Many of our housing problems can be traced to the fall of the residential hotel, which was once a fixture of the American city's residential mix... and could be again.
In defense of the hotel:
pretty funny that Amtrak built a whole new Manhattan terminal, implemented the same absurd boarding process, BUT also re-created the Yglesias loophole, wherein you can just skip the huge line and access your track from the LIRR concourse below
โWe built cities all over America that are designed for automobiles and not designed for people... Our housing costs are high, in part because of the way that we've designed our cities."
-
@GovDougBurgum
North Dakota comments during the
@NatlGovsAssoc
winter meetings
Two hundred-year-old towers were supposed to turn into 400+ apartments. Instead they're going to be dynamited in the name of counterterrorism.
New me on a debacle in Chicago:
You ever see those color-coded maps of how much downtown land is devoted to car storage?
@Parking_Reform
has put them all in one place, and ranked 50+ U.S. cities by their parking land use
nice new maps in the NYT today remind us that one of the easiest, greenest things we can do as a society is allow more people to live in walkable neighborhoods close to jobs
The freedom afforded by remote work has allowed WFHers to congregate in such scenic and low-cost locations as ... central DC and the Inner Mission in San Francisco (column and ๐งต)
some of this was really good! fewer parking garages, lower rates of drunk driving.
some was not so good: disinvestment in mass transit, traffic congestion.
some was ??? (restaurants opening ghost kitchens)
what happens to all of that when Dara turns the screws?
News: My book about parking is coming out on May 9th!
It's the story of how our demand for free and easy parking screwed up our citiesโand how we can undo the damage.
Pre-order it now and earn valuable parking karma:
โWhat is tourism?โ asks Walentas. โItโs people who work 50 weeks a year, then put all their money in a bag, come here, and throw it in the air. Then they go home without consuming health care or education or anything. Itโs the greatest return on investment you could ask for.โ
So is Amtrak ever going to bring back service between NYC and Montreal or is that going to be one of those things that disappeared forever during the pandemic?
Santa Monica didn't allow enough housing; now its housing stock will jump 7 percent overnight as developers take advantage of an old state law's "Builder's Remedy"
โBetween 1923 and โ28 commercial builders erected more than 20,000 apartment houses with more than a third of a million unitsโor enough to house over 1.5 million people. But as [Abraham] Kazan also knew, virtually all of the new housing was much too expensive for working people.โ
We need a flexible, variable-term accommodation that can:
-keep prosperous vacationers out of the longterm housing stock
-footloose young people out of family-sized apartments
-the elderly out of far-away nursing homes
-the destitute off the street
A gas tax holiday would give $3 to the richest US households for every $1 to the poorest. It's bad for the environment, guts infrastructure funding, and probably wouldn't help Democrats that much anyway. So why are so many of them trying to make it happen?
but extended-stay hotels are desperately needed at higher price points too. boarding houses were how young people found independence in the big city, without having to invest in furniture or deal with roommates.
Re-reading the original 1982 "Broken Windows" article and I'm struck by the authors' focus on fear and *perception* of safetyโwhich may not overlap with actual incidence of crime at all.
new opening on urbanist twitter for the Narrow Lanes Person. potentially a very powerful policy change but needs someone to tweet about it constantly for a few years
what this article suggests is: perhaps Airbnb users do not actually want to sleep beneath a stranger's family photos -- they just want an affordable mid-term lodging in a nice residential neighborhood
I cannot get over the fact that the entire city of San Francisco voted on whether to let cars back onto the park roadโand there were TWO ballot initiatives about it!
the answer is sitting right in front of us! hotels used to provide shelter for all of those people, and we made a big mistake when we stopped thinking of hotels as housing
A very interesting report from Rebuild by Design: "Toward a Rainproof NYC." One of the biggest changes we'd have to make, short of rebuilding the whole sewer system, requires re-thinking streets and parking lots to *hold water* in a big storm.
Terrific piece of reporting thatโs about way more than JD Vance, and shows an important political truth most journalists hide: A lot of the time you interview people, they simply do not know or care what youโre asking about
nowadays 20-somethings rent up the family-size housing stock, consume lots of throwaway Ikea furniture, and are expected to go a full decade before finding a place of their ownโif they even manage to move out of their parents house at all!
reading Paul Groth's excellent book Living Downtown I also learned that SROS were:
-not counted as housing during urban renewal, which led to undercounts of displaced persons and little help when they were evicted
-not eligible for Section 8 for years
Food for thought for NYC: What happened when Paris decided to limit curb-lane dining to the summer months, from April to October?
The number of participating restaurants fell by 65 percent.
Some stats for ya:
-Car trips starting and ending in Paris are down 60 percent since 2000
-Car trips between city and suburbs down 35 percent in that time
-168+ schools with car-free blocks created since 2020
-one (1) cyclist killed in 2022
In other words, while we now pine for the housing boom of the 1920s, which has left the city with a huge stock of affordable apartments, contemporary housers saw it as unaffordable
finally of course there is Airbnb: one-quarter of all Airbnb stays are now 30 days or longer. it's the company's fastest-growing type of business. it's eating up the housing stock and taking apartments and houses off the market.
The sense of urban disorder driving big-city elections is about homelessness, not violent crime, and no amount of broken windows policing is going to help until we find a way to house the homeless.
unfortunately, many of the places where Airbnb is devouring the housing stock are also the places where it's really hard to build new hotels. like New York City, where new hotels are effectively banned!
On the M1 bus crawling down 5th Avenue, thinking about how they punted on redesigning this street so a handful of billionaires could be dropped off in front of Cartier
This is an important distinction: Hiring more cops is not going to help voters feel safe if what's *actually* making them feel unsafe is people using hard drugs in public, people in visible mental distress, vacant storefronts, and so on. Those things are not policing problems!
Just finished
@henrygrabar
โs book Paved Paradise and I cannot recommend it highly enough. I now ruin every dinner party though by only talking about parking, but definitely worth it
[VICTORY ALERT]
@GavinNewsom
has signed AB 835, the single-stair study bill! Thanks to
@alex_lee
for his leadership on moving California toward international best practices for fire suppression and livable apartments. More on single-stair here:
if you measure rents against local minimum wage, the most expensive cities in America are, of course, Atlanta, Austin, Charlotte, Nashville, and Raleigh (from Zillow)
Desperate times call for desperate measures, but I predict that after 30 years of absorbing the science on the harms of air pollution people will look at upzoning major corridors as environmental malfeasance
With AB 2011's passage, virtually all commercial zoned land in CA can now be redeveloped into housing.
It's likely the biggest housing production bill in state history, and a sign that "the politics of this issue is changing dramatically.โ