Stay indoors. But also return in person. Wear a mask. Not that one. The expensive one, that you can’t find. Take rapid tests. Which you also can’t find. But if you find them, don’t buy them. Rapid tests don’t work. You need PCR. There are zero appointments in your area.
Here’s what people really want from tech:
• Instagram – chronological timeline
• Spotify – let us block artists
• Amazon – don’t create an inescapable surveillance panopticon
• Facebook – don’t end democracy
• Snap – more filters
Lizzo, a Black female superstar, collaborating with Carla Hayden, the first African American and first woman Librarian of Congress, to use a flute from James Madison, the Founding Father who originated the 3/5 Compromise and also the Library of Congress itself? The symbolism!!!
Some personal news: I have accepted a new position as content moderator for all my family and friends, as they send each other coronavirus misinformation and rumors.
Do men know there’s also a whisper network for good men? Like, do they know women also tell each other about the men who are allies and advocates for women, and we share specific stories about why they’re great? And we recommend them for jobs and opportunities. Do they know this!
This tweet is taking off, which, lol, sorry this is reverberating for all of you. We’re all in this together, I guess. Even the antivaxxers, whether they believe it or not!
I close my emails with “Best.” Best what? You assume regards, but it’s waffles. I am wishing you best waffles at the end of every email. You’re welcome.
To the Big Law associate who sat next to me and worked on a brief for an entire 7-hour flight: Good luck on the case! Also, unrelatedly, please get yourself a privacy screen.
If you need N95/KN95/KF94s, check out
@projectn95
Also search office & building supply stores: Staples, HomeDepot, etc.
Be careful w/Amazon & online shops you don’t know.
Manufacturers sometimes link to authorized sites too.
@3M
:
This is a big deal. Cambridge Analytica accessed Facebook user data w/o authorization, using that data for the tailored voter analysis that decided the 2016 election.
Serving on a hiring committee last year taught me how much of a job search is really out of your control as a candidate. You could be incredibly qualified, but whether you get hired might depend on factors you have no idea about at all.
For many reasons, this event would not have been what James Madison or many of his contemporaries would have wished for or expected from the future. But this is the future now. We can make the future what we want it to be—more vibrant, more just, more equitable, more free.
I’ve been in so many rooms where someone will talk about, like, how a colleague stood up for her in a meeting, and then other women chime in to tell positive stories they’ve heard about this man, and it becomes accepted knowledge that this man is good. Do men know we do this
I just think it’s neat how we’ve safely preserved this historical item belonging to an important, complex, historical figure, and this is how we choose to bring history alive to the public, imbuing the flute and the concert and the people involved with new meanings. Symbolism!
Elon making himself a national security risk to get CIFIUS to block the Twitter sale is maybe not the legal strategy I would’ve advised, but let’s see how this plays out
Reminder: When you give your DNA data to companies like or 23andMe, you give up not only your own genetic privacy, but that of your entire family. (It’s in the terms & conditions.)
HT
@xeni
If I’m reading this correctly, the EO claims tech platforms are doing something they’re not, in violation of an incorrect interpretation of law, and tasks agencies it can’t task to look into the things that aren’t being done that wouldn’t be wrong. Anything I missed,
@Klonick
?
You do not need a STEM background to become a tech lawyer. But you do need to learn enough about tech to be able to competently represent your clients.
Here is an extremely short list of books I recommend for law students and lawyers who want to gain foundational tech knowledge:
Childhood behaviors absolutely do not determine adult futures, but also, when I was a kid, I arranged my stuffed animals into tiers of governance, with local and federal representatives, and now I'm a law professor.
Anyway, I’ve somehow made another thread again while trying to just post an offhand comment, but listen:
If you are a man and you’ve been putting in the work, know that the women around you appreciate it. Even if you don’t hear it directly from them. Word spreads quickly.
James Madison was America’s 4th president. He helped shape the US Constitution and the Bill of Rights. He was also a slave owner, and he created the 3/5 Compromise (that each enslaved person would count as 3/5 of a person for state electoral vote totals). A complicated legacy.
Must be nice to have always had your rights “deeply rooted in history,” never knowing what it’s like to live as a woman, POC, LGBT, disabled, or otherwise marginalized person, fearing that, with the stroke of a pen, your rights could be taken away from you.
Alito's draft opinion explicitly criticizes Lawrence v. Texas (legalizing sodomy) and Obergefell v. Hodges (legalizing same-sex marriage). He says that, like abortion, these decisions protect phony rights that are not "deeply rooted in history."
Why was this released 9:30 PM Friday on St. Patrick’s Day weekend? Because the implications are that none of your data was/is safe on Facebook and, yes, FB data directly helped swing the election.
Katalin Karikó was overlooked for decades.
She struggled to get funding. She didn’t get tenure.
But she believed in her ideas and continued her work.
Her research on mRNA went on to save millions of lives.
Today she has won the Nobel Prize.
It’s easy for lawyers to make fun of people invoking HIPAA incorrectly, but if nothing else, it shows that we expect a lot more health privacy than our laws currently protect. That’s a problem.
Lotta jokes out there about
#notallmen
, but it’s hard for dudes! They’ve also been taught outdated concepts about gender and what it means to be a man, and they have to figure out how to be allies and supporters. Outdated gender concepts are harmful for everyone.
MSNBC, NBC, ABC, CBS, NPR all cut off Trump’s broadcast, stopping the spread of his disinformation-filled speech.
Tech is fed up. The media is fed up. America is fed up.
@MattLevy51
People frequently give away like half of a leftover grocery store sheet cake. I once told this to a friend assuming she’d be shocked, but it turned out said friend was actually a BuyNothing half-eaten cake picker-upper.
The labor story is bigger than just the delivery strikes today.
GE workers protesting to switch production to ventilators.
Instacart, Amazon, and Whole Foods workers striking for hazard pay and sick leave.
Kaiser nurses protesting for
#GetMePPE
.
This is how movements begin.
I vividly remember a staff meeting where people applauded a coworker for cutting parental leave short and coming back just a week after his baby was born 🚩 🚩 🚩
I've heard of at least 3 companies giving shout-outs to employees who missed the birth of their child to take a work call or trip.
Missing the most important moments of your life for work isn't a flex, it's just sad. And it's the company's fault for creating that culture.
This makes sense if you view verified badges as status symbols and not what they were supposed to be: trust marks to certify identity so people can rely on what they see being said on Twitter. It’s a plan that makes sense if truth/trust on social media doesn’t matter to you.
Some news from inside Elon’s war room: Twitter is strongly considering making verified users pay $4.99 a month to keep their badges.
Many questions remain. Subscribe to read ➡️
American recommendation letters: “This candidate is the most brilliant person alive. I will never in my entire life have a student as smart as this one again.”
European recommendation letters: “This person completed the requirements for my class. They are currently alive.”
Nothing to see here, just the President of the United States abusing the power of the office to control private business and get a cut for his personal interests, which include teaching American children an alternate version of history as part of “patriotic education.”
NEWS: Trump wants $5 billion from companies creating a new U.S.-based TikTok venture directed toward teaching American children “real history, not the fake history.”
Story by me,
@MarioDParker
@josh_wingrove
So much to say about
#WhereIsPengShuai
, but there’s one thing people are missing:
The story of tennis players rallying around Peng Shuai is a fierce example of the power of professional ethics and worker advocacy.
A few privacy questions for
#Neuralink
:
• What data is collected? How? Where?
• How is the data used, processed, stored, and deleted?
• Who can access the data—at all stages?
• Can the data be transferred or sold? To whom?
• What data rights do users have, if any?
I’m confused. Did all 50 state data breach notification laws suddenly stop existing, and also the FTC stopped existing, and the GDPR stopped existing too?
Because that’s the only scenario where this doesn’t land Facebook in a heap of legal trouble.
Abortion is a privacy issue. Contraception is a privacy issue. Gay marriage is a privacy issue. All of these rights stem from our belief that individuals possess a fundamental right to privacy over their own bodies and autonomy for their own choices. All of this is at risk now.
This draft opinion overturning Roe and Casey is not just an imminent threat to women— it is a broad attack on the right to privacy and the fundamental rights enjoyed by women and sexual minorities. Nobody is safe from the United States Supreme Court’s radicalism. Nobody.
@rebeccaga0
@karenkho
Inspired by your tweet, I looked up tofu through the decades and found this 1996 WaPo trend piece that doesn’t include a single Asian person but does include 3 truly terrible recipes, including “tofu-stuffed French toast.”
To be fair, the privacy violations stem from a 3rd party app. Arguably, the problem is Facebook app review. But allowing 3rd party apps to access/transfer this much personal data is a failure in Privacy by Design (
@AnnCavoukian
).
Coronavirus is already in most of the continental U.S. Closing borders now—literally or through travel restrictions—will not stop the pandemic. It will only help those who always wanted America to be an isolationist, nationalist state without free and open movement.
OK, I can’t turn off professor mode, so I’ll drop some links on James Madison’s complicated legacy. We can debate the meaning and impact of the 3/5 Compromise or Madison’s legacy, and, indeed, this is the kind of thing I discuss with my law students. These are good questions! 🧵
For anyone teaching hacker culture this fall,
@HackCurio
(founded by
@BiellaColeman
) is an excellent collection of free resources, with video and context:
Update: I’m happy to report I’ll be joining the faculty at
@UNHLaw
as an Assistant Professor this fall!
I’m grateful to everyone who has supported me along the way, including everyone at
@yaleisp
and
@BU_Law
❤️
🎉 I’m officially on the market for a TT law professor job this year! 🎉
Please reach out if your school is looking for:
(1) a privacy, tech, and IP law scholar,
(2) with a proven record of academic and public impact, and
(3) a deep comitment to students, service, and society.
Lot of comments saying people would be fine w/giving up their family DNA data, if it helps catch a serial killer. Be careful: this same rationale can justify almost any invasion of privacy. Think facial recognition, iPhone backdoors, etc.
For "Intro to Data Privacy" this year, I wanted to show students a brief glimpse of the breadth of privacy perspectives in law. I offered a selection of readings and asked students to choose just one to read/skim and share insights with the class.
Here's the list of readings:
Honestly, go for it. Never blindly agree with experts, including me. Critique everything, including this thread. Educate yourself on our shared history and participate in our democratic discourse. You have the right to freedom of speech. Use it for good.
Big news from Amazon, following up on IBM's announcement also cancelling some of its facial recognition business. Could be the start of a wave—and a win for privacy and civil liberties advocates.
“The outbreak was traced back to an outdoor pre-orientation party for PharmD students on August 2nd.”
Outdoors, masked except when eating, at a school with a 94% vaccination rate.
Stay safe, everyone.
Everyone making fun of that brief with fake ChatGPT cites should be ashamed of themselves. ChatGPT worked hard on its J.D. from Duke and scored a 177 on the LSAT (99th percentile).
The SIFT method from
@infodemicblog
is simple and useful to share with others.
S I F T
-Stop.
-Investigate the source.
-Find better coverage.
-Trace claims, quotes, and media to the original context.
ht
@WillOremus
Aggressive hustle culture is annoying, but so is aggressive wellness culture. It’s great to tell folks to stop working on the weekends. But things are not going to change until we fix the systemic issues that incentivize overwork.
Legal issues:
-Could qualify as a data breach from Facebook (state law)
-Could be criminal or civil fraud - by Cambridge Analytica & co, not FB
-Could be a CFAA violation - also by CA, not FB (HT
@markpmckenna
)
-Almost definitely open for FTC action - all parties
I wish
@Twitter
had a preview option to let you know how drafts would look in the timeline, especially with the random and inexplicable cropping choices of the photo thumbnail algorithm.
This shouldn’t dissuade you from applying! Try your best anyway. Just know that if you do get rejected, it’s not a sign that you’re a bad candidate. So many things are outside of your control. Keep trying!
Cool! So all you need to do to have privacy is just wear this microphone jammer bracelet and apply some anti-facial-recognition makeup and put on some adversarial AI prints with thermal imaging blocking fabric and….
@nytimes
on our Wearable Microphone Jammer (see it in action here: ). it uses ultrasound to disable surrounding microphones from recording you; lead by Heather Zheng &
@ravenben
with Yuxin Chen, Huiying Li,
@tengshanyuan
, Steven Nagels and I ->
#chi2020
1/N
Today I started my Internet Law class by comparing quotes from Trump and Biden on Section 230 and telling students that, by the end of class, they would know more about the law than both U.S. presidents. And most members of Congress.
Every software developer knows that almost all new tech is based on, includes, or references old, reused, copied, and/or free and open source code. FOSS is how the software industry rose to dominance. Copyright is not the incentive for innovation in code.
#googacle
Google isn't neutral. Facebook isn't neutral. Twitter isn't neutral. That's not what their purpose is.
You know what's neutral? Libraries. Libraries provide free, equal access to knowledge. They lift communities w/classes, programs, & safe, open spaces. Support libraries.
The internet is more than top-level, consumer-facing apps and sites. But learning about internet architecture and infrastructure can be intimidating.
Here are some readings I assigned to my Internet Law students to demystify the topic 🧵:
Amazon rep: “This was an extremely rare occurrence.“
So we’ll just take your word for it then?
This is why we need transparency and accountability on privacy. Esp for tech cos like Amazon that are omnipresent in consumer lives AND also supply tech/services to gov/military/LE.
Thrilled to announce I will be joining
@usflaw
as an Associate Professor of Law starting this year! I'm excited to join an institution dedicated to making the world a better place. I'm also looking forward to returning to the Bay Area!
#BestCoast
Facebook also released this statement conveniently on the same day that
@profcarroll
's lawsuit against Cambridge Analytica was officially filed. (Link is an
@aprilaser
explainer from Oct 2017.)
AI emotion recognition does not work. Period.
The tech isn’t ready. The research isn’t there. Privacy and human rights are at risk.
More research is good, but Apple needs to give users freedom to opt in/out of emotion recognition, and more transparency and accountability.
For instance, here are 10 moods the iPhone can now infer about you based on what you type. They include “anxiety” “anger” “positive” and “death”. UCLA could be among the first researchers to get access to these metrics. (7/n)
@thebestsophist
@hypervisible
Been there. It’s a 3-character minimum, because of course no surnames are shorter, especially not in one of the most populous cultures in the world.
@annehelen
It’s a risk-averse strategy that maximizes chances of finishing the game vs. chances of finishing in the fewest steps. Yes, I have thought about this too much.
Whether this qualifies as a data breach (thus triggering data breach notification laws) is a good Q. One factor = if the unauthorized transfer of data collected w/consent qualifies as unauthorized acquisition by Cambridge Analytica.
Stop using FaceApp because there are no controls on how your face data is used.
But also—walking around anywhere can get your face included in facial recognition databases.
So … stop going outside?
This privacy protection model doesn’t work.
Millennials thought 9/11 was our generation’s defining moment. And then the 2016 election. And now the pandemic. But it’s only 2020, and we’re not even 40 yet.
Here is my syllabus for the very idiosyncratic privacy law class I’m teaching this fall at Yale.
“The Changing Right to Privacy” looks at privacy from diverse, interdisciplinary perspectives – inc. philosophy, ethics, history, policy, & critical theory.
Of course the animals still went on magical fantasy adventures, but perhaps the greatest adventure of them all was participation in a representative democracy backed by the rule of law ✨
In my talk on Biometric Privacy at
@defcon
@cryptovillage
last year, I explained some of the privacy threats of brain-computer interfaces like
#Neuralink
.
Link to my talk:
🎉 I’m officially on the market for a TT law professor job this year! 🎉
Please reach out if your school is looking for:
(1) a privacy, tech, and IP law scholar,
(2) with a proven record of academic and public impact, and
(3) a deep comitment to students, service, and society.