DRCE at CERI-Sciences Po/CNRS, Prof at King's College, President of the French Political Sc. Association, Chair of BASAS & NonResident Scholar at the Carnegie
Congress is not a victim of its limitations only, but also of the decline of India’s democratic institutions & practices. It may reinvent itself as a social movement fighting, again, as an emancipatory force. My interview that has been cut by half in IT.
One of my books helped a JNU student to save his life. I have never felt so useful, and so disturbed at the same time by the madness of today’s identity politics.
Why it is even more important to remember Ehsan Jafri today, when two of those who fought for his memory and Justice, Testa Setalvad & RB Sreekumar, have been arrested.
@amnestypresse
@CarnegieIndia
@CarnegieSAsia
@RSF_inter
The Supreme Court of India has not opposed the govt for 4 years, neither on Bills (Aadhaar - a money bill -, Electoral Bonds, J&K, CAA...), nor on appointments & transfers of judges. Why? Not only because of the 2014 blitzkrieg and 2015-16 attrition war
South Asia is rediscovering non-violence to defend constitutional values. But this phase of ahimsa 2.0, be it in the Pashtun belt or in India, can only succeed if the judiciary commit itself to a new form of activism: the ball is in the court of the judges
Empirical data show that caste is one of the sub texts of Hindutva. Not only upper castes are back in politics at their pre-Mandal level, but reservations are diluted & the savarnas are eulogized for their values - that vigilantes & the state are enforcing
To understand how the most popular Indian TV channel has influenced public discourse, Vihang Jumle and I have scrutinized Republic TV debates over the last two years & compared them to those organized by NDTV. The result of this inquiry is worth reading!
#indianmedia
,
#indiantv
Delhi riots are a variant of a post-Gujarat 2002 pattern of violence that crystallised in UP in the 2000s: it intended not only to polarise, but also to ghettoize. It was related to elections, but took place after, as a revenge in the looser's bastions.
Dynasts have never been so many in the Lok Sabha. They represent 1/4 of the BJP MPs, despite the opposition of the party to political dynasticism. Why? They win more often than others & they allow parties to nominate female candidates within taking risk.
To remember Ehsan Jafri, who was murdered exactly 21 years ago, is important because he represented a political culture that has been dominant in Gujarat - 4 decades ago... and history matters even more when textbooks are rewritten & revisionism prevails.
Before he returned from Europe last year, we talked a lot. He knew that something like that would happen. But he had to continue the work he is now doing for years. We met in Gulberg Society in 2012: he has not changed. Such a wonderful man. Courage Hashr!
Tday marks 1 year since the Modi govt arrested India's leading intellectual Prof.
#AnandTeltumbde
Rama Teltumbde, his wife &
#BabaSahebAmbedkar
's grand-daughter to
@Article14live
: "Anand is being victimised. All we ask for is bail & the trial to start."
Paul Brass has left us, but his books are still with us. I give here the reasons why we need to (re)read them To understand today’s India & the best methodology in political science.
Twenty years after the French edition, my biography of Bhim Rao Ambedkar is now available in four languages, including English, Hindi and Tamil : Babasaheb spoke to everybody and remains relevant to everybody, via the Constitution of India & his writings which are worth reading!
Under Modi - who speaks less in parliament than any other PM - the "temple of democracy" is decaying: bills are rushed through, not referred to committees, debates non existent... Nobody cares, but how can democracy work without a functioning parliament?
The book that you were waiting for is finally here … Modi’s India: Hindu Nationalism and the Rise of Ethnic Democracy by Christophe Jaffrelot is now available to pre-order:
Releasing November 2021
@ContextIndia
@jaffrelotc
@karthikavk
Gujarat is one of the states where the number of RTI activists who have been harassed, assaulted and killed is the highest. Basim-U-Nissa and I have tried to understand why, in a special issue of EPW drawing from a King’s India Institute conference.
If you are interested in the trajectory of the Adani group and in the relations between business and politics in India, this academic book may help you to make sense of today's situation:
After Bhagat Singh & BR Ambedkar, BJP tries to appropriate Karpoori Thakur. I show that he fought agst the Sangh Parivar all his life, as a pro-reservations socialist & vice versa.
@KingsIndiaInst
@CERI_SciencesPo
@CarnegieIndia
The book on The Emergency that I have co-authored with Pratinav Anil will be published by Hurst in Europe in a couple of months: the proofs have just arrived! It will be published subsequently by OUP New York and HarperCollins India.
Mandal at 30: the decline of OBC politics comes not only from Modi’s Hindutva & idea of the neo-middle class, but also from political divisions among OBC leaders & economic differentiations among OBC jatis. But the game is not over as quotas are not filled
The review of "Modi’s India" by S Ganguly in Foreign Policy says the book "is novel in the sheer wealth of detail it amassed about the trajectory of Modi". This is why it is long - and worth reading, I think. Thanks Sumit!
@PrincetonUPress
@WestlandBooks
In this book that I have co-edited with Angana Chatterji and Thomas B Hansen, 15 scholars review five years of the Modi gvt in each and every respect, including the economy, Hindu vigilantism, foreign affairs, Dalits’ condition, Kashmir & the North East...
Paul Brass has left us, but his books are still with us. I give here the reasons why we need to (re)read them To understand today’s India & the best methodology in political science.
@KingsIndiaInst
@CarnegieIndia
@CarnegieSAsia
What is the new Lok Sabha looking like in terms of caste composition? Gilles Verniers and I analyse the social profile of the Hindi belt MPs where the Mandal moment is over & where the BJP has played the caste card in addition to Hindutva against SP & BSP.
If in Paris, you are most welcome to attend this event at CERI at 5 pm on March 4, with Prof. Peter deSouza and Hilal Ahmed, on India and its minorities.
Rahul « had » to be disqualified because of what he says in the LS, but also because of his Yatra’s success: he can now continue to work as a people’s leader with the support of the rest of the opposition. But the ball is in the court of the judiciary too…
I am grateful to The Caravan for publishing this excerpt of my latest book, « Modi’s India », on the elitist dimension of Hindu nationalism. Westland is publishing the book in India and Princeton Univ Press in the US and in Europe.
@karthikavk
@WestlandBooks
@PrincetonUPress
What blinded GoI to the 2nd wave of Covid? Hyper nationalism that resulted in bravado, exports of vaccines and belief in pseudo medicines at the expense of the scientists’ advice. Is the international image of receiving-aid India changed now?
#india
#covid
You’re most welcome to join this webinar if you are interested in the impact of reservations on Dalits, and the impact of privatizations on reservations !
The appointment of Hardik Patel as Working President of Congress in Gujarat, at the age of 26, reflects the shift of the party from caste to kisan politics - & its realization that its future partly lays in village India, the impoverished part of the state.
In this article that I have co-authored with Haider Abbas Rizvi, we show that Muslim countries with which India had increasingly good relations have become less friendly because of the situation of its Muslim minority and recent developments in Kashmir.
Pratinav Anil and I are very pleased to announce the publication of our book on The Emergency. Once again, Hurst and Co, my publisher for 25 years, has done a wonderful job!
Tonight, Ravish Kumar, on NDTV, used the data Vihang Jumle & I have published in The Caravan to demonstrate that Republic TV simply ignored the opposition or systematically criticized it. Sometimes you find yourself more useful...Watch:
#NDTV
@vihangjumle
The second part of the interview I gave to The Wire focuses more on the BJP rule and the Sangh Parivar. Comments are always welcome - provided they fit in a proper debate...
Laws against « love Jihad » show that India is moving from a de facto ethnic nation (when vigilantes were in charge of such things) to an official, de jure, ethno-state - and that it is moving away from Savarkar’s Hindutva. Why?
#hindutva
#lovejihaad
Liberalisation of India's agriculture is happening while it is in crisis & needs state support. Farmers fear, for good reasons, some corporitisation of this sector, as oligopolistic conglomerates show interest in agribusiness.
Soon after I wrote an oped called « The resistible rise of Narendra Modi », when many columnists preferred to focus on the corruption of Manmohan Singh’s gvt. Historians will look at the early 2010s as a turning point but I wonder what place the A Hazare mot will get in history.
India is gradually moving away from multiculturalism toward a type of 'ehtnic democracy', exemplified by Israel and Sri Lanka, where minorities are treated as second-class citizens.
~Christophe Jaffrelot, 2011
@jaffrelotc
warned us much before BJP came to power.
Peak of the pandemic is still to come but public hospitals are already saturated in some cities. Utsav Shah & I show that India did not invest in public health but let instead private hospitals flourish. If they don’t help, the state will have to intervene
In 2009, the poor started to vote for the BJP en masse. This is counterintuitive given the weakening of pro-poor policies like NREGA and the elitist character of BJP. In this art., I look for explanations on the basis of the CSDS data. Caste is one of them
India's trajectory towards Hindutva, national-populism & ethnic democracy can better be explained by factoring in sociological variables including the fear of "declassement" by the upper caste middle class. I'm grateful to the Illiberalism Studies Program
Kalaiyarasan & I, on the basis of the latest statistical data, show that Pasmandas are not lagging behind other Indian Muslims as much as lower castes among Hindus. But Muslims as whole are declining.
@KingsIndiaInst
@CERI_SciencesPo
@CarnegieSAsia
Like all populists, Modi claims that fighting poverty is one of his priorities, whereas anti-poverty programs have been reduced.The NREGA is a case in point. India has never been so inegalitarian, with 58% of the wealth owned by 1% people & 73% by 10%
An excellent source for following what is going on in India about the anti-CAA and anti-NRC protests, initiated by the students of Ashoka University in the best tradition of the national freedom movements of the past:
I am happy to celebrate Bhagat Singh’s birthday by forwarding this excerpt of a recent book that The Wire is kind enough to republish with this caption: « Bhagat Singh Is Not the Man the Right Wants You to Think He Is » via
@thewire_in
?lang=en
Kalai & I show that positive discrimination has achieved unique results in India, but that the reservation is being undermined by privatisations, the shrinking of the state, recent decisions of the judiciary & decline in political clout of OBCs an Dalits.
Transparency is a pillar of democracy, but state institutions cultivate secrecy: anonymous electoral bonds, sealed envelops to the Supreme court, weakening of the RTI Act... Has anybody something to hide? The nation wants to know! But nobody's asking...
On the 12th you are most welcome to take part in this session on « The marginalization of Indian Muslims » by using this Zoom link:
ID: 83337021563 ; Passcode: 608608
Contact:
Razi Raziuddin:+1-(301)-788-8884(razi24
@hotmail
.com);
I’m glad to announce the publication of the book Pratinav Anil & I have co-authored on The Emergency, a painstakingly researched book based on archives that had never been used before. Hurst Publisher has done an amazing job again!
@MikeDwyerMike
#Emergency
#india
#IndiraGandhi
OUT NOW 💫
‘India’s First Dictatorship: The Emergency, 1975-1977’ by
@pratinavanil
&
@jaffrelotc
sheds light on one of the darkest moments in India’s recent history, drawing upon a trove of new sources.
Get 25% off with the code ‘DICTATORSHIP25’ here:
The fight against « Urban Naxals » reflects caste antagonisms, affinities between police forces & vigilante groups, the way CBI relates to thr central govt, judicial authoritarianism & Hindu nationalists’ attitude re Intellectuals. See Bhima Khoregaon case
The Hindi version of my biography of Dr. Ambedkar that Rajkamal published is now available as a e-book: may those who have a keyboard in devanagari make this announcement in the right language for the Hindi speakers and forward the link? Bahut danyavaad!
My interview on crony capitalism in India - the full podcast - is now available on my YouTube channel. It largely draws from my contribution to the book I have co-edited last year with A Kohli and K Murali: Business and Politics in India - and updates it!
Shweta Bhutada and I show that Muslims are under represented in the police and the army to such an extent that it contradicts the multicultural philosophy of the 1950 Constitution - and that a majoritarian bias of the security forces may gain momentum...
Why is Narendra Modi above accountability? Bcz of his charisma? Bcz of a long tradition of hero worship in India’s political culture ? Bcz of the fascination for the strong (wo)man in this culture? Bcz of the prestige of the guru? My oped offers responses.
I argue here that the Pew survey shows how Hindutva as an ethno religious ideology is making progress at the expense of Hinduism as a religion & that to live separately is not like living peacefully because tolerance is not toleration.
@KingsIndiaInst
The fight against "Urban Naxals" reflects caste antagonisms, affinities between police forces & vigilante groups, the way CBI relates to the central govt, judicial authoritarianism & Hindu nationalists' attitude re. intellectuals. The Bhima Khoregaon case illustrate these trends
« Modi’s India », my book published by Princeton University P in 2021 is now available in Tamil! I am most grateful to K. Balasubramanian, the translator, Anush, the head of the publishing house (Ethir Veliyeedu) and Vignesh Rajahmani who made it possible!
@krvtweets