Abeba Birhane @Abebab Twitter profile

Pinned Tweet

Abeba Birhane

2 days

New paper! We evaluated 14 models trained on 400M & 2B samples on classification using CFD as probe. As training data increased, so did the probability of misclassifying human images as offensive classes such as criminal Paper: Code:

2

85

194

Last Seen Profiles

@knifesaintkris

@_aj

@Moutalogy

@SamNolan04

@TrinityTigersB2

@ACordova92

@MauArtist

@septemberVrouw

@HunterChorus

@AvascanExplorer

@ronii_fs

@JohnBrennan

@hunxho

@tomg_

@MHuzaifa125

@LxSingh9

@Wildniss_Sello

@ICANN

@Blfire

@CommackSchools

@TimB0626

@Imuhhhhjustabug

@NewDealChief

@CoE_Call_Centre

@MarillionOnline

@YinzerSzn

@pekinshowamachi

@maridaalberto00

@namekawama18205

@Verkkouutiset

@1kEmanuelWilson

@ugursoytas

@IkueWanaka12592

@RUM_TTV

@Divine_Bliss

@fideloper

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

1 month

who's gonna tell them what the very purpose of creating mind maps is

Abhishek

@HeyAbhishekk

2 months

ChatGPT can now create Mind Maps. No more wasting hundreds of hours making visuals for studying or simplifying complex ideas. Here’s how to do it for free in a few seconds:

225

1K

8K

37

2K

49K

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

3 years

academia to Black women

33

2K

14K

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

2 years

i'm a dr

483

136

9K

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

5 years

Academia to black women

22

1K

9K

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

5 years

Reverse racism isn't a thing. If you think me pointing out racism in academia is racist, it's because white privilege has taught you not to recognize structural racism and discrimination. It's because your privilege rests on not understanding it.

36

1K

5K

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

3 years

message from my mum who lives in Ethiopia: URGENT, CALL ME! me: what's it mum? mum: I saw the floods on the news in Thailand. did you survive? me: i live in Ireland m: me: m: me: m: you know how similar the sound to normal people. don't you dare be disrespectful me: sorry mum

57

139

3K

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

3 years

Facial recognition tech can do no such thing

Jean-Baptiste Lefevre

@jblefevre60

3 years

👓 Facial Recognition is able to analyze in real time the Emotions & feelings! #AI #MachineLearning #FacialRecognition 🎥emotion @DeepLearn007 @PawlowskiMario @mvollmer1 @gvalan @ipfconline1 @diioannid @ShiCooks @kalydeoo @Ym78200 @Nicochan33 @chboursin

86

322

726

71

427

3K

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

3 years

Today is my official first day as an Ethics Research intern with DeepMind 🙌🏾 ☺️

132

43

3K

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

3 years

please forgive me, I was forced to read papers around "AI for Africa" today

53

693

3K

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

3 years

Facial recognition can do no such thing

Spiros Margaris

@SpirosMargaris

3 years

How #FacialRecognition can Reveal Your #Political Orientation #fintech #AI #ArtificialIntelligence #MachineLearning #DeepLearning #election @analyticsinme

179

134

420

94

380

3K

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

2 years

"trustworthy", "smart" & "privilege" are not things that can be read off faces. this is nothing but a form of machine aided phsygnomy that will be used for insidious purposes which will end up harming those that don't fit social and historical stereotypes

14

496

2K

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

3 years

just to own reviewer #2 who said my paper demonizes machine learning

60

163

2K

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

3 years

there. is. no. such. thing. as. unbiased. data. and never can there ever be.

47

346

2K

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

1 year

longtermism might be one of the most influential ideologies that few people outside of elite universities & Silicon Valley ever heard abt. as a former longtermist, I have come to see this worldview as most dangerous secular belief system in the world today

Why longtermism is the world’s most dangerous secular credo | Aeon Essays

It started as a fringe philosophical theory about humanity’s future. It’s now richly funded and increasingly dangerous

aeon.co

2

483

2K

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

2 years

I was in the process of being hired (part-time) at a Scandinavian university towards the end of last year & experienced one of the most distressing & draining cases of racism (will not name the university, department or individuals to protect those that fought for me) thread 1/

36

489

2K

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

4 years

Today I asked a new cohort of about 30 ML PhD students to assume they were given these tasks by their employers and how they would respond. These questions raised heated debates 🔥🔥🔥 and the class went on way longer than anticipated

69

449

2K

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

2 years

over a year ago, i commented on how big tech might take African language datasets, collected and curated by underfunded and overworked African researchers and i was dismissed as 'alarmist' 1/

2

674

2K

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

6 years

How to make a racist AI without really trying "... the sentiment is generally more positive for stereotypically-white names, & more negative for stereotypically-black names." I urge you to read this if you do sentiment analysis of any sort.

17

1K

2K

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

3 years

when you put theft in context, the poor are robbed the most

Rose 💙💗🤍💗💙 says TRANS RIGHTS

@transrightsrose

3 years

If this doesn't radicalize you, look at it again.

146

6K

23K

2

532

2K

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

4 years

How it How it’s started going

15

334

2K

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

3 years

3 weeks ago LAION-400M dataset (now a billion+), first Image-Alt-text pair dataset of this scale was released. @vinayprabhu , @MannyKayy & I dug into it Long tread 1/ Warning: paper contains NSFW content that may be disturbing, distressing &/or offensive

58

565

2K

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

3 years

📢New paper out in Artificial Life journal 📢 This paper is central to my PhD thesis, it brings together embodied & enactive cog sci & complex systems to argue that ML predictive systems are scientifically problematic and ethically dubious.

53

459

1K

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

2 years

🙌🏾🙏🏾❤️

50

71

1K

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

3 years

the road to total tech-surveillance is paved with convenience

15

343

1K

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

3 years

I can't even with this one

65

173

1K

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

1 year

we do. we wrote about 2 major undersea cables in Africa owned by Google & Meta explaining how they 1) physically follow the transatlantic slave trade route & 2) ideologically constitute a new form of digital colonialism. our paper was rejected cuz it doesn't reference Western lit

18

431

1K

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

4 years

My paper "Algorithmic Injustice: towards a relational ethics" just won the @black_in_ai Best Paper Award at @NeurIPSConf and I'm shook! Absolutely speechless!!! #NeurIPS2019

97

184

1K

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

2 years

📣 some personal news 📣 today i officially start at mozilla foundation as a senior fellow 🙌🏾 😊 looking forward sharing more over the coming year

96

35

1K

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

5 months

me & my collaborators have done the most extensive research of the LAION datasets (3 academic papers & the first to investigate dataset in 2021 showing misogyny, pornography, & malignant stereotypes) yet, the Stanford study has not cited us once. this is academic misconduct

Samantha Cole

@samleecole

5 months

big breaking news: LAION just removed its datasets, following a study from Stanford that found thousands of instances of suspected child sexual abuse material

2

599

2K

19

459

1K

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

4 years

. @NatureComms , you are responsible for reinstating long discredited pseudoscience by publishing physiognomy. Retract this pseudoscience immediately.

37

334

1K

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

5 years

"Where are you from? England. But where are you originally from? Originally, I am from loving parents." The best thing I heard today

14

150

1K

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

4 years

Nothing scares me as much as seeing naive engineers with no knowledge of structural injustice, pervasive power asymmetries, or conservative and racist history of the field of AI, being endowed with the power to make tech that infiltrates the social sphere.

16

348

1K

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

8 months

extremely thrilled and honoured to be on this list 🙌🏾

TIME

@TIME

8 months

TIME's new cover: The 100 most influential people in AI

431

1K

3K

120

126

1K

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

1 year

argh! (different generative models, similar outcome)

8

275

1K

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

4 years

"Computational and cognitive sciences are built on a foundation of racism, sexism, colonialism, Anglo and Euro-centrism, white supremacy, and all intersections thereof" New preprint from @o_guest and yours truly.

69

410

1K

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

5 years

Face recognition technology

Brent Toderian

@BrentToderian

5 years

QUESTION: If you had the power to ban just one thing from cities in order to make them MUCH better, OTHER THAN CARS (too easy), what would that one thing be?

3K

255

1K

12

83

1K

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

3 years

I'm I doing this right

9

173

1K

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

3 years

I'm tired of people claiming "AI benefits society" without acknowledging that benefits and harms are distributed unevenly

17

225

1K

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

3 years

My TL a few tweets apart. Nobody does firing in retaliation as well as big tech corporations

3

350

1K

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

4 years

Every tech-evangelist: #GPT3 provides deep nuanced viewpoint Me: GPT-3, generate a philosophical text about Ethiopia GPT-3 *spits out factually wrong and grossly racist text that portrays a tired and cliched Western perception of Ethiopia* (ht @vinayprabhu )

67

388

1K

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

2 years

The tech space is full of men who have no idea of the history of their field, leading to stupid comments like this... and every now and again, you have men like this who show the true colour of the field by saying things out loud

55

158

1K

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

7 years

Descartes was wrong: ‘a person is a person through other persons’ – my piece for @aeonmag via @aeonmag

Descartes was wrong: ‘a person is a person through other persons’ | Aeon Ideas

What’s a better way to understand human psychology – ‘I think, therefore I am’ or ‘A person is a person through other persons’?

aeon.co

98

432

1K

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

6 years

You had me at "data are". #AcademicValentines

10

200

1K

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

3 years

I'll start. Evolutionary psychology.

22

24

970

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

4 years

Some exciting personal news: it's now official that I will be joining the DeepMind ethics team in London as Ethics Research Intern in January for a number of months.

115

45

991

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

1 year

screams in cognitive science

4

63

923

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

7 months

I'm thrilled to be selected as one of UN's inaugural AI Advisory Body to support the international community’s efforts to govern artificial intelligence.

United Nations Envoy on Technology

@UNTechEnvoy

7 months

Today, @UnitedNations Secretary-General @antonioguterres launched his AI Advisory Body. The Body will focus on: 🔹Risks and challenges of AI 🔹 Enablers & opportunities for the #SDGs 🔹 International governance of AI Find out more :

28

194

391

75

111

928

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

1 year

asking big tech ceos about the risks of AI is like asking tobacco companies about the risks of smoking

President Biden

@POTUS

1 year

Artificial Intelligence is one of the most powerful tools of our time, but to seize its opportunities, we must first mitigate its risks. Today, I dropped by a meeting with AI leaders to touch on the importance of innovating responsibly and protecting people's rights and safety.

4K

2K

13K

2

249

886

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

4 years

No. Tha answer is no

Forbes Tech

@ForbesTech

4 years

The Pentagon’s $1 million question: Can AI predict an enemy’s emotions? By @iblametom

7

13

23

29

111

869

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

1 year

gentle reminder: all large language models are good at is predict the next word in a sequence based on previous words they've seen. that's all. there's no understanding of meaning whatsoever

1

222

869

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

3 years

do you know what's more dangerous than bad AI? the current culture that promotes blind faith in AI. people just lose their sense of reasoning and critical thinking when presented with claims of AI being able to do this or that, even the seemingly sensible ones

15

164

861

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

3 years

Our ( @radical_ai_ , @dallascard , @willie_agnew , @DotanRavit , @TheMichelleBao & I) preprint is up on ArXiv (paper currently under review) Paper: The Values Encoded in Machine Learning Research Code and supplementary material: 1/

23

285

837

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

3 years

Algorithmic injustice: a relational ethics approach New paper fresh off the press! 🥳🥳🥳

17

245

830

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

4 years

I have a joke about Black women in academia but you'll find the tone too aggressive

4

112

825

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

2 years

I'm begging tech bros to take basic lessons on human brains, behaviour and cognition. When someone starts with "the brain is just...", you know it is a gross simplification but this one is catastrophically wrong too

Ilya Sutskever

@ilyasut

2 years

Given that the brain is just a bunch of big matrix vector products, linear algebra deserves more appreciation

80

65

739

25

91

808

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

3 years

Artificial Intelligence, A Guide for Thinking Humans — Melanie #Mitchell #amreading

11

155

783

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

7 months

"The vast majority of computer vision research leads to technology that surveils human beings, a new preprint study that analyzed more than 20,000 CV papers and 11,000 patents spanning three decades has found." thanks @404mediaco for covering our paper

How the “Surveillance AI Pipeline” Literally Objectifies Human Beings

A preprint study covering 20,000 computer vision papers and patents over three decades shows “The Surveillance AI Pipeline,” and why the field needs more interdisciplinary studies.

www.404media.co

7

335

768

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

3 years

What's something that seems scientific but isn't?

818

56

725

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

3 years

@bodamianrapsody @evan_greer "this is no different from someone seeing you from their front window" he says watching a video of a kid being broadcast to the world

4

716

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

5 years

Dear men of twitter, This platform would be a much pleasant space if you could refrain from making irrelevant, condescending, and pointless responses to every tweet women post. Thank you!

19

80

728

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

4 years

Preprint for our paper ‘Robot Right? Let’s Talk about Human Welfare Instead’ is up on arXiv . @theblub & I argue not just to deny robots ‘rights’, but to deny that robots are the kinds of things that could be granted rights in the first place. 1/

34

268

714

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

4 years

I don't know who needs to hear this but 'I am apolitical' is a political statement

18

110

718

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

3 months

very soon, synthetic content will pollute the entire www, like a toxic waste

Sam Altman

@sama

3 months

openai now generates about 100 billion words per day. all people on earth generate about 100 trillion words per day.

1K

15K

1

187

711

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

2 years

AI can absolutely NOT do such a thing

It's Nice That

@itsnicethat

2 years

Can AI imagine the next victims of police violence? Future Wake explores injustice through code >

13

4

11

20

94

714

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

2 years

this is a horrible move. AI/robots CAN'T detect lies. looks like even the EU falls for AI snake oil.

James Gingerich #B2B #Technology #Influencer

@jamesvgingerich

2 years

The EU is putting lie detector robots on its borders. (Now This) #Robotics #AI

54

99

142

31

239

704

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

3 years

most academics don't like actual interdisciplinary work, just the idea of it

25

49

698

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

2 years

If senior professors in position of power can outright attack me like this and alter my career paths, just imagine the trauma, obstacles and frustration other (less outspoken/those who prefer to remain quiet) Black scholars go through as they navigate academia. End/

19

42

690

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

4 years

when you solve the harmful and negative societal consequences of algorithmic decision-making by "debiasing" your dataset

4

151

690

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

4 months

Google has agreed to settle a $5bn class action lawsuit for invading the privacy of users by tracking them even when they were browsing in "private mode".

Google settles $5bn lawsuit for 'private mode' tracking

Large technology firms have faced increased scrutiny of their practices in the US and beyond.

www.bbc.com

1

314

685

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

2 years

You might think it's just one person, but he is a symptom of much larger rotten ecology that is academia, esp historically white dominated depts Given the powerful position he holds, it pains me to think that things are unlikely to change & the environment will remain toxic 10/

2

45

654

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

3 years

it's astounding how much of current "algorithmic (un)fairness" literature assumes there's an uncontested "fair" dataset/representation/ground truth out there

9

96

652

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

3 years

Race "sciences" (Racism, more accurately)

11

13

607

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

2 years

let's ditch the common narrative that "AI is a tool that promotes and enhances human prosperity" (whatever that means) & start with the assumption that AI is a tool that exacerbates inequality & injustice & harms the most marginalized unless people actively make sure it doesn't

6

175

616

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

1 year

"Do they Know it's Christmas" is racist and patronizing. stop playing it

3

77

616

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

3 years

Dear the ML/AI community, DO NOT research autism without autistic people DO NOT research disability without disabled people DO NOT research race without people from historically marginalized races DO NOT research gender without intersectional feminist theories Thank you!

9

132

620

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

2 years

we have arrived at peak AI hype accompanied by minimal critical thinking

3

97

613

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

2 years

just processing the news that our paper "The Values Encoded in Machine Learning" has been awarded the best paper at #FAccT22 and absolutely speechless grateful for the team 💜

wells santo (link in melee, not in bio)

@WellsLucasSanto

2 years

I want to give a HUGE shout-out to @Abebab @ria_kalluri @dallascard @willie_agnew @dotanravit @TheMichelleBao for getting Best Paper at #FAccT22 for "The Values Encoded In Machine Learning Research"!! An incredible paper from an *incredible* team!

3

32

138

24

74

619

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

10 months

there is no such thing as brain correlates of homosexuality. this is unscientific with a disastrous implication in countries where homosexuality is illegal. just let people be or let people identify their own sexuality

Wesley Yang

@wesyang

10 months

AI was able to detect homosexuality by observing the electrical activity of brains with 83 percent accuracy

661

716

8K

3

151

606

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

4 years

The field of AI

Jen Manion, PhD 🏳️‍⚧️🏳️‍🌈🍕🏖

@activisthistory

4 years

What's it called when a group that is 90% white say they have no bias?

2K

21K

4

95

603

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

3 years

"aligning AI with human values" often amounts to "aligning AI with the values of the status quo" (certainly not with the values of the most impacted by AI) so long as we fail to scrutinize which humans we are talking about

5

134

594

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

2 months

the AI industry is destroying the environment (massive energy consumptions, tons of gallons of water for data centres) while systemically concealing such information. I'm grateful for journalists like @_KarenHao doing the crucial investigative work. excellent thread

Karen Hao

@_KarenHao

2 months

A big question looms over generative AI: what really is its impact on the environment? I spent months investigating a single campus of Microsoft data centers in the Arizona desert - designated in part for OpenAI - in an attempt to find out. Thread.

33

780

2K

5

365

601

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

3 years

Petition to replace "bias" with "harm", "injustice", "oppression" or other appropriate terms that reflect the depth of these problems in algorithmic systems.

10

134

593

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

1 year

@ylecun Pretty much exactly what happened was you overhyped and released a model. People tested it (you should be thankful for us as it's your job to do this before release) and demonstrated that not only does it fail to stand up to your hype, but it is also dangerous.

9

50

593

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

1 year

I repeat: let the tech industry establish guardrails and self-regulate is equivalent to expecting the tobacco industry to do cancer research and self-regulate

Meet the Press

@MeetThePress

1 year

WATCH: Former Google CEO @ericschmidt tells #MTP Reports the companies developing AI should be the ones to establish industry guardrails — not policy makers. “There’s no way a non-industry person can understand what’s possible.”

206

97

479

10

168

585

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

4 years

Addressing the legacy of eugenics in statistics will require asking many such difficult questions. Pretending to answer them under a veil of objectivity serves to dehumanize like the rhetoric of eugenics that facilitated practices like forced sterilization

8

221

578

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

4 years

It's dystopian only when China does it

5

200

553

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

9 months

*screams in cognitive science* no, AI does not learn the same way we do

3

109

566

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

3 years

my thesis would probably win the "bleakest phd thesis" competition if there were one (and if i ever finish writing)

24

564

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

2 years

a robot does not *wake up*. a robot does not take a *deep breath*. it is a machine that depends on human labour through and through. stop spreading misinformation

Vala Afshar

@ValaAfshar

2 years

The robot wakes up and takes a deep breath - imagine this technology in 10 years

3K

9K

46K

4

69

555

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

2 years

the push for 'open sourcing' without appropriate regulatory and structural safeguard will only benefit the already powerful and in possession of resources end/

3

98

547

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

7 years

Maryam Mirzakhani, the first woman to ever win the Fields Medal, Nobel Prize of mathematics is Iranian. #NoMuslinBan

7

409

534

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

6 years

Here's a follow-up You weren’t supposed to actually implement it, Google

5

280

530

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

3 years

“Your life starts getting worse when you start advocating for underrepresented people. You start making the other leaders upset,” @timnitGebru #IStandWithTimnit #SolidarityWithTimnit

Google Researcher Says She Was Fired Over Paper Highlighting Bias in A.I. (Published 2020)

Timnit Gebru, one of the few Black women in her field, had voiced exasperation over the company’s response to efforts to increase minority hiring.

www.nytimes.com

5

188

542

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

3 years

Just like that, Google lost the little legitimacy it had. @timnitGebru has been nothing but the ideal role model for Black women, an aspiration, and a towering figure that keeps pushing the whole field of AI ethics to respectable standard.

@[email protected] on Mastodon

@timnitGebru

3 years

Let me be very careful since I know what I'm dealing with and they can use everything I say against me.

14

41

360

1

109

535

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

2 years

The prof's actions constitute racial discrimination, & the department opened an investigation, which has now come to a conclusion. While I suffered emotional distress & my career was derailed due to his action, the only consequences he faces is he's sent to take ‘trainings’. 8/

1

54

531

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

9 months

AI can do no such thing. this is pseudoscience dressed in machine learning

Wesley Yang

@wesyang

10 months

AI was able to detect homosexuality by observing the electrical activity of brains with 83 percent accuracy

661

716

8K

5

91

525

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

4 years

Academia: academic writing is dry and full of jargon. This needs to change *writes in a directed and relatively jargon free manner* Academia: sorry, your writing doesn't follow proper format and reads more like an essay than a paper. Go back and rewrite.

14

55

534

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

1 month

"a model called Voice Engine, which uses text input and a single 15-second audio sample to generate natural-sounding speech that closely resembles the original speaker" the ONLY thing this enables is fraud at a mass scale

OpenAI

@OpenAI

1 month

We're sharing our learnings from a small-scale preview of Voice Engine, a model which uses text input and a single 15-second audio sample to generate natural-sounding speech that closely resembles the original speaker.

499

1K

5K

7

154

528

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

2 years

this is a great example of how ML really is nothing more than pattern finding in data AI doesn't (and can't) make sense of the social world the way humans do and any patterns picked could be these silly details than anything fundamental about a behaviour we are modelling

13

172

511

Abeba Birhane

@Abebab

11 months

New paper!📢 On Hate Scaling Laws for Data-Swamps with @vinayprabhu , Sang Han & @VishnuBoddeti Paper: Code: WARNING: Contains examples of hateful text & NSFW images that might be disturbing, distressing, &/or offensive Long 🧵 1/

19

189

518