Senior writer + founder of
@NiemanLab
at
@Harvard
. I write about (a) digital journalism, (b) southern history, mostly. Cajun. Takes mine, not Harvard's.
There are two approved Louisiana history textbooks for the state's 8th graders.
This is how one of them introduces the Civil War: as tough times for a poor young white woman whose family owned 120 slaves.
I'm not sure how you write a story about how great the schools in Highland Park, Texas, are without noting that they exist entirely to allow rich white Dallasites to maintain Jim Crow-style segregation.
THREAD
Astonishingly racist: The Louisiana House votes to make juvenile records PUBLIC —
but ONLY in the three Blackest urban parishes that include New Orleans, Baton Rouge, and Shreveport.
Story from a very long House floor session last night: Louisiana House approves releasing youth crime records in majority-Black parishes
#lalege
#lagov
via
@theadvocatebr
There is some nonsense going on in Caddo Parish (Shreveport), Louisiana.
Black man and white man run against each other for sheriff. Black man wins by 1 vote. He's the first Black sheriff elected in this majority-Black parish.
There's a recount, as you'd expect. He wins that…
Wow — this is awful.
For the record,
@Harvard
has no school of journalism, no department of journalism, and no professors of journalism.
(It does have
@niemanfdn
! But we have no faculty and no classes. And it does have
@ShorensteinCtr
, but no journalism-specific faculty.)
I have been the victim of a very serious phishing attack. I’m putting this statement out to set the record straight about what I’ve been through. I will not be addressing this issue any further on social media.
In the Pfizer vaccine trial for 5- to 12-year-olds, there were 4,647 participants and only 5 "severe adverse events," none of them related to the vaccine.
The best of them, BY FAR:
"Ingestion of a penny (1 person in the vaccine group)"
A former NBA player dies young, and AI writes this headline:
"Brandon Hunter useless at 42"
And check that prose:
"Former NBA participant Brandon Hunter who beforehand performed for the Boston Celtics and Orlando Magic, has handed away on the age of 42."
How in the world do you
(a) create a formula to determine how much “adversity” a 17-year-old has faced,
(b) using only school-level and neighborhood-level data, not personal data, and then
(c) hide the formula’s results from the kid?
It's jarring how comparatively little attention is being given to the fact that the last president was *impeached* specifically for trying to extort Ukraine and playing footsie with Russia and he's gonna run again in 2 years
The judge who granted the search warrant against the Marion, KS newspaper once drove into a school building. This happened while her license was suspended for an earlier DUI. She had been an active prosecutor for eight years already when this happened.
Since Giuliani’s last year in office, murders in NYC are down ~50%, major felonies are down ~40%.
Perceptions of crime are so wildly divergent from reality, so tightly tied to emotional responses to societal change.
Remember that dramatic Page 1 of the
@nytimes
last Friday, with the enormous spike showing 3.3 million unemployment claims?
To save the Times graphics team the trouble, this is what the same page would look like with today's 6.6 million unemployment claims.
These are not, on the whole, great ways to say “Trump, claiming unprecedented power to bypass laws and Congress, signs order to defund Social Security and Medicare”
Louisiana principal Jason St. Pierre removed a girl as student body president and denied her access to scholarships because...
he didn't like the way she danced at an off-campus party, saying she "wasn’t living in the Lord’s way."
If I ran a newspaper, I'd be running organized daily tests of the postal system.
Every day, send a set number of letters to a set number of locations — across town, three towns over, your state capital, big coastal cities, rural areas. Track how long each one takes to get there.
It is frankly astonishing that the
@nytimes
is treating a credible accusation of rape against the president by a well-known journalist as *a book publishing story*
"Most of our large universities are turning out socialists, cynics, and atheists"! So we're starting a new college "to teach pure Americanism"!
The speaker: Nathan Bedford Forrest II, describing in 1921 a new college in Atlanta owned by the Ku Klux Klan.
This guy ran in a D+71 district — one of the most Democratic districts in the country — and lost 86-14.
And yet he’s saying it was probably just the most massive and counterintuitive voter fraud in human history.
Other things to know about Jeffrey Clark, the scheming DOJ lawyer here:
— It took 16 months for the GOP Senate to confirm him
— A year ago, he was found to have been practicing law without a license
— He represented BP in the Deepwater Horizon oil spill
This is how it introduces Reconstruction: through the gosh-darn sticktoitiveness of Francis Tillou Nicholls, the ex-Confederate "redeemer" who crushed black political rights.
The
@nytimes
is a glorious and critical institution.
But how ABSOLUTELY INSANE is it that its vision of the struggling middle class is someone making $200-400K in a Pennsylvania small town?
I am kind of amazed that this exchange hasn't gotten more attention:
Top officials from both the Trump and Clinton campaigns agreeing that Facebook's ad-pricing algorithm charged Clinton 100 to 200 TIMES as much for its ads as it charged Trump.
My small contribution to this eternal debate: We can distinguish between "lie" as a noun and "lie" as a verb. Something can be a "lie" without knowing if the person saying it is "lying."
Example: "The Holocaust never happened" is a lie, even if the person saying it believes it.
Right and the point here is we don’t know. So absent that omniscience, we have all reported he said something that wasn’t true and explained just how untrue it was. All day on Twitter and in the pages of NYT.
Bret Stephens cites a Henry Harpending paper in his "Jewish genius" column
Here's an
@nytopinion
piece from *just last year* noting Henry Harpending was a white supremacist nut about this stuff
An underrated part of the
@Saints
' game-winning FG last night is that
@wil_lutz5
and
@thomasmorstead
are both already celebrating when the ball is still like 40 yards from the goalposts
Of the Boston public high school valedictorians the
@BostonGlobe
tracked down, more became homeless than became doctors (the career 1/4 of them had said they aspired to).
Today, only 40% earn more than $50K a year, and 1 in 4 don't have a college degree.
The
@nytimes
has more subscribers today than it has ever had in its history — over 5 million.
It made $140 million in profit last year.
Its newsroom has grown from 1,110 to 1,700 journalists in the past six years, and it's gonna be around a lot longer than
@realDonaldTrump
.
Advertising in the Failing New York Times is WAY down. Washington Post is not much better. I can’t say whether this is because they are Fake News sources of information, to a level that few can understand, or the Virus is just plain beating them up. Fake News is bad for America!
Okay, hold on. Bloomberg describes this guy as a "Shy Trumper," someone "hesitant to share their politics with pollsters, colleagues, and friends."
But this guy also self-published a book called "TRUMPBOOK: How Digital Liberals Silenced A Nation Into Making America Hate Again"
I love how fast companies shift from "pay us lots of money and we will optimize your advertising so it changes more people's minds!" and "jk, ads don't work, ha ha" in times of crisis
Dallas ISD students are 69.9% Hispanic and 21.4% Black.
Highland Park ISD students are 6% Hispanic and 0.8% Black.
85% of Dallas students qualify for free/reduced lunch.
0.2% of Highland Park students do.
The "middle class"
"everyday Americans" the
@nytimes
chose to highlight here have household incomes of:
$120-200K
$120-200K
$200-400K
$200-400K
$75-100K
$120-200K
$120-200K
The median US household income is $61,000.
Matthew Stafford, Clayton Kershaw, and Scottie Scheffler are very talented athletes, and I have no reason to think they aren't wonderful people.
But a story that portrays their high school as some kind of hits factory should acknowledge *why and how* it became one — bigotry.
When Kavanaugh is claiming to have no idea who Ford is, he was hanging out all the time with HER BOYFRIEND throughout the summer of 1982!
(Kavanaugh testified that Chris Garrett is the "Squi" in the famous July 1 calendar entry.)
One way to describe Nellie Bowles' "German great-great-great-grandfather" is as a San Francisco butcher.
Another is as the "the Cattle King of California," the largest landowner in the U.S., and founder of a family fortune that's lasted six generations.
141 years ago, on New Year's Day, a boy was born in Tolcsva, a village connected only a few years earlier to the rest of Hungary by rail. He was the first of what would eventually be 12 born to parents Michael and Hannah.
Nine months later, the family set sail for America.
1/x
This is a map of the Dallas Independent School District. See the white hole in the middle labeled University Park and Highland Park? Those are called the Park Cities, and they make up Highland Park Independent School District.
It's very white.
This might even be worse — the "life in antebellum Louisiana" chapter. It is literally: "Look at this cool French white guy who lifted his sense of rhythm from slaves playing in Congo Square"
After Joe McCarthy was censured by the Senate in 1954, he stayed in office for two-plus more years.
But other senators publicly ignored him; his speeches were to an empty chamber; the press no longer bit on his claims. He became a pariah.
Just spitballing for Hawley and Cruz.
Scoop from
@kdoctor
:
"Leaders in the field of nonprofit journalism are deciding over the next 48 hours whether or not to make a bid for all of
@mcclatchy
, sources tell me."
The idea: create the country's first major nonprofit newspaper chain.
The transcript text is right around 2,000 words, and the call took exactly 30 min — that's about 66 words per minute.
That's quite slow — roughly half normal speaking rate. (Zelensky is fluent in English.)
Could suggest how much text isn't included.
Highland Park didn't have a single Black homeowner until ***2003***.
The town paper put the event on p. 1 with the lede: "Guess who's coming to dinner — and staying for a while?"
A white man makes dozens of homemade bombs and plants three of them at a BLM rally — but luckily the bombs are discovered before they can kill anyone.
For doing that he gets...zero prison time? Just probation?
25% of 18- to 24-year-olds,
19% of Hispanics,
15% of blacks,
22% of essential workers, and
31% of unpayed caregivers for adults
have "seriously considered suicide" in the past 30 days
It is interesting that by far the worst American natural disaster (in terms of lives lost) of the past century is being treated as a weird regression-driven footnote
When the town was planned in 1913, it required all property owners to have a deed covenant saying it "shall be used for residence purposes only, and by white persons only...not excluding bona fide servants of any race."
(And, just to be technical, Louisiana doesn't officially "approve" textbooks, in that school districts are free to choose whatever textbooks they like. But this is one of the two Louisiana history textbooks that are officially reviewed by the state in the list districts get.)
Highland Park didn't get its first Black student until ***1974***.
They'd never even *had* to set up "separate-but-equal" school systems.
They'd found the simpler solution: Just don't have any Black students to begin with!
The magic of all this segregation is that Highland Park residents pay a school property tax rate ~10% ***less*** than Dallas residents do —
but their tax base means they still get to spend 78% ***more*** per student than Dallas schools can.
One of the many maddening things in this John McWhorter column is his claim that a typical 19th-century American was "better educated in some ways" than today's college graduate.
His evidence: a quote he liked from some dude's diary in the 1830s.
1/x
For giggles, I checked how this AI company
@Seekr_io
currently rates the "reliability" of stories on Kevin McCarthy's ouster as speaker.
VERY HIGH: Breitbart, Daily Mail, NY Post, OANN, ZeroHedge, WashTimes
VERY LOW: Bloomberg, NYT, BBC, Guardian, ABC, NBC, Time, Politico
🤔
Ah, but what if those live-in servants had (gasp) kids of their own?
Highland Park taxpayers literally *paid* Dallas schools to take its few Black residents off their hands into the 1960s.
Chile rechaza las acciones destinadas a alterar proceso democrático en EEUU y condena la violencia e indebida interferencia con las instituciones constitucionales
Chile confía en la solidez de la democracia estadounidense para garantizar el imperio de la ley y estado de derecho.
58% of adults oppose hormone treatments for 15- to 17-year-olds.
Headline: "Most Americans support anti-trans policies favored by GOP"
58% support a clean debt-ceiling bill with zero spending cuts.
Headline: "Americans split on who they’d blame if U.S. defaults"
Same number!
Bonus: You'll be SHOCKED to learn Highland Park has been a leader in pushing anti-CRT nonsense.
The idea that Highland Park schools might be "indoctrinating" its students against white people may be the most hilarious thing I've ever heard.
"Racist Elijah Cummings" "has done a terrible job for the people of his district." "Elijah Cummings has been a brutal bully." "Elijah Cummings spends all of his time trying to hurt innocent people." "Investigate this corrupt mess immediately!"
to
"My warmest condolences"
Using broader community data means that the richest white kid and the poorest black/Hispanic kid in a given high school are assigned the same “adversity score”
Perhaps worth remembering in the context of teenaged Kavanaugh: He joined a secret society at Yale known for excessive drinking and nicknamed “Tit and Clit.”
There's a lot of new detail in this story. Among other things, Kavanaugh's accuser, Christine Blasey Ford, contacted the Washington Post and Feinstein in July, and took a polygraph in August, but then decided she didn't want to come forward.
Ummmm, check out how Fox News contributor Charlie Hurt frames D.C. and Puerto Rico statehood:
"It’s going to be about structural changes, like adding two new welfare states to the union so that they can cement their power for a generation."
Given how little attention climate change gets in the national media, to waste even a fraction of it on deniers paid by the fossil fuel industry making things up is a journalistic sin
That student, James Lockhart, enrolled for a single school year.
Six years later, as of this 1980 Texas Monthly story, he remained the only Black graduate in Highland Park history.
"I'm not allowed to say anything anymore," says man quoted in national magazine, who will vote for Trump because, in today's P.C. climate, you can't even insult people to their face anymore without them unfriending you
All the pieces of American criminal-justice dystopia:
— a black man stopped "because" his headlights were too bright
— who then gets tased 4 times, killing him
— all of it filmed for the nation's entertainment by "Live PD"
— which then destroys the video
I wrote about how Amazon's doorbell company
@ring
is, um, hiring a managing editor? To oversee crime reporting?
More importantly, it's about what happens when coverage of crime is done by institutions that have a financial incentive to make you afraid.
In 2005 — not long ago! — I was covering K-12 schools for
@dallasnews
and co-wrote this story:
Highland Park HS had an annual "Thug Day" when all the rich white kids dressed up as Black people.
Also, "Fiesta Day," for dressing up as your lawn guy.
Should journalists call the death of Iranian Gen. Qassem Soleimani an "assassination?" Assassinations are illegal. i.e. “No person employed by or acting on behalf of the United States Government shall engage in, or conspire to engage in, assassination."
Police can do that because Highland Park makes all sorts of normal behavior — jogging! eating in a park! playing tennis! "protracted lounging"! — either illegal or reserved for Highland Park residents only.
Consider this my gift to the world:
Here are the daily/Sunday circulations of the largest newspapers in the United States — information that is surprisingly difficult to find online!
These are all the papers with daily circulation of at least 75,000:
Seriously, this is how it sums up antebellum life in Louisiana.
Would anyone reading this understand that the majority of human being in the state were enslaved?
Or that being enslaved wasn't mostly about getting to "gather to cook, talk, sing, dance"?
The years after Brown v. Board of Education were spent trying to figure out how to avoid getting sued and forced to educate Black kids.
Dallas eventually stopped taking them.
I'd like to hear the justification of any news outlet that interviews or quotes anyone CONTRACTUALLY BARRED from saying anything negative about a candidate.
Interesting moment on CNN: After Rob Astorino defends Trump’s post-conviction praise of Paul Manafort, Poppy Harlow notes Astorino is on Trump’s 2020 advisory cmte. He says yes. So he’s signed an NDA, she adds. He nods. Which has a non-disparagement clause. He sits frozen still.
An alderman — a recent president of the Dallas Bar Association! — asked residents to fire all their Black servants so the town could avoid the issue.
Another alderman suggested ethnic cleansing, "that all Negroes be moved out of Highland Park," but someone noted that's illegal.
New by me —>
An incomplete history of
@Forbes
as a platform for scams, grift, and bad journalism.
You simply can’t have 1000s of unpaid, wildly conflicted people writing unedited copy at scale and expect all they produce to meet journalistic standards!
An HP senior in that story: "I think it’s real scary to go to school with blacks and I’m glad I don’t have to."
The writer: HP kids see "people of different races not as fellow students but as servants, people who provide convenience and comfort for them, who aim to please."
In 1969, when the town worried that some of its ~50 Black children — again, the kids of live-in servants — might try to enroll, it banned all kitchens in "servants' quarters." Starve 'em out!
It worked: The number dropped quickly to zero.
In March 2008,
@brianstelter
wrote a story for
@nytimes
about how young people were getting news online. It's a pretty straightforward story — but there's one quote in it that still has an impact on debates about digital journalism today. 1/x
That tax base has also allowed Highland Park to have 3.5x as many officers per capita as Texas (and 2.8x Dallas), despite having little crime.
For decades, HP police have been used as a sort of private security guard for keeping undesirables out of town.
Cities that no longer have a 7-day home-delivered print newspaper:
Pittsburgh
Youngstown
Cleveland
Detroit
Ann Arbor
Flint
Grand Rapids
Syracuse
Harrisburg
Toledo
Rough, *rough* time for newspapers around the Great Lakes.
"Students at Highland Park High School dressed as gang members, rap stars, maids and yard workers this month during homecoming week — a tradition one Dallas civil-rights leader says is racially insensitive."
(See, we needed someone in the lede to *say* the obvious. No bias!)
"On senior Thug Day, students wore Afro wigs, fake gold teeth and baggy jeans. On Fiesta Day, which was to honor Hispanic heritage, one student brought a leaf blower to school."
An outraged whistleblower called us about it.
(Technically, you can also get a "Master of Liberal Arts (ALM) in Extension Studies, field: Journalism" via
@HarvardExt
, but that is a separate open-admission program designed for adult learners, taught by adjuncts, and with no full-time journalism faculty.)
Well, one.
There was one Highland Park family who didn't want to give up their live-in maid. So she kindly rented an empty apartment within Dallas district boundaries so her maid's kids could pretend to live there.