@DouggieTheCoolG Well some people do like it, but others don't.

@TywynWharf2002 Why does everyone hate Trusty Rusty so much? Personally I love it.

@NJC2005 - Duncan insulting Rusty despite becoming friends in Rock 'n' Roll. - According to NWTom25, this was where the "no coal makes engine stop" thing came from even though it was used before in Escape! - Duncan's driver being an idiot.

@TywynWharf2002 Rusty to the Rescue is fine. It's just the narration that is messed up. Like it should not take all day for Rusty to get to the Vicarstown Goods Depot.

@ThomasSirHandel Then how long do you think it should've taken him?

@TywynWharf2002 I love all four of them.

@Streakofscarlet I do too.

@TywynWharf2002 Anyone who finds the first two controversial deserves a kick in the groin. I don't make the rules, that's just how the dome fits.

@TywynWharf2002 Because he can't hold a good episode? Even in Christopher Awdry's RWS books he didn't have a starring role.

@TywynWharf2002 I for one always loved “Rusty to the Rescue,” regardless if it was intended to be nothing more than a sequel to “Escape.” “Rusty and the Boulder” really brought out the suspense for me. “Rusty Saves the Day” and “Trusty Rusty” however I never liked

@TywynWharf2002 i like rusty

@TywynWharf2002 Because he doesn't have flaws, meaning barely any good episodes. None of these are really controversial.

@TywynWharf2002 I ponder this myself

@TywynWharf2002 I don't call Rusty and the Boulder or Trusty Rusty controversial

@TywynWharf2002 Well rusty and the boulder is not at all, the bottom two are just bad episodes and in rusty to the rescue brit not only through out logic in having a narrow gauge line to the mainland but also disregarded the gender of rusty to make him gender fluid which they only did for one ep

@TywynWharf2002 There really isn’t any reason Trusty Rusty should be a controversial ep lol. At least compared to the likes of Rusty and the Boulder

@TywynWharf2002 I think its because he didn't have a large role in the RWS so especially with Season 4, they heavily expanded on him.

@TywynWharf2002 Rusty and the Boulder, Rusty to the Rescue, and Trusty Rusty were good in my opinion. But Rusty Saves the Day makes Sir Topham Hatt not caring about the bad condition that the Skarloey Railway was in. And I don't why that has unexpectedly happened.

@TywynWharf2002 Because he is a diesel 😅

@TywynWharf2002 The only one I dislike is "Rusty Saves the Day". "Trusty Rusty" is a bit weird given Duncan's personality, but it's not that bad. "Rusty and the Boulder" is very unrealistic, but if we ignore realism it's such a great episode with plenty of suspense and drama (like most of S5).