in an open, tolerant society where a diversity of life experiences and views are respected and valued.
Trans-identifying males - or trans women if you like - redefine what it means to be a man, not what it means to be a woman.
Instead of displacing the problems of masculinity into women's spaces, we need inclusive male spaces where trans-identifying males feel safe and respected.
On International Day for the Elimination of Violence against Women, a letter telling us to remember the real victims of male violence: other males.
Embarrassing and spectacularly ill-judged.
The Court ruled on "the lawfulness, not the desirability, of the policies". The current undermining of female prisoners' right in favour of a small sub-section of male prisoners is, currently, 'lawful'.
Addressing this mess is a political challenge, as much as it is a legal one.
I hear that
@EHRC
has been meeting with a range of stakeholders, representing different positions on complex and contentious areas of equalities legislation, policy and practice.
Shocking news.
What is the point of a Trade Union that is complicit in the bullying, harassment, intimidation and targeting of members of the profession it claims to represent?
#IStandWithKathleenStock
@TheAA_UK
@_HelenMott_
As a male AA member I would expect you to prioritise a lone female driver over me, and am shocked that you don't. Have only just recently renewed but will reconsider membership when it comes up next year if this remains your policy.
Please rethink this sexist policy.
The court accepts that the decision to house male prisoners who identify as women in women's prisons means reducing the rights of female prisoners.
Rights are a pie, the Court agrees, and female prisoners are being expected to give up some of their share to accommodate males.
So this is something of a pyrrhic victory for the Prison Service. It has been put on notice that its current approach undermines the rights of female prisoners (while doing so 'lawfully') and that it could be vulnerable to future legal challenge.
Proud to have given a witness statement as part of the judicial review challenge to current Prison Service policies on trans prisoners.
Hearing my statement being cited in court yesterday was a weird experience. 1/3
Classing male defendants convicted of murder as female is terrible for the integrity of social statistics
It is also terrible for public understanding of murder and who commits murder
This deceit by public bodies and news organisations needs to be sorted out, and quickly
The Court recognises that accommodating males who identify as women in women's prisons does risk discriminating against female prisoners, and regardless of whether a male prisoner assaults a female prisoner. Their very presence could be enough.
"Keeping male and female prisoners in separate accommodation is one of the minimum expectations for the treatment of prisoners"
Why do so many politicians struggle with this basic safeguarding principle?
Good to see
@SexMattersOrg
website is now live
"The Guardian, in common with other major news organisations, refers to individuals by the gender they use for themselves"
In other words,
@guardian
knowingly confuses and deceives its own readers, in common with other major news organisations
Your report uses female pronouns and female descriptors to refer to Scarlet Blake, despite the fact that he is male and committed an act of male violence against another male.
“I was going to be talking about feminism and art, and the difficulties that exist for women trying to break through... I’m not transphobic. I have been openly gay for 35 years. I think this movement is misogynistic — they are only targeting other women.”
Joan McAlpine, an SNP MSP, said: "Aside from the statistical corruption, I cannot be the only woman who finds it deeply offensive that male sexual violence can ever be badged as a female crime."
This is why it matters when male defendants convicted of murder are classed as female
Because so few female defendants are convicted of murder, any male murder conviction classed as female dramatically distorts the female murder convictions data
Whenever I read a story on the BBC News website these days, referring to a woman committing a crime, particularly a serious crime of violence, I always end up asking myself if this is in fact a male perpetrator being described by the BBC as a woman.
In my professional role I have studied violence for many years. Serious acts of violence are almost always perpetrated by males; very few women and girls perpetrate this kind of violence. The story therefore gives a highly misleading impression.
The Court also notes that the Prison Service data collection on trans prisoners "lacked clarity, and left many questions unanswered", including in relation to the collection of sexual offences data.
A man at a high profile event calling for women to be punched in the face, while being cheered on by the crowd, should expect to be arrested
It's long past the time for activist groups to get their houses in order, and confront and address the rampant misogyny in their ranks
Well that was one hell of an event. Hundreds of people meeting to discuss women's imprisonment. Must have been the largest event on this topic since, well, ever, I think
#WPUKPrisons
And a shout-out to
@fairplaywomen
who have worked tirelessly on the challenge from the start, and
@NoXYinXXprisons
who tweeted out the court proceedings over the past two days. 3/3
The current Prison Service approach has turned women's prisons, but not men's prisons (of course), into mixed-sex institutions.
Over the past two days the court has heard about the incoherence and unfairness of the current approach. 2/3
Women's prisons have become mixed-sex institutions by stealth.
This amendment, being debated in the House of Lords today, reaffirms a long-standing principle that should not be controversial: women should not be imprisoned alongside men.
I support it.
#KeepPrisonsSingleSex
I always thought that this would be a difficult case to win. I'm disappointed that the Court decided against issuing a more robust defence of the rights of female prisoners in relation to male prisoners who identify as women. There is, though, a lot to welcome in this judgment.
It really shouldn't be necessary for the police to have to waste their time on this kind of thing, but well done
@metpoliceuk
These kinds of anti-democratic threats and intimidation only ever come from trans-activists
Never from feminists and their allies
If you are not prepared unequivocally to condemn the physical attack last night on Julie Bindel by a well-known trans activist I'm not interested in anything else you have to say. Feel free to block me to save us both from grief in the future.
Violence, and crime more generally, is a highly gendered act, largely perpetrated by males. It is possible both to be accepting of the way individuals chose to identify and express themselves, and also ensure that news reporting is accurate.
I have heard that at least two female child prisoners are currently being held at the male young offender institution at Wetherby.
It follows the removal of child prisoners from Rainsbrook secure training centre because of safety and welfare concerns.
This is unacceptable.
My goodness. Today's inspection report on Eastwood Park women's prison
Awful for those women held there, the vast majority of whom are in acute mental distress
Awful for the staff, many of whom appear to be doing their best in appalling conditions
I went to an informative briefing yesterday on the Equality Act. An important implication: it is within the law to stop housing trans-identifying males in womens prisons.
In other words, the current prison service policy is a political choice, not a legal requirement.
I am very concerned that transgender people continue to face routine discrimination and violence. I am also concerned that
@BBCNews
and
@BenInLDN
insinuate that it is transphobic to defend women's and girls' boundaries and existing legal protections.
If the Cass review has made you curious about the impact of gender ideology on public institutions, the Adult Human Female film offers a great overview of the issues at stake
Here’s
@janeclarejones
, explaining the material consequences of gender ideology
Currently, protected characteristics in relation to hate crime are disability, race, religion, sexual orientation and transgender identity.
Difficult to think of a logical reason for the exclusion of misogyny, apart from misogyny itself.
New report out from the prisons inspectorate on imprisoned girls.
There are only *14* girls in prison in England and Wales. This should make it easy to cater for their distinctive, often profound needs, right?
But no.
Those in the greatest need get the least support. 1/6
I have provided written evidence in support of this challenge and hope it succeeds.
The current Prison Service policy did not properly consider the potentially adverse impacts on female prisoners.
A full review and inclusive consultation is needed.
Ps, I always aim to ground what I argue in the data
For this thread I used the 'Criminal Justice Statistics Quarterly' dataset
The 'Outcomes by Offence data tool: June 2023' sheet is the easiest place to start, if you want to do your own data crunching
I'm concerned that some NSPCC staff do not appear to understand basic safeguarding principles around adult strangers encouraging children to contact them online, or the harm caused by the pornification of female bodies, or those that present as female
👇👇👇👇
"Staff were at pains to highlight with us that the issue is not always one of whether a trans person is themselves a danger, but that for many women simply having to share intimate spaces where they are vulnerable with someone who is male… is in itself re-traumatising"
So that was a bit of a mad week. All but one of the Labour leadership candidates signed up to a Stalinist witch hunt. One of them slandered a highly respected socialist feminist on national radio. And a judge likened a British police force to the Gestapo. Phew!
Shocking misogyny at
@EdinburghUni
"The organisers were told that there was going to be too hostile an environment to hold the event and... they couldn't guarantee the safety of speakers or attendees - most of whom would likely be women."
"In... the cruellest trolling by the Guardian yet, Eddie’s quote is placed above photos of 16 women who were murdered because they were women; not because they identified as women, not because they dressed as women, but because they were born women."
I stand in solidarity with my friend
@Docstockk
against the disgraceful targeting and harassment she is facing at
@unisussex
Anyone who knows Kathleen, or has read her excellent book, Material Girls, knows her to be a thoroughly decent, compassionate and thoughtful person
I don't know how
@BBCNews
can square its charter commitment to "provide duly accurate and impartial news" with such misleading reporting
This is particularly the case given that it was so unlikely that Blake's crime would have been perpetrated by a female
So I've been called transphobic by several people this week, including by some who should know better. It's not nice, but it is nothing compared to what many gender critical women face day-in, day-out, year-on-year. I admire you all. /1
I'm a world expert on being talked over, lied about and defined by misogynists, on being instructed to centre everyone but my own demographic in my activism and on being denied credit for my own achievements by envious men. In other words, I'm a woman.
So at a rough count, that's at least eight BBC stories that gave a false impression about the sex of a suspect accused of murder
When the BBC's local, national and international radio and TV output is taken into account, there must surely have been many other misleading reports
Great letter in today's Guardian. I too am astonished that slanders and smears have been endorsed by Labour leadership and deputy leadership candidates Lisa Nandy, Rebecca Long-Bailey, Emily Thornberry, Angela Rayner, Dawn Butler and Rosena Allin-Khan.
Now look at female murder convictions
Only 187 across the entire period: a low of 12 in 2015, a high of 23 in 2017, six per cent of all murder convictions
In reality it will be fewer than this, as there are likely some males hiding in the female data
Good. Face down the bullies.
“Authors Aloud said: ’Rachel Rooney works with us in her capacity as a poet. We’ve had nothing but praise and compliments for the sessions she runs in schools so we’ve got absolutely no plans to stop working with her’.”
“I cannot see that Maya has done anything wrong other than express an opinion that many feminists share – that there should be a public and open debate about the distinction between sex and gender.”
Like many others, I've had to use mixed-sex changing rooms and toilets. A grim and uncomfortable experience every time.
Single-sex spaces are good for the privacy and dignity of both females and males.
“Six of the NHS’s seven specialist gender services in England for adults had ‘thwarted’ an attempt... to obtain and analyse the health outcomes of people who had been treated... This refusal to cooperate ‘was coordinated’, she told the Guardian”
Effacing the birth sex, in official statistics, of alleged perpetrators of sexual violence, undermines our ability to measure, understand, address, reduce and prevent it.
"We contend that if it is lawful for a prisoner of the male sex convicted of rape to be housed alongside women, many of whom have been the victims of rape and serious sexual assault, then the law must change"
@MsHelenWatts
No. It's nonsense. I am not aware of any females, "abusive" or otherwise, currently being housed in male prisons in England and Wales, and it's highly unlikely they would be.
"One of the biggest social shifts in a generation is taking place with almost no political discussion... This is an act of national cowardice by our would–be leaders, dressed up as high-minded moral superiority."
As the UK's national broadcaster, with a public service remit,
@BBCNews
has a particular responsibility to ensure its reporting is accurate
This includes conveying relevant information to the many millions who go to it as a trusted source of information
There are anti-abortion and pro-abortion charities
Those that promote religion, others that promote secularism
Animal rights charities and those that support hunting
The world of charities is about plurality
Attempts to enforce a narrow group-think are, frankly, uncharitable
Being pro-female does not make you a transphobe. Being anti-male violence does not make you a transphobe.
Being these things makes you a human being.
Have a good weekend all. /4
This is not just about the targeting of an individual, deeply unpleasant though it is. It also goes to the heart of what universities are about.
As Kathleen points out, "What kind of future does a University have where intimidation determines what is said or taught?"
Sad that some of the most socially privileged young political activists in the country can come up with such a confused, intolerant, anti-democratic and intellectually-barren statement.
"News reporters should only report facts, and newspapers should only publish facts in their news sections. To do this, editors and news management need to be able to recognise what a fact is, and how to distinguish facts from beliefs. If they can't, this is not the job for them"
How many readers, viewers and listeners were mislead by
@BBCNews
(and yes, many other news organisations) *for months* about the quintessentially male nature of Blake's murder of Jorge Martin Carreno?
"How is a presenter or reporter to explain why there is a controversy at all about trans-identified men in, say, women’s sports or prisons, if they are unable to say that they are male?"
I wrote about my disciplinary (one of them) and truth at the BBC. It makes me so frustrated that we have to reveal private details about our lives for a cause that is natural and just and in the public interest.
/
14 August 2023: “A woman has appeared in court charged with murdering a man who was found dead in a river two years ago”
No reference to Blake identifying as transgender
"One victim of violence... has been reprimanded... for using male pronouns... The judge refused the victim compensation, saying that when asked to refer to the defendant as ‘she’, the victim had done so with ‘bad grace’ or continued to use ‘he’."
"The left in Britain and Ireland have badly misjudged this issue. Trans rights are human rights, but women understand the difference between identity, how people present socially and biology."
The decisions, tactics and conduct of the Metropolitan Police in Clapham this evening require an urgent, independent review.
Two decades after the Met was found to be institutionally racist, it's difficult to avoid the conclusion that it is also institutionally misogynist.
Female journalist writes a reasoned, principled column in defence of women's sports. Male journalist subjects her to a knee-jerk, misogynistic attack (the latest in a long line).
In the long-run, reason will win over hate. Keep going
@VictoriaPeckham
"We utilise the single sex exemptions to ensure that our refuges, women’s centre and group work are women-only. This is lawful under Paragraph 27, Part 7, Schedule 3 of the Equality Act 2010."
Solidarity with
@nia_endingVAWG
16 August, 2023: “A woman has appeared in court accused of murdering a man found dead in a river two years ago”
No reference to Blake identifying as transgender
The case of Karen White, a biological male who identifies as a woman, is really shocking. The Prison Service needs to review urgently its approach to prisoners who assert a gender identity that diverges from their birth sex. /1
Don't worry if you're imprisoned while awaiting trial, only to be found innocent, Lord Bellamy said yesterday
It will give you an opportunity to brush up on your IT skills