Director of CT Media Host of The Bulletin. Promised Land, & The Rise & Fall of Mars Hill. Author of "Land of My Sojourn" — out now. (Order at the link.)
The scarring effects of Trauma on the brain can be mapped on MRI— a kind of short-circuiting that can effect memory, cause panic attacks, and much more. This is what what we call PTSD.
Saying it doesn’t exist is like pointing to a severed limb and saying “merely a flesh wound.”
Just to be clear, these students aren’t expressing solidarity with innocent Palestinians caught in the crossfire. They are cheering on a militant terrorist organization that unleashed a torrent of rape and murder on 10/7, has indiscriminately fired rockets at civilians for almost…
@MikeCosper
@MikeCosper
My biggest problem with this conference is why
@PastorMark
was invited to speak.
He ran away from accountability instead of owning up to his abusive behavior that destroyed Mars Hills.
Here is
@suttonturner
giving an example of his abusive behavior.
“Who is building something better, more sustainable, and more rooted?”
Great question.
Who is building communities where glad-hearted worship is central, where godly men build and godly women glorify, and where swords are paired with shovels and not strippers?
#MoscowMood
After a weekend when protestors barred Jews from access, chanted genocidal slogans, and celebrated 10/7 as the work of “freedom fighters“, this is one of the most morally bankrupt things I’ve seen in a long time.
Nobody should have to go to jail for smoking weed.
We must continue to change our nation’s approach to marijuana while reforming the justice system so it finally lives up to its name.
Regarding the myth of a homogenous society before the civil rights era, William should go visit the memorials in his own town of Louisville for Bloody Monday, August 6th 1855. The anti-immigration and anti-Catholic “know nothing” party rioted in the German and Irish…
A good law of history is that if you ever find yourself opposing a student movement while siding with the ruling class, you are wrong. Every single time. In every era. No matter the issue.
The hateful right wing reaction to the Nala Ray story is proof once again that at its core, the gospel is a scandal and an offense to people who hate mercy and love the law.
.
@SpeakerJohnson
(R-LA): "I don’t walk around this building being worried about a motion to vacate. I have to do my job. We did. I've done here what I believe to be the right thing and that is to allow the House to work its will."
I appreciate this thread, even while I think some of its sentiment is misplaced (even dangerously misplaced). There’s a sense in which it gets right at the heart of why I wrote Land of My Sojourn.
Most of the Christians I’ve spoken to who have struggled with their faith would…
I put up this tweet yesterday on how it would be nice to hear from people who grew up evangelical and remain happily evangelical and aren’t on some ax-grinding book tour or perpetually resentful.
The responses have been great. It’s pretty fun to see people have the permission…
1) By what definition are you calling it a genocide? I’m genuinely asking — how do you define it as genocide with such certainty? How familiar you are with the IDF’s tactics on the ground to minimize civilian deaths?
2) What should a nation do when a terror state invaded,…
I have my own critiques of this sort of thing, but I am similarly concerned by the sense of condescension and contempt expressed here on X towards attendees.
Driscoll et al tap into real spiritual hunger, loneliness, and masculine identity. The raw contempt for them and their…
STRONGER MENS CONFERENCE 2024 was one for the books! What an incredible weekend - God moved in powerful ways and thousands of men were impacted! 🙌
We can’t wait for SMC25!
“Unlike David French” is doing a lot of work in this tweet, given that French influenced policy for years as a constitutional lawyer defending religious liberty and free speech, and that he left that career to serve in the war in Iraq during the surge.
In defense of
@realchrisrufo
, he’s not some pundit like David French. He’s been out there directly causing policy changes, and has shown he’s not afraid of a fight. His concern here is behavior that makes his genuine political work more difficult, not avoiding awkward cocktail…
Wild news day.
Israel defends Al Aqsa Mosque.
Jordan and Saudi Arabia defend Israel.
Iran starts a large scale war and immediately calls for a ceasefire.
Hamas embedded their force inside the civilian infrastructure of Gaza, counting on it as a psychological force multiplier. Israel’s counterattack would be devastating, and Hamas knew the world would blame Israel and not Hamas.
That tactic worked. Why would Hamas negotiate when…
Two things are bewildering about this post.
First, the willful blindness to the expressions of pro-Hamas, “glory to the martyrs,” and antisemitic sentiment in the protests.
Second, the relentless rejection of ceasefire offers by Hamas. The call to moral absolutes goes only one…
Many people are trying hard to make it sound like all the students and protestors calling for a ceasefire are antisemitic and pro-Hamas in order to discredit them.
Every protest I’ve been a part of has been clearly grounded in love and nonviolence, with Jews, Christians,…
“Go back to Poland.”
As
@havivrettiggur
put it to me, “The history of Jews in the 20th century was learning Hebrew, learning English, or dying.”
America’s status as a safe haven is being tested by these protests, and failing disastrously.
Jewish students get harassed trying to leave
@Columbia
’s campus tonight. You can hear someone yell “Yehudim Yehudim”- “Jews Jews.” They curse and yell “go back to Poland.” Antisemitism has become the new normal here.
I dunno, maybe years and years of bemoaning American Imperialism and carnage and generally crapping on this country and it’s principles of pluralism and liberty set the stage for some awful stuff.
This idea — which I've heard often — ignores the fact that Mars' leadership wanted Mark and worked to establish conditions in which he could stay. It wasn't about his theology, mood, or temperament, it was about specific actions and his unwillingness to address / correct them.
I’ve always had a sneaking suspicion that
@PastorMark
got ran out of Mars Hill by the same spirit that attacks the Moscow Mood. Then when reformed people didn’t get his back he went t to where he was welcome.
Please, remember, if you’re parroting the “Ukrainian Nazis” talking point, it’s an incandescently stupid one. See Timothy Snyder ‘s comments here. Snyder is one of the leading scholars of Ukrainian and Nazi history.
Man who constantly complains about not wanting to shed American blood in foreign wars wonders where the harm is in leaving Russian imperialist expansionism unchecked.
A decade-plus of attempted pacification of Iran has led directly here.
Along with the Iran deal, the withdrawal from Afghanistan, and the tepid support of Ukraine against Russian aggression.
Meanwhile, China and Taiwan are watching.
Don’t confuse this with the TikTok activism you see on campus.
This could cost these women their very lives. Women in Iran have been murdered for less.
The campus activists are cheering on the IRGC, the Houthis, and Hamas, whose draconian laws they are resisting.
This is Tehran, Iran.
After over 40 years of restrictions, women are declaring enough is enough! They're dancing in public, challenging bans on singing and showing their hair.
Their message? Dancing is not a crime. Women, Life, Freedom.
NEW: Pastor Mark Driscoll gets kicked off stage at a men’s conference after he calls out pastor John Lindell for allowing a demonstration from a male stripper.
The incident happened at the Stronger Men’s Conference in Springfield, MO.
After Vegas stripper and ‘sword swallower’…
Co-sign. 🇺🇦
I will never understand how we could turn our backs on a partner of democracy—it’s deeply un-American.
I don't recognize the domestic weakness to capitulate to the fringe of both parties.
I’m the spirit of my friend (and occasional sparring partner)
@andrewtwalk
‘s “I’m just fine” thread, and in the spirit of Land of My Sojourn’s themes, I want to hear your “I’m still here” story. Maybe things weren’t so fine, you had your dark night, but somehow, you woke up on…
One of the interesting lessons of this campus activism:
For a decade, right wing pundits have fear-mongered and shouted “Marxism” every time a left wing politician said something they didn’t like. Now, while campus radicals are literally using Marxist ideology to justify their…
This tweet and the embedded tweet — a perennial discussion for producers.
Here’s the key. It is extremely rare that the loose conversations between friends is interesting to outsiders. Two examples for shows where it works.
One is Joe Rogan. Everyone thinks “I can just record…
A second opinion: Because I’m not an info-bot scouring podcasts for downloadable data but a souled and relational person, keep up the human aspect of podcasting. My fave are the ones that feel like friends at a table
Most of these kids didn’t get to walk at graduation from High School in 2020 because of COVID restrictions.
Now, they won’t walk at college graduation because of anti-Israel protests.
A couple of last thoughts (for tonight) after watching the Carlson / Isaac conversation :
It’s true the Christian population in Bethlehem and Gaza are shrinking. But why doesn’t Tucker ask about the PA in Bethlehem? It was 80% Christian during the post 1967 occupation. When the…
When advocacy for Palestinians crosses into apologetics for terrorism, that’s an easy judgment to make. I know many pro-Palestine activists who are disgusted by these protests and recognize that in the long haul, these hurt the cause for more than they help.
But people are so…
@MikeCosper
@havivrettiggur
I mean, you were more balanced with how you reacted to pro gun control and pro BLM movements in the past. Why is it so hard for you to be balanced here?
“The U.S. Congress Commission on International Religious Freedom considers Russia as one of the world’s “worst violators” of religious freedom, on par with Iran and Pakistan.”
Russia's War Against Evangelicals | TIME
Columbia University students chanting:
“Hamas make us proud, kill another soldier now”
Young American trust fund girls chanting “free all our prisoners” as if they were members of Hamas
Madness…
@PrestonSprinkle
I won’t defend those statements. I will point out the dates on them, and ask, do you think that’s been the policy in Gaza?
Genocide — a word invented to describe the systematic and mechanized murder of Jews by the third Reich — has a meaning. Do you actually think Israel is…
You will not find this tone of righteous indignation about the accidental drone killing of 10 civilians during the Biden Admin’s Afghan pullout in 2021.
These deaths are tragic and horrible, and those responsible should be held accountable — dismissed and even charged if…
"We received Israel's report on terrible killing of
@WCKitchen
team in Gaza. We're reviewing it very carefully. We'll be discussing its conclusions with Israeli officials and humanitarian organizations... It's very important that Israel is taking full responsibility."
-- Blinken
@NatePyle79
Strongly disagree. For the money and time, you could see much better versions of all of this at a concert, MMA fight ,or actual monster truck rally. The spectacle is a value add, or cultural signaling maybe. But I guarantee if you talk to attendees, they’ll agree that these were…
This is correct.
And to be clear — a just war response (i.e. proportionality) isn’t a math equation involving casualties or the damage to Iran. It is about eliminating or shrinking Iran’s capacity to threaten this way again.
Just like after October 7, the world supports Israel when she gets hit but is quick to condemn her when Israel hits back. That's wrong. No other country would be expected to do nothing in response to 300 missiles launched against its territory.
#StandWithIsrael
All this underscores the central fact, true since long before October 7: Hamas is a death cult. They worship the death of Israelis and promise to continue shedding their blood, and they worship the death of their own people, human sacrifices used to turn the world against Israel…
Sure… but don’t you see that starts by not invading sovereign territory, slaughtering and raping 1200 innocent people, taking hundreds of hostages, embedding your military under civilian infrastructure, refusing to negotiate for hostage releases, killing and raping hostages in…
@MikeCosper
In the face of the ongoing occupation and inhumane destruction of Gaza, should the Palestinians bear the sword, pursue Justice, and preserve its legitimacy by guaranteeing the safety of its civilians?
Of course, that question won’t be the headline. Instead, headlines will be about how Israel needs to try harder to negotiate. All the moral imperative will be on them, especially after the failures this week.
People won’t ask why Hamas gunmen are boarding aid trucks on a…
Shakira shares her thoughts on Greta Gerwig’s ‘BARBIE’:
“My sons absolutely hated it. They felt that it was emasculating. And I agree, to a certain extent. I'm raising two boys. I want 'em to feel powerful too [while] respecting women. I like pop culture when it attempts to…
The fact that she keeps referring to this apparently ravenous and terrifying, must-be-blown-to-kingdom-come dog as “Cricket” is truly the best bit the writers of 2024 have come up with so far.
I can understand why some people are upset about a 20 year old story of Cricket, one of the working dogs at our ranch, in my upcoming book — No Going Back. The book is filled with many honest stories of my life, good and bad days, challenges, painful decisions, and lessons…
@chuckdegroat
That’s definitely along the lines of what I’m talking about — it’s rare and small often, but it’s also often still built to “signal” masculine in certain ways.
For instance, I’ve heard of quite a few ministries where men gather to either do relief work or to serve as handymen…
This logic (stated by many others as well), is just wild to me.
“Okay, Iran just needed to get this out of their system. Now Israel needs to be a grown-up and not respond.”
Iran supports Hamas, who holds Israel (and American) hostages.
Iran’s proxies have been shooting…
assessment at this point:
iranian attack was designed to be easily intercepted and reset the bar on deterrence.
next steps will depend on biden administration (and allies’) ability to keep israel from a direct military response on iranian soil.
even so, plenty dangerous…
@amsacramone
The greatest thing about being assimilated by the Deep State Borg is the comprehensive free health and dental care. (Plus… Eventually, your teeth are replaced by titanium alloy — no more cavities!)
Re: Foreign Aid:
“Today, I voted no... These bills were brought forward under a contrived process to achieve a pre-determined outcome — a $100 billion, unpaid-for foreign aid package while failing to secure the border.
For months, House Republicans — specifically, Speaker Mike…
And btw — if you’re equivocating checkpoints, walls, and a security state to Hamas’ terror campaigns, that’s not only wildly inaccurate, it’s grotesque.
This formulation, justifying 10/7, is paternalistic in the extreme, robbing Palestinians of their agency and reducing them to violent animals who cannot help but rape, murder, and pillage.
@aaronieq
@MikeCosper
Yes.
You back a people into a corner, leave them no reasonable options for both liberation and peace and then wonder why there is violent resistance.
In the early months of the war, politicians and news orgs were disciplined about noting that the death count was from the “Hamas Run Gaza Health Ministry, which doesn’t distinguish between civilians and soldiers.”
As public sentiment turned against the war, they lost that…
@colinsmo
The withdrawal policy and talks with the Taliban began under Trump. It’s not complicated. Biden executed it disastrously, but the policy was a disaster to begin with.
The common thread between progressive foreign policy (Obama/ Biden) and populist foreign policy is that America…
This is almost exactly what the Stronger Men’s Conference would say about their content, which is my whole point in the first place.
Joe’s response was an attempt at a contrast, but Canon has no problem with stunts of their own in order to get attention.
And as I said waaaay…
@MikeCosper
That’s ridiculous. A fun promo is not the substance of what Canon is putting out. You can disagree with their content, but there is zero question that their books, blogs, interviews, and curriculum are offering deep and substantive vision of the role men are to play in theirs…
Eight years ago, a GOP member saying “peace through strength” would have been something to ignore. Maybe even roll your eyes at. Today, with a pro-Putin caucus at the core of the party, it’s notable.
Notable quotable:
House Speaker Mike Johnson, to
@Jaketapper
, on the significance of the foreign aid bills: "I'm a child of the '80s. I regard myself as a Reagan Republican. I understand the concept of maintaining peace through strength."
@MikeCosper
They don’t count because that’s not what they were. I think Stalin was pretty smart guy and adept tactician. Doesn’t mean I’m a fan of Stalin.
It is true — and I have said many times — that I think the Trump admin’s policy towards Iran was a proper course correction.
But the disaster in Afghanistan went into motion under Trump, and his policy towards Russia was as ambiguous as (or worse than) Biden’s.
Mike either forgets or conveniently overlooks that under four years of Trump there was no “pacification” of Iran
Trump’s aggressive but smart approach to Iran totally crippled them
And in mere months, Biden undid it all
Listen to this.
The faux-Fanon revolutionary babble is an excuse to:
Celebrate the murders of October 7th.
Praise Hamas as “Freedom fighters.”
Call students to take up revolutionary violence of their own.
People are going to get hurt.
If you wanted Trump jailed for…
You know, lets take off the gloves:
Terrorism is an ideology.
They are openly supporting terror.
They are terrorists.
These are not kids. These are adults.
People their age have jobs and serve in the military. People their age know what consequences mean.
It's time for…
In my March cover story for CT, I talked about how Christians get seduced by antisemitism. An example I cited was the wide embrace of a crèche in Munther Isaac’s church, featuring Jesus wrapped in a keffiyeh. Today, Isaac is featured on Tucker’s show.
Ep. 91 How does the government of Israel treat Christians? In the West, Christian leaders don’t seem interested in knowing the answer. They should be. Here’s the view of a pastor from Bethlehem.
Why aren’t more people taking a public stand against this brazen Jew-hatred that is endangering Jews on campus and beyond? Where are our friends who have unhesitatingly stood up on behalf of other minority groups being isolated and demonized?
The settler movement deserves criticism and scrutiny, but it has nothing to do with the war in Gaza. Quite the opposite — settlers were uprooted and forced out of Gaza by the IDF in 2005. Talk of the settlers in regard to this war is a non-Sequitur.
Likewise, if we are going to…
What’s crazy about this post by
@MikeCosper
is the lengths he will go to not blame Israel. Anyone in their right mind can see how the building of settlements on Palestinian land, building of walls that mean people can’t visit family members 3 miles away in Jerusalem destroys life
@WendyAlsup
I think that’s a fair subject for debate, but I think there is serious danger in making moral equivocations between them. Netanyahu has not ordered mass murder, in spite of accusations otherwise. The WCK killings led to an immediate acknowledgment of failure and consequences for…
I have an essay in
@ActonInstitute
‘s Religion and Liberty discussing polarization, BLM, the American Right, and how the surge of antisemitism since 10/7 ties them together.
📸 October 29, 2010, before a LIVE from the NYPL conversation...
Keith Richards in The Rose Main Reading Room at The New York Public Library
.
@officialkeef
marvels at a Shakespeare Folio
[William Shakespeare, died on this day, in 1616]
.
@officialKeef
A fair(ish) question. Set aside the question of accusation of intl law violations — what should one expect the Palestinians to do in response to occupation?
Since 1964 (pre-occupation) the Palestinian Nationalist movement has been built on the Algerian model. Use terror and…
@MikeCosper
Or if you want to apply this reasoning fairly, you might need to say "no other people would be expected to do nothing while under perpetual occupation. Just war would eliminate Israeli’s ability to continue to violate Int law and Palestinian rights."
Yes… a good correction here from Matt.
I was thinking of the leaders on the board and in the “C-Suite (equivalent)” more than the core of mars. What motivated that coalition was different than early years — and reformed theology was a secondary priority (at best).
@MikeCosper
Long time Mars Hillian and former MH pastor here👋🏼 both are true. If you follow MD’s story, he changed teams about every 5 years. Kind of like a kid gathering his toys and going to another sandbox because the big kids were mean to him.
McCarthyism was about falsely accusing people of being covert Communist revolutionaries and ruining their careers.
Jodi Dean wrote a grotesque apologia for 10/7 in a communist framework.
Also, ma’am, please see your profile. Whatever this is, it ain’t McCarthyism.
@MikeCosper
So your contention is that because Carlson didn’t ask questions you and Politico found sufficiently tough, this makes him pro Putin? Can’t he just be anti-American intervention?
@MikeCosper
You might consider Vance’s own explanation for his position. It is cogent, it is serious. It’s fine to disagree with it (I have friends and colleagues I respect who do). But it’s cheap to dismiss it as “pro-Putin.”
@aaronieq
I see this argument making a category error. The war in Gaza, pursuing Hamas, is not rightly categorized simply as “vengeance,” as though it were a mere question of individual agency. It is a government bearing the sword, pursuing Justice, and preserving a its legitimacy by…
If you want to understand why neo-Marxist progressives would make common cause with Islamist terror, or how they could be so uncritical of the violence (including the sexual violence) of 10/7, read this naked apologia for Hamas by Jodi Dean:
The populist right and left are both seething right now over Ukraine and Israel Aid. Their logic is different, but they have a common ethos. I wrote about this for
@ActonInstitute
Religion and Liberty recently.
@gpackiam
One of my favorite Luther insights on Law/Gospel: Even the Ten Commandments begin with grace. “I am the Lord your God, who brought you out of Egypt.” Saving mercy precedes his invitation to obey the Law.
This reminds me a bit of “trust your pastors.”
Or “If a Christian says one thing and a Jew another, whose testimony will you believe?”
This is not what Joshua is intending, but it is part of the subtext of “listen to your Palestinian brothers and sisters.”
When that person…
@MikeCosper
Mike, respectfully, if one of our brothers who is a pastor in this area is asking for help … the best posture might be humbly listening, not assuming we know better.
I know you’re a good man of conviction. I’m asking you to consider a more nuanced position on this.
Dispelling the falsehoods about the red heifers:
1. No, there are no plans to sacrifice them right now. They’re being bred to create a herd that can live in an educational visitor center in ancient Shiloh.
2. No, they’re not genetically modified. They’re Texas Red Angus.
3.…