Today’s been a good day. I received a very welcome apology from the German Parliamentary committee into
@Wirecard
which personally meant a lot. And three hours after my testimony the President of BaFIN has resigned.
When I highlighted the
@wirecard
(WDI) fraud way back when, the PM of its largest institutional shareholder got straight on to Markus Braun, Wirecard’s CEO. Braun provided soothing words to calm the shareholder.
Three years later in 2019, that same shareholder contacted WDI’s
I’m looking forward to attending the inquiry at the Bundestag later this week. What a turnaround of events. From being targeted for highlighting the criminal actions of
@wirecard
’s management, to receiving an invitation to the German parliament.
It’s June 18.
@wirecard
’s big day. The moment its investors have all been waiting for. Finally the release of its 2019 audited results. And the only thing available on its website is a ridiculous slur against me. Tick tock.
There is a French listed company which last year was accused of round tripping with a major supplier.
A major supplier is also a large shareholder in said company 🤷🏼♂️.
Nine months later and that supplier / shareholder has “corrected” its inventory and reported its sales at -25%
It’s gratifying that for once an auditor takes a principled stance on such matters.
#BOO
#ESG
PwC quits as auditor to Boohoo on reputation concerns via
@FT
Modern day Keynesian economics:
Each $1 million increase in charitable donations leads to a $5.5 million rise in advertising to tell everyone about it.
I recall when I met the FBI & DoJ in NYC in 2017 to discuss the cyber hacking. I asked if they also wanted to talk about
@wirecard
’s money laundering. Their response: “Oh we know all about that.”
US authorities knew for years.
Zatarra discovered it in 2016.
Germany? In 2020! 🤦🏼♂️
Exklusiv: Neue Details zur Razzia bei
#Wirecard
2015: Damals beschlagnahmten Ermittler auch den Mailverkehr von
#Marsalek
und weiteren Managern. Laut US-Ermittlern liefen über Wirecard Zahlungen an illegale Glücksspielwebsites in den USA in Milliardenhöhe
Lawyers for Tulip Siddiq MP indicate they are dropping her false, absurd and deeply defamatory complaint against
@Channel4News
to the Metropolitan Police ...
Sell Side research never ceases to amaze. How any analyst can recommend Buy on a company which can't show audited 2019 financials, a special audit can’t find €1bn, & its management is being investigated for furnishing the market with false & misleading statements, is beyond me.
My sincere thanks and congratulations to the
@FBI
agents and the attorneys from
@SDNYnews
for their immense work and dedication to bringing this "hack-for-hire" agent to justice. My heartfelt appreciation also goes to
@jsrailton
and the
@citizenlab
specialists for their
Just two guys practicing having their prints taken? One on the left seems to know what he’s doing well enough. One on the right not so much, and definitely in a bad mood about it.
If BaFIN had put 10% of the time it spent investigating myself and subsequently others, such as
@FD
&
@stef_palma
for their incredible reporting in
@FT
, into investigating
@wirecard
, this would’ve been over long ago. 1/3
My deepest thanks to the members of
@citizenlab
, who following years of dedication and tireless work have today begun to uncover a massive Hack-For-Hire Operation, which I have been subject to for over three years.
1/4
Litigation Finance permitted words & phrases of the day
Approved (“safe”):
Solvent
Super strong
Buy back
Great quarter
Record results
Forbidden (“makes algos go out of their minds”)
Insolvent
Laughable
CFO married to CEO
Aggressive mark-ups
Non-cash fair value gains
Woodford
Excellent article on the verisimilitude of ESG investing in
@FT
@journofletcher
@TomStub
Remarkable view to highlight. “Yeah he’s a murderous thug that gave a kill order on a journalist. But on the other hand he is letting women drive.”
This is great work by
@meyerar
&
@JosefStreule
digging into the money laundering activities of
@wirecard
and the companies in its orbit. You don’t create a universe of 1,000’s of fake companies just for accounting fraud. And this becomes evident here👇🏻
Astonishingly great (as per usual!) work from Hindenburg👇🏻
It’s heartwarming to see that Temenos’ management have cashed out in the billions when all this has been going on whilst also implementing share buybacks.
It’s often highlighted to me that European markets are cheap relative to the US. They are, and for good reasons. Poor demographics, windfall tax fear, a mindset that sees profit as a dirty word, crowding out of private investment, and red tape to name but a few👇🏻
Wirecard employees used to walk out of their headquarters with millions of euros in Aldi and Lidl bags, police have been told. Latest scoop from the indefatigable
@OlafStorbeck
BaFIN should be investigated. I contacted them to highlight this company and they simply didn’t want to know. Indeed they launched an investigation into myself and
@FD
. And remarkably implemented a short sale ban when the FT alleged fraud. 4/8
It was astonishing. Imagine reading a file, essentially saying “We agree what you’ve stated is true, but we don’t like how you highlight it, so now we’d like to prosecute you for your tone”.
Remarkably, BaFIN even determined the source material was provided to mislead.
@wirecard
Amazing detail here: Bafin determined that the Zatarra report on Wirecard was accurate... but didn’t like its negative tone so pursued the short sellers!
Bafin also happily forwarded on Wirecard’s theories about short sellers to Munich prosecutors
🚨 Exclusive: Neil Woodford has broken his silence on the collapse of his investment firm and revealed he plans to start all over again.
There's sadness, anger, defiance – and even an apology of sorts in
@Lucymburton
's interview here:
Marked by the scandal
The elaborately researched film "Wirecard - Die Milliarden-Lüge" lets those who unmasked the company have their say. And shows new dimensions of the case.
Dokumentarfilm "Wirecard - Die Milliarden-Lüge"
via
@sz
EY to axe 40 partners and hundreds of jobs in Germany after Wirecard dents growth. Also a sign of back office cuts to come if EY spins off its consulting business globally.
Scoop w/
@OlafStorbeck
Good review of how short activists root out
#ESG
failures and so-called ESG funds pro tem have had it easy. Going forward these funds might actually have to deliver on the ESG.
Short sellers: the new anti-heroes of ethical investment? | GlobalCapital
I’m curious to know if it was before or after Fries pitched up at this press conference that Fries blew the whistle? A press conf during which Braun claimed
@wirecard
had itself been defrauded! 🥴. Or was it after the 👮♂️ moved in? Or not at all?
I think it is absolutely pathetic n disgraceful that (1) not only does James Fries continue to falsely cast himself as the
#Wirecard
whistleblower, but (2) that so called reputable news outlets such as Bloomberg
@business
&
@hgmiller29
continue to peddle such verifiable nonsense.
Quelle surprise. The drink sodden popinjay is ... drink sodden. What a sorry state of affairs. And people wonder why 17.4m want to call last orders on the EU.
Most pressingly
@wirecard
states that unless it can file its 2019 accounts by tomorrow then EUR 2bn of loans can be terminated. In that event I believe it becomes insolvent. Aside from this, serious questions need to be asked. 1/8
The only thing that one can be certain with
@wirecard
is its debt is very real. The fake cash comes from Wirecard’s receivables. Therefore it’s probably right to assume a significant portion of its receivables, that haven’t yet been turned into fake cash, are also fake. 1/2
There are many shocking aspects to this story. However also alarming inferences. For example, presumably
@KrollWire
would hold itself out as a quality investigative firm. And yet either they couldn’t determine that they were working for Europe’s largest
Unsurprisingly, the
@AuditReformLab
finds that Audit firms failed to warn of 75% of big company collapses. Naturally,
@EYnews
is “the worst performer”.
Whilst
@Wirecard
was a thoroughly avoidable disaster, you have to hand it to the members of the inquiry committee & their Herculean effort to clean up the mess. Many responsible have been held to account, coupled with determination to ensure lessons are learnt. How refreshing.👇🏻
Wirecard inquiry:
@FabioDeMasi
“says he and his colleagues feel they owe it to those people to get to the bottom of the Wirecard debacle — even if it often means working until the small hours to do so”.
So BaFIN only supervised
@wirecard
bank but did it not intervene because it views money laundering as a spectator sport?
Wirecard : Wie sich Bafin-Chef Felix Hufeld rechtfertigt
This is a very informative and really entertaining listen on the
@wirecard
story. Some great insights and analysis by
@PaulJDavies
Wirecard's Missing $2 Billion - The Journal. - WSJ Podcasts
@WSJ
@WSJbusiness
It was great to be invited on to
@zer0estv
and thoroughly enjoyable to discuss the short selling scene in Europe with Carson. I could have happily chatted all day.
Carson had the chance to sit down with Europe's best short-seller on to talk about the biggest short of 2020....Wirecard! Check it out! -->
@Lordshipstrade
@muddywatersre
Wonderfully sardonic review by
@FTAlphaville
of
@thgplc
’s chief whining officer’s latest sob story.
I’d be amazed if
@Numis
don’t threaten a defamation claim unless the CWO retracts his comment.👇🏻
I ❤️ this comment re
@embracergroup
. Of course any analyst with a position on a company believes the other side is wrong, but to not understand? An unwillingness to want to see the other side of the coin was a key issue
@wirecard
& many other shorts over the years. Especially so
It’s incredible that the institution ordaining the rules of engagement for market participants doesn’t seem to adhere to these rules in fully disclosing its employees’ conflict of interest. 1/2
Huge thanks to
@jsrailton
and the rest of the team at
@citizenlab
for their dedication, support and indefatigable efforts to help to expose the hack for hire group.
Good piece on the Noble demise. A further interesting feature is the question marks regarding the Singaporean regulator’s approach during this time, and in particular its handling of whistleblowers. Although this isn’t just applicable to Singapore.
Most excellent.
Infections from 7,000 to 531
Hospitalisations from 700 to 38
&
Deaths from 307 to 3
Way to go Israel and what encouragement for other nations as they roll out the vaccine.
Covid: Israel's vaccine rollout linked to infection fall - BBC News
Come hell or high water £BOO’s management is determined to get what they reckon is owed.
And persistently lowering the targets will get them there some day. Pitiful.
1/5 This is a point which I made to
@wirecard
’s lawyers in 2017. Risibly they argued it “inconceivable” that “a listed company with a market capitalization of €6.5 billion operating within a highly regulated industry could lack any value.”
Statement from IMF makes for interesting reading wrt its approach to accounting. $BUR ...
IMF Bentham Limited - IMF Bentham responds to share price movement of rival Burford Capital Limited
Had legal action against
@Wirecard
’s critics ever proceeded to court, no doubt this bozo would have been called as a so-called expert for the prosecution. What an expert he must be to conclude Wirecard was actually investment grade. Frightening.
In my view, the entire
@wirecard
saga demonstrates that in its current form, BaFIN isn’t fit for purpose.
The short sellers who cashed in when Wirecard plunged
New twist in the FT Investigation -
Wirecard executive Jan Marsalek bragged to London traders about his access to secret documents by showing them the formula for Novichok, the world's deadliest nerve agent. Free to read story:
Excellent insight into the final years of
@wirecard
. Echoes of Capone. Sadly the tax man was ignored in this instance, along with every other whistleblower.
Exklusiv: Ein bayerischer Finanzbeamter untermauerte nach einer Steuerprüfung schon 2019 Manipulationsvorwürfe gegen
#Wirecard
. Seine Erkenntnisse über dubiose Partner und Geschäfte gingen auch an die Staatsanwaltschaft. Doch die winkte ab. Mit
@hmtillack
This is an important point.
@wirecard
’s €1.9bn hasn’t suddenly gone missing in 2020. It never existed.
@EYnews
has likely signed off bogus accounts for years. Were it not for the overwhelming focus on 2019’s audit, one questions if EY would have blithely signed off yet again?
Wirecard missing US$2 billion. Did it just go missing in 2020 or did E&Y sign off on it being missing in previous financials? Remember that any E&Y CPAs must have reported SARs to their FIU and SARs are compellable, for you EU detective reporters.
Late to reading this but what a story. Murder and plane crashes aside! … Financial negligence, thick as thieves relationships, racy investments, chasing creditors, … and all brilliantly written. Top journalism.👇🏻
💥 A BRUTAL MURDER, A FATAL PLANE CRASH AND A BILLION DOLLAR SCANDAL 💥
Bruno Crastes triumphed over adversity to become one of the most gifted investors of his generation. Why did he blow up his career betting on the notorious financier Lars Windhorst?
I am convinced that
@JonesDay
breached SRA Codes of Conduct across 2011 and 2019
@sra_solicitors
As for Kroll’s conduct, matters are considerably more serious.
@wirecard
: a record of deception, disarray and mismanagement via
@FT
Braun’s removal would be the worst thing that could happen for
@wirecard
’s shareholders. He’s doing a remarkable job of stymieing Wirecard’s demise. Without him the house of cards would’ve very likely collapsed years ago.
Die Deka fordert als erste große deutsche Fondsgesellschaft die Ablösung von Markus Braun als Wirecard-Chef. Das in der vergangenen Woche veröffentlichte KPMG-Sondergutachten habe sie „schockiert“.
What Harry and Meghan should have done is befriend a notorious paedophile. That way no one would have wanted them to pitch-up for their silly Royal duties and they’d get to keep the publicly funded housing, travel and security.
It’s always surprised me of the lack of interest by some German journalists on this. Especially since a key part of the
@Wirecard
affair centred on constraining freedom of the press by scandalous means such as prosecuting the very journalists responsible for reporting the fraud👇🏻
Ich fände ja ein großes Stück zur Rolle der Münchner Staatsanwaltschaft und von Frau Bäumler-Hösl im Fall
#Wirecard
viel spannender als die alten Siemens-Storys
Then heaven help Germany if it ever hopes to be taken seriously as a distinguished, reputable and credible center for financial markets instead of being regarded as a location where the methods of a banana republic are discharged.
@BondHack
When I met the Prosecutor in 2019, I think they felt BaFIN as inept. With the revelations since, their view is probably now hoping it was mere incompetence. You should have heard what BaFIN had concocted on
@FD
. Your eye balls would bounce around like a couple of bingo balls.
@WolfpackReports
@WillauerProsky
I’m saddened to hear this. Matt’s great sense of humour was rivalled by his kindness. The Christmas cards Matt sent each year were marvellous, with pictures of bankers being throttled and all sorts. Heaven knows where he got them from but they always prompted smiles & laughter.
And the award for best Investor Relations performance goes to....
....Blue Prism’s CEO, for insinuating UK investors are too stupid to value his business.
$PRSM
Blue Prism’s US plan casts London in unflattering light
As CEO of
@wirecard
he always was a bamboozler with jargon. But therein lies a weakness. From the market communications that Dr Braun made over the years, there’s undoubtedly a series of questions to put to him to persuade any sensible court that he’s a proficient deceiver.
Peppered with PowerPoint presentations and industry jargon, Markus Braun's statements in the landmark Wirecard trial often sounded more like investor briefings. The presiding judge was not impressed.
(1st 300 clicks free)
A BBC Panorama investigation has found that the Manchester-based fast fashion firm Boohoo has broken promises to make it’s clothes fairly and ethically.
Incidentally,
@wirecard
’s involvement in money laundering is detailed very well in the excellent
@sky
documentary, Wirecard: A Billion Euro Lie, starring yours truly. It’s a gripping account of the scandal. Received great reviews!
I recall when I met the FBI & DoJ in NYC in 2017 to discuss the cyber hacking. I asked if they also wanted to talk about
@wirecard
’s money laundering. Their response: “Oh we know all about that.”
US authorities knew for years.
Zatarra discovered it in 2016.
Germany? In 2020! 🤦🏼♂️
Good to see BellTroX on this list. BellTroX began its hack-for-hire campaign against me shortly after I highlighted the
@wirecard
fraud.
#Zatarra
@citizenlab
Facebook bans seven ‘cyber mercenary’ companies from its platforms
@guardian
@FabioDeMasi
@handelsblatt
@SZ
2/2 BaFIN didn’t like that we’d said the fraud perpetrated by
@wirecard
rendered its equity worthless. Of course it was just as worthless in 2016 as it is now.
BaFIN failed in its responsibility and protected Wirecard, allowing the fraud to continue for another four years.
I’m thoroughly fed up of policy decisions being driven by the personal whims of cretins & who can shout the loudest, as opposed to a rational, data driven, cost-benefit approach. What a pity there’s no viable opposition to hold these prats to account.
Amusing review of Matt Moulding’s whiny LinkedIn post re £THG. THG should do everyone a favour and go and list in the US. Would be great to see what the SEC makes of all these bid rumours that seem to go nowhere and the trading that precedes them.