@SodorSamurai
I think it’s fine in S6-S7, purely because in those seasons Henry was still a capable but flawed engine, and the recast did a better job at portraying that. I felt sympathy for him. In the HIT era, the face looks like $#!t.
@SodorSamurai
I think they recasted the face because they were worried the gaps between his eyes would be more noticeable on the big screen for MR and that's why they recasted it to make the eye holes smaller but it looks so off