THIS is what Tolkien was talking about when he said he loathed allegory in all its forms.
He wrote a deeply allegorical work, a lot of his work is allegorical, obviously so, what he hated with people fishing like this in deeply uninformed ways.
BG3 is so Good it makes me forget the fact that it suffers from the first rule of storytelling and games. That your character will always be the least interesting one. Everyone else you meet as always more interesting, has a better story, more personality, motivation, backstory.
So here's the good news. You ready? Lemme tell you a story of what happened when Wizards of the Coast (possibly after the Hasbro buyout) spent a LOT of money on a real market research survey. They found out something ALARMING. Well, alarming for people trying to monetize D&D...
The process of prepping an adventure has known states.
1: This is a cool idea.
2: Oh god I'm not even 5% done, this will never work!
3: Actually it's starting to take shape and be a thing.
4: This is going to work!
5: I'm not done and I've run out of time. This will have to do.
If you try something crazy in D&D, and it doesn't work, PROBABLY the lesson isn't "You should never do that, it's never fun." Probably you just need to try it under different circumstances.
Folks telling you "that never works" maybe don't have your best interests at heart.
Game Developers are publicly sharing their salary, not because they're trying to impress you with how much or how little they made, but because talking about salaries publicly takes power away from the owners who want to use the workers' ignorance to lowball them.
Crazy how most homebrew D&D adventures are literally an untested alpha. "I just wrote this, it's only a bunch of notes, no one has ever played it, I hope it works."
The fact that these things work AT ALL is a testament to the power of the DM to curate an experience on the fly.
Another way of saying it is, I think he hated the sport of allegory. The process by which a reader begins by assuming there must be a hidden allegory and it was their job to find it, rather than just taking the work on its merits.
I tried writing a video script about the OGL debacle but it was literally too depressing, so I scrapped it.
Hasbro is going to get what it wants. None of this other shit matters to them. They're going to convert D&D into a digital loot-box game, it will make them a lot of money.
@mattcolville
baldur's gate achieved something truly incredible in simulating d&d so closely that i actually feel totally enervated and mad at my best friends when we finish for the night
The good news. You are smarter, more ethical, more compassionate, and a harder worker than the President of the United States.
The bad news is: see previous sentence.
Blazing Saddles couldn’t get made today. If you took that script to a studio, they’d say “Hey, this is the script to Blazing Saddles, get out of here.”
I've got this weird idea that in an age where so much of our entertainment is just corporations buying up stories we grew up with and recycling and regurgitating them, getting behind the GM screen and inventing a universe at the table is like a revolutionary act.
The fact that our stream already has a reputation for being nothing but endless combat after we just streamed an entire session with no fighting and only a handful of die rolls says a lot about the culture surrounding streaming D&D.
Someone in the Discord said “watching Matt I feel like I could do anything with D&D. Tell any story.” And I feel like this is a major accomplishment for me, even if only one person feels that way.
@matthewmercer
I genuinely have a hard time imagining the audition you would fail to ace. As good as everyone thinks you are, I think you're actually better than that.
This is what happens when you remove gatekeepers from the process. You can do extraordinary things. We wanted to make a book, we made a book. They want to make a show...THEY'RE GONNA MAKE A SHOW!!! :D
When WotC bought DnD Beyond, I told my team: "The clock is ticking." From that point forward I knew there was no future, long-term, as a third party developer. Because I did not believe they were forward thinking enough to implement a Steam style platform
In reality, even when the *business* of D&D was on life support, the hobby was doing fine. Was it growing? Was it increasing shareholder value?
What are you, an investor? What do you care? Go roll up a character and save the world.
Here endeth the lesson
Every six months or so, I see discussions pop up defending CR from people saying it “isn’t real D&D”. (Mind you, I don’t see most of the instigating statements, which might mean I have the right people muted...?)
Regardless, the whole premise of this argument is hilarious to me.
I dunno how this ends, no one does, but every hour Ukraine holds out is hugely, emotionally inspiring to me and millions of people.
The future is uncertain, but Ukraine's resistance is becoming the stuff of legends.
No matter what happens now, those people are fucking heroes.
Gonna be interesting to see what happens as we slowly exit this pandemic and everyone realizes they just endured over a year of non-stop fear and anxiety and in some cases worse.
It's not going to be an easy or simple emotional journey, I suspect.
I got drunk in Madrid once and woke up with a tattoo. I was going to get it removed but I was surprised at how good it was.
I guess I wasn’t expecting the Spanish ink precision.
Things were not always thus. Going to conventions in the 90s, D&D was pretty unpopular. I have personally experienced a broad ecology of publishers and players where D&D was considered a thing of the past.
And that era seemed a lot more dynamic and fun to me.
Fuck I’m just so proud of everyone and the team and my players and the community is so awesome I’m gonna legit cry.
I want to buy everyone a pizza like for real.
Lotta people getting muted today because now I'm a virtue signaling SJW. Which makes a nice change from muting people because I was a sexist.
I mean, when I said I started the YouTube channel because I wanted to make more DMs I meant it. Not just more white dude DMs.
People want Jedi in Andor because if there are space wizards, then normal people can relax, because the Space Wizards will stop the Empire.
Which is why there are no jedi in Andor.
I’ve never subscribed to the theory that Luthen is some secret Jedi fugitive.
I think he was a potentially well-off man in a comfortable profession who woke up one day and decided that he didn’t like what the Empire was doing to people and is using his wealth to change that.
Tolkien also was a little disgusted with the term cul-de-sac because it’s French and certainly English should have its own words for things.
So since cul-de-sac literally just means ‘bottom of a sack’ that’s what Tolkien used. Bag End. Bilbo lives in a cul-de-sac.
I think most current D&D players started with 5E and so don't have robust language for talking about all the different styles of play D&D has been used for.
Like...are folks aware that there's a difference between an adventure with a dungeon, and a Dungeon Crawl?
Herbert I think would have been perfectly fine with all this. It's the reason why he greenlit the Dune encyclopedia. He didn't feel like it was his job to be the authority on the universe he created. If it was a real place, he would just be one among many commentators.
I hope we get a ton of new RPGs out of this debacle. Big games, little games, games that are ABOUT something. A New Wave of RPGs.
#NewWaveOfFantasyRPGs
I am not running D&D right now, but I am a dungeon master. I am not playing in any games right now, but I am a gamer. I am not working on my novel right now, but I am a writer. I experience no doubt or ambiguity about these things, ever. Don't let other people define you.
It's worth noting that in 1970 the National Guard murdered 4 college students who were peacefully protesting the illegal bombing of a country we weren't at war with.
When polled, a majority of Americans figured those kids deserved it.
I think a lot of people would benefit from trying out games outside the D&D ecology. I see a lot of folks online saying "Well, the flavor text says X, what more can be done?" When D&D's your only example, you're not aware of how narrow a range of behaviors the rules encourage.
Telling a story about the forging of the rings in the Second Age. That is, in principle, a good idea. It's cool.
Making Middle-earth look more like...Earth, i.e. casting more women and POC is also good, any modern take on that setting should follow suit, it's a no brainer.
I think folks assume "I can't do a DM Tips channel, I haven't been doing it for 30 years." But A: we already got enough of that and B: it's MORE interesting AND useful to see DM Vlogs from people just starting. Those experiences and lessons are more important to new players.
We have announced a plan for a system neutral open RPG license in collaboration with other game companies. We believe it will irrevocably and unquestionably keep alive the spirit of the Open Game License. Learn more:
#OpenRPG
#pathfinder2e
#starfinder
Worked on games for LucasArts, EA, THQ, 2K and they all said the average age of the AAA customer is ~32.
Every time we heard this, folks rejected it in favor of the folklore than video games are for teenagers.
My brothers in Christ, teenagers ain't got that kinda money.
ARCADIA is doing AMAZING the reception has been hugely positive. We want to keep working with, featuring, promoting amazing talent. Here are the benefits of writing for ARCADIA:
1: We pay $0.25 a word. We expect 1200 words a day. We settled on those numbers because...
1/
I wear a mask when I go out, not because I think I am infected or because I'm afraid you might be infected, but because I want you to see that I am taking your health seriously.
People want "advanced techniques" for experienced GMs, but I think actually what's going to happen is Running the Game will evolve into Designing The Game.
Which makes sense, as I consider all GMs to be budding designers, whether they like it or not!
Cat: human I am dying
Me: oh no!
Cat: this is the end. Hear my piteous yowl
Me: what's wrong??
Cat: there is no food
Me: wait what?
Cat: cats need food to live
Me: I literally just fed you
Cat: ys but was distracted by outside cat. yeeowl
Me: you are too dumb to live
Cat: yeeoowl
I inadvertently visited YouTube in a new browser, with no history, without logging in. And I saw regular YouTube, no suggestions tailored for me. Just the most popular content.
Holy crap what a shit show. I can’t believe people use this site...
Someone in twitch chat, after I said I never met my dad but I know he was in the Air Force during the Vietnam War, said “of course Matt Colville would have Luke Skywalker’s origin story.”
That…is not something I have ever thought before and it’s kind of…I mean wow.
I said I'm in favor of reparations for the descendants of slaves. I said Black Lives Matter and Trans Rights are Human Rights. I refer to the GOP as a Death Cult, but the
#1
topic that causes me to ban the most people, by FAR, is still Star Citizen.
I have millennial friends with WAY FEWER life options than I had because they've got tens of thousands of dollars of student debt I never had to deal with. It's pretty easy to be my age or older and have no idea how common or severe this is. It's a massive generational change.
Cat; I must get in this cupboard
Me: ok why
Cat: is important
Me: y tho?
Cat; there is something inside. pls open
Me; what is inside?
Cat: I cannot speak and so cannot say but is v. important
Me: ‘k. *opens cupboard*
Cat: *sits on shelf*
Me: that’s it?!
Cat; yes, thank you v much
When I, a Gen-Xer who paid their own way, found how much debt my Millennial coworkers were saddled with, often $80k or more, for degrees it turned out they didn't need, I was STUNNED. There is NO WAY I'd be where I am right now if I came out of college with permanent debt.
It's really weird to see people I respect coming out against protests on Supreme Court Judges lawns.
What do these folks think is the *appropriate* action to take? Voting? I.e. the same process that got us where we are?
I think we need more explicitly evil PCs in D&D. Maybe not enough folks are reading OG Dragonlance. Maybe I've gone mad and this is a historically terrible idea. But some of my favorite PCs were evil.
Folks have detected (because I haven't tried to hide it) that I've been pretty down on streaming D&D recently. I don't want people to get the wrong idea, so I wrote up my current thoughts.
?
The real answer, the market survey revealed was....
They hadn't stopped playing.
Turns out there HUNDREDS OF THOUSANDS OF PEOPLE still playing D&D regularly. All through the 90s.
But they weren't playing 90s D&D. Second Edition D&D.
They were still playing AD&D!