Hi all. The ducks are going to fly away from this place and eventually land in bluer skies. They thank you for all the food for thought youβve given them and wish you happy solving for years to come.
#NYTXW
π₯π₯π₯π₯π₯π₯π₯π₯π₯π₯π₯π₯π₯π₯π₯
THU: Wow. This is really a beauty! Feels like so much work went into this and the result is theme dense yet such a smooth solve and a super fun revealer. A total joy to solve this one. The ducks want in. 8:44 π₯π₯π₯π₯
#NYTXW
SUN: Puzzles like this make me feel better about being harsh on the lazy Sunday ones. This one is cool and clever - both a construction marvel and fun for the solver. Loved how I was able in some cases to parse some of the upper answers from lower ones 18:40 π₯π₯π₯π₯
#NYTXW
THU: Love this type of theme where the gimmick requires a different element for each themer. And the reveal is so so good. Lotsa threeβs but itβs ok when the solve is this fun. 7:11 ππππ.
#NYTXW
THU: So good. Such a clever well executed theme that youβd think might be tough to work with, but the whole thing feels so smooth and alive. Even the grid itself is pretty. 7:13 π₯π₯π₯π₯
#NYTXW
THU: Love this one. Felt clear something was off and didnβt immediately see it after the revealer but then a very satisfying aha moment. And nice that there were no other *βs in the other clues. Super fun Thursday gimmick. 8:12 π₯π₯π₯π₯
#NYTXW
SAT: Love these kinds of Saturday puzzles. Intimidating at first and then you chip away, and even if you donβt know all the answers (even after you get them - 51A?), the end feels satisfying. Enjoyed the mathy stuff too. 17:31 π₯π₯π₯π£
#NYTXW
THU: Very enjoyable word play for Thursday trickery but I think 35A is incorrect in the grid, right? The ****** letters are off? Other than that bit of confusion, fill was lovely. 7:12 π₯π₯π₯π£
#NYTXW
FRI: Wow. This one feels like a work of art. Six lovely grid spanners and (I think) it uses all the alphabet while still managing to be super smooth and fun and lively. Canβt stop admiring it. 7:44 π₯π₯π₯π₯
#NYTXW
WED: Offensively bad. This theme is so weak not only because weβre all familiar with the aptness of these names but also because it features a outspoken homophobe among them (44A). Yuck. 5:40 No ducks.
#NYTXW
THU: Really fun. Couldnβt see what was going on but the 15 across the middle started to clue me in. And then the revealer sealed the deal - love when that happens. 60D was cruel - I had a D! :). Q: is 1D the playing cards? 8:44 Grade: A
#NYTXW
SAT: So smooth with a fun vibe and some super clever word play/misdirection. βCheap cabβ and βcomplex ruleβ were my favorites. I used to be averse to the themeless but themes can be restrictive and with beauties like this, maybe we need more of them. 10:34 π₯π₯π₯π₯
#NYTXW
FRI: Canβt remember a recent themeless I enjoyed less than this one. So stale and old-fashioned with some ridiculous entries - 9D, 46D for example. Really no fun at all. This one must have been sitting in the queue for years π£ 12:12
#NYTXW
THU: Killer theme. This is what Thursdays are for. Love when you have to go to the revealer for any of it to make sense. The fill required tho is choppy and rough in parts (esp SE). Very ambitious concept - big points for that. π₯π₯π₯12:22
#NYTXW
SUN: A dull uninspiring theme made this one feel like a slog especially since there were a number of spots where the difficulty level seemed unnecessarily high due to some strange answers and oblique cluing. Had pretty much no fun with this one at all. π₯ 23:35
#NYTXW
THU: Straightforward (but not too easy) puzzle of this type but super well executed and fun to figure out. Loved all the entries that contain the gimmick and the revealer is chefs kiss. Really nice one after a rough 2 days. 9:16 π₯π₯π₯π£
#NYTXW
SUN: I absolutely love an event puzzle like this where you can just feel the care and effort put into it. Super satisfying and beautifully constructed. Puzzle of the year for me so far. 25:34 (I wish it lasted longer) Grade: A+
#NYTXW
FRI: Really nice one today that played faster than it seemed while solving it and caused a bunch of satisfied smiles along the way. Bonus points for 58A/60A on top of each other. 8:17 Grade: A
#NYTXW
Crossword twitter: if youβre a daily
#NYTXW
solver and want to have your quacks heard each day, follow this account and vote in our daily poll. π₯π₯π₯π₯π₯π₯π₯π₯π₯
FRI: Nice one with a fun lighthearted tone and a nice combination of old and new stuff. Played pretty easy once things started moving. Never heard of the model but looked her up and quite the life! Also wished the Erykah Badu song for 13D. Good stuff! 8:22 π₯π₯π₯π£
#NYTXW
THU: My favorite type of themed puzzle especially when all of the you-know-whats are different. This was expertly done with a clever revealer and an exhaustive list of themers. 8:44 π₯π₯π₯π₯
#NYTXW
THU: Nice one today, although once the gimmick revealed itself, the clues felt more impressive than the answers. Still fun though and the 4 nine letter downs were first rate. 52D also great! 8:36 π₯π₯π₯
#NYTXW
SUN: Enjoyed this one. Itβs the kind of theme that, even after you grok the trick, itβs fun to figure out the others. Especially liked the last one - clever. Good end to a pretty good week. 17:36 Grade A-
#NYTXW
SAT: Really really nice grid that is super smooth - really not a single awkward square. Felt like this one was clued too straightforwardly though - Iβd like to have spent more time with it which is a testament to its quality. 8:02 Grade: B+
#NYTXW
WED: I get the appeal - it's a good quote and the fact that it fits is so tempting. But the amount of junk to make it work is just not worth it. Also, isn't this show a bit of a relic at this point? Grade: C
#NYTXW
THU: Found this one difficult even after figuring out the theme which youβd think would help me sail thru. Clever and original with good fill and fun technical reveal in the app. Thankful for puzzles today..and every day. 9:44 Grade: A-
#nytxw
FRI: Super joyful puzzle today loaded with fun and clever misleads. Embarrassed to admit I had the towel monogram wrong and smiled when I had to fix it - as I suspect many of us did. 9:27 Grade: A
#NYTXW
WED: If ever there was an example of a puzzle that the constructors enjoyed making more than the solvers enjoyed solving, this is it. Impressive, sure. I love math, but really not a fun theme to work out. And are we really doing 19A on a Wed? 5:02 π₯
#NYTXW
FRI: This just didnβt feel fun at all. So impressed with itself using high value letters and arcane trivia. You know what, puzzle? 29A should never be plural. So there. Grade: D+
#NYTXW
FRI: Such a nice, fun themeless with joy all around. Love being challenged by the vagueness of the clue rather than the arcane nature of the answer (to me), although Iβve never heard of the spacewalk acronym. That upper right is a thing of beauty. 9:40 π₯π₯π₯π£
#NYTXW
THU: I REALLY didnβt like. But I think Iβm in a bad 1A. Those random circled letters especially hidden in phrases that are equally random are not fun. And just too much going on made for ugly fill. Can someone explain 4D? 12:47 Grade: D-flat
#NYTXW
FRI: Super smooth themeless that feels airy and light with no forced sections and a bunch of fun adjacent long stuff. The clue for 27D is worth the price of admission alone. If this is the last puzzle the ducks tweet about, itβs a great one to end on. 7:41 π₯π₯π₯π₯
#NYTXW
WED: Beautiful Wednesday with lively theme entries and a clever, very New York revealer. Never heard of the cathedral features but inferrable due to the missing ingredient :). 6:14 Grade: A
#NYTXW
THU: This one has a clever concept and is super fun (and challenging!) to solve. For me, entering in the app was not intuitive - it expects rebus like entries - which is why I was so confused by 49D. Really good one though. 14:49 π₯π₯π₯
#NYTXW
TUE: Really really nice one today - super clever and fun theme with lots of theme density and exhaustiveness. Loved the film references as well, especially the director on top of his own movie. 4:49 π₯π₯π₯π₯
#NYTXW
THU: One of the more annoying puzzles in recent memory. If the goal is to annoy, itβs a success. So much bad stuff to get this to work - short foreign words, TO and ON dupes, the whole SW section - and for such a nothing payoff. 9:10 π£
#NYTXW
SAT: Quite the workout to end our puzzling year! Love a grid like this that takes a while with answers that lead to facepalms - like 32A - and even shorter stuff like 43A. Happy New Year everyone! 19:40 π₯π₯π₯π₯
#NYTXW
THU: Wow, that was quite a remarkable crossword achievement! Took me quite a while - till the revealer actually - to see it and then I admired it more on review. Super fun Thursday trick. Really really enjoyed it - granted, Iβm in a good mood today :). 9:48 π₯π₯π₯π₯
#NYTXW
FRI: Most fun Friday in quite some time and not just because it was super gay which was definitely a very much appreciated some theme in this puzzle. So much so that I almost put βYAS!β at 24A. 11:23 Grade: A
#NYTXW
THU: Super delightful even though 1) I feel like Iβve seen this gimmick before and 2) itβs pretty easy. But itβs executed so cleanly. Kind of feels as free of restraint as a good themeless - yet thereβs a fun additional element. 6:35 Grade: A-
#NYTXW
TUE: Original, but not a fan of this one at all. The first themer is rarely heard without a βyouβ in front of it and the second one is not a standard phrase at all. Revealer does less revealing than it does make you look back and say βohβ. Meh. 4:46 π₯
#NYTXW
THU: Wow. That feels like exactly what a Thursday should be - an original gimmick thatβs kind of tough to grasp but so satisfying when you make it. This is a nice feat of construction thatβs as fun to solve and it must have been to make. 8:33 π₯π₯π₯π₯
#NYTXW
THU: Maybe Iβm cranky this week but how is this fun for anyone but the constructor? Does it look more interesting in print? In the app, it felt really tedious. Super easy though so at least quick. 6:22 Grade: D
#NYTXW
WED: A really nice and moving tribute puzzle that doesnβt sacrifice quality to be theme-heavy. The themers are so good (especially the last one) as are the upper right and lower left sections. Also the inclusion of 30A right next to 35A is a nice touch. 6:32 π₯π₯π₯π£
#NYTXW
TUE: Super cute, easy, smooth Tuesday with a charming theme that contained some wacky but somehow sensical themers. I especially enjoyed the second and the last. Extra points for 9D clue. 4:01 π₯π₯π₯π£
#NYTXW
MON: Theme answers shouldnβt be duplicated two days in a row. Kind of goes without saying, no? This one was really dull. No sparkle. And painful in parts. 4:34 Grade: C
#NYTXW
THU: Super clever one that plays remarkably smoothly considering the number of theme entries. The revealer is great and simple and letβs the inside of the grid breathe. Only gripe: too straightforward. Knocked this one out too fast. 5:44 π₯π₯π₯π£
#NYTXW
FRI: Pure delight from start to finish. Fresh fun entries with clever clues - felt like I had a slight smile on my face for all 9:45 of it. The middle right is a masterpiece. Grade: A+
#NYTXW
SUN: On the bright side, the revealer is nice, unnecessary but nice. Sadly, thatβs the only bright spot. How is this fun or interesting at all? Just feels so random and such a stretch. And 82A? 104D? In short, not fun. π₯ 18:48
#NYTXW
WED: Never a fan of the lifetime achievement puzzles - this one was no fun. Just forcing stuff related to the theme to get symmetry. The corners felt sectioned off - the SE one was painful with the bird and the plural at 56D. Not well built, ironically. 8:45 Grade: C-
#NYTXW
TUE: Hardest Tuesday in recent memory and although an interesting theme (not really a theme), the challenge was less fun and more βdid I spell that right?β Impressive construction to get that all in didnβt really translate to solving joy. 8:45 π₯π₯
#NYTXW
FRI: Really nice themeless with some sparkling long stuff that was well clued with clever misdirection - minus the Trump one! Had trouble getting a foothold at all and worked my way up the from the bottom. Eight 15βs and still such a smooth grid. 12:39 π₯π₯π₯
#NYTXW
WED: The weekβs π streak continues. Just donβt see why this is interesting - itβs not clever wordplay at all and the circled letters arenβt impressive; they seem almost random. The note is just insulting. Mercifully Monday level easy. 5:11 π₯
#NYTXW
SAT: I realize itβs a Saturday and itβs supposed to be hard but some of these sections seemed hard for the wrong reasons. I live in NYC and NOBODY says 1A. Also the Iroquois tribe on top of a number thatβs never spelled out. Google 41A. Just unfair. 14:45 Grade: C-
#NYTXW
FRI: Delightful themeless made even better by the deceptive cluing - like 13A. Love that one. Also really enjoyed the adjacent initials at the office. One of those that flows once you get going. 9:14 π₯π₯π₯π£
#NYTXW
WED: Canβt remember a Wednesday Iβve liked less. Self-serving and boring, yes. But the worst part is that some of the themers are not even stand alone phrases. 35A is not a thing at all ever. 58A too. Just how does this make the cut. 6:01 Zero ducks.
#NYTXW
MON: Cute fun simple one today with an old fashioned theme that had some bounce. Mondayβs must be so hard to keep interesting. Quibble: the Liza musical is too similar to a theme entry without being one. 4:01 Grade: B+
#NYTXW
TUE: A really good Tuesday puzzle - clever and original theme with 4 lively fun theme 15βs and solid fill all around. Love a theme where the revealer really does reveal. Only (very) small gripe is that Dutch artist - seems like avoidable trivia. 4:51 Grade: A
#NYTXW
FRI: So good. Love this type of themeless where Iβm entering stuff wherever I can all over the grid and watching sections slowly fall into place. Smooth and lively. 9:38 Grade: A
#NYTXW
SUN: At the risk of being Grinch-like, this one is really flat, uninteresting theme - not clever or tight and some of them donβt make much sense. 17:44 π₯π£
#NYTXW
But from here to all of youβ¦β¦
THU: Clever use of the theme which is likely pretty popular among the NYT solving crowd. Puzzle played really easy once you see the gimmick. Some unpretty short stuff required to make it work (8D) but fun nonetheless. 7:12 Grade: B+
#NYTXW
TUE: Really nice Tuesday. Love the theme subject, and while these homage puzzles can seem a little arbitrary, this had an impressive amount of theme density while also being a pretty smooth solve. The added twist (no pun intended) was very nice. 4:32 Grade: A-
#NYTXW
FRI: Excellent themeless with a bunch of rarely used letters that managed to maintain a nice smoothness. Great feat of construction but also fun to solve. 26A felt like a forced attempt at duplicate cluing (35A) which isnβt necessary. 10:46π₯π₯π₯
#NYTXW
SAT: Cheeky cluing appropriate for the date (sort of) but still challenging despite the obvious answers. Particularly enjoyed that stack in the SW. Fun times. 12:12 π₯π₯π₯
#NYTXW
SAT: Nice one. Flew through right half and then got slowed down, finally figuring out 43A. Such impressive construction - if not as joyful as other Saturdays. 7D is interesting in lieu of a discussion about the Japanese clue yesterday. 11:49 Grade: B+
#NYTXW
WED: Not a good one at all. These complete the partial clue puzzles have not been killing it. Itβs not really clever or interesting that the themers can be split into 2 words to complete random awkward sentences that nobody would ever say. Shame. 5:40 π₯
#NYTXW
THU: Super clever gimmick that became clear three-quarters of the way through which is ideal for a gimmick puzzle like this. Also a lovely designed grid that made this a very fun solve. 8:34 π₯π₯π₯π£
#NYTXW
WED: Theme is very clever esp. the last themer but the fill surrounding it is astoundingly poor. Too many crosswordy names to even count and 4D crossing the teletubby is not nice. 7:35 Grade: B-
#NYTXW
SUN: This is just about as painful as a Sunday can get. Unless thereβs something Iβm missing, this βthemeβ is just a completely random set of anagrams that arenβt particularly noteworthy or fun. Pickings must be so slim. 16:44 No ducks
#NYTXW
FRI: Lovely smooth as silk themeless with 6 (!) 15βs all of which were fun and completely in the language. Beautiful stiff. Only thing that bugged me was 22D but ducks donβt care. 11:11 π₯π₯π₯π₯
#NYTXW
TUE: Canβt really see theme at all until youβre done and it doesnβt really quite work - why are they in the same line? - but not an entirely unpleasant solve. 47D is missing a D though, no? 4:28 Grade: B
#NYTXW
MON: Super solid Monday. Really appreciated the theme having no revealer and the mini-theme that was symmetric and semi-related to the main one. Also love the recent inclusions of the non-binary pairs - gives grids an energy boost. 4:11 π₯π₯π₯π£
#NYTXW
SUN: This one put me in a bad mood. I was waiting for something more and nothing ever came. Theme is weak and theme cluing is annoying. Why the quotes? More importantly, why canβt the Sunday be good? Itβs perplexing. 17:36 π£
#NYTXW
TUE: A really good early week puzzle - with a perfect revealer. Didnβt pay much attention to the theme while doing it but was amused to look back. Q: Is 26D actually a thing? 4:39 Grade: A-
#NYTXW
TUE: Just about the perfect early week puzzle. Smooth easy solve, a pretty grid, a playful theme with a visual element and a lovely reveal that doesnβt seem super evident as you are entering the themers. Those four 10βs going down are just a bonus. 4:46 π₯π₯π₯π₯
#NYTXW
WED: This feels like a good example of βjust because you can doesnβt mean you shouldβ. Really not fun to solve at all. And the restrictions led to so painful stuff like 16D (wow) and 47D. Way too much short stuff as well. 8:33 π₯
#NYTXW
THU: Very clever theme. I started with a different symbol (as I suspect many of you will) and then realized the wrinkle. Couple of stretches to make it work (18D, 48D) but forgivable. Grade: A- 11:31 Good week so far!
#NYTXW
MON: Really nice Monday - four 15βs is a lot of theme and itβs done well here with solid fill all around. Really liked 44A. Also appreciated the visual nuance of the themers going up and down 4:39 π₯π₯π₯
#NYTXW
WED: Tough to find many good things to say about this one. Really corny tired theme entries with a flat (!) revealer that adds nothing. The third themer adds an adjective just make the letter count work. A π£ seems generous. 7:33
#NYTXW
THU: Fun original concept - love the theme placement in the middle so you can see whatβs going on before moving to the bottom half. π to the first themer including the key word in a 2-word phrase (with the revealerβs meaning) unlike the others. 8:49 π₯π₯π₯
#NYTXW
SAT: Another nice themeless that, for a few minutes, left me scratching my head. But the grid encouraged me to 21D and it started to flow. Nice looking grid too. Not sure I understand 17A but this is 23D. 12:11 π₯π₯π₯
#NYTXW
SAT: Solid themeless that was enjoyable to solve but didnβt really sparkle for me. Nice cluing in parts (15D) but some clunkers as well (34D). 11:48 π₯π₯π£
#NYTXW
MON: Nice fun theme on a Monday although Iβm sure Iβm not the only one who wanted to put in Dolly for the last one, which funny enough would have fit. Some old timey fill and 42D again but still enjoyable. 4:22 π₯π₯π₯
#NYTXW
THU: Really nice one today. Perfect level for a Thursday. Felt something was odd - got bottom right, got reavealer and then aha moment that helped with the others. Felt like I solved it just as it was intended. Joyful. 10:45 Grade: A
#NYTXW
SAT: Hard but nice Saturday challenge. This is how I think Saturdays should be - several tough words that, although maybe not precisely known, are gettable from crosses that also may not be precisely known but like vaguely familiar and gettable. Fun stuff 13:34 π₯π₯π₯
#NYTXW
MON: Excellent start to the week with a smooth grid and clever revealer. Lively theme entries helped this Monday to a Grade: A. βGood Lookingβ puzzle. 4:10
#NYTXW
WED: At the risk of sounding like a jerk, maybe this one was too easy for a Wednesday? Theme was clever but very straightforward and could be done countless ways. Some really nice diverse recognition here - 38A should be a mainstay. 4:34 Grade: B
#NYTXW
SUN: Super fun and clever Sunday that offers a really nice aha moment that took me way too long to figure out. I enjoyed that it was well hidden - at least to me. Wondered why there was so much short stuff! 18:12 π₯π₯π₯
#NYTXW
WED: The good week continues with a clever and original theme that felt airy and fun to solve. They donβt all work perfectly (does anyone say 31A without the first letter) but still charming. And the 8D/25D pair is gorgeous. Too easy? 4:48 π₯π₯π₯
#NYTXW
THU: Terrific theme conceptually - loved how the acrosses in the themers stand alone and then change meaning with the downs included. But, despite the reveal the bottom third seems bereft of theme and that SE is brutal. Think we needed a more famous 60A there. 8:44 π₯π₯π£
#NYTXW
MON: Nice theme progression - light and fun and well suited to a Monday and managed to use each theme word in a different context. Fill was just average with one too many ABBRβs - literally. 4:33 Grade: B+
#NYTXW
FRI: Truly delightful with fresh answers all around and 6D! (whose name seems well suited to themelesses). Also enjoyed some tricky fun cluing. Minor points off for the 10A/D crossing abbrs. and a missed chance to go all Potter at 53D/63A. 12:55 Grade: A-
#NYTXW