The real ‘history war’ is the attack on our archives and libraries : a call for the government to end the history wars and protect our cultural institutions, by
@fbongiornoanu
and I
ABC news breakfast are chuckling about the big increase in caravan ownership reported in the census. I wonder how much of the increase is not from grey nomads but from people who can no longer afford to buy houses?
The ‘No’ campaign’s official slogan – “Don’t know, vote no” – is a great distillation of the right’s political strategy. Not ‘Don’t know? Do the work and find out’, but just rest on your prejudices, don’t grow, don’t learn, don’t change.
You know which schools don't expel gay or transgender kids? Public schools. Yet the federal government continues to shovel taxpayer funds into private schools. How is this ok? Clearly many parents who choose private schools endorse the exclusion and expulsion of LGBT kids.
Very pleased to see that
@Macquarie_Uni
VC has announced that casual staff who are required to self-isolate/quarantine for two weeks will be paid for their rostered hours, and same applies if the university has to close. It’s welcome recognition of precarious workers.
Love how the press gallery is talking about the huge challenges the new government faces without directly addressing the reason they’ve got such a hard task is that the Coalition did so little for so long
The super changes show how hard it is to have a conversation about equity in Australia. Try winding back benefits to the wealthy and the media will howl for weeks: try making the case to raise Newstart or fund public education properly and suddenly we can’t ‘afford’ it
It’s an indictment of the press gallery that Kevin Rudd has done a better job of outlining Dutton’s appalling views on race, disability and disadvantaged people than all of them put together:
���But Crabb fundamentally misses the point of journalism. It’s not about humanising those in power, it’s about humanising those who are let down by those in power.’ Still the best commentary on Kitchen Cabinet, by
@amymcquire
All these Liberals claiming that the office of Prime Minister ought to be shown more 'respect' seem to have forgotten the lack of respect they offered Julia Gillard when she was PM. This doco offers an excellent reminder:
This is a jaw-dropping response from Amanda Stoker to the crisis at the NAA. To say 'time marches on and all sources degrade over time' is flippant and negligent. Not really what you'd expect from a government that claims to defend 'western civilisation':
Arts and humanities graduates are NOT less employable than STEM graduates
@RNBreakfast
- this is a myth disproved by the government’s own data. Please don’t perpetuate it, Hamish McDonald
#RNbreakfast
This is an excellent, historically-informed commentary on Harry and Meghan from three great scholars (and royal-watchers!): John Docker, Ann Curthoys and Lyndall Ryan
This is where we are: casinos get JobKeeper but public universities - the ones that educate our doctors, nurses, teachers, historians - get nothing but punishment from the Morrison government
#savehighered
Jacqui Lambie makes a stronger argument in favor of affordable higher education than any of our vice chancellors have managed in this entire debate. This is such great news!
"Suburban dads can be a bit clumsy with their language." – Former Prime Minister Scott Morrison regarding comments made while he was Prime Minister
#Nemesis
Listening to the RN interview with David Pocock and it’s extraordinary the extent to which the media frames IR from the perspective of business. Like, workers might have the right to strike? Horrors!
The panel on
#Insiders
today argued that to investigate the cabinet race allegation would be beyond the pale because the incident happened well before the man entered politics. But didn’t the Murdoch media relentlessly investigate Julia Gillard’s pre-political career? Honestly...
Again, the mainstream media misread - ignored? - the public mood and told us that the NSW election result would be ‘close’. It’s nowhere near close. We need fewer bloviators on couches, more reporters on the ground speaking to real people, please
#NSWvotes
Scott Morrison has also been asked by
@lanai_scarr
whether he would prefer to have a beer with President Biden or Donald Trump. He says he gets along with both of them because that's his job but he thinks it would be more "colourful" with Trump.
The news this morning was devastating for all of us in higher ed, especially in humanities. But we need to fight. For starters, I've emailed Senate cross-benchers Lambie, Patrick and Griff asking them not to support these reforms and I'd urge you all to do the same thing.
Thread: Humanities researchers don't tend to need a lot of infrastructure to complete their research: mainly they need books, journals, a computer, and a quiet place to write. For years, the academic office has been under threat from managers who wanted to impose open plan...
The Australian War Memorial accepted more than $830,000 from weapons manufacturers in 3 years. It’s outrageous that an institution devoted to remembering those who died in war should be accepting money from companies which profit from war.
Congrats to new Fellow Professor Michelle Arrow from
@Macquarie_Uni
. Award-winning author + historian, Michelle is a specialist in Aus political, social + feminist history. Her work has enhanced public understanding of Aus history + its role in the nation’s life.
@MichelleArrow1
‘It seems to me that workers in almost every industry are jaded and disengaged – they’re being forced to work harder and be a jolly part of a team culture … and expected to be happy with pay rises of 2 to 3 per cent, if that’.
This is a great piece by
@timdunlop
- how is this government, with its many failings, ‘even in with a chance? There is only one answer. They have been kept in the game by a media that haven’t fulfilled their role as watchdogs on political power.’
Dan Golding
@dangolding
absolutely nails it with this terrific piece about the government's treatment of universities, university workers and especially year 12 students. Share it widely!
The trouble for Labor is that every time they fall short on something that should be the core business of Labor governments - like DV support, or health, or public schools - we remember that they can find $50b for defence. It's the wedge that keeps on wedging
‘He believes the amount of work teachers are allocated shows “how little the university cares about the quality of education students are getting”. Exactly.
This is a must-read for everyone in
#auspol
- our universities need urgent reform:
Dame Edna and the PM who conferred her title, Gough Whitlam. Edna was an extraordinary satire of mid-century, middle class femininity. Vale Barry Humphries
Remembering the wonderful life of a truly trailblazing historian, Lyndall Ryan. Activist, femocrat, academic, she made a huge contribution to Indigenous history, most recently with the massacre map. What a huge loss.
As if accountability wasn’t bad enough at universities already, we have well-paid uni executives taking expensive, secret advice from consulting firms?I’ll bet PwC has zero experience in research or teaching. We need university governance reform now:
Was there a sadder spectacle in Australian politics this week? I mean, he can't even remove 'MP' from his twitter handle! Great headline on this piece by
@rachelrwithers
It’s that time of year again! How do we tell them that the ideology ‘strangling’ universities is the one that jacked up student fees and casualised most of the staff?
Hmm. This story - which centres on the political fallout from Morrison’s trip to Hawaii - seems to give sole credit for breaking that story to Phil Coorey, not Sam Maiden. Didn’t she win a big Walkley for the story? If they can’t report that right…
So I wrote this about the political uses of women’s rage for
@ConversationEDU
. The women’s liberation movement turned anger into political action - we need to begin thinking about how we might do that today:
A decade of shocking neglect, coming after decades of efficiency dividends, and we have a National Library with no space for new books and a National Gallery that leaks. On their estimates, they need more than $360m for repairs and future-proofing.
We want to be back teaching students on campus too. But the big threat to the university experience is not covid but government policy. 35 000 of our colleagues have lost their jobs since 2020. We will need to invest in universities if we want the student experience to improve:
Gee it’s great that the Morrison government is chucking money at renovators while traumatized people on the South Coast are sleeping in caravans and tents
#4corners
A strange look for Uni of Melb to have the Menzies Inst loaded with largely non-academic ex-libs... just as a similar institute for say a Hawke Inst loaded with labor hacks would be inappropriate.
This result just keeps getting better and better. This is a win for historians and history-lovers: Stoker was the one who said that it was ok for irreplaceable archives to be destroyed by neglect at the National Archives because that was simply to be expected of old documents.
It’s an indictment in most of the media class that they tend to see stories through the prism of their middle/upper class interests. It’s no coincidence that
@SquigglyRick
(with his lived experience of poverty) has been so tenacious, and so powerful, in explaining Robodebt.
I know we have come to expect hypocrisy from our politicians, but this is next level stuff. Centre Alliance had the power to stop this bill in its tracks and it failed. Now our young people face massive fee uni hikes and universities will cop huge funding cuts. Shame.
I will be forever grateful to
@Flinders
for
#MyArtsDegree
. It took me ten years to complete while working and raising three children. I would not have had my career or the privilege of sitting in the
#HoR
without it.
#auspol
This is actually a story about the impact of 17 000 job losses in universities, though you would never know it. The workloads of the remaining have increased dramatically over the last year:
I am delighted and overwhelmed to be the winner of this year's Ernest Scott Prize: many thanks to the judges and everyone associated with this award. I'm so grateful!
Liberals for Yes leader Kate Carnell says party members are being threatened with losing preselection if they campaign for ‘Yes’.
“This has been politicised to the point that people aren’t comfortable to campaign for what they believe in.”
#auspol
One of the worst aspects of the neoliberalisation of everything that we don't talk about often enough is the ways that it makes managing institutions so so awful that the good people burn out and only the worst, most ill-suited people seek out the roles.
‘Valuing the generalist degree – with graduates able to enjoy learning, develop the courage to think, reflect, interpret, evaluate, humanise […] – will give young people confidence and a sense of their own agency.’ Excellent, by
@CathyColeborne
I am really thrilled and honoured to receive an ARC SRI grant to write a biography of Anne Deveson. It's a big, inspiring project and I'm very grateful to everyone who has helped me with it so far, including my lovely MQ history colleagues:
Anyone who is shocked by the state of our underfunded public schools hadn’t been paying enough attention to the scandal that is education funding in Australia. I hope the Independent MPs might exert pressure for reform:
Today I was invited by the P&C to tour Narrabeen Sports High School
I was shocked at the state of neglect & disrepair. This wonderful school community & our young people have been seriously let down.
Leaking roofs, unsafe stairwells,mould, gas leaks.
Unsafe & unhealthy
#auspoI
If you're chasing someone with an overdue deadline in the middle of a pandemic, perhaps lead with kindness, rather than passive aggression? Like, we're all overwhelmed and over-committed but we're all doing our best.
And yes this is a subtweet
Today is the 50th anniversary of Elizabeth Reid’s appointment as Whitlam’s women’s affairs adviser. I wrote a piece for
@SatPaper
to mark the occasion:
Today a group of high-powered lawyers in Sydney are launching a non-partisan lobby group, inspired by the treatment of Julie Bishop, that will scrutinise parties for their record on, and offerings for, women.
I tried to do a proper unboxing video but there were too many layers of packaging to do it one-handed! Women and Whitlam has arrived at my place - it will be in bookshops by April:
So ‘lest we forget’ only applies to military history, apparently. The government is about to spend $500m on an extension to the War Memorial while the National Archives is starved of essential funds to perform preservation work. What a disgrace.
#ozhist
@spenderallegra
Where would they suggest we reduce government spending? On private schools? Franking credits? The previous government racked up huge debts with little to show for it, and our essential public services are crying out for investment. That's the problem we need to solve.
Who would look at the NSW public education system and think: 'what this depleted sector needs is a funding cut?' If declining enrolments is the problem, this isn't the way to fix it,
@pruecar
This graph from the story above powerfully visualizes the unbalanced levels of spending on the war memorial compared to our other cultural institutions:
So Guy Rundle claims here that he can tell the difference between a victim and a ‘capital V Victim’ of sexual assault. I know he likes to be a contrarian, but this is just gross:
Why on earth, then, would you propose to make researchers share offices like gig workers, when the main thing they need to produce this research is time, books, and quiet space? It's a rhetorical question, obviously...
The Howard government cut spending in universities and boosted government funding to private schools. Twenty years later, we can see what a genius idea that was:
Australia spends 0.49% of its GDP on research.
Germany spends 3.13% of its GDP on research.
It is a national shame how poorly funded our universities are - the entire point of universities is to link students to research, the frontier of knowledge
#insiders
#auspol
Thank you to
@bairdjulia
and
@ABCthedrum
for having me tonight. It was great to discuss the importance of the arts, humanities and social sciences with the panel, particularly my eloquent and passionate MQ colleague,
@AmyThunig
:
TONIGHT: Macquarie University Associate Prof.
@MichelleArrow1
joins us to discuss the government’s hike in price for humanities degrees.
Will it really achieve what the government hopes – or do we risk losing valuable skills?
#TheDrum
Great piece on the composition of University Councils: many council members have never undertaken research or taught in a university, which explains a LOT about our current predicament:
This is a dreadful decision from
@MakeMayoMatter
and
@Stirling_G
. They have condemned young people to crippling student debts. Sharkie once spoke out about the value of her arts degree. She has pulled the ladder up from anyone else who wanted the same opportunities she had.
Breaking:
@MakeMayoMatter
on Sky says she will support the government’s uni bill after various concessions from the government. We think we’ve got to a good position with government she says
#auspol
@callapilla
We are spending $500m on an extension to the War Memorial while historical records elsewhere are being destroyed because of years of funding cuts
#auspol
A sad story. The National Archives are now deciding which audio visual records will be prioritsed for digitising and which they will have to lose as they race towards the 2025 deadline. 'There's no way we can save it all'
@RebeccaHuntley2
Our assistant minister for women, Amanda Stoker, spoke at a ‘pro-life’ (forced birth) rally last weekend. There are definitely people here who want to restrict abortion access.
What did you expect would happen to universities when you prohibit them from JobKeeper and staff are cut? Classes get bigger, teaching and marking loads increase, and the student experience deteriorates. It’s almost like staff working conditions are student learning conditions.
Frankly,
@AlboMP
, schools funding is a bloody disgrace. Education is fundamental to democracy and equality - and we’re entrenching disadvantage by spending too much money on kids who don’t need it, and not enough on those who do. Fair funding for public education!
#ForEveryChild
Further confirmation that the National Archives will receive the funding it needs - thanks again to
@swrighteconomy
and
@katinacurtis
who first placed this story on the political agenda, and to Gideon Haigh and Graeme Davison, whose advocacy was decisive:
Towards the end of a big week, I'm very happy to share the news that I have been promoted to Professor! Thanks to all of those colleagues and friends who have supported me along the way.
The most disturbing thing about what is happening in Aus higher ed is that being excellent does not protect you. Talented people do all that is expected of them and more, and it still isn’t enough. Higher education is completely broken. So sorry this happened to you, Una:
Today marks my last day of my 5 year contract at
@unimelb
. The uni created a permanent position around my teaching and research, but then gave it to someone else. So I’m leaving academia. 🧵
Pity the private school principals who are 'grappling with how to cope' with cuts to their (excessive) funding. Maybe we could put them in touch with public school principals, who I'm sure could help them out with budgeting and making do with less?
In government the Libs/Nats delivered $10 billion in special deals to already over-funded private schools… and they still feel hard done by.
#ThoughtsAndPrayers
'For the Australian War Memorial to include meaningful exhibits about the wars that were fought on this land would be a powerful act of truth-telling in service of the nation.'
#AnzacDay2023
#VoiceToParliament
Today’s Oz: humanities students face bigger interest bills on their graduating debts of c.$43 000, thanks to the Morrison government’s spiteful 2020 ‘reforms’. Debt repayments kick in for grads when they start earning barely more than minimum wage. So unfair, needs urgent change!
This is interesting…
‘The Fair Work Ombudsman has blamed universities’ “entrenched non-compliance” with workplace agreements for the systemic underpayment of casual staff, and called for an overhaul of their corporate governance.’
So all that Job-Ready Graduates did (which we all warned about!) was to saddle young Australians with even bigger debts. Slow clap for Dan Tehan and everyone else (including Rebekah Sharkie) who enabled this dreadful bit of policy ‘reform’:
Underfunding public schools shows disrespect for the students who attend them and the teachers who work there. We’ll never boost respect for teaching while we underfund the schools attended by the majority of Australian children:
Private schools will receive almost $3bn above the Schooling Resource Standard by 2029 while public schools are being underfunded nationally by up to $6.5bn each year via
@dailytelegraph
“Elsevier preys on the academic community, claiming huge profits while adding little value to science.” This is an interesting development by a courageous editorial board - let’s hope it builds more momentum for reform:
My partner is a public school teacher and today he received the most wonderful, heartfelt thank you letter from a former student. If you’ve ever wondered if you should send that email thanking someone for the impact they’ve had on your life - do it. It’s priceless.
Sarah Henderson and Katie Allen are giving what Niki Savva described as good Stepford Wives performances on
#insiders
insiders this morning. Still trying to defend the indefensible
So we can’t afford an increase to Newstart, but we can afford to spend billions on submarines - and Dutton says it’s ok, we can make cuts to the NDIS to pay for it. What a depressing day:
‘The Australian War Memorial received more funding than the rest of Australia’s national cultural institutions put together in the last two years of the Coalition government.’ Surely our cultural institutions should be growing, not saving the furniture?