@avsterbone
avsterbone
9 months
Take the case of Mr. Beard. He thought he was legally open carrying (no permit required) but because he had an inside pocket holster with the muzzle hidden, it’s illegal without a CPL. He now has to pay thousands of dollars, forfeit his firearm and spend 12 months on probation.
20
51
436

Replies

@avsterbone
avsterbone
9 months
For the past 4+ hours I have been watching raw court camera video of Detroit’s CCW Criminal Docket. People who are simply charged with carrying a concealed pistol without a license. Here is what I found: - 99% black - 99% male - ~70% no prior record
80
257
1K
@avsterbone
avsterbone
9 months
Another gentlemen simply had an expired CPL, same result. Laws like these are extremely punitive with NO benefit to society. I implore @MIHouseDems @stephanielily @NoahArbit and others to watch the end result of these laws. You’re really hurting people for absolutely no reason.
8
40
471
@avsterbone
avsterbone
9 months
Link to all proceedings:
2
12
138
@avsterbone
avsterbone
9 months
Another EXTREMELY concerning trend I noticed is defense counsel is often completely incompetent and doesn’t understand Michigan gun laws at all. AND THIS IS THEIR F’JOB! As an attorney Mr. Menken should know if 45 days has passed, the CPL is presumed VALID absent a denial letter.
6
37
358
@avsterbone
avsterbone
9 months
Imagine being such an awful defense attorney that you ask the PROSECUTOR what the law is. Utter incompetence. @MichOpenCarry
11
23
340
@avsterbone
avsterbone
9 months
It is worth highlighting that Wayne County Prosecutor, Kym Worthy, allows diversion for theft, breaking & entering, resisting arrest along with a whole host of other crimes with actual VICTIMS. But charged with CCW? Too bad!
Tweet media one
5
34
248
@avsterbone
avsterbone
9 months
Shoutout to @AuthorSingh for putting together this great story on @BearingArmsCom !
2
11
54
@avsterbone
avsterbone
9 months
Today in the House Criminal Justice Committee a woman testified detailing her story of how she became a convicted felon when she drove a shot loved one to the hospital. She didn’t realize there was a handgun in the vehicle. Go to 25:05
1
8
46
@avsterbone
avsterbone
8 months
Nathaniel Rucker simply missed the deadline to renew his CPL. He had several deaths in his family during the COVID pandemic and has a career as a security guard. That will all come to an end thanks to Michigan’s draconian CPL law that treats Mr. Rucker like a felon for missing a…
7
55
282
@avsterbone
avsterbone
8 months
With @MalloryMcMorrow @stephanielily @AmosONeal1 currently pushing through gun control bills disguised as a solution to “domestic violence” the following case couldn’t have come at a better time. Krystal Gibson feared for her life after being in an abusive relationship. She made…
12
44
167
@avsterbone
avsterbone
6 months
@MalloryMcMorrow @stephanielily @AmosONeal1 Listen to 57 year old Theresa Mccants, who has no prior criminal history, cry at the prospect that she will be defenseless against attackers as a survivor of domestic violence. Her crime? Carrying on an expired CPL.
2
6
36
@avsterbone
avsterbone
5 months
@MalloryMcMorrow @stephanielily @AmosONeal1 This is just absolutely 🤯. So the assistant prosecutor (off-screen) is telling a defendant who was just discharged from probation that their CPL application will be adjudicated by the “Gun Commission.” County Gun Commissions/Boards were eliminated in 2015.
1
1
16
@avsterbone
avsterbone
5 months
@MalloryMcMorrow @stephanielily @AmosONeal1 Public Defender is visibly frustrated people keep getting arrested for CCW. Says it would be a better society if we stopped doing this. I couldn’t agree more.
1
4
31
@avsterbone
avsterbone
4 months
@MalloryMcMorrow @stephanielily @AmosONeal1 Public Defender AGAIN lashes out at these increasingly ridiculous CCW charges. Says there is no emphasis on educating these people on the law. It’s purely a money racket for the state.
2
3
21
@avsterbone
avsterbone
3 months
@MalloryMcMorrow @stephanielily @AmosONeal1 As I continue to watch these cases, I am noticing a trend where defendants are separating the magazine from the handgun in an attempt to legally transport it. Specifically, they put the handgun in the trunk and the magazine in the glovebox. Unfortunately, this is not compliant…
1
2
15
@News2ATeam
News2A
6 months
@avsterbone Does he permanently lose his firearm rights?
1
0
1
@avsterbone
avsterbone
6 months
@News2ATeam 1 year suspension on the right to purchase & possess. 3 year suspension on the right to carry.
1
0
1
@blitziod
steve anderson
9 months
@avsterbone Is this a possible Bruen challenge ? “ at the time of the founding simply having the muzzle hidden was not considered concealed “?
0
0
5
@LukeDashjr
Luke Dashjr
9 months
@avsterbone @opensrcdefense These judges should be fired. Pleas to exercising your right shouldn't be punishable even as part of a plea deal
0
0
0
@JamesDeroest
James DeRoest
9 months
@avsterbone Not knowing the law is not a defense. At the end of the day though, he got probation, so he's serving no time. Everyone knows that you check the law before you carry. He didn't, he assumed or at worst took someone else's word for it.
1
0
0
@CRTC_Nichols
Charles Nichols' 13th year of 2A lawsuit
9 months
@avsterbone In California, an inside-the-waistband holster is concealed carry but if the holster is a belt holster, outside of the waistband, then the handle of the handgun can be obscured by one's coat and it is still #OpenCarry . That said, California has banned the Open Carry of rifles,…
0
0
1