Also btw the amount of people in the comments and the QTs completely unbothered by this change/seemingly not even registering it is very telling lol and also depressing.
But you know. This is par for the course for YA authors who get cred and recs and applause for making fat characters ... until the second they get adaptations that is.
Nina Zenik is fat. That was a cool fun thing in the Grishaverse. The people making the SHADOW & BONE show KNEW this & saw fat actresses for the part. (I know this because I've heard from at least one.) Then they decided they didn't care and neither would the audience. *I* care.
This is why I rarely, rarely recommend books about fat characters that aren't by authors who are presently fat and who use the word. Because other people will 1. Quickly sell us out 2. Cast/draw etc. thin people and swear to your face they aren't changing anything.
@misskubelik
It sucks in general when fat characters either don't exist or are sidelined, but actively slimming a hero down for an adaptation? Hurts even worse.
@aDillonDev
yeah my brain is still kind of glitching on the image tbh with you because like I don't know I can't sort of process that's Nimona, you know? Again! Not even that fat! A small fat, no doubt. But BIG in the hips and the bottom. And now -- just disorienting (and sad) to see.
@misskubelik
I’m so tired and sad too. The shading is maybe dramatic but also feels like trying to create an even slimmer impression. So many kids being told their even slightly bigger bodies are not allowed to exist in media. That they are not allowed to be heroes.
@lifebreakingin
yeah I thought maybe the shadow was ... trying to trick us into thinking maybe she's fatter?? Which, as I said, she was - at best - a small fat. But this is just basically erasing her large hips, thighs, and bottom as well as her rounder chest area.