Hands up if youve lost all faith in the Criminal Justice System?
Think its broken? Not fit for purpose?
Trial by Jury needs a major overhaul?
Sentencing is an absolute joke mostly?
A shambles. Rotten to the core.
@DonnaDlm71
Never liked the jury system, police and CPS base their work on facts and evidence, jury's base theirs on emotion, personal feelings and at times ignorance and prejudice
@DonnaDlm71
You’ve let emotion cloud your judgement here. Our judicial system is one of the best in the world. Looking at the law, points to prove, motive, intent etc murder was always an aspirational verdict in this particular case. Let’s not forget they’ve been convicted of a homocide
@NeilCross5
Im not really just referring to this case. There are many that disappoint. I think trial by jury needs reform or review at least. Sentencing is a mess.
Agreed murder was a big ask ( but in truth i suspect it was that).
But I very little faith that sentencing will be harsh here.
@DonnaDlm71
@NormanBrennan
I work in the courts and the Juror system is not broken. I have only seen one questionable decision in my time in court. Its possible the CPS in half accepting the manslaugher plea by one defendant prior to the trial, opened the door eventually to Manslaughter verdicts
@DonnaDlm71
The idea is right but the emotions and prejudice of a Jury together with a failure to understand the detail of law has diminished the value
Maybe it is time to increase the use of stipendary magistrates and a revamp of Crown Court proceedings
@DonnaDlm71
I’ve never had faith in our justice system , we’re way too weak and lenient . More so for the serious crimes. Life should me life , not 10/15 yrs for example. Tougher sentences could be a deterrent, like many other countries
@DonnaDlm71
Lost faith in it years ago, needs a whole reshuffle from top to bottom, it’s needs someone to take it by the scruff of the neck and set guidelines where crimes are punished correctly without taking any bullshit
@DonnaDlm71
Said this yesterday
@DonnaDlm71
For such cases professionals must be used. Too much pressure placed onto ordinary folk & the knowledge that if they can kill a Police Officer, who is next? Agree needs to be changed, & swiftly
@pritipatel