It is regrettable that many Western commentators repeated Putin’s narrative that the problem came from an aggressive NATO expansion aimed at encircling Russia.
Time for a reset of narratives. Here are some simple insights, informed by our work on the game theory of alliances. 🧵
Amazing: a trail of termites (up) and a trail of ants (down), both protected by a row of their soldiers in a stand-off, without fighting.
from
@mehdi_moussaid
This is a black and white photograph. Only the lines have colour.
What you “see” is what your 🧠 predicts the reality to be, given the imperfect information it gets.
Brilliant:
When the euro bank notes were designed, they used European-style bridges which were *non-existing*, not to have to choose between countries.
The Dutch town of Spijkenisse claimed them all for the Netherlands by building them on a waterway.
- Senator: Would you be comfortable sharing with us the name of the hotel you stayed in last night?
- Zuckerberg: Eh... No
- Senator: I think that maybe is what this is all about. Your right to privacy.
Somebody did a simulation of a giant 🍌 orbiting around the 🌍 at the distance of the ISS.
And, surprisingly, it challenges our intuitions of how orbiting objects would look like in the sky.
This 1944 CIA memo, on how to infiltrate an organisation and make it dysfunctional, is amazing.
Worth framing in the coffee room of every company.
ht
@esportslaw
Cats can also be game theorists.
Problem: coordination game. A resource can only be accessed by one player at any given moment.
Solution (when game lasts long enough): turn-taking strategy.
How it is enforced: emergence of a norm of reciprocal sharing.
One of my favourite examples of how people react to economic incentives:
Architectural tax avoidance👇
🇬🇧 UK : tax on windows
🇻🇳 Vietnam: tax on frontage
🇫🇷 France: tax on floors (roof exempted)
🇧🇷 Brazil: tax on church construction (when finished)
It’s incredible that some in the West keep repeating Putin’s propaganda about “Nazis in Ukraine”.
Truth: the far-right is smaller in Ukraine than in most European countries.
🇫🇷 34% (2017)
🇮🇹 17% (2018)
🇪🇸 15% (2019)
🇧🇪 12% 2019)
🇳🇱 11% (2021)
🇩🇪 10% (2021)
👉🇺🇦 2% (2019)
Amazing animation of how the Charles Bridge was built in Prague in the 14th century.
We easily underestimate the technical knowledge people had in the past.
This map superimposes the border of the German Empire (1871-1918) on the electoral results of the 2007 Parliamentary elections in Poland.
Another great example of the long term impact of past institutions.
Orange/red = PO, centre right
Blue = PIS, right (currently in power)
Another fascinating mind-bending illusion. There is no yellow in the circle below (!). Instead, our brain very confidently fills the gap of the colour scheme.
by
@AkiyoshiKitaoka
Behind Macron’s victory there is a large social divide.
Macron got 71% of professionals/managers.
Le Pen got 68% of workers.
In France, like in the US and other countries, the political fight is not between left and right anymore.
A 🧵
Here is a great explanation of the Lagrangian multiplier (the intuition of which is typically not given). 🧵
The problem: maximising a function f(x,y) under a constraint g(x,y)=k (the point has to be on the red curve).
The notion of “probability” is both familiar (we use it), and mysterious (we would typically struggle to define it).
Here is a 🧵 to remove the mystery and make the meaning of “probability” more intuitive.
The “protection of an ethnic minority” argument is a go-to excuse to interfere in another country, and therefore could not provide confidence in the future attitude of Russia. The current events provide, unfortunately, a vivid demonstration.
We need to stop the “NATO aggression” narrative. It has been used as an excuse by an authoritarian state to:
- crush the democratic aspirations of peoples in several European countries,
- reinforce the police strate in Russia against the aspirations of Russian citizens.
In short, Eastern European countries had a choice, they opted for the European Union and NATO, when they could, for the security it offered them. Remember, this was Kyiv in 2014.
It is mind-boggling how many commentators in the West have blamed NATO’s aggressiveness. When, instead, NATO has repeatedly opted not to fight to stop Russian military interventions in Georgia, Syria, and Ukraine.
Everybody should know about Berkson’s paradox.
👉 When two positive traits are (spuriously) negatively correlated, in a population *selected on these traits*.
Examples: 1/
“Handsome men are jerks.”
via
@anecdatally
NATO is a voluntary association, and an association with Russia would also have (initially) been largely voluntarily.
But Eastern European countries *demanded* to join NATO. While NATO countries were initially not warm about this prospect.
Your periodic reminder not to compare impact factors across disciplines:
Medical paper “invents” a way to estimate the area under a curve using rectangles.
Gets over 400 citations
How people come up with “random” numbers:
A: “Pick a random number from 1-10”
B: 🤔°(1 and 10 are too obvious. 5 stands out in the middle. Half way between 5 and 10 is hidden in the mix. It won’t be the same number other picked 😁.)
“Seven”
🇫🇷 Landreau vs 🇧🇷 Ronaldinho (2002)
One of the most interesting penalties ever for behavioural game theory: the goalie making a direction stand out to play a mind game.
These concerns are why Eastern European countries have been interested to join the EU and NATO: they try to escape the threat of being vassalised in an alliance with Russia.
And NATO’s aggressive expansion? NATO countries have rejected Ukraine’s and Georgia’s membership.
👇
/end
These insights are informed by our work on coalitional game theory, where we used Russia and its alliance as an illustration of a “too big to prevail” paradox.
The reasons are now obvious for everybody to see. Small countries run the risk of being bullied in an alliance with a hegemonic partner. In such an alliance, they have very low bargaining power 👉 they are at the mercy of later “revisions” of the terms of the alliance.
The reaction from satellite countries was not paranoid. Russia used pressure to force Georgia and Moldova in the CIS. Then it established the “Monroeski Doctrine”, stating its right to intervene in CIS states to “protect” the right of ethnic Russians.
A way to picture the magnitude of the wealth accumulated by Russian oligarchs.
One oligarch’s super yacht seized in Italy is worth more than all the money pledged by the EU to arm Ukraine.
What about countries from the former USSR (Georgia, Armenia, Ukraine)? Russia proposed an economic integration, the “Community of Independent States” (CIS). It failed because the other countries resisted integration.
CIS 👇
Striking identical results from different countries: the gender gap in income is primarily driven by motherhood.
In order:
1) Denmark
2) Sweden
3) New-Zealand
It's surprising how some Western commentators are *still* complacently repeating Putin's propaganda.
Candace Owen: Ukraine wasn't a thing until Russians created it in 1989.
Voltaire (1731): "Ukraine has always aspired to liberty".
As a consequence of these concerns. Countries skeptics about an integration with Russia created in 1997-99 the GUUAM group (Georgia, Ukraine, Uzbekistan, Azerbaijan, Moldova), to increase their bargaining power against Russia,
Excellent animation showing how rich people think they are middle class.
Barely anybody believes to belong to the top 20% (here in Austria).
By
@matschnetzer
A picture which should be shown to every student in social science.
When an article says something like "people in this category have a *significantly* higher level of X" with an effect size of 0.1 standard deviation, the effect is half as small as the one in the top picture.
When a camera’s framerate is synchronised with the frequency of a guitar’s string vibration, you can visualise the amplitude of the string’s vibration.
Our paper on game theory and how professional tennis players serve is now forthcoming at Quantitative Economics!
We find that tennis players are really good at playing mixed Nash equilibrium strategies on their serves, but not perfect. 🧵
Prospect Theory's famous “S-shaped” value function is a cornerstone of behavioural economics. Surprisingly, more than 40 years after its inception, there seem to be a lot of remaining puzzles about it.
Or... perhaps not anymore. A 🧵that may change your view on Prospect Theory.
Very impressive effect of COVID-19 on the "home advantage" in football (soccer). ⚽️
When playing in an empty stadium, the advantage of the home team drops by 50%.
👇Large effects on results, fouls and cards.
Fascinating animation shows the evolution of temperature anomalies since 1850.
👉 Global temperatures were stable in the 19th century. They are now on an (accelerating) upward trend.
By
@RARohde
This map shows data on tolerance around the world, towards homosexuality (World Value Survey).
Among the most tolerant countries:
🇦🇷Argentina
🇦🇺Australia
🇨🇦Canada
🇯🇵Japan
🇳🇱Netherlands
🇳🇿New Zealand
🇳🇴Norway
🇪🇸Spain
🇸🇪Sweden
🇨🇭Switzerland
🇬🇧UK
🇺🇾Uruguay
A great way to realise the sheer quantity of information our 🧠 seamlessly processes when we do a “simple” task like driving a car.
This is what the Tesla autopilot sees using a neural network which took 70,000 GPU hours to train.
ht
@Rainmaker1973
Amazing: a bug in Nature’s code.
🐜🐜🐜 use pheromones to follow trails. If a trail loops, they get locked running in a circle and die from exhaustion.
via
@Mehdi_Moussaid