❤️ Umair Profile Banner
❤️ Umair Profile
❤️ Umair

@umairh

228,453
Followers
1,680
Following
512
Media
49,727
Statuses

Founder, . I like disco and the sunlight can kill me, but I repeat myself. Author: The New Capitalist Manifesto from @HarvardBiz .

Joined April 2008
Don't wanna be here? Send us removal request.
Pinned Tweet
@umairh
❤️ Umair
7 months
If someone told you HALF of our global economies would be destroyed due to climate change, would you believe them? Well, the research doesn’t lie. We're on a collision course, and this is a data-driven reality check. 1/7
Tweet media one
181
2K
6K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
4 years
Congrats to Joe Biden for winning the Presidency for the fourth time this week
1K
61K
539K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
4 years
My partner, the doctor, rolling her eyes: tell them I don’t want their claps and cheers during a pandemic, I want them to stop voting like dummies for sociopaths who don’t want them to have decent healthcare systems at all in the first place
624
38K
144K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
3 years
Especially white Americans don’t like to hear it, but we got to the “coup” stage of fascism because we didn’t impeach at the concentration camps, cages, family separations, beatings, gassing, disappearances. Fascism’s a pattern of escalation and nobody tried to really break it
1K
25K
116K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
4 years
Guys. Every single person who’s survived authoritarianism will tell you that when they start abducting people off the streets, you are in deep, deep trouble as a society.
175
9K
39K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
2 years
I have no idea why Brits are ok with living in a society where you can’t get an ambulance so maybe your baby or parent or partner dies. It is really mind boggling to me to see how easy it is to break a society’s spirit in this total way.
485
3K
14K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
3 years
You guys should be pretty worried that people who basically study doom for a living like me are like wait this shit is off the charts of even our worst predictions
168
2K
13K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
9 months
Hawaii in flames, 100 dead and counting. Thousands evacuated in Spain. Thousands of hectares of Portugal, on fire. The blazes in Canada? So far, they’ve destroyed an area the size of… Greece. Oh, and Greece? It’s on fire, too. We're surrounded by megafailure. 1/7
Tweet media one
443
4K
12K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
10 months
Suddenly, this summer, the planet seems to be on fire. Marine heatwaves, wildfires, heat domes, and none as dramatic as what’s unfolding in Greece. Welcome to the Pyrocene, the first era of the Age of Extinction. It’s the age of fire and it’s undeniably here. 1/6
Tweet media one
287
3K
9K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
10 months
The killing heat has arrived. People are literally being burned alive, collapsing on sun-scorched surfaces and dying from extreme burns because surfaces are just that hot. Yes, really. This isn't dystopian fiction, it's our reality. And it's only going to get worse. 1/6
Tweet media one
339
3K
8K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
9 months
Remember when Covid hit, and “we were all in it together"? Now? Covid isn't gone. But if you do take precautions, people will insult, mock, even harass you. We learned something grim from the pandemic: People won't change a thing about their lives, even for their own good. 1/6
327
1K
8K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
1 year
This “town hall” should live in infamy. It should be taught in journalism school and media programs as one of the lowest points there ever was. Trump is just on a rampage of lies and Kaitlin Collins is getting utterly trampled by them
351
2K
8K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
10 months
The world's on fire--literally. Look at Sicily. Greece. Canada. Oceans are boiling. Emissions are rising. I'm not homesick or lovesick--I’m planetsick. Furious at what we've done. Our planet is dying and we're to blame. Distinctions don’t matter. We did it. Homo sapiens. 1/6
Tweet media one
719
2K
7K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
10 months
This is the summer climate change got real, got scary, and it happened... unbelievably fast. Canada burning, heat domes scorching, floods roaring. Marine heatwaves with ocean temperatures off the charts, impacting everything from marine life to global heat storage. 1/8
Tweet media one
509
2K
5K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
10 months
We need to talk about wet bulb temperature. We're moving from the era of global warming to "the era of global boiling." In the not so distant future, we won't check just the temperature before we head outdoors — we’ll check the “heat index,” or the wet bulb temperature. 1/6
Tweet media one
242
2K
5K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
5 years
@FrankLuntz @ImperialVienna This is why the entire world thinks Americans are morons, and in your case they may have a point
26
120
4K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
2 years
No joke guys. I’ve lived it and I can tell you you are in a hardcore social collapse now. This is the real thing. That stunned sense of disbelief is what they want. Don’t let them have it. Organize and fight.
52
1K
5K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
4 years
guys as a survivor of authoritarianism I think you are in way deeper shit than you know, this bizarre RNC family business cult of hate is exactly how it happens. I mean *exactly*
69
2K
5K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
10 months
There’s a single statistic everyone in the world should know this summer: fossil fuel subsidies are ten times greater than climate finance.
216
2K
4K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
2 years
Musk wants to “authenticate” everyone which means Twitter has your personal info, Trump gets reinstated…you can see where this goes.
376
1K
4K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
2 years
A party that wanted to fight for democracy would lead a general strike. It’d impeach and remove justices for lying under oath. It’d pack the court and more. This is not a game anymore guys. This is a moment that needs serious leadership not this horseshit from the Dems
139
1K
4K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
10 months
It’s a little bit weird that the planet’s burning and we’re not doing much of anything about it
459
841
4K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
10 months
Is this our first Extinction Summer? They're calling it a global heatwave. Temperature records are shattered. Floods roar globally, and so do wildfires. There are 3 things everyone should understand right now about our civilization, its climate, and where we go from here. 1/6
Tweet media one
702
2K
4K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
10 months
Call it the Great Gaslighting of the 2020s. "Climate change obsession's a mental disorder"? Meanwhile, the real world’s on fire. People are dying, and we're being told we care too much. The norm? Indifference. The message? "Learn to live with it." 1/6
Tweet media one
148
941
4K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
4 years
Alright. We need to talk about fascism and America. Finally, finally, finally, white pundits are starting to call this fascism, shocked and appalled, as if minorities and women haven’t been saying this for years.
107
1K
4K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
5 years
@thehill “Lunch debt”, what is even wrong with this country
13
134
4K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
2 years
It’s beyond guys. Next level. I predicted all the chaos but the way people embrace it, love death, hurting others, just for the sake of it...that takes even me by surprise. It’s really shocking to see this level of insanity and yes it is insane
53
468
4K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
10 months
Red alerts across Italy. The Acropolis, closed — because of the heat. America's coast-to-coast heat dome. Canada — still on fire. This is the summer climate change arrived, with a vengeance. Welcome to the coming age of climate regret. 1/6
Tweet media one
456
1K
3K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
2 years
I’ve had covid what? Maybe three times at this point? And I am fucked up. I am way less healthy than when the pandemic began. I suspect the same is true for most of us. And the more we get it the more damage it will do. We are playing with fire at this point.
104
637
3K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
2 years
Guys is it just me or there’s this weird confrontational energy out there? Like some weird ripple of anger pulsing through things. People seem really mad and on edge even more so than usual
228
254
3K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
9 months
Imagine a decade ago I told you, "Everything that can go wrong will go wrong. Climate change will accelerate, fascism will rise again. The economy will stagnate. A pandemic is coming. Oh and—have you heard of wet bulb temperature?" You'd have laughed at me. But here we are. 1/6
Tweet media one
179
660
3K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
4 years
If we were watching this in any other country, a head of state declaring pre emptive victory, and calling for the vote to be stopped, the word would be “coup.”
42
627
3K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
4 years
So if Jewish is now a nationality according to the fascists what exactly are American Jews? This kind of stuff should make us all shudder. It is the path to literal and textbook fascist atrocity
88
938
3K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
11 months
Remember when I'd say things like "our civilization is at breaking point" and "we're headed for collapse"? Yesterday I woke up to the headline that — LOL — Britain’s water system has, uh, literally collapsed. So here we we are. Knee deep in the Age of Collapse. 1/
20
490
3K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
11 months
The main question they will ask about our era is just exactly how did everything get so fucking stupid so fast
247
474
3K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
10 months
I don’t know what it’ll take. Ecocide? Wet bulb events? Agricultural and water system breakdown? It’s hard to say. Our grandkids are never going to forgive us, we haven’t lifted a finger yet as a civilization to stop any of it.
241
614
3K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
5 years
Seriously guys countries get leaders of a caliber like Warren, who have the smarts, the fight, the drive, the right intentions, maybe once in a generation...if they’re lucky. Don’t fuck this up guys.
66
485
2K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
11 months
When I got to Canada I was so messed up, so brutalized, by growing up in America—I was 16—I didn’t come out of my dorm room for like a month, maybe more. I was like Canadians can’t be this nice, there’s something really wrong here. LOL. But they were and then life was livable
140
260
2K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
3 years
It’s going to be really bad, because a lot of law enforcement in America is on the side of the fascists. Relying on it to police a wave of fascist terror is not going to work. It’s going to be ugly in ways Americans have never really lived through.
38
453
2K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
10 months
Not really sure what happens when the oceans start boiling and our politicians are like “I hate tree huggerss!!” and the biggest thing in the average person’s mind are movies about toys, lol if this is the end, it’s so much stupider than anyone imagined
156
460
2K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
9 months
See that chart? That's the US suicide rate--and it's on a steep, steep rise. Suicides in the U.S. are more common now than at any time since World War II. The growing despair of American life. Stressors are hitting from every angle, and we're only beginning to understand it. 1/6
Tweet media one
118
683
2K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
10 months
Everyone, meet 2023’s latest villain: the doomer. You see their pessimism ridiculed from the Guardian to the Washington Post. But are they really wrong about the climate crisis, or are we just unwilling to face the magnitude of the problem? 1/6
Tweet media one
115
485
2K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
2 years
Believe me when I tell you that for those of us who’ve studied and lived through actual fascist collapses, the situation in america is even worse than you think. It is as bad as it could possibly be. Don’t minimize or deny. This is a living nightmare and it now gonna get worse
69
720
2K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
9 months
"We learned something from the pandemic. And it isn’t a good something. We learned that people appear totally incapable of changing the smallest aspect of their lives for either their own good, or the common good. And worse, if you point any of that out, you’re the bad guy."
@umairh
❤️ Umair
9 months
I just published The Age of the Breaking of the Human Spirit
8
25
89
103
541
2K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
2 years
I don’t know guys. I have this feeling lately. Creepy, deep, scary. Of *wrongness**. Something is not right with people anymore. I don’t know if you’ve felt it too. They’re not the same anymore. Something in them broke not so long ago. They don’t care about anything anymore.
243
229
2K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
11 months
You've probably seen the chart below by now. It's the IMF confirming that greedflation, something I wrote about a year ago, is very, very real. And that’s…a Very Big Deal. Because what’s rising in the world today is what I’ve come to call Idiotnomics. (1/9)
Tweet media one
42
776
2K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
4 years
This is from my dr wife again: “No really I don’t want your claps; I want you to stop voting in xenophobic, racist assholes who defund the healthcare system to the point of collapse!!!”
18
568
2K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
5 years
I’ve seen what three, four societies collapse into fascism firsthand. THIS IS HOW IT HAPPENS. Not just the violence of the bad guys. But the silence of the majority about what the bad guys really are. DON’T BE SILENT. Call this EXACTLY what it is.
18
785
2K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
3 years
You will not get another chance at this, trust me. You are lucky to have this one. You take on the fascists now, you assume your responsibilities culturally, socially, economically, remove them from normal life. Or they go on terrorizing you in escalating violence and impunity.
24
577
2K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
1 year
"The biggest insurance company in the country can’t absorb the risks of climate change. And we’ve barely even begun to experience it. It’s just 2023. That is how dire shape we’re in. Our systems already can’t cope."
244
859
2K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
5 years
This is the line, guys. You take responsibility for your society or the fascists take it over. It’s very simple. They are literally killing kids in camps.
9
449
2K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
2 years
We are seriously, severely underestimating the risk of extinction, how catastrophic “climate change” is and will be. The hard truth is we’re a civilization running out of the basics, water food air and energy now. No plan for tomorrow. Trying desperately to ignore it all.
171
447
2K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
8 months
Here's a startling fact: the first "global stocktake" on climate change just happened, and its conclusions are chilling. Our planet? Off track. We're headed for a temperature rise of up to 2.6°C. A century's progress? Reversing. The age we're entering? Unimaginable to many. 1/7
Tweet media one
60
665
2K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
3 years
The privatization of covid vaccines is a crime against humanity which is going to cause death on the scale of a world war
@ProSyn
Project Syndicate
3 years
The right to compulsory licensing of intellectual property to protect public health was already agreed in 2001 and extended to exports in 2005, notes @JeffDSachs . Given #COVID19 , the case for #IP waivers is even stronger today.
1
50
110
8
490
2K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
10 months
Consider this. Climate diplomacy is about to get very real, and that’ll lead to conflict. The next stage of the Pyrocene, where things get really ugly, is yet to come. Are we ready? 6/6
32
290
2K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
10 months
Wet bulb events are knocking on our door - a condition where the human body can't cool itself anymore. Just go outside, stay there for a couple of hours, and you…die. A prediction set for 2050, but we’re on the cusp this summer. Why aren't we talking about this more? 2/6
18
303
2K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
9 months
We learned something from the pandemic. And it isn’t a good something. We learned that people appear incapable of changing, even a tiny bit, for the common good. That they appear truculently indifferent, selfish, and worse, if you point any of that out, you’re the bad guy. 3/6
28
272
2K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
10 months
What's happening is just the beginning at 1.2 degrees of warming. Orange skies over America, unbreathable air, continent-wide megafires. But our minds struggle to connect "a burning planet" with "1.2 degrees warmer on average." Nonlinearities are hard to unpick. 4/6
4
227
2K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
10 months
On Greek islands, megafires are breaking out and tens of thousands rush to beaches for evacuation. The images are haunting. Embers flying, air turning unbreathable, masses of confused and panicked people with nowhere left to go. This is a portrait of climate emergency. 2/6
Tweet media one
5
239
2K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
5 years
The Dems need to put American collapse in a global frame and point out hard right economics led America to become a poor country. But they don’t do that. They buy into the idea they have to justify things to the right, not that the right has to justify things to reality
31
551
2K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
5 years
How insanely narcissistic do you have to be to compare yourself to the holocaust for being mocked on twitter when (wait for it) *there are uhhhh actual fascists putting kids in camps where they don’t get medicine or soap*
17
281
1K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
4 years
I understand all this is new and frightening and bewildering to Americans. Please take it from us survivors, a head of state giving public orders to fascist paramilitaries is literally as bad a situation as a democracy can be in.
12
506
2K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
10 months
Look at Florida, a perfect example of this madness. Climate change is wreaking havoc on it, but it's turning…fascist. In less than 4 years, they’ve gone from banning the word gay to teaching that slavery... wasn’t so bad. This is where we are. 6/6
29
309
2K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
4 years
@CNNSotu @jaketapper You’re invoking...Mr Rogers...to ask us to have sympathy for dudes who put...kids in cages? And you don’t see the horrific and mind-bending irony?
6
126
1K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
9 months
Yesterday, I opened Twitter to glance at the world. Apocalypse greeted me. Huge clouds of smoke & ash. Flames ripping through towns. Lahaina left to nothing, 36 dead. This is our reality. We are in a civilizational emergency. But we’re still in denial about it. 1/8
Tweet media one
336
325
2K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
4 years
When Trump basically tells you he wants a hard coup if the soft one fails, which is what “please kill my opponents ha ha” means, you should listen closely and understand just how much peril american democracy is really in. This is its absolute last chance.
21
400
2K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
10 months
I've been saying lately that everything the far right touches dies. Well, this chart is proof. Britain, once vaunted and admired, is now collapsing. Its economy’s in tatters, society’s fractured, and pessimism reigns. Let me explain. 1/6
Tweet media one
42
502
2K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
10 months
It's not just the Greek islands. It's only the start of Europe’s fire season. And in America? People are falling on burning hot pavement and dying of burns. Add Canada’s coast-to-coast fires and mega-heat around the globe, you see a civilization truly entering the Pyrocene. 3/6
9
189
1K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
10 months
I don’t know when the average person is gonna figure out the reason the planet’s boiling is that we’ve done literally nothing at a serious level economically judicially politically to stop emissions, which is ludicrous and horrifying with you think about it
125
382
1K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
3 years
Americans need to understand just how how crucial this moment really is. If appeasement and complicity are chosen now, nothing can undo it. The fascists will have won, and whatever remains of democracy will be little but theatre, a joke, an excuse.
22
455
1K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
10 months
The impact? Insurance systems already failing. Banking systems next. Water systems barely coping. Healthcare systems stretched. Crop failures. The destruction of arable land. As one Greek professor said, "I don’t think they'll be able to operate this year..." 5/6
4
183
1K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
8 months
It was (is?) an apocalyptic summer, and the news isn't getting better. Startling new research concludes that up to a billion people could be lost to climate change. That's bigger than... any war, any plague. 1/7
Tweet media one
187
513
1K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
4 years
Trump never should have awakened the gay disco gods by playing YMCA for fascism and thus inviting their wrath. That’s another major lesson here
26
217
1K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
9 months
It took us millennia to discover scientific miracles like vaccines, masks, and sanitizers. Now we’re not using a single one. Meanwhile, Covid rages on — yet another wave’s arriving. The elderly, ill, frail, immunocompromised are... sacrificed to it. 2/6
135
220
1K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
5 years
Literally the entire American media and thinking class will talk today—half of it *seriously*—about buying Greenland. Not a single one will learn a single lesson of Scandinavian social democracy. That my friends is why America is the dumbest country in the world
42
279
1K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
9 months
Now think about climate change. If people can't wash their hands and wear masks for a deadly virus, what chance is there they're going to do anything about... a boiling planet? 4/6
33
202
1K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
3 years
It’s a mistake to see this as some kind of last desperate gasp. It’s the opposite. Fascists storming the capitol tells you how committed they are to violence, and how little they think of democracy. This isn’t an end. It’s the new beginning Trump wanted all along.
24
532
1K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
10 months
When I read about bleached corals and animals burned alive in mega fires and beached whale pods I just feel bereft. I think all these creatures deserve to live.
94
236
1K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
1 month
Everywhere I look, I see examples of languishing. Bright young professionals stuck in underemployment, middle-aged individuals in careers that once promised ascendancy now feeling trapped, and the elderly facing retirement in insecurity and isolation. 1/
30
243
1K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
4 years
What I can tell you is that when a head of state speaks this way, this openly, this hatefully, against the rudiments of democracy and for violence and brutality, you must understand it is not remotely normal. It’s rare even in failing states. It is a prelude to fascism.
23
382
1K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
4 years
I don’t know if Americans really understand that mass death and secret polices are clear signs of hardcore social collapse. But they should.
17
373
1K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
11 months
I have the feeling that from here things destabilize very very fast. I can’t shake that feeling and it’s a realllllly unsettling one.
116
139
1K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
10 months
Climate change is a civilizational emergency. Non-binding pledges and agreements, a media that won’t connect climate change to disasters, societies ignoring the realities – it's not enough. We need to wake up and transform. And we need to do it now. 6/6
54
369
1K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
10 months
We're in the Age of the Idiot. Those with power have made a fools’ bargain with lunacy in the name of “fairness.” But...who is that fair to? The truth? Democracy? Reason? Or the Centrists, who gain power by appeasing the far right?
8
207
1K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
9 months
Meanwhile, we're all trying to make ends meet while cartoon villain level billionaires sweep up the gains in the economy. We used to live in an age of breakdown; now we live in an age of meltdown. And our faith in humanity has been shaken to the core.
14
143
1K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
10 months
Anyone who dared to bring up this reality last year was dismissed, scorned, even mocked. "Alarmist," they said. "Lunatic," they laughed. But as we hit the limits of human livability, these dismissed voices are gaining validity. It's about time. 3/6
5
147
1K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
3 years
Like I said, it’s just a feeling in my gut. But I can’t shake it. This is so not how a nation should behave after narrowly escaping a full blown fascist collapse.
55
196
1K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
5 years
Does anyone wanna tell me why the Dems are cool with people uh “ignoring” subpoenas
66
250
1K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
2 years
I just published It’s Not That I’m an Alarmist… It’s That You Might Be an Idiot
71
375
1K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
10 months
Let’s ask a few questions that just the last few months raise. How does Canada…stop burning? Some say that its only the arrival of the winter snows that’ll put the flames out. But does that mean that giant smoke plumes over America are now…part of what summer is? (1/7)
Tweet media one
145
499
1K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
9 months
Wildfires are wreaking havoc through Hawaii. Billowing clouds of smoke and ash. People yelling "go, go, we can't do anything for her!" Others left for dead. People, jumping into the ocean  to survive. Climate change is a civilizational emergency. 1/8
82
490
1K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
4 years
I don't think I've heard a single American pundit express the slightest bit of remorse or humility for minimising the dangers of Trumpism, much less attacking those of us who warned of them. It's a kind of profound statement that they could give a shit about anything themselves
33
308
1K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
10 months
While these messengers of truth were dismissed, who was seizing power? The Fanatics, aided by... the Centrists. Those who consider their job mediating between two sides, crafting comfortable compromises for themselves with lunatics, leaving the rest of us on a burning planet. 4/6
4
179
1K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
5 years
I’m so old I remember when Hillary warned us about trump and all the very same white dude pundits who are now hysterical about trump attacked her and mocked her for it
@reproforall
Reproductive Freedom for All
5 years
Secretary @HillaryClinton : "The occupant of the White House poses a clear and present danger to our future. We have known who Donald Trump is for a long time now. We are at a crossroads right now, and that's especially true for reproductive freedom." #NARAL50
Tweet media one
20
140
443
22
314
1K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
11 months
Why don’t the 1% care about Extinction — aka the mega-scale impacts of climate change? There are two answers to that, the simple one, and the deep one. The simple one — and it’s a good enough answer, too — goes like this. Money and power.
94
322
1K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
5 years
I don’t wanna focus on it today since I write about it all the time but today alone you see American collapse full scale. How failed institutions multiply one another. Press glorifying bona fide authoritarians who...abuse the press. A democracy can’t survive this way.
33
331
1K
@umairh
❤️ Umair
1 year
There’s not a lot else to say at this point. This is social collapse. You’re living it. But the majority is also strangely accepting of it. That paradox is really what dooms some societies never to be able to recover
30
222
1K