@sfgiantfutures Thoughts on a package of Wade and Black for Goldy with Eldridge / Bericoto being the future 1B platoon?

@drudown84 Risky move, IMO. Not wild about trading Black in general, but as good as Goldschmidt has been, he’s having his toughest season of the past 4 at age 35, signed for $26m next year… I’d want to see reasons to believe Goldschmidt would have a resurgence away from St. Louis.

@sfgiantfutures Harrison's elite fastball solidifies hom at number one. As great as Wisenhunt's changeup is, the fastball is still the best pitch in baseball. So, Harrison has a higher ceiling.

@GiantsFan831 Agreed, but that’s why I was asking who is the #2 pitching prospect? (I left unsaid that Harrison is #1 .)

@sfgiantfutures Whisenhunt imo but I’m loving that Black can challenge him for that ranking.

@sfgiantfutures Carson Wisenhount

@sfgiantfutures Whisenhunt still the #2 … but Black will likely get his shot first… probably ahead of Harrison too

@sfgiantfutures 2A and 2B I cannot choose lol All depends on if you prioritize Craft or Stuff

@sfgiantfutures Whisenhunt and it's not even close. Whisenhunt might be better than harrison

@sfgiantfutures Carson I’d say

@sfgiantfutures I think both should be promoted instead of FA shopping—although would be open to including one of the two for Goldschmit… With the thinking that adding him would help our cause in landing Ohtani in offseason as well… need to be able to provide cover for him in our lineup

@sfgiantfutures If Black hadn't changed to a cross fire delivery and a sweeping slider to start the year this comp might be much closer than most may think. Once Black switched back to his old delivery and slider he took off.

@sfgiantfutures I’d say Whiz is #1 , Harrison #2 , Black #3 , Roupp #4 . If Harrison can get some control he’s easily #1 , till then….he’s Jonathan Sanchez

@sfgiantfutures I was really impressed watching Whisenhunt here in Eugene earlier this season.

@sfgiantfutures Landon Roup and Hayden Birdsong making arguments too

@sfgiantfutures That’s tough. Neither Black nor Whisenhunt have a solidified third pitch, but Whisenhunt has the better primary pitch of the two. I might also add Keaton Winn in there. You could pretty much order those any way and I wouldn’t be mad. Roupp is fast-climbing as well.

@sfgiantfutures Whisenhunt

@sfgiantfutures Need 26 not a ranking …

@sfgiantfutures Whisenhut seems to get all the press but I’ve seen Mason pitch since HS and he keeps getting better and smarter.

@sfgiantfutures Whisenhunt might be #1 , period