Personally, I really don't care what livery Rosie should be painted in, as long as she's a good character with potential which she is in a way.

@SodorSamurai I’m not fussed either, I’m just glad she’s back, even if it’s for one last time in the spotlight

@DanielAlsop2 Well she had two major roles in S21 and S22 and that was it for her, sadly.

@SodorSamurai It did make Rosie stand out amongst the other engines.

@JonathanAsiama2 Well true, but it’s not that I view her as a girly stereotype.

@SodorSamurai roses are actually red

@CTFEologist Yeah, and violets are blue.

@SodorSamurai She looks fine either way to me, tho I do prefer the addition of the headlamp

@SodorSamurai Pink Rosie > Red Rosie imo

@SodorSamurai They shouldn't have changed her original livery, because there was no point. Her original livery made her stand out from everyone else. They took what made her unique, and ruined it. It's also strange they removed her makeup, why'd they do that?

@SodorSamurai I like the red better but I don’t like the NWR lettering and the lamp isn’t necessary. Makes her look like an oc.

@SodorSamurai I think there is a happy medium like ROSE pink or darker lavender. Realistic but still fantastical enough to fit the show.

@SodorSamurai I like both liveries that she's been given, but the red one just wins it for me.

@SodorSamurai They could have changed the pink to magenta, but should have kept the white Window and maybe gold lining and lettering.

@SodorSamurai I like both but the original makes her stand out more. I can’t really think of another engine that’s pink on the railway.

@SodorSamurai You're not alone. They can keep the lamplight thingy on her head but I think the pink lavender color suits her way much better.

@SodorSamurai Actually, we just got a letter reply from original show producer Ian McCue. They changed her paintwork because of how stereotypical it looked in the HiT era.

@SodorSamurai Personally, I like both, I feel like Rosie being painted red could work if they had expanded her more in the CGI series before the repaint. Personally, as long as I get to use both versions I guess it's either or.

@SodorSamurai Agreed. There isn't anything stereotypical about her pink paint at all, it's actually a really nice colour scheme if i'm being honest, and i think her being such a bright/unique livery actually helped her stand out among the cast. Ian McCue doesn't know what the hell he's saying.

@SodorSamurai Nah. I’m fine with it too. This could probably be nostalgia speaking here, but I always felt Rosie looked off, when coloured red