"For decades, we’ve been told that closing
#nuclear
plants is a good thing, yet a growing body of research shows that it’s far safer and cleaner than coal and gas." (1)
"When it comes to flooding, we’d rather live in a warmed climate with flood protection than live in a preindustrial climate with preindustrial flood protection."
Read
@PatrickTBrown31
on flood exposure and risk:
"Every unit of clean electricity from a nuclear power plant requires excavating just 30% or 23% the mass of rock and metal, compared to an equal unit of solar or onshore wind electricity."
Read
@wang_seaver
on the mining impacts of clean energy
@TheBTI
:
With the passage of the Inflation Reduction Act,
@fredstaffordcs
argues it’s time to revive a New Deal politics of public power—one in which nuclear energy and the Tennessee Valley Authority should be front and center:
Climate change is not like an asteroid: it doesn't happen all at once. There isn't one specific deadline we can point to.
A better metaphor? Climate change is like diabetes: a long-term condition that requires ongoing care.
@TedNordhaus
@atrembath
When
#nuclear
reactors are taken off the grid, fossil fuel use — and the emissions that come with them — consistently increase.
Will shutting down Diablo Canyon, which generates more than all of CA’s wind and half of its solar power be any different?
.
@SuzyHobbsBaker
: "Advanced nuclear reactors must be thoughtful. They must be iconic. They must be beautiful. We have to get it right from the beginning."
#WholeEarthDiscipline
The NRC announced that Diablo Canyon is allowed to operate while its owners & regulators go through the painstaking process of determining what special actions are needed to keep it running for another 20 years. This is a big deal for the NRC - here's why:
Eating meat comes with lots of externalities to consider, including its land-use intensity.
Cultivated meats, in comparison, are 98% less land intensive than beef per 100 grams of protein.
Learn more about meat alternatives in our new report:
"We can take inspiration from the 'defund the police' movement. What if we expand our thinking and find money to fund renewables by defunding the $20 billion in fossil fuel subsidies every year?" -
@leahstokes
#BTIWebinar
Efforts to close Diablo Canyon relied on a preposterous claim: that it would be cheaper to close the plant—which provides 10% of CA’s electricity—and replace it with RE and energy efficiency investments.
It's worth interrogating the basis of that claim:
Premature shutdowns of nuclear plants in developed countries have caused additional annual CO2 emissions equal to combined annual emissions from 37 African countries, find
@OSGuido
and
@wang_seaver
:
"Norway is effectively telling Africa: We’ll stay rich, keep you from developing, and send some charity your way as long as you keep your emissions down." — BTI's
@vijramachandran
in
@ForeignPolicy
:
Meat and dairy alternatives are much more climate-friendly than all animal-based foods—even chicken produced in the US—when the carbon opportunity cost of production is accounted for, writes
@SaloniShah101
:
On a regular day in 1965,
@stewartbrand
put on his jumpsuit, top hat, and sandwich board, and set off to the UC Berkeley campus armed with buttons he had made for distribution.
Seeing Different: a series inspired by our 2019 Paradigm Award Winner.
Delighted to announce
@charlesjkenny
as our 2022 Paradigm Award winner!
His work on human development and the economics of happiness are foundational components of this summer's
@TheBTI
Dialogue theme: “Progress Problems.”
Learn more here:
If we are to successfully
#decarbonize
, we’ll need a lot of reactors. Getting there will require a smoother, faster process from
#design
to flipping the switch - part of that has to be the NRC making timely decisions, as it did in the case of Vogtle 3:
Nuclear power plant closures consistently result in increased emissions.
In the case of San Onofre Nuclear Power Plant, it meant an additional 37 million metric tons of additional emissions for California.
Learn more:
"The first full month without [Indian Point] has seen a 46% increase in the average carbon intensity of statewide electric generation compared to when the [nuclear plant] was fully operational" —
@sunraysunray
When nuclear plants close, emissions rise.
California gave waivers to natural gas plants that were slated to close because they use ocean water for cooling.
No such waiver was offered to Diablo Canyon — despite it being the state’s largest source of
#CleanEnergy
.
@TedNordhaus
@jamesonmcb
California gave waivers to natural gas plants that were slated to close because they use ocean water for cooling.
No such waiver was offered to Diablo Canyon — despite it being the state’s largest source of
#CleanEnergy
.
@TedNordhaus
@jamesonmcb
The actual technological pathways to deeply decarbonizing the entire global economy are few and far between, writes
@TedNordhaus
.
Nuclear is without question one of them.
Decarbonization requires more mining. How much more depends on the energy technologies used.
A new
@TheBTI
report concludes all clean energy technologies are leagues better than fossil fuels, with nuclear energy having the smallest mining footprint:
"When nations build nuclear plants, emissions reliably fall and when they shut them down, as we’ve witnessed over the last decade in Japan and California, they reliably rise."
@TedNordhaus
cuts through anti-nuclear "bullshit" in his latest piece:
Climate feedback loops garner lots of attention, but less-appreciated social feedback loops affect the generation of climate science itself, with serious consequences.
Read
@PatrickTBrown31
's piece for Breakthrough Journal on the meta-science of climate:
Chicken without the bird? David Kay of
@MemphisMeats
explains that meat requires 23 calories of inputs for every calorie of output, so cell-based meat can significantly lessen the environmental impacts of our food system.
#Ecomodernism2018
"Every indication suggests that the
@californiapuc
should carefully review both its medium-term grid reliability planning and its decision to force Diablo Canyon’s retirement," writes BTI's
@Dr_A_Stein
:
"To electrify everything, from our businesses to our homes, we will need nuclear energy."
BTI's Alex Trembath via this segment on growing pro-nuclear environmentalism from
@CBSMornings
'
@benstracy
:
The World Bank and IMF are getting it wrong on climate change; the poorest countries should not be forced to pivot to emissions reduction to qualify for loans,, argue
@vijramachandran
and
@AW_Baker
.
The Breakthrough Dialogue is one of the most important things we do at
@TheBTI
: we bring together our network, new friends, and critics, and talk about important environmental challenges facing our world today. This year's event starts today! Follow along with
#RisingTides
.
The externalities from animal agriculture, such as GHG emissions and health impacts, cost the American public at least $388 billion per year.
Alternatives to animal-based meat can help with that:
Watch now:
@TheBTI
's executive director
@TedNordhaus
testifying on Nuclear Regulatory Commission Reform before the House Energy and Commerce Committee:
Shutting down the Palisades nuclear power plant in Michigan will be equivalent to tearing down almost every wind turbine in the state, argue
@JonahMessinger
and
@RFMeraxes
:
"The real question is this: what are the trade-offs between the damages associated with mining for minerals needed for
#decarbonization
and the damages of not reducing
#emissions
?"
New analysis from
@TheBTI
's
@juzel_lloyd
👇
A New Day for Nuclear Advocacy…and Environmentalism? Union of Concerned Scientists Becomes First Major Environmental Group to Publicly Back Policy Support for Nuclear Energy
@TedNordhaus
’s latest
@TheBTI
If
@NuScale_Power
's reactors cost the anticipated amount, they'd be competitive with natural gas up to discount rates of 5% with reference gas prices, 7.5% with high gas prices, and 3% with low gas prices.
Learn more here:
In attempt to calculate risk, the Nuclear Regulatory Commission has been writing extreme "worse case" scenarios for years. However, this past year the NRC has staffed a new team of engineers who are calculating the unimaginable:
#BreakthroughInstitute
We calculate that each ton of carbon reduced in 2020 will come at the cost of $1,750 in reduced economic activity. This is more than an order of magnitude more expensive than clean energy technologies available today.
When
#nuclear
reactors are taken off the grid, fossil fuel use — and the emissions that come with them — consistently increase.
Will shutting down Diablo Canyon, which generates more than all of CA’s wind and half of its solar power be any different?
Nuclear power plant closures consistently result in increased emissions.
In the case of San Onofre Nuclear Power Plant, it meant an additional 37 million metric tons of additional emissions for California, write
@Dr_A_Stein
&
@jamesonmcb
:
Are cities the answer to our environmental problems? Maybe, but it's a big issue that deserves deep engagement.
#RisingTides
"I hope by the end of this session you are usefully confused." -
@CharlesCMann
"Air pollution is a very different challenge than climate change. It's highly local and regional, and mitigation has immediate impact." -
@erikolsonn
, summer fellow, in his final presentation.
BREAKING: BTI's
@jamesonmcb
and
@Dr_A_Stein
sent a letter to Rep. Nancy Pelosi, Sen. Chuck Schumer, Rep. Eddie Bernice Johnson, and Sen. Joe Manchin urging Congress to expand federal tax credits for clean energy to include advanced nuclear energy.
"State regulators are failing to eliminate fossil fuels from CA’s energy stock, and with alternatives lacking in scale,
@TheBTI
's experts believe a more realistic path to achieving CA’s climate goals is by salvaging our last nuclear facility." (2)
"And yet even faulty technical concepts and practices are difficult to move away from because of the climate industry that benefits from them -- and the heightened views of risk they support."
@JessicaWeinkle
for
@thebti
's Journal:
Nuclear power plant closures consistently result in increased emissions.
In the case of San Onofre Nuclear Power Plant, it meant an additional 37 million metric tons of additional emissions for California, write
@Dr_A_Stein
&
@jamesonmcb
.
Learn more:
Meat and dairy alternatives are much more climate-friendly than all animal-based foods—even chicken produced in the US—when the carbon opportunity cost of production is accounted for.
Read our analysis:
💡 Our new report, "Advancing Nuclear Energy," is out today!
We find that advanced
#nuclearenergy
can play a valuable role in the US
#cleanenergy
transition and national energy security.
Read the key findings here:
We're hosting a webinar with
@leahstokes
,
@vsiv
of
@ColumbiaUEnergy
, and
@atrembath
on the role of clean energy deployment policy and how existing solar and wind tech fits into pathways towards decarbonization.
6.4.20 10am PT / 1pm ET.
Register here:
NEW REPORT:
@wang_seaver
and
@juzel_lloyd
confront a glaring issue that the climate community and solar sector have avoided for too long:
Solar manufacturing in Xinjiang is linked to forced labor and environmental injustice, and we need to act.
Nuclear power plant closures consistently result in increased emissions.
In the case of San Onofre Nuclear Power Plant, it meant an additional 37 million metric tons of additional emissions for California, write
@Dr_A_Stein
&
@jamesonmcb
:
After a short hiatus, Breakthrough Journal will be relaunching on Substack. We will publish essays on topics relevant to climate politics, environmentalism, development, and more. Read our launch post, from
@TedNordhaus
,
@atrembath
, and
@alexjmssmith
here:
"If you wanna start up [the US nuclear industry] again, you’ve got to get serious about building new plants, about training the workforce, about developing a fuel supply that’s not dependent on Russia."
ICYMI,
@TedNordhaus
with
@CNBC
's
@SullyCNBC
:
Food insecurity is a persistent challenge in African countries with low farm productivity. Western govts and eNGOs must come to grips with the fact that African farmers needs more fertilizer.
Read
@vijramachandran
+
@alexjmssmith
in Breakthrough Journal:
If every American replaced 4 of every 10 meals containing beef with chicken or pork, it would reduce US agricultural emissions by ~20%.
But this shift affects beef producers, so rural communities must be part of the conversation.
@alexjmssmith
@danrejto
"In the film, the scientists are fully behind the technological alternative. In real life, many climate advocates and experts reject obvious technological solutions like zero-carbon nuclear power," writes
@atrembath
via
@ForeignPolicy
:
1. Our joint NGO comment on Part 53 to the
@NRCgov
has now been published on ! We're going to need a strong coalition of supporters to see real change in the rulemaking process for nuclear power.
Read the full comment below👇
The claims that growth is endless and the planet is finite aren't very useful. That doesn't mean future ecological collapse isn't possible, but it does mean we must change the kinds of questions we ask in order to build a resilient future.
@TedNordhaus
It’s the largest climate attitude survey ever conducted, with over 1.2 million respondents from 50 countries.
Unfortunately, it’s also not a very good survey — and that’s not by accident.
by
@KdeKirby
If you're looking to CA as a model for state-level climate action, look with a critical lens.
"It's accomplishments are illusory," writes Jennifer Hernandez, " products of deindustrialization, high energy costs, and, more recently, depopulation."
"There can be no prosperity in a region wracked by extreme energy poverty. And putting restrictions on the energy choices of the people who need it the most is deeply unethical."
@gyude_moore
on energy injustice on the African continent
"Solar in India is up to 50% cheaper than in the US. We can learn from India how to deploy clean energy more cheaply in the US. We should consider different policies beyond tax credits and loan guarantees to ramp up deployment faster." -
@vsiv
#BTIWebinar
"Our state will need Diablo Canyon’s electrical generation to keep the lights on, and Gov. Gavin Newsom should be leading the charge to accomplish that."
New from BTI's
@Dr_A_Stein
and
@atrembath
in
@CalMatters
:
"The most efficient and effective energy transition on record was achieved by central planners deciding how and where to invest."
Great piece from
@EricLevitz
citing our
@jamesonmcb
:
Most state Renewable Portfolio Standards expire in 3-5 years. As states revise their decarbonization mandates, they should consider
#CleanEnergyStandards
, which would enable much higher targets. It's a huge opportunity for state-level climate leadership:
“It’s not fair to tell poor countries you need to stop when richer countries are simultaneously increasing their fossil fuel capacity.”
—
@vijramachandran
#EcomodernJustice
Faster-growing, genetically-engineered trees used for timber production could effectively mitigate climate change by reducing deforestation, writes BTI's
@EmmaKovak
:
“As environmentalists, we know that to get serious about climate change, we need to radically transform how we get our energy. But we also need to transform our thinking around solutions that will help reach our goals – such as nuclear power.”
@J_Lovering
:
"Given the historic trends of falling clean energy costs and strengthening climate policy, it seems unlikely that we will remain in a current policy-type world for the remainder of the 21st century," writes
@hausfath
.
It’s time to accelerate that trend.
We at
@TheBTI
deeply value two-sided conversations that move beyond tribalism and into pragmatic action. We want to unstick the sticking points and come up with new, productive frameworks. Here are some of the ways we do that. 1/7
Nuclear power plant closures have consistently resulted in increased emissions.
Closing the San Onofre Nuclear Power Plant, for example, generated 37 million metric tons of additional emissions for California, write
@Dr_A_Stein
&
@jamesonmcb
:
Advanced
#nuclear
tech can produce power on demand, but without emissions or air pollution — a valuable complement for sometimes-available renewables like solar and wind.
Here's how policymakers can pave the way for this critical
#cleanenergy
technology
The five fastest historical decarbonization rates over a ten-year period have all been achieved in nationalized and centralized energy systems.
Public power as a climate strategy:
@jamesonmcb
Making carbon-free electricity isn't hard, but matching it to consumer demand every minute, of every day, of every season is.
@MattLWald
explains how thermal energy storage can help
#nuclearenergy
generators with this tricky problem:
“Ocean heat content is, in many ways, our best measure of the effect of climate change on the earth."
Our Director of Climate & Energy,
@hausfath
, in
@nytimes
from
@KendraWrites
: