Amazingly at age 92, Charles Taylor has yet another big book coming out with
@Harvard_Press
- I look forward to reading it (I knew he was working on this book along with his last book The Language Animal since when I interviewed him over a decade ago)
BOOK GIVEAWAY! 5 signed copies of my book Virtue and Meaning (
@CambUP_PHILNYUK
): 1 to someone who likes this post, 2 to people who retweet; 2 to new followers. Lottery system; will notify via DM on Friday. Restricted to people in the US due to shipping costs.
There's a phenomenon of Marxists who end up moving in a conservative direction (MacIntyre, Cohen, Lasch, etc.). Can people think of other instances? Also, how do you explain it? I ask because I'm working on an essay on After Virtue and Conservatism for a CUP volume on AV at 40.
BOOK GIVEAWAY! I’m giving away two hardback copies of The Virtues of Limits (
@OUPPhilosophy
), randomly selected from LIKES, RETWEETS, and NEW FOLLOWERS. I’ll announce the winners in 5 days. (I also plan to do a giveaway when the paperback is out.) US only due to costs.
I'm looking forward to Charles Taylor's new big book "Cosmic Connections: Poetry in an Age of Disenchantment" (
@Harvard_Press
) coming out next week. I'm especially looking forward to the chapters on Hopkins and Eliot. It's amazing he is still publishing books like this at 93!
Lots of good examples so far - any explanations? The most common, I think, is "mugged by reality"? Would people argue Marxism itself has a conservative tendency (as a kind of romanticism)? A conservative lament: "All that is solid melts into air, all that is holy is profaned"?
Got some more copies of The Virtues of Limits (
@OUPPhilosophy
@OxUniPress
) for review work, which I will be sending out to people who helped me with the book
I'm pleased to announce I've finalized a grant agreement with
@templeton_fdn
for a 3-year project on “Spiritual Yearning and the Problem of Spiritual Alienation,” connected with their research initiative on “The Search for Meaning among the Nonreligious.”
My spouse Kirstin’s latest watercolor painting and one of my favorites: our son Peter playing with the water at a creek in Rocky Mountain National Park.
I am looking for recommendations for good work on loneliness, whether from philosophy, psychology, or the social sciences. I am writing on this for my current book project on spiritual alienation. Thanks!
Very happily, I just received this in the mail - many thanks to Eleonore Stump for sending me a copy of her new book The Image of God (
@OUPPhilosophy
)! I look forward to reading it (it’s very relevant to my current book project, Spiritual Alienation & the Quest for God).
Happy Feast of St. Thomas Aquinas: 'Nobody will understand the Thomist philosophy who does not realize that the fundamental part of it is the praise of Life, the praise of Being, the praise of God as the Creator of the World. Everything else follows a long way after that' (GKC).
A fav from Aristotle: "Whatever someone regards as ... the end for which he chooses to be alive, that is the activity he wishes to pursue in his friend’s company. Hence some friends drink together, others play dice, while others do gymnastics and go hunting, or do philosophy."
I thought some people might like to see the other possibility I was given for a cover for The Virtues of Limits (
@OUPPhilosophy
) - I think I definitely made the right choice, but I also like the alternative cover.
Many thanks to
@sabrinablittle
for this excellent review of my book The Virtues of Limits (
@OUPPhilosophy
). Sabrina really grasps and appreciates the nature of the project, while also adding very important insights of her own.
My review of
@davidlmcpherson
's book, The Virtues of Limits, is out in the Journal of Moral Philosophy. It is easily one of the best books on virtue in the past decade.
My wife Kirstin is learning the classical realist method of drawing, and she just finished a drawing of Homer (11 x 15 graphite on paper; for sale for $100, shipping included in US)
Today is the official publication date for The Virtues of Limits (
@OUPPhilosophy
@OxUniPress
) in the UK! The pub date is February 15th in the US, though copies ship out on January 15th in the US. Here's the 30% discount code for the OUP website: AAFLYG6
@BrandonWarmke
My personal favorite is "brave" - in the olden day it described something done on the battlefield, now it is said of those who say the things that meet with widespread approval of one's academic peers.
My review of Simon May's excellent book Love: A New Understanding of an Ancient Emotion (
@OUPPhilosophy
@OxUniPress
@OUPAcademic
), where he puts forward a compelling account of love as seeking "ontological rootedness," that is, being at home in the world:
This is ridiculous. I hope
@OUPPhilosophy
stands strong against these anti-philosophical bullies. OUP needs to be a place where these debates can happen, not a place that silences one side. I am sure the vast majority of OUP authors, like myself, agree.
We, the members of the OUP USA Guild, are calling upon our colleagues and authors to take a stand against the upcoming publication of “Gender-Critical Feminism”. Sign the petition below (OUP employees and authors only).
The paperback edition of my book Virtue and Meaning: A New-Aristotelian Perspective (
@CambUP_PHILNYUK
@CambridgeUP
) is now available, and at an affordable price!
I just uploaded on PhilPapers this essay I wrote on Bernard Williams, Alasdair MacIntyre, and Charles Taylor, which is titled "Three Rival Versions of the Relationship of Religion and Modernity," which was for a symposium on religion and secularism:
@ehritzema
I think that is a good explanation - there's something right in the Marxist critique of capitalism, but it lacks a feasible and desirable positive program. And of course traditionalists conservatives have often been critical of capitalism too:
I just saw Rosalind Hursthouse has a collection of essays coming out with
@OUPPhilosophy
, and it has a number of essays that I did not know about, but which look very interesting. I look forward to getting this.
Because I do not hope to turn again
Because I do not hope
Because I do not hope to turn ...
Teach us to care and not to care
Teach us to sit still.
Pray for us sinners now and at the hour of our death
Pray for us now and at the hour of our death.
- T. S. Eliot, "Ash Wednesday"
I am thrilled to share our press release for the 21 new hires we have made this year! Top-notch scholars and people! I am really excited for what we are building
@ufhamilton
(soon to be the 17th college
@UF
).
(2/2) The abortion debate is not about whether the human embryo or fetus (or child) is alive (clearly this is the case), but rather about when a human life has full moral status. In other words, it is a debate about whether we all share a fundamental human equality.
"Alienation is the normal condition of human existence. Rebellion against God is the natural reaction to the discovery that the world was not made for our personal convenience... Religious faith asserts the goodness of being in the face of suffering and evil."
- Christopher Lasch
Working on getting the final manuscript of The Virtues of Limits ready to submit to
@OUPPhilosophy
@OUPAcademic
- the biggest influences are clearly: Wiggins, G. A. Cohen, Sandel, Kass, Diamond, Chesterton, Kolnai, Scruton, Aristotle, and Wendell Berry.
First day of class at UF is in the books. I thought I’d share some pictures of the beautiful future home of the Hamilton College (the Great Books college I am involved in getting built up), which is undergoing major renovations, particularly inside. Can’t wait to move in there!
My wife Kirstin’s first commissioned watercolor painting - I am very proud of her development as a watercolor painter (she’s just been doing it for about a year or so).
We are hiring for a number of senior, junior, and postdoc positions in the Hamilton Center for Classical and Civic Education at UF. We are building up the Center into a Great Books college. It’s an exciting undertaking! Here’s the senior position:
@spartanburger91
@DrJavadTHashmi
@Helenreflects
Height is a little over 11″, and the depth is 12″ - I was just trying to maximize space and fit standard academic books (including bigger ones). 10 foots ceiling with 9 shelves for 8 rows of shelves.
🐊 Big news: starting fall 2025, I’ll be moving to the University of Florida where I’ll be Associate Professor of Humanities at the Hamilton Center for Classical and Civic Education.
I’m thrilled to help build a growing institution devoted to truth-seeking 🐊
@UF
@ufhamilton
One of my favorite lines in all of Plato's works:
"Let parents, then, bequeath to their children not a heap of riches, but the spirit of reverence."
- Laws, Book V
"Given the limits of our existence, we will never realize a state of perfection through our striving, and so we need a way of living with imperfection, that is, we need a way of coming to see life in the world as good and worth affirming despite the ill."
#TheVirtuesofLimits
For those interested, here is a podcast on Dostoevsky I did with
@jennfrey
on
@eudaimoniapod
a couple years ago. It is always fun talking with Jen. Her podcast is really great and I encourage you to follow it.
Thanks to Todd May for this nice review of The Virtues of Limits (
@OUPPhilosophy
) in
@NDPReviews
. While I don't think the criticisms quite capture the nuance of my views (hard to do in a short review), it appreciatively conveys the overall argument well.
My new book The Virtues of Limits (
@OUPPhilosophy
) is on sale for 40% off ($42 in hardback) with free shipping (you'll see the discount when you add to cart) - OUP is having sale connected to the Eastern APA until Jan 22. Please retweet if so inclined!
‘In virtue of the deep involvement of moral luck in the acquisition and persistence of virtue, it is misleading to think of virtue as an individual achievement. But that is no tragedy. We may well have a richer view of virtue if we regard it largely as a gift.’ - R. M. Adams
You can read (and download) the first chapter of my book The Virtues of Limits (Oxford, 2022) here. Also, please repost, if you feel so inclined. Thanks!
Exploring two fundamental existential stances, "Existential Limit" by
@davidlmcpherson
delves into the works of Friedrich Nietzsche and, more recently, Ronald Dworkin.
Read the
#FreeChapter
here, as part of our
#VirtuesandVices
collection:
I read a draft of this new book from
@BrandonWarmke
and
@JustinTosi
, and it is excellent. They offer a compelling defense of “minding one’s own business” through becoming rooted, attending to your home and what is near, and making space for solitude.
I am very happy to share this symposium on my book Virtue and Meaning: A Neo-Aristotelian Perspective (
@CambUP_PHILNYUK
@CambridgeUP
) just published in
@ResPhil
with excellent contributions from
@CharacterGap
and P. J. Ivanhoe.
My book The Virtues of Limits (
@OUPPhilosophy
@OxUniPress
) is now available for pre-order in the UK (I will post again when the US page goes up; you can also order to US and elsewhere from UK). Here is a 30% discount code: AAFLYG6
“One may stand perplexed ... seeing men’s sin, asking oneself: “Shall I take it by force, or by humble love?” Always resolve to take it by humble love. If you so resolve once and for all, you will be able to overcome the whole world.” (Zosima in The Brothers Karamazov)
A symposium on my book Virtue and Meaning: A Neo-Aristotelian Perspective (
@CambridgeUP
@CambUP_PHILNYUK
) is now out with American Catholic Philosophical Quarterly:
Just back from our family trip and happily found a hard copy of this symposium on my book Virtue and Meaning (
@CambUP_PHILNYUK
@CambridgeUP
) waiting for me, which has great contributions from
@CharacterGap
(Wake Forest) and PJ Ivanhoe (Georgetown).
Very hard to pick one, but I think a case can be made for humility (the master limiting virtue), reverence (necessary for humility and avoiding nihilistic will to power), gratitude (Ignatius: ingratitude is the greatest sin), and love (Augustine: ethics is rightly ordered love).
“The task of morality is to place limits on our desires and our wills such that they accord with the given structures of the world and human nature.” Thanks
@Zheschool
for this fine review of my book The Virtues of Limits (
@OUPPhilosophy
): via
@americamag
Here in
@PublicDiscourse
, drawing on Philippa Foot's idea of the virtues as correctives, I seek to answer The Big Lebowski's question "What makes a man?"
"There is a human loneliness that stems from some other source than the lack of companionship ... The separation between the self-conscious being and his world is not to be overcome by any natural process. It can be remedied only by grace." (Roger Scruton, The Face of God)
Today is the official US release date for The Virtues of Limits (
@OUPPhilosophy
). Here is the 30% discount code for ordering the book on the OUP website: AAFLYG6. The first printing sold out, but it is currently reprinting (it is in stock on Amazon).
The virtue of neighborliness is a kind of human solidarity that recognizes the moral significance of proximity. It calls us to solidarity with concrete rather than abstract humanity. As Chesterton puts it: "we have to love our neighbour because he is there."
#TheVirtuesofLimits
(1/2) After listening to the oral arguments in the Dobbs case, I am continually amazed how many people (including Justice Sotomayor today) frame it as a debate about “when life begins,” and act as if that is some heady philosophical dispute.
Updated Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy entry on Virtue Ethics out today (by Glen Pettigrove, originally by Rosalind Hursthouse). I am happy to see my book Virtue and Meaning (Cambridge, 2020) now in the bibliography.
“The aim of life is appreciation; there is no sense in not appreciating things; and there is no sense in having more of them if you have less appreciation of them.”
-- G. K. Chesterton
I really appreciated this essay by
@sabrinablittle
on the virtue of contentment, which draws on my book The Virtues of Limits (
@OUPPhilosophy
). I look forward to Sabrina’s book The Examined Run, forthcoming with OUP.
I look forward to this very interesting volume of essays coming out in a month. My wife Kirstin and I contributed an essay on Babette's Feast, one of our favorite films.
'The [religious] response to loss is to bear it as a loss ... seeing it as a form of consecrated suffering. ... The loss of religion makes real loss difficult to bear ... people flee from [it]. The loss of religion, one might suggest, is the loss of loss.'
I had great talk on and conversation about The Virtues of Limits today at MSU Denver for the Denver Project for Humanistic Inquiry (despite what the photo suggests, which was taken before hand, it was a great turn out at a very cool venue).
Wonderful, insightful reflections by
@nmpenn
in
@PublicDiscourse
on the importance of embracing our limits, which engage with my new book The Virtues of Limits (
@OUPPhilosophy
@OxUniPress
). Thanks Nicole! I also love the painting used here.
The word “utopia” is formed from the Greek words ou (“not”) and topos (“place”), which suggests it is a “no place”: it exists nowhere, except for in the imagination. A politics of imperfection, by contrast, is an embrace of somewhere with all its imperfection.
#TheVirtuesofLimits
“[To] be able to give, one has to possess; and we possess no other life, no other sap, than the treasures stored up from the past and digested, assimilated and created afresh by us.”
- Simone Weil, The Need for Roots
Here's the link for my upcoming online talk on The Virtues of Limits (
@OUPPhilosophy
) for
@TAngelicum
, where you can register (open to all). It is 10 am, Sat, April 23 in Hong Kong, and 8 pm, Fri, April 22 my time in the US (Mountain Time).
“We must have limits or we will cease to exist as humans; perhaps we will cease to exist, period. Our human and earthly limits, properly understood, are not confinements but rather inducements to formal elaboration and elegance, to fullness of relationship and meaning.” (W Berry)
“Above all, do not lie to yourself. A man who lies to himself and listens to his own lie comes to a point where he does not discern any truth either in himself or anywhere around him, and thus falls into disrespect towards himself and others.”
-- Zosima in Dostoevsky’s BK
@BrandonWarmke
Interesting that the survey had a 10% response rate - I know I didn't respond! I don't like this kind of stuff. I suspect heterodox people might be less likely to respond to this stuff. But still I think the numbers would be bad with a 100% response rate.
1/2: “[For] Aristotle the life of the mind consists, to a large degree, in observing, doing research, and reflecting on one’s observations. Yet this activity is carried out in a certain spirit, which we might go so far as to describe as an almost religious passion for reality …
This is an excellent essay by
@xaviersymons
. We need to give up our illusory and harmful aspirations toward omnipotent control and learn to accept and embrace our human finitude (themes of my own work, especially of my new book The Virtues of Limits).