Charlie @CharlieYalf Twitter profile | Pikagi

Pikagi

Charlie

@CharlieYalf

774

Followers

714

Following

582

Media

3,746

Statuses

Senior Digital Accessibility Specialist • Offline & Online Founder • Incluseum • Good Growin' Farm • e/acc effective accessibility @

https://bento.me/charlieyalf

https://t.co/3RPXrhupRT

Joined October 2023

Don't wanna be here? Send us removal request.

Pinned Tweet

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

2 months

A11YAuditing is now I launched 4 products between Nov’ 23 and Feb’ 24. My intent was to find a tool people wanted to use and I wanted to build. When I launched a11yauditing I was blown away by the response - with over 20 reports generated in the first

Tweet card media

Get Your Website Report | A11YBoost

Automated reports and monitoring for your website covering Accessibility, Performance, Design, User Experience and SEO. Simply enter your URL.

11

2

28

Last Seen Profiles

@sou_xg

@eloficinista

@CClignancourt

@stw46

@IrvingPDChief

@ccabogota

@ackedman

@LucasCardosoMor

@WisdomAdediji

@theboytree

@family_251

@arcticmonkeyt

@CharityPer78605

@kamiboido

@subject_92

@PHmiese

@spergasaurus

@fatbumperlover

@Hennac03

@TheGreaterArea

@biizzlx

@JY_station

@JilatanJilbab

@YinshiRen

@jandakembangstw

@irishacw

@hijabjilbab1

@cynthiahruff

@Pea_GPTs

@JilatanJilbab

@vinarzn

@Jennalux3

@thakurign

@jandakembangstw

@BoylerSportsTV

@denzel_470

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

7 months

@ryanlongcomedy Criminal that this train of thought was interrupted. I want to hear more!!

Tweet media one

5

6

274

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

7 months

@Endthemisery1 She literally says her job isn’t the issue. A little bit of critical thought would get you to where she is - how society structures employment, regardless of how much an individual likes their job, needs vast improvement.

1

4

261

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

7 months

@techdroider Gonna be more breakages than the era of the wii controller. what is this

Tweet media one

1

4

242

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

8 months

@ImNotAbdi @JJKALE2 “It’s not my job to answer your questions” is such a cop-out. If a journalist/interviewer is using the piece as a platform to get their view across, as piers morgan does, then as pointed out, they absolutely should be held accountable and answer questions too.

0

7

127

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

5 months

FREE PLANS vs PAID ONLY Choose your fighter. @euboid & @marc_louvion both making great points depending on where you are in your journey.

Tweet media one

Tweet media two

32

5

113

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

7 months

Optus is down nationwide in Australia today. If you don’t know, they’re one of Australia’s largest telecommunications providers. Businesses and individuals without mobile, wifi, payments etc. But nothing is more important than this. #OptusOutage

Tweet media one

2

21

97

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

7 months

@unusual_whales The ‘announcement’

Tweet media one

8

1

90

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

7 months

@namyakhann Back-end developers making landing pages and calling front-end easy. Front-end developers making a CRUD api and calling back-end easy. The devil is in the details.

4

5

87

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

7 months

@ostonox This would be me

0

2

87

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

7 months

@ChrisMinnsMP Now do teachers, nurses and social workers just to name a few.

1

2

85

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

5 months

Day 1 of #100DaysToSolopreneur Achievement Unlocked: Make first $1 I MADE MY FIRST SALE! Since starting this challenge 24 hours ago I have been absolutely blown away by the support in every direction. On top of the likes, comments and follows i’ve also had people reach out

Tweet media one

17

2

83

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

7 months

@rafcorreia @docoho @edwardr42000 I’m glad you’ve never seen that, but please don’t talk for other people and particularly not for ALL disabled folk. For me, as a disabled person, I have definitely seen the issues being discussed by RTD & I don’t see how it’s ableist to acknowledge and dismantle a harmful trope.

6

2

80

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

4 months

Decided I’m going to start liking my own tweets and comments because why would I post it if I didn’t like it?

20

1

72

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

7 months

@JoshLekach Something really important & simple here; genuine compliments and warmth come from just a little bit of attention and specificity. In every instance he goes into just a little bit of detail. He doesn't say "I like your glasses" he says "I like your art deco glasses". It works.

2

0

68

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

4 months

Just used @supabase for the first time and got user auth going in like 6 minutes? This is unreal.

8

1

68

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

5 months

If you’re wondering if building in public is worth it… This is the past 24 hours alone 🤯

12

3

65

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

8 months

@JeremiahBonds @ZacksJerryRig I also have it turned on and saw videos of kidnapping/corpses.. Definitely improvement needs to be made as to the auto-tagging of NSFW/NSFL content if they want to keep allowing it to be uploaded.

2

1

63

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

8 months

@fesshole All tradespeople/specialists should do this - being an expert isn’t about having encyclopaedic knowledge - it’s about being able to quickly apply your knowledge on existing systems with new information.

0

1

60

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

1 month

Storytime: A surgeon ruined my life, left me with chronic pain, a mobility disability and set me off on a journey where I spent years going through medical system to end up with CPTSD. All this talk about TherapistAI makes me want to mention one thing - accountability. But

14

3

55

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

1 month

@ImLunaHey It’s a representation of my work in grade 9

5

1

53

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

1 month

@jeremy_b12345 @lucas__crespo @itsurboyevan Yeah the only way to make this viable would be to up everyone’s subscription, including those with no access to a theatre 🙃

5

0

52

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

7 months

@6NewsAU That’s a seriously damaging number and highlights that Australia shouldn’t be relying on a private company for essential infrastructure.

2

0

51

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

2 months

Special announcement is @supabase is making me Chief Accessibility Officer. Just kidding… unless.

Tweet card media

Charlie’s ticket

Build production-grade applications with a Postgres database, Authentication, instant APIs, Realtime, Functions, Storage and Vector embeddings. Start for free.

3

5

49

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

4 months

I started my career on Rails, eventually I gave it up for the shiny new JavaScript toys - but honestly I’m beginning to wonder why I ever gave Rails up? Dependable, opinionated frameworks may be the future.

@NathanSRobinson

Nathan S. Robinson

@NathanSRobinson

4 months

I'm calling it. 2024 is the year of Rails. From new programmers and indie hackers like me to big corps migrating legacy code. Rails was never dead, but boy are we back 💪🚀 #Rails #Ruby #buildinpublic

21

10

145

7

1

46

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

7 months

I’m obsessed with Sam Campbell. Far North Queensland unlocks something weird deep in the comedic soul. #Taskmaster

1

5

45

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

8 months

@softminus Pretty bummed out whilst my house is being rebuilt from a missle, but at least i'll have great internet after.

0

0

39

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

25 days

@Andyparackal @rabbit_hmi Would be nice to at least know the reason for suspension 🤷‍♂️ @X could do better here

2

0

39

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

7 months

@SteffenKonrath @AricToler @nytimes Apologies this situation is too complex for you. I hope you continue to read pieces like this and reach a better clarification.

0

0

39

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

7 months

@___frye I mean even with this boy we still don’t have the tetrahedons right??? Proven market fit tbh someone get on it.

Tweet media one

0

1

35

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

7 months

@rafcorreia @docoho @edwardr42000 Is there more context than this? The ‘crippled villain’ trope is harmful and I think there’s room to discuss how we would make villains today if aesthetic based ableism wasn’t at the forefront of those decisions. What am I missing?

@RadioFreeSkaro

Radio Free Skaro

@RadioFreeSkaro

7 months

The full episode of Doctor Who: Unleashed is available on iPlayer, but we thought it was important to share Russell T Davies’ comments on accessibility and the portrayal of Davros. #DoctorWho

482

414

3K

7

2

38

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

5 months

Day 0 of #100DaysToSolopreneur This is me making the promise publicly. I've spent the past 82 days learning as much as I can, implementing as much as I can. And now, I have the full roadmap. In 100 days I will have earned $10k and have $3K MRR through products and productised

13

0

33

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

4 months

I’m working on a new tool and I need landing pages to test it on so why not drop your landing page below 👇 #buildinpublic

31

3

33

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

6 months

How am I going? #buildinpublic #seo

Tweet media one

14

0

29

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

7 months

@levelsio 96% profit sounds good, before actual costs: Rent, staff, investment costs in equipment and operations for scaling business, marketing, taxes, the 74 other products you need to make a cafe viable outside of butter cakes etc.

2

1

31

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

2 months

It's seriously impossible to simply redirect a https:// URL on @Namecheap ??? Please tell me this advice is wrong? Simply trying to get a11yauditing to redirect to new URL. If so, this is a useless product for sure.

Tweet media one

51

0

29

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

8 months

@abcnews Queensland offering $100,000 for new police recruits according to a billboard I saw today 🙃 How much are we offering teachers? The shortage will continue until the job is worth doing.

2

0

28

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

3 months

@depthsofwiki (This probably isn’t to do with Hunger Games but rather the 2009 movie District 9 which had heavy apartheid themes)

0

0

27

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

3 months

Doctor Charlie checking in! 🚑🚑 Is your website unwell? Or maybe it looks healthy, but you're just unsure how to make sure it's in peak form? Introducing my latest tool! A11YAuditing! 26+ AI & non-AI tests covering Accessibility, Performance, Design,

Tweet media one

Tweet media two

11

3

28

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

6 months

@namyakhann Right - clearer CTA, clearer navigation. The light shining directly on ‘buy credits’ and ‘get started free’ seems contradictory and garish imo

1

0

27

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

7 months

@TrungTPhan Also a storyline in HBO Silicon Valley. I think you have to have a certain pillar of your personality hinging on your singular workplace identity for this to work. If that was offered to me, I’m not getting down about it, I’m getting on the side hustle with a guaranteed income

1

0

27

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

2 months

What fiction book are you reading at the moment?

Tweet media one

15

0

24

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

7 months

@7NewsSydney @billshortenmp Can't wait for the Australian government to use more algorithms and AI to commit criminal acts just to be able to blame it on a primary school prop department product. #auspol

2

0

21

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

7 months

@zlatov_cristina Simple - Easier to write unreadable code, easier to read unwriteable code.

4

1

23

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

1 month

2 weeks later.. progress has been slow but steady! #buildinpublic

Tweet media one

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

2 months

It begins.. #buildinpublic

Tweet media one

5

0

21

7

1

24

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

7 months

@Thinkwert You joke… but science has already gone too far.

Tweet card media

Clear Tomato Soup

I've had lots of requests to make more clear recipes, but this one stood out! Effectively a sort of consommé, this is a recipe for a clear tomato soup made u...

www.youtube.com

2

2

21

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

4 months

Evolution of AI in Digital Accessibility (A11Y) - A longer article I wrote about the history of AI in A11Y, the pessimism of digital accessibility and how we innovate inclusively with movements like e/acc! It's a longer one than usual so strap in.

The Evolution of AI in Digital Accessibility

Incluseum has been exploring the world of Artificial Intelligence, it's previous implementations within accessibility and it’s possible future. We look at the history of Overlays, the current state...

incluseum.digital

1

2

23

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

1 month

Buddy, you’re growing the wrong way.

Tweet media one

11

0

22

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

2 months

It begins.. #buildinpublic

Tweet media one

5

0

21

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

2 months

Do people not want your product or do they just not understand what it actually does?

25

0

21

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

4 months

I have been trusted to harvest and deliver a last minute order as my partner is off assisting another farm. Getting official with the Good Growin’ merch and hoping the restaurant approves!

Tweet media one

Tweet media two

5

0

21

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

7 months

@NathanSRobinson You can’t go wrong with @freeCodeCamp I owe the beginning of my now 5-year, six-figure career to them.

Tweet card media

Learn Ruby on Rails - Full Course

Learn Ruby on Rails in this full course for beginners. Ruby on Rails is a is a server-side web application framework used for creating full stack web apps.🔗...

www.youtube.com

2

2

20

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

2 months

Waking up and knowing today is the day @illyism gives his secret sauce to @morningmakersho

Tweet media one

5

3

21

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

5 months

There’s heteronormativity and then there’s AI-baked heteronormativity. I googled “Sam Altman married”.

Tweet media one

1

2

21

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

3 months

We've now conducted over 3000 tests in the first 3 days of a11yauditing! Over 100 websites have already benefited from the free report! 🤯 Idea validated, already working on the next deployment! #buildinpublic

10

1

21

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

1 month

What are you reading?

Tweet media one

12

0

20

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

24 days

Just made the thickest hot chocolate of my life and it solved some things to be honest

7

0

20

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

3 months

Screenreader Accessibility Testing CRASH Course Bookmark this for when you're launching your next project. Free Screenreaders You Can Test Your Website With! Windows - Narrator Window's built-in screen reading tool, just press the windows key and type "narrator" - NVDA The

4

5

19

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

7 months

Currently working on getting everything verified in a live environment! @Namecheap for the domain, dns and email. @auth0 for user management @stripe for payments @Replit for deployment Total one-off spend: $25USD Fixed recurring costs: $30USD a month #buildinpublic

3

0

17

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

2 months

The collab I always knew I needed!! @morningmakersho X @that_igor_ I’ve lost count of the value MMS is providing but here’s an attempt: - genuine community - free tools - expert advice - dank memes - weekly secret call Come join us!

Tweet media one

4

4

18

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

7 months

@ESYudkowsky When AGI is mainstream & consuming enough jobs that there is no value to higher-education driven services. I can imagine a world where that child goes to a university actually driven towards providing a space for learning and education; not a job knowledge factory we have now.

6

1

18

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

2 months

Is there anything tailwind is missing?

21

1

18

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

7 months

@elonmusk @xai How do you align your belief that AI should be regulated with the work you’re doing with @xai at the moment @elonmusk ? Not an underhanded question, I’m sure you have your justification and I’m curious what it is.

10

0

16

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

4 months

I've heard everyone struggling to find the really good, independent products on ProductHunt that made it famous to begin with! So, I put together a free chrome extension that focuses on the little folks. My way of giving back to the #buildinpublic community that supports me.

9

2

17

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

1 month

Surgery went well, back home now! 🦷

4

0

17

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

1 month

A11YBoost is now live on microlaunch! I’ve got the whole month to try to get #1 but getting a lead early means more eyes and with it, more feedback! Go chuck an upvote? Even better - give it a roast. link 👇 #BuildInPublic

Tweet media one

6

2

16

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

3 months

Listening to @morningmakersho and @d4m1n spent time talking about it, so I had to make it. #buildinpublic

Tweet media one

4

2

16

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

7 months

@dvassallo @avindrafernando Accepting a name and email via an input field is vastly different to using cookies to gather information and is a completely different conversation and would require a privacy policy, not cookie banner. Are you being dense on purpose?

1

0

16

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

8 months

@Leo_Puglisi6 God I hope she goes Leichhardt - if this isn’t insane and wildly funny to you please spend a bit of time around Cairns.

0

0

16

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

23 days

GO UPVOTE THIS AND SEND A SCREENSHOT AND IN RETURN ILL BE YOUR BEST FRIEND.

@thiswillblossom

Lera 🌚 Momentum

@thiswillblossom

23 days

clipwing is live on producthunt 💣 clipwing is a super simple video tool helps you edit short clips with trendy captions and produce podcasts fast. if you love what we're doing – please, support us 💔

49

25

99

9

2

16

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

5 months

Payment providers: I’ve been using stripe as that’s what I know, but I’ve seen a lot of discussion about @lmsqueezy . What are people using? Why?

10

1

14

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

5 months

Unfortunately not dealing with chronic health well the last couple days which is why updates have been quiet. The work has been done but after that, the energy hasn’t always been there to engage. I think it’s important to share not just the highlights but also the reality of

6

0

15

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

2 months

Not me with a perfectly good paid Notion plan just..

Tweet media one

5

0

14

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

2 months

Market Report: Non-stop sales for the first hour!! Absolutely amazing to get chatting to customers, see how excited (and confused) people are by fresh mushrooms! If this continues we can consider today a massive success!

Tweet media one

4

0

15

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

4 months

3 weeks down, 49 to go. How has your year started? #buildinpublic

Tweet media one

6

0

15

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

4 months

To everyone that thought my mushroom post yesterday looked unreal, may I introduce you to Coral Tooth Mushroom. As though you have combined clouds and the ocean. Air solidified. These will be ready to harvest tomorrow!

Tweet media one

Tweet media two

4

0

15

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

4 months

7 places you can deploy a static index.html for free: - @github pages - @Replit core - @Cloudflare pages - @Vercel - @staticallyio - @Netlify - @TiinyHost When I was first learning to be a developer, I had $0 - as an industry we have more free resources than any other.

@deepfates

google bard

4 months

Is there literally no way to just post an index.html page somewhere for free??

643

57

2K

2

4

14

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

4 months

This week was the toughest I’ve experienced in a few years. Confidence and self-worth at a near low. Seeing this notification genuinely means so much more than @pseudokid probably meant. In spirit, here are the accounts that have inspired me. 👇🧵

@pseudokid

Raymel is building in public 🚀

4 months

@JonniGani As to the account that inspired me, it's @CharlieYalf Love his dedication to accessibility!

0

0

1

6

0

14

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

2 months

One of the stranger and more difficult parts to manage about disability is the never ending side effects. I have a damaged nerve in my leg, but today I can’t move my neck or shoulder. Over the weekend, doing the markets I relied heavily on my walking cane, a bit too heavily it

4

0

14

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

4 months

If you're not a designer and want to copy the viral "Roast My Design" trend you're seeing a lot on X you obviously can't. Contribute to open-source projects and share that instead!

3

1

14

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

2 months

Wish me luck. Reddit can be brutal #buildinpublic

Tweet media one

7

0

14

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

5 months

I told you you'd be seeing this @clip_wing video a lot! I was so blown away by what @thiswillblossom just dropped one me I had to put together a little X ad campaign with it, so if you see it in the wild cheer it along!!

1

3

14

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

3 months

New update is out! Offering more explanation of the value of the report before signing up (By offering examples of issues found). @shipixen gets a pretty 'nice' score, but still a bit to improve @d4m1n 👀

1

3

14

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

4 months

It’s no secret I’m a fan of (check my banner) and @thejorgemedina is a cornerstone of the #buildinpublic community so make my day and go support them!

Tweet card media

easybranding.io

An easy-to-use platform to design your personal brand in minutes and start creating on-brand visual content to stand out and elevate your online presence.

easybranding.io

@thejorgemedina

Jorge Medina

@thejorgemedina

4 months

IT’S LAUNCH DAY!!! 🚀🤩 Easybranding is LIVE on @ProductHunt and it would mean the world if you’d help me get the #1 of the Day award!🥇 Please upvote & comment here 👇🤓 Thank you!! 💛 #buildinpublic

48

20

100

1

0

14

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

2 months

Packing for our first public markets tomorrow. We’ll be heading to Queensland’s largest produce trading hub and hopefully get some folks sorted for their Easter lunch!

Tweet media one

5

0

14

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

3 months

Signing up for @posthog and reminding them that their sponsorships are well spent. @morningmakersho Go check out so I can see if it's working 👀

Tweet media one

3

3

14

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

3 months

I've just deployed the mighty update to with a massive thank you to @lmsqueezy for the blazing fast verification. Manage domains and reports, get report history, automate reports straight to your inbox and who doesn't love a good graph? #buildinpublic

Tweet media one

5

2

14

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

4 months

Yesterday I supported both @starwardshar ’s BirdBanner and @d4m1n and @TakoTreba ’s Morning Maker Show on @ProductHunt . I did not realise that in doing so, I could have had the power to change who’s #3 ! A big congratulations to both of them!!

Tweet media one

4

0

13

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

5 months

The indexing begins... It's been a massive learning curve going from learning how to build accessible products, to learning how to release them, get them indexed, handle metadata, emails, privacy policy and so much more. Building is just the first step. #buildinpublic

Tweet media one

3

0

13

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

4 months

Should I launch this as my first product on ProductHunt? 👀

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

4 months

I've heard everyone struggling to find the really good, independent products on ProductHunt that made it famous to begin with! So, I put together a free chrome extension that focuses on the little folks. My way of giving back to the #buildinpublic community that supports me.

9

2

17

1

0

13

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

6 months

@ChrisMinnsMP And what about teachers, nurses and social workers? Have we seen a rise in enrolments there as we pay them to study and participate in placements? Oh. #auspol

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

7 months

@ChrisMinnsMP Now do teachers, nurses and social workers just to name a few.

1

2

85

0

2

13

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

3 months

no but why are they posing like its the first day of school?

Tweet media one

2

0

13

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

5 months

Accessible, bold colours with no inspiration? ColourEasy's got you! A video to break down the most simple function of ColourEasy and explaining those that motivated me to build it. #buildinpublic

2

1

13

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

2 months

Pink Oyster Mushroom

Tweet media one

1

1

12

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

2 months

Playing around with @shipixen tonight! does its job well, but you wouldn’t know it looking at the landing page. Hoping shipixen can help fix that pronto. Follow along as I find out. #BuildInPublic

Tweet card media

Get Your Website Report | A11YBoost

Automated reports and monitoring for your website covering Accessibility, Performance, Design, User Experience and SEO. Simply enter your URL.

3

5

12

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

1 month

A11YBoost is heading to @MicroLaunchHQ in May! Why am I telling you this now? Because my waitlist page is live and it would mean the world to me for y’all to hit that Get Notified button!👇

2

4

12

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

2 months

Coral or mushroom?

Tweet media one

7

0

12

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

5 months

@notshenetworks The top comment there that hiring based on merit means DEI shouldn’t matter UNLESS your system or the wider system is flawed to begin with. Is so close to getting the point.. 🤏

2

0

12

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

6 months

In my career as a developer & a11y consultant i've noticed something dangerous. Great products missing out on their potential to reach a multi-trillion dollar market & improve people's lives because accessibility stopped being accessible. No more.

0

0

11

@CharlieYalf

Charlie

1 month

@BelindaJones68 Not knowing Flint or the situation but it seems fair that someone (a victim) wouldn’t disclose at the time and they’ve very much entitled to disclose at a later date? Not seeing the dishonesty here.

2

0

12