I wrote this piece in The Nation about the cuts at WVU and how small states will crush their R1 unis to cash grab for big tech. WVU is the only R1 in WV and these cuts will shred higher ed in the state. Please read and share. (A thread)
Wedge issues like book bans appear when fascists have no plan to govern and just want to direct white rage at public institutions like schools to erode support for the public good.
Here's the group that is dismantling WVU.
They have been hired as consultants at land-grant universities around the country to help shred the liberal arts. Would be sensible for people to know who they are, as more unis hire them:
Another way of thinking about it: book bans emerge when white people feel so OUT OF CONTROL and WEAK that they must PRODUCE CONTROL over objects that center critiques of power.
A few things about the horror show at WVU:
1.) The point is to create a two-tier educational system where the poors get garbage and the elites get the real deal education.
Book bans ALWAYS fail. And generally the books sell gazillions more copies, bringing more attention to the object of the white tears. But more than that, book bans and other local cultural wars show us where fascists think they have power to define the limits of the public good.
Predictably, they generally focus that white rage onto Jewish or Black people as a way of sharpening whatever aspect of whiteness feels to be in crisis (generally as a result of sustained public critique of white supremacy and colonialism.)
Book bans make white people feel IN CONTROL, so they can consolidate a narrative among their in-group. But the effect of that is also raising awareness outside of that in-group, so that people mobilize to defend institutions of free speech (like schools and libraries).
Also, fascism works BEST in an ECONOMY OF SCARCITY because people feel social PRECARITY (economic, social, political) and so they don't want to produce ABUNDANCE (of support for public goods).
PRODUCE ABUNDANT SUPPORT FOR PUBLIC GOODS.
Obviously, you should buy and read the banned books and leave them in little free libraries, share them with community members, and support teachers who teach them.
BORROW them from lending institutions to justify their purchase. REQUEST their purchase at your local library.
Invest your TIME and POLITICAL ENERGY into public: schools, libraries, museums, historical societies, parks, etc.
Any scarcity that happens in the US is an intentional political calculation (generally, systematic racism) that helps justify austerity and brutality.
But understand that book bans work as PROHIBITIONS, which is the only way that fascists see power: as something to be centralized and hoarded, not something to be debated or shared.
The white tears over the 1619 Project and Maus reveal that white supremacists perceives THEMSELVES in CRISIS (over social control, historical meaning-making).
The only way out of that crisis is the destruction of non-white knowledge bases (public education, publishing, etc.).
This is b/c KNOWLEDGE CAN NEVER BE TAKEN AWAY. So if fascists can prevent knowledge (of fascism/racism/colonialism) from being shared (or distort it, via Fox News and conservative media ecology), they can control politics. This is why public ed will always be central to FREEDOM.
When white people (hetero men, esp.) feel like they are in crisis, they SEE NO PLACE FOR THEIR WHITE SUPREMACY IN THE PRESENT OR FUTURE so they resort to 1.) NOSTALGIA to REPRODUCE older forms of white identity/history and 2.) terrorism to REGAIN CONTROL.
Related: book bans are about the convergence of RACE PANIC and SEX PANIC. That nexus is what has mobilized white rage since Brown v. Board (unsurprising since all of white America's racial guilt/shame get played out in the realm of PUBLIC EDUCATION).
Also, public ed & libraries were FEMINIZED b/c of the way that the workforce managed sex/gender in the 1960s. So, if you care about fascism in the US and you are a (cishet)dude invested in FREEDOM, you need to work alongside librarians & teachers to safeguard public institutions.
That is, a book ban is not about *the ban itself*. It's about the process of **activating the fascist in-group** to coup at the school board meeting and reassert control over education and over white fascists who might be flirting with liberal thinking/reading/speaking.
Book bans are a failure every single time. (People will continue to read Beloved.) But they **demonstrate the limited political repertoire of fascism**. Which means that they also show us HOW PREDICTABLE fascism is and how fascism can be thwarted.
I see this is going a bit viral. I direct the Gender Studies Program at the University of Arkansas. If you'd like to support our students' work here in the South, consider doing so through endowment giving. Every bit helps:
The
@WVGovernor
bragged about a $1.8 billion surplus in June. WVU’s current budget deficit is 2.5% of this. Can’t think of a better way to spend some of that money than helping one of the most important institutions the state has
Snitching undermines public trust in PUBLIC INSTITUTIONS and create an atmosphere of FEAR which creates an illusion of scarcity through profiling and reprobation.
This. Is. The. Way.
"I would like to request that you remove the ASU faculty members from the Professor Watchlist," Crow wrote. "If you will not do so, please add me to the list, as I will continue to support all of ASU’s faculty members . . . "
1.) The WVU story is also about THE DESTRUCTION of the rural US before, and certainly since, the COVID-19 pandemic begin. But the worst is yet to come. It will just be VERY uneven.
Let's talk about the ENROLLMENT CLIFF as the justification divest from public education.
Good morning, new Twitter followers!
Turns out: the fash element is still alive and well on Twitter.
The good news is that the antis are funnier and hotter. **chef's kiss**
Did you have a book come out in the last two years? Drop it in the comments.
Gonna request that my uni library and my public library buy as many as possible.
2.) The dismantling will be successful in places with poor STATE funding for public higher ed (like WVU).
This was made possible by the Bush federal cuts to higher ed in 2008, which shredded higher ed investment in higher ed.
Exclusive: Members of the Little Rock Nine, who in 1957 integrated Little Rock Central High School under threats from white segregationists, are denouncing the Arkansas Department of Education’s restrictions on an AP African American Studies course.
Amy Coney Barrett will carry forward the bulk of the toxic whiteness of SCOTUS during the Biden Administration and it will expose how white women augment the violence of white supremacy.
5.) While the public university has been under assault for 50 years (with the past 20 being the worst of it), it's been a pretty bipartisan affair. The electeds are making money from the fallout, because destroying public ed IS *THE* AUTHORITARIAN GRIFT.
The tweets supporting
@JonesForAR
are a gorgeous array of pro-democracy forces reshaping AR politics. Exposing the vapid dog whistle about the "radical left" in AR by SHS, they create democratic community in the service of public goods meeting public needs. ❤️
If you're watching the debacle at
#WVU
as corporate apparatchiks dismantle the state's only Research I institution, I thought I'd highlight some of the CONSULTANT DOUBLESPEAK emerging as rpkGROUP and McKinsey reshape higher ed.
A thread.
3.) Bush (and Biden) shifted funding to community college and vo-tech. Those should be funded but it became zero-sum and undermined the mission of public higher ed. Esp at the land-grants.
4.) Public colleges and uni absorb THE VAST BULK of college education in the country, with privates accounting for a tiny percentage of the college-educated. Crushing them this way will have a MASSIVE effect on the population. See also: Florida.
I see that WVU will be contracting with DuoLingo instead of . . . <checks notes> . . . providing actual language instruction.
Very compelling to have the owl chastise you instead of learning sentence structure from a qualified professional.
6.) It's lovely to see successful unionization efforts amidst the assault on higher education because it's really the only bulwark against this kind of corporate takeover.
I have worked on campaigns and in politics for nearly 30 years. This is the most engaged I have ever seen the country in both state/local politics and national politics. A few observations:
Here's the thing about campus divestment movements: they expose the universities (private colleges, esp) for being FRONTS for LAUNDERING DIRTY MONEY for people who DO BAD THINGS. Like make weapons. Or commit genocide. OR BOTH.
1.) Back to the cluster at WVU. There are TWO stories here.
ONE is about Gordon Gee being a hatchet man & spendthrift. I'm from Ohio and remember what a disaster he was at OSU. He just keeps getting passed around R1s, where he continues to fail up.
7.) To be clear: AI will be the replacement for the public university professor. So, it's probably useful to see WVU as an example of the bureaucratic coup against public goods like public higher education. The result will be to funnel more money to the technocrats.
All eyes are on
#WVU
and I want to talk to the professoriate about how to navigate this extremely anti-intellectual moment. I know it's frustrating and scary and the anxiety is terrible, but we must face this head-on.
(Yet another) thread.
8.) RPK is the firm at WVU who has been retained at land grant unis across the country to dismantle the liberal arts, etc. More unis will hire them.
Thread on that here:
Here's the group that is dismantling WVU.
They have been hired as consultants at land-grant universities around the country to help shred the liberal arts. Would be sensible for people to know who they are, as more unis hire them:
As always, I am thinking about how many men have benefitted from abortion care and don't say a fucking word about it advancing/improving/saving their lives.
Can we just be honest that the chicken plant outbreaks that are massively escalating COVID spread in Northwest Arkansas are a result of anti-union/right-to-work (die) legislation? Infected workers have no healthcare, no sicks days. Opposing unions is LITERALLY KILLING PEOPLE.
Bigger picture: the tech industry is in trouble, and higher ed represents one of the few untapped markets if they can convince friendly administrators to let them be content providers.
Obviously, shitty financial management creates the conditions for austerity. So, budget cuts precede this kind of arrangement with consultants. Would be interested to see which WV politicians have financial stake in RPK . . . .
WATCH: Among those arrested today were Noelle McAfee, Chair of the Philosophy Department at Emory University.
I’ve asked for a comment from Emory on this arrest, no word yet.
This video provided to us by an
#Emory
PHD student. You can hear him in this video.
@ATLNewsFirst
Things are terrible but my heart SWELLS for all of these students protesting. Not all of their parents will be support their actions but ALL of the professors across the country who are worth their salt are SO PROUD.
#WeReopenSchoolsWhen
we actually hire and train enough contact tracers who speak Spanish & Marshallese and when we bother to translate text alerts in both Spanish & Marshallese.
@AsaHutchinson
@ArkansasEd
This historical period is going to distribute risk and suffering to white liberals in way that they refused to imagine. Some thoughts about that. (1/ )
A 🧵 about fascist media aimed at children.
Last week, my 11 y.o. sent me a cute video of Sonic the Hedgehog saying a bunch of fascist, QAnon gobbledygook about the "radical Left." We had a long talk about propaganda models and YouTube videos aimed at kids.
Thinking today about how hard the Bush cuts to higher ed ushered in the consultants to produce the "college experience" in the face of hiring freezes, printer quotas, and library relocations. (1/)
3.) Cutting the languages, in particular, is a canary in the coal mine, since the elite programs will retain those programs to train private school kids to go into international finance, business, law, etc. and the state school kids will get votech.
Over the next four years, we will stop the radical indoctrination of our students, and restore PATRIOTIC EDUCATION to our schools. We will teach our children to love our Country, honor our history, and always respect our great American Flag.
Working on the new book and writing about sex panic and the production of conservative sexual expertise in the face of changing sexual norms.
A thread.
2.) The languages are attractive for cuts because it feeds the jingoism of white supremacy, since so few white Americans speak a second language fluently (unlike adults the rest of the world).
I spoke with the Consul General of Israel this morning to receive an update on the ongoing conflict and reaffirm Arkansas' unwavering support for the Israeli cause.
We stand with Israel.
1.) Consultant groups like rpkGROUP and McKinsey cut liberal arts programs, which bring in massive revenue for general education and for their own majors and degree programs. But the cuts don't just decimate the programs, they crush confidence in public goods.
The rollback of child labor laws in AR is ideologically connected to the Duggars' situation with TLC and Quiverfull ideology: physical and financial exploitation of children, especially the girls.
6.) The point of this kind of takeover at schools like WVU (in right-to-work states) is to kill tenure and erode the public's confidence in the R1 public university. The move to punish the professors speaking out about the corruption is direct evidence of malfeasance.