Noam Chomsky tells an Edinburgh Book Festival audience that Vladimir Putin should be given the benefit of the doubt on his motives for invading Ukraine, and that he (Chomsky) supports Scottish independence. The audience, which must be overwhelmingly idiots, whoops and cheers.
“So… what? We’re just meant to accept that a big kid did it and ran away?”
Pointed questions from
@GlennBBC
and embarrassing evasions from
@_KateForbes
.
Ian Blackford delivers the best joke of the Edinburgh Fringe, by telling his “in conversation” audience that there are no economic downsides to Scottish independence.
Lorna Slater today fled the chamber to avoid listening to Liam Kerr’s point of order, which cited irrefutable evidence that either Slater has misled the Scottish Parliament, or Michael Matheson has misled Westminster’s Scottish Affairs Committee. (Video part 1/3)
Interestingly, many people (correctly) pointing out that Yes Scotland and the SNP had to be legally completely independent, to comply with Electoral Commission rules.
@Ross_Greer
might regret revealing the CEO of the SNP organised a pay rise for him at Yes Scotland…
1/ Yesterday,
@HumzaYousaf
said that high energy bills in Scotland are “entirely linked to the fact that we are not independent”.
This is straightforwardly false. A short thread…
1/ The curious case of Humza Yousaf and the Horizon scandal.
On 6th February 2024, I received this FOI response, in which Scot Gov unequivocally stated that Humza Yousaf never received any correspondence about the Horizon scandal when he was the Cabinet Secretary for Justice.
Extraordinarily childish behaviour from a First Minister. Humza Yousaf repeatedly refuses to apologise for calling Douglas Ross a liar at FMQs today. The Presiding Officer clearly not impressed.
Number of times these words appear in the
@scottishgreens
paper on independence:
border = 0
currency = 0
exports = 0
imports = 0
growth = 0
carbon = 0
emissions = 0
electricity = 0
net-zero = 0
imagine = 4
The maddest part of
@Ross_Greer
’s pensions remarks is his analogy with the American Civil War. He doesn’t seem to know that the war ended with seceding states being reabsorbed into the Union - the exact opposite of what Scottish independence would be.
1/ Remarkable FOI response here. Scot Gov admits it cannot justify a statement made by Sturgeon at FMQs recently, because the statement wasn’t true. Sturgeon has quietly corrected the Official Report…
Other revelations from Friday’s hearing have understandably grabbed the headlines, but this shouldn’t be overlooked: in June 2020 (ie during the first lockdown) Scot Gov cabinet considered how the pandemic could be politicised to restart campaigning for independence.
Complete gibberish. The grid in Scotland is owned by two private companies (Scottish Power and SSE) who depend on cross-border transfers from English and Welsh bill payers for network upgrades. Independence jeopardises those transfers, and therefore jeopardises network upgrades.
Ash Regan believes the UK Government produces the GERS figures.
“We can’t stop the UK Government… but what we can do is we can develop our own set of figures”
A candidate to lead the Scottish Government does not know the GERS figures *are* Scottish Government figures. 🤯
For anyone trying to understand opposition to the GRR bill, this contribution from barrister Naomi Cunningham is very useful. (From yesterday’s Women and Equalities Committee meeting at Westminster.)
Incredulity on
#BBCSundayShow
as Lorna Slater appears to be making policy on the hoof, 48 hours ahead of a key deadline on the Deposit Return Scheme. Everything is up in the air for small producers, but she can’t define what a small producer is…
The most interesting thing about this is how easily Sturgeon tells an obvious lie. The promise was broken because it was a daft and unworkable promise. It had nothing to do with Covid.
Swinney’s remarks here are a disgrace. Firstly, he is wrong: GERS allocates >100% of net North Sea revenue to Scotland. Secondly, the total net flow is a fiscal transfer from rUK to Scotland: the opposite of his claim. And that’s after >100% of North Sea is allocated to Scotland.
More footage from the 2014 vault.
@NicolaSturgeon
is adamant that there will be no horse-trading over pension obligations. She gives an “absolute guarantee” that the Scottish Government will honour the obligations. Something has definitely changed.
Many people believe the word “net” gets
@NicolaSturgeon
off the hook here. It does not. She is lying. When the wind blows, Scotland exports renewable electricity to England. And when it doesn’t, Scotland relies on nuclear and gas, just like England does.
1/ Bombshell FOI reveals Mark Blyth - high profile economic adviser to Scottish Government - came out for independence without having done any work.
Blyth subsequently admits that he’s 🚨 “struggling to find the positive case that I hoped for” 🚨
Hugely significant moment: Sturgeon flounders when it’s put to her that no written record exists of when, how, and why things were happening. Her defence: this doesn’t matter, because things did happen. Effectively an admission that document retention was inadequate.
If I was a Scottish nationalist right now, I’d worry that voters might be noticing what’s going on, and concluding that independence would simply be the same shit-show, but with far less money to spend. And how many people are going to vote for that?
Màiri McAllan says Scotland is half way to net zero *not least* due to the ScotWind leasing round. But none of the ScotWind projects have been built yet - their contribution to progress so far is nil. No wonder targets are missed when the Cabinet Secretary appears to be clueless.
Anas Sarwar asks the First Minister about his record of misleading parliament. Humza Yousaf responds by saying that it doesn’t matter, because people keep voting SNP. Pathetic.
Sturgeon always struggles with economic questions. On this morning’s Today programme she was embarrassingly out of her depth on the role of the Bank of England and QE.
Of course she told lies, but I’m not even sure she knows she is lying. She might just be terrifyingly ignorant.
Astonishing remarks from Alyn Smith just now on Sky News. He believes Ian Blackford actually deserves praise for one of the very worst aspects of his handling of the Patrick Grady situation.
1/ Disgraceful behaviour from
@AngusRobertson
in the Scottish Parliament today, as he repeatedly refuses to answer an urgent question from
@LiamKerrMSP
on why he continued to push the bogus offshore wind stat *after* officials advised him to stop using it.
Remarkable twist to the story in Angus:
Tim Rideout taught SNP supporters how to game the Covid business support grants, and encouraged them to divert the money to his own group.
He did all of this on Facebook, and boasted: “I have made over £50k for the indy cause today”
“There was a hampering that would not have been there had we been independent.”
An extraordinarily delusional remark. Furlough scheme was funded entirely by the Bank of England printing money. An independent Scotland, unilaterally using sterling, simply could not have done it.
Amazing. The SNP really is doing this.
@NicolaSturgeon
suggests English taxpayers will fund the state pension in an independent Scotland, and relies on erroneous remarks made by Steve Webb in 2014, which he subsequently corrected in this letter:
This looks like clear evidence that Ken Thomson (former Director-General for Strategy & External Affairs in the Scottish Government) was encouraging message deletion in order to defeat FOI requests. His defence relies on us believing he doesn’t understand how FOI exemptions work.
5/ Which is interesting in light of his remarks today.
Humza Yousaf could have proactively chosen to do something about the Scottish convictions back in 2020.
And he cannot pretend to be unaware that the situation in Scotland was always separate to that in the rest of the UK.
NEW: FM
@HumzaYousaf
“utterly furious” UK Gov hasn’t extended legislation to pardon sub-postmasters to Scotland - accuses ministers of using Horizon victims as “political pawns”.
“Outrageous…unfair…unacceptable”
@LBCNewsScot
Humza Yousaf quotes out of date 2020 figures at FMQs because the 2021 data is less favourable.
The continuity First Minister means continued misleading use of statistics.
Stephen Flynn at PMQs says average energy bills in Scotland are £1,000 more than UK Gov Energy Price Guarantee - an extraordinary claim recently splashed across the front page of
@heraldscotland
. These Islands has investigated it, and can find no evidence to support the claim.
Fiona Hyslop repeats bogus SNP grievance about transmission charging and customers bills (at yesterday’s Holyrood NZET committee).
The guy from Ofgem patiently explains how it actually works, and that Scottish consumers pay lower transmission charges than anywhere else in GB.
Humza Yousaf’s “plan” is rightly being condemned as ludicrous. But worth remembering that it’s exactly the same plan Kate Forbes articulated during the leadership contest. And she is supposed to be the sensible one. There are no sensible ones.
1/ How could
@NicolaSturgeon
be so confused about QE, as evidenced by her floundering interview on the Today programme this morning?
Clearly Sturgeon is out of her depth. But so are the people she turns to for advice on these matters.
Tough questions from
@HTScotPol
and tetchy responses. Is it really credible that Sturgeon cannot remember when she found out about her husband lending £107,620 to the SNP? (Second question in clip.)
Jamie Dawson KC: “That review will not have access to WhatsApps which have been destroyed by Ministers and senior officials, will it?”
Humza Yousaf: “No.”
Jamie Dawson KC: “I have no further questions M’Lady.”
The Presiding Officer threw Oliver Mundell out of the chamber in 2020, after he twice declined to apologise for calling Nicola Sturgeon a liar. Interesting in the context of Humza Yousaf’s behaviour today. He declined three opportunities to apologise, but was not thrown out.
Extraordinarily childish behaviour from a First Minister. Humza Yousaf repeatedly refuses to apologise for calling Douglas Ross a liar at FMQs today. The Presiding Officer clearly not impressed.
Perfect illustration of the WASPI grift.
An MSP for 17 years. Presiding Officer of the parliament for 5 of those.
And we are supposed to believe she just didn’t know about the equalisation of the state pension age?
First announced by Ken Clarke in 1993!
When I started work at 16 I expected my pension when I was 60. I paid for it every pay day.
Never happened. It was delayed and delayed again. 50s women are owed our own money.
Don’t make excuses. Politics is about priorities. Give us what we are owed & what we paid for.
#WASPI
Population of Scotland = 5.5 million. For 600 million glass bottles to be littered every year would require the average person in Scotland to dump 109 bottles per year onto our streets, beaches, and parks. Obviously that doesn’t happen, because the majority are already recycled.
The Westminster Government is not just trying to scupper the Deposit Return Scheme - they're trying to undermine devolution.
It's also really poor for the environment. If we don't include glass that's 600 million bottles that won't be removed from our streets, beaches and parks.
This is no longer a story about the 25% claim. It’s now about the integrity and honesty of a Scot Gov Cabinet Secretary.
Angus Robertson ignored official advice to stop using the stat. He has serious questions to answer.
Speaking yesterday about the 60% of Scottish exports which go to rUK,
@StephenFlynnSNP
says: “most of it travels through to go elsewhere”.
A conspiracy theory from the mad fringes of Scottish nationalism, repeated by the SNP’s new Westminster leader.
“We must become ungovernable. We must make the economic and social cost of keeping Scotland in the union greater than the cost of letting us go. In short, we must be willing to adopt a fully treasonous attitude towards Westminster and the union.”
Yesterday’s maddest speech.
Have reflected on this tweet. I now realise how preposterous it was to suggest a Scottish nationalist might read a book about economics. I apologise unreservedly for the offence I have caused.
Asked by
@GlennBBC
how someone who wants her to remain First Minister, but does not want independence or a referendum, should vote,
@NicolaSturgeon
says: “They should vote for me.”
How can SNP votes now legitimately be used to represent a post-election mandate for a referendum?
You are not going to believe this.
This morning
@Ianblackford_MP
spoke to
@KayBurley
and explained the proposed SNP negotiating position.
The SNP will demand to be “properly compensated [by UK Government] for the contribution that people have made in anticipation of a pension”
Scot Gov gives ~£25m a year to “third sector” organisations, but it can’t identify those organisations and tell us how much each received, because retrieving that information would be too expensive.
Interesting FOI response on a day when financial transparency is in the news…
This is staggering, not least because the motorhome was clearly recorded on the balance sheet in the 2021 accounts. How can the treasurer be unaware of the explanation for that line item? He signed off those accounts. His signature is actually underneath the balance sheet.
Remarkable. On the very same day that her Cabinet discussed politicising Covid to restart campaign for independence, Nicola Sturgeon indignantly denied that any such thing was happening. Clips from her daily Covid briefing on 30th June 2020.
Other revelations from Friday’s hearing have understandably grabbed the headlines, but this shouldn’t be overlooked: in June 2020 (ie during the first lockdown) Scot Gov cabinet considered how the pandemic could be politicised to restart campaigning for independence.
The snippets quoted in the press really don’t do justice to quite how devastating Jamie Dawson KC’s remarks were in describing Scot Gov’s interactions with the UK Covid-19 inquiry. Part 1/2 of some highlights…
Does Shona Robison actually understand how Barnett consequentials work? The fact that business tax cuts in England generated consequentials for Scotland does not mean Scot Gov has to spend that money on the same thing. That’s the whole point of devolution.
Entirely false statement from
@HumzaYousaf
at FMQs.
At year end 2022, total UK renewables installed capacity was 53.5 GW and renewable electricity generated during the year was 134.8 TWh.
Scotland’s figures were 13.9 GW & 35.3 TWh respectively, so 21% and 26% of the UK totals.
Worth rewatching this moment from a recent
@ITVBorderRB
interview, where
@petermacmahon
deftly identifies that Shona Robison has agreed to NHS pay deals in Scotland which she expects the UK Government to pay for.
Justifiably furious point of order from
@agcolehamilton
, referencing my report for
@These_Islands
debunking a bogus claim about Scotland’s potential offshore wind resource, which has been repeated on numerous occasions in the Chamber of the Scottish Parliament… (Part 1 of video)
Owen Jones invites Humza Yousaf to rebut the argument that Scottish independence means austerity on steroids. And he can’t do it. In fact, he doesn’t even try.
This is why, despite repeated promises, the fiscal plan is still nowhere to be seen. It is too horrific to publish.
This is astonishing. Grace Blakeley has written a book about financialisation and inadvertently revealed that she has no idea how a bank works, what bank capital is, or even on which side of the balance sheet it belongs.
This is very silly, and more than a little sinister. I’m not a Tory, but Scottish Conservatives do exist. “Make Scotland Tory free” means fewer Scottish voices are represented at Westminster. Scotland does not speak as one, however much the SNP might prefer that it did.
Great to hear
@NicolaSturgeon
challenged on her lies about Scotland’s renewable electricity. Production & consumption are not the same thing - spot on from
@BBCLauraMac
.
And Sturgeon wants Scotland to remain in the single GB electricity market - very interesting!
Breathtaking ignorance. France has been able to cap electricity tariffs because state controlled EDF is overwhelmingly nuclear. Gas tariffs are up substantially because France relies on imports. It has virtually no domestic oil & gas production so there is barely anything to tax.
Believers in SNP spin that Scotland is self-sufficient in renewable electricity may be interested to learn that more than 40% of Scottish demand is currently being met by importing electricity from England and Wales.
Yesterday, Stephen Flynn gave a speech at the Institute for Government, demanding the devolution of more powers over energy. Asked to explain exactly what he was proposing, he identified “the ability to licence”… something which is already devolved. 🤯
Less than 24 hours after
@JohnSwinney
’s 100% renewables lie,
@Ianblackford_MP
lies to the House of Commons.
A slightly different lie to the Swinney version, but equally false. The SNP is institutionally dishonest on this issue, and nobody is holding them to account for it.
It certainly isn’t true that Scotland has 25% of Europe’s potential offshore wind resource. But it may be true that one MP in particular has told 25% of the lies about this. The
@StephenFlynnSNP
supercut.
Sturgeon’s defence that we didn’t need to see her WhatsApps, because she was always entirely honest at the daily briefings… is rather undermined by this irrefutable evidence of dishonesty at a daily briefing.
‘Can you guarantee to the bereaved families that you will disclose emails, WhatsApps, private emails if you’ve been using them. Whatever. That nothing will be off limits in this inquiry?’
My question to
@NicolaSturgeon
August 2021
Sturgeon once again makes the untrue claim that Scotland’s electricity consumption is almost 100% renewable.
Clip from yesterday’s speech in Washington DC.
Good grief. Sturgeon cannot answer the most elementary of questions on the currency policy.
This plan would be torn to shreds in an actual campaign, which is doubtless why Sturgeon doesn't really want a referendum.
"Can you name another country that does anything like that, other than Panama and Montenegro?"
@C4Ciaran
asks Scotland's First Minister Nicola Sturgeon about the SNP's plans to use the pound as an interim currency after independence.
Scottish nationalist ultras have obviously had a committee meeting and decided the best way to win over the majority in Scotland who don’t want a referendum in 2023 is to shout at those people and call them fascists. I’m not entirely convinced they have thought this through.
Angus Robertson yesterday gave evidence on Scot Gov’s promotion of Scotland internationally to the Scottish Affairs Committee at Westminster. He refused to answer questions on why, after officials him to stop using it, he continued to push the bogus wind stat to foreign govs.